Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

1. Is the Mass that we celebrate today the Mass that was promulgated by Pope Paul VI in 1969?

2. Is the Mass that we celebrate today the Mass that was envisioned by Council Fathers in Sacrosanctum Concilium?

3. Is the Mass that we celebrate today the Mass that is faithful to the demands of the Church as it stands in light of 2000 years of history?

Ok, those are the baseline questions, here is the reasoning for the asking. Recently, I have started taking a more critical look at the necessity of the impending translation. As I have pondered this thought of a new translation, is this a needed thing or is it simply a "moving of the deckchairs on the Titanic?"

Why do I ask this? If one takes a critical view of the Mass, even in the most orthodox of parishes, do they follow the rubrics as they are defined? Are the pastors and parochial vicars finding the "Spirit of the Law" in the "Letter of the Law?" Looking to the GIRM, it presupposes a couple of things, first the GIRM presupposes a wide use of the Latin language and second, it presupposes a totally different orientation of the priest in relation to the people and the altar.

As we move through the document Sacrosanctum Concilium, there is nothing that is definintive. If I view Sacrosanctum Concilium from a "conservative view," then it is a conservative document, however, if I view Sacrosanctum Concilium from a "liberal view" then it is a liberal document save one sub-paragraph, which is ignored almost wholesale, in today's Church. That sub-paragraph is:


[quote name='Sacrosanctum Concilium #22:3']
Therefore no other person, even if he be a priest, may add, remove, or change anything in the liturgy on his own authority.[/quote]


Yet, isn't this what happens daily at Mass across the globe? Even the most orthodox of priests improvise to a lesser degree, by not following the rubrics of the Mass as defined in the GIRM. This flies in the face of the above quote, does it not?

How can we as lay Catholics expect to find merit in a new translation, when we can't even get a Mass said according to the rubrics? What is the point of having the new translation, if the ceremony is more or less "bastardized" to the will of the priest celebrating the Mass?

If I were to attend Mass with the sole purpose of critiquing the celebrant of the Mass and nothing else, by using the GIRM and Sacrosanctum Concilium as the source texts of the critique, would I see what is written down happening in the parish on a daily basis? (It is my contention that I would not.)

It is the above question that I ask that leads me to believe that the new translation is simply a set of "deckchairs." I am not asking for a reversion to the Tridentine Mass. Hardly, but what I am looking for is an honest response to why the Mass is not celebrated the way it was intended, vis-a-vie Vatican Council II.

I believe that this issue is pandemic. I believe that this issue is at the heart of what is going on with every single crisis of faith that a Catholic will have. 98% of Catholics view the Mass as their main outlet for expression of their religion. Shouldn't they be allowed to have a Mass said properly, according to the defining documents and according to the rubrics?

So, thoughts. This is not a debate. This is a very serious series of questions that I am dealing with at the moment.

Posted

I've got a question:
Weren't the WYD masses said by JPII (I'm thinking of Toronto, since that's the only one I've been to) not following your understanding of the GIRM? If that is the case, it would seem, then, that you'd be implying that the pope himself isn't correctly following the rubrics, etc. That leads me to one of two possible conclusions:

1. You're incorrectly understanding it.
2. The pope is misleading his people...

And I don't think it's number 2.

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted (edited)

Cam, I appreciate your thoughts greatly (mostly because I am in wholehearted agreement!)... especially the 2nd to last paragraph. I think most of my struggles have emerged from frustration with liturgical celebrations. The widespread abuse is my main reason for attending the indult (Tridentine Mass).

I know a few very holy and orthodox priests (one of which I ask prayers for...) who are also greatly frustrated with the manner in which the Liturgy is celebrated and would LOVE to change a lot in their parishes. However, the abuse of Sacrosanctum Concilium and the GIRM is so ingrained and widespread in parishes that it's a pastoral issue to try and change them "back to the way they should be"... the majority of Catholics sitting in the pew don't know the rubrics and most of them could probably care less. We wouldn't want to compound the problem by having some priests celebrate Mass the way it should be, while others continue celebrating illicit Masses-- it will only cause confusion and frustration.

It would've been nice if with this new translation, the bishops came down hard on obeying the rubrics.

[quote name='scardella' post='1022758' date='Jul 12 2006, 10:46 AM']
I've got a question:
Weren't the WYD masses said by JPII (I'm thinking of Toronto, since that's the only one I've been to) not following your understanding of the GIRM? If that is the case, it would seem, then, that you'd be implying that the pope himself isn't correctly following the rubrics, etc. That leads me to one of two possible conclusions:

1. You're incorrectly understanding it.
2. The pope is misleading his people...

And I don't think it's number 2.
[/quote]
Actually... the joke among most priests is that Liturgy in Rome is an example of what not to do. We had a priest who had been studying in Rome and he joked when he came back that he couldn't remember how to celebrate Mass the right way.

Papal Masses especially were never the example to follow... more pomp and circumstance for the television, etc. than concern for liturgical correctness (note also that Papal Masses are not planned by the Pope)

Edited by Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

[quote name='scardella' post='1022758' date='Jul 12 2006, 09:46 AM']
I've got a question:
Weren't the WYD masses said by JPII (I'm thinking of Toronto, since that's the only one I've been to) not following your understanding of the GIRM? If that is the case, it would seem, then, that you'd be implying that the pope himself isn't correctly following the rubrics, etc. That leads me to one of two possible conclusions:

1. You're incorrectly understanding it.
2. The pope is misleading his people...

And I don't think it's number 2.
[/quote]

So, Steve, how do you reconcile what ACTUALLY happens at Mass to what is intended to happen at Mass?

Look to the documents and look at what is happening. How do you reconcile it?

Posted

BTW, I'll have to go back and re-reread the GIRM to give anything more insightful...

Posted

Ok, then.....

Get back to the thread when you have read the appropriate documents.

Guest JeffCR07
Posted

Cam, I agree very much with your points. It is my opinion that the problem is to be found in general catechesis, yes, but more importantly, in priestly formation. The vast majority of seminarians and priests have learned, or are learning, how to say the Mass in a way that is not fully in line with what the GIRM and the Second Vatican Council actually intended. Even the more "orthodox" seminaries don't get everything right. Moreover, simply "not knowing how" isn't the only problem. It is possible to study the GIRM and the Counciliar Documents intently and teach oneself how to say the Mass properly (and some do).

But there is a second problem and exacerbates this first one: if an individual priest teaches himself how to say the Mass properly, it is very likely that people would approach the Bishop and ask why one of his priests is saying the Mass in a "wierd" sort of way. The fact is, many priests are afraid to approach their bishop because they do not want to appear as if they are pointing the finger at the bishop for saying Mass "wrong."

Finally, it seems to me that there is one last problem. Even if an individual priest were to teach himself how to say the Mass exactly as the Council intended, AND he approached his bishop and was given the go-ahead, he is still just one priest. Even if there are a handful of priests such as this in the US, they are only a handful, and the amount of lasting impact that they can make is extremely limited. These individual men can be (just like most priests) moved from parish to parish every couple of years, and there is no reason to suppose that once the individual priest is gone, the parish will demand of their next priest that he say Mass in the same fashion.

In my humble opinion, what is needed in order to rectify the situation is a grassroots movement among seminarians. They need to, collectively, approach the priests in charge of their formation and ask for instruction on how to say the Mass in this particular way. This will allow for a diocese-wide change 10 years down the road, and, when the positive influences of this change are seen by other diocese, imitation may follow. I am hopeful because in many respects this is already being seen - groups like the Society of St. John Cantius are already pushing as a community rather than as individuals for a greater conformity to the actual Conciliar intent.

Like you, I am saddened by the fact that the vast, vast majority of Catholics are not attending Mass as it ought to be said. But this should only confirm us in our prayer for the Church.

Your Brother In Christ,

Jeff

phatcatholic
Posted

[quote name='Cam42' post='1022722' date='Jul 12 2006, 09:01 AM']
1. Is the Mass that we celebrate today the Mass that was promulgated by Pope Paul VI in 1969?

2. Is the Mass that we celebrate today the Mass that was envisioned by Council Fathers in Sacrosanctum Concilium?

3. Is the Mass that we celebrate today the Mass that is faithful to the demands of the Church as it stands in light of 2000 years of history?[/quote]
YES, when it is celebrated correctly. have you never been to a "traditional" or "high" novus ordo mass? i have. its beautiful. if you're ever in KY, go to St. Martin of Tours in Louisville, KY. they have the best novus ordo mass i've ever been to in my life. it has the proper combination of the latin and the vernacular, all the music is from the Adoremus hymnal, the tabernacle is front and center, the choir is in a choir loft, only enough EMoHC's as are necessary, they use incense, and bells, and torch-bearers and everything. THAT'S what Pope Paul VI and the Council Fathers envisioned. THAT'S what is faithful to 2000 years of liturgical tradition. and its not dead. you can find it. even St. Peter's here in Steubenville does a fine job (altho i have a special place in my heart for St. Martin's). you must not allow yourself to be scandalized by the poor implimentation of this vision. have hope!! we MUST have hope, it is the quintessential catholic virtue (i'll take hope over protestant "assurance" any day of the week). without it, we fall into the despair that is hidden within your post, and that Luther embraced when he abandoned the Church.


[quote]Ok, those are the baseline questions, here is the reasoning for the asking. Recently, I have started taking a more critical look at the necessity of the impending translation. As I have pondered this thought of a new translation, is this a needed thing or is it simply a "moving of the deckchairs on the Titanic?"[/quote]
it is most definitely needed, and surely not merely an incidental change or a whole lot of nothing. the very conviction you have to celebrate the Mass "in spirit and truth" should cause you to welcome this new translation. afterall, this is a turning back to what was originally intended. is that not what you bemoan, that the mass is not being celebrated as it was intended to be? this new translation, i think, is a most welcomed step in the right direction, and i think it is a hallmark of things to come. our present pope just happens to be that guy who wrote "The Spirit of the Liturgy."


[quote]Why do I ask this? If one takes a critical view of the Mass, even in the most orthodox of parishes, do they follow the rubrics as they are defined? Are the pastors and parochial vicars finding the "Spirit of the Law" in the "Letter of the Law?"[/quote]
yes! those "most orthodox parishes" are orthodox at least in part for that very reason: b/c they respect the liturgy and they have not be swayed by this or that aggiornamento liturgist who is always seeking for an "updating" of this "old" and "irrelevant" tradition we hold so dear.


[quote]Looking to the GIRM, it presupposes a couple of things, first the GIRM presupposes a wide use of the Latin language and second, it presupposes a totally different orientation of the priest in relation to the people and the altar.[/quote]
indeed, and this is a problem for the majority of our novus ordo parishes. the orientation of the priest is particularly troubling to me, and B16 has voiced his concerns with it as well. i often wonder how facing the people even came to be so prevalent. i am aware of no document that allows it, and apparently (tho i haven't read this for myself) there are places in the Missal where the priest is actually instructed to turn around and face the people for certain parts--which implies that his time should be spent largely facing away from them. i have seen latin laudably retained in a novus ordo mass, but the orientation of the priest is perhaps the only concern that ALL novus ordo parishes must address.


[quote]As we move through the document Sacrosanctum Concilium, there is nothing that is definintive. If I view Sacrosanctum Concilium from a "conservative view," then it is a conservative document, however, if I view Sacrosanctum Concilium from a "liberal view" then it is a liberal document[/quote]
i disagree w/ this statement. for one, even tho certain people (even many people) have been able to read their own agenda into the document or take certain phrases out of context, that does not mean that the document fails to be definitive. the bible is definitive about many things, yet there is no shortage of novel interpretations. anyone who is not aware of the Tradition in which the Conciliar documents reside is going to read them incorrectly. the documents are meant to be read with this Tradition as a guide, and we have faith that nothing which comes out of an infallible council is contrary to this Tradition.

there are in fact many very clear statements, not just the one you quoted. some of them include:

--liturgy is to be taught in seminaries, religious houses of study, theological institutes, and in parishes (no. 15-19).
--more of Scripture is to be read in the Mass (no. 24, 35, 51).
--liturgical books are to be revised (no. 25).
--rites are to be revised so as to reflect a noble simplicity (no. 34, 50, 66, 117).
--introduction of the vernacular in the Mass (no. 36, 54).
--liturgical commissions should be established (no. 44-46, 126).
--the prayer of the faithful is to be restored (no. 53).
--Communion may be granted under both kinds (no. 55).
--permission extended for concelebration (no. 57, 58).
--sacred music is to be taught seminaries, novitiates and houses of study of religious of both sexes, and in other Catholic institutions and schools (no. 115).
--polyphony should not be excluded from liturgical celebrations (no. 116).
--new hymnals should be prepared (no. 117) and new songs composed (no. 121).
--other instruments, besides the pipe organ, admitted to the Mass (no. 120).
--art, vestments, and ornaments should strive after noble beauty rather than sumptuous display (no. 124) and should be moderate in number (no. 125).
--canons and ecclesiastical statutes which governthe provision of material things involved in sacred worship should be revised (no. 128).

other changes were made as well, for example, regarding the other sacraments and sacramentals (ch. 3), the divine office (ch. 4), and the liturgical year (ch. 5). however, one has to remember that, despite all this, Sacrosanctum Concilium is a document of liturgical [b][i]principles[/i][/b], not directives.....................and principles require application and implementation. of course, it is in the move from principle to application that error can take place, b/c a principle can be applied in many different ways. but, surely Sacrosanctum Concilium can't be faulted for that. it was never intended to be a document like the GIRM.


[quote]save one sub-paragraph, which is ignored almost wholesale, in today's Church. That sub-paragraph is:

[b]Therefore no other person, even if he be a priest, may add, remove, or change anything in the liturgy on his own authority.[/b]

Yet, isn't this what happens daily at Mass across the globe? Even the most orthodox of priests improvise to a lesser degree, by not following the rubrics of the Mass as defined in the GIRM. This flies in the face of the above quote, does it not?[/quote]
actually, no, this doesn't happen in an orthodox parish. i am quite aware of the contents of both the GIRM and SC, and i can tell you that i have been to parishes where these documents have been adhered to faithfully.


[quote]How can we as lay Catholics expect to find merit in a new translation, when we can't even get a Mass said according to the rubrics? What is the point of having the new translation, if the ceremony is more or less "bastardized" to the will of the priest celebrating the Mass?[/quote]
i would definitely not go so far as to say that the mass is being wholesale "bastardized" by our priests. even in parishes where the music is not always what it should be and there are what i would deem an excessive number of EMoHC's, the priest has been faithful to the missal before him. the point of the new translation is to bring all involved into an even greater faithfulness to this missal. i think that such a move can only be praised. the hope is that, w/ this new translation, a greater sense of faithfulness to the mass can be fostered. it is already good insofar as it is more representative of the original latin, and the potential exists for much more good to be fostered in the hearts of the priests and the faithful.

catechesis should take place along with the implementation of this new translation. there need not be the "mass confusion" that some people envision. its not that hard to explain why this is taking place and what the significance is of the new translation in comparison to the old.................and i have no doubt that this catechesis will undoubtedly take place. and when it does, some people may actually learn for the first time what this mass is really all about. PRAISE GOD for that!


[quote]If I were to attend Mass with the sole purpose of critiquing the celebrant of the Mass and nothing else, by using the GIRM and Sacrosanctum Concilium as the source texts of the critique, would I see what is written down happening in the parish on a daily basis? (It is my contention that I would not.)[/quote]
in some places you will, in some places you won't. that is my contention.


[quote]It is the above question that I ask that leads me to believe that the new translation is simply a set of "deckchairs." I am not asking for a reversion to the Tridentine Mass. Hardly, but what I am looking for is an honest response to why the Mass is not celebrated the way it was intended, vis-a-vie Vatican Council II.[/quote]
many reasons have been offered, but none of them should ever posit an inherent deficiency in the Conciliar documents. this i think is arrogant and UN-Catholic. just as it is easy to blame God for all the evil in the world, it is easy to blame the Church for the "crisis" we are experiencing. but, this i simply will not do.

i blame instead the culture we live in, and the lack of catechesis which, if u think about it, actually took place during the PRE-conciliar, Tridentine Church or else that wouldn't have been such a revolution when the documents came out. the people first in charge of implementing the council were pre-conciliar, Tridentine Catholics. maybe the question should be "where did we drop the ball before the Council" not "where did the Council drop the ball" or "where did we drop the ball after the council". the council came on the heals of a cultural upheaval that we are still experiencing today. it should be no surprise that some (or even many) would take the modern philosophies prevalent in their day (i.e.: modernism, secularism, relativism, etc.) and apply them to the Church and her teaching.


[quote]I believe that this issue is pandemic. I believe that this issue is at the heart of what is going on with every single crisis of faith that a Catholic will have. 98% of Catholics view the Mass as their main outlet for expression of their religion. Shouldn't they be allowed to have a Mass said properly, according to the defining documents and according to the rubrics?[/quote]
of course they should be! this is what the new translation is setting out to do! by implementing a new translation that is more faithful to the Latin the Church is doing that very thing you are calling for: "allowing the Mass to be said properly."


[quote]So, thoughts. This is not a debate. This is a very serious series of questions that I am dealing with at the moment.
[/quote]
i too hope that this does not become a debate. it would sadden me to debate with you. i hope what i have said here is helpful to you.

pax christi,
phatcatholic

Posted

You might want to start on your Snickers Bar...

[quote]"Not going anywhere for a while? Grab a Snickers Bar."[/quote]

It might take a while for me to get through them.

Posted

As I'm going through this, I want to ask:

Are you having issues with the use of the vernacular?

Posted

Partially. Latin is the normative language. If there is a genuine pastoral need for the use of the vernacular then it may be employed.

However, I don't think that a wholesale scrapping of the Latin is accpetable, in any way, shape or form.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

I just noticed that it says you're from Detroit Michigan. Some of the worst liturgical experiences I've ever had in my life were in the Detroit area. hmm.. It really isn't that bad everywhere. :(

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Cam42' post='1023003' date='Jul 12 2006, 01:30 PM']
Partially. Latin is the normative language. If there is a genuine pastoral need for the use of the vernacular then it may be employed.

However, I don't think that a wholesale scrapping of the Latin is accpetable, in any way, shape or form.
[/quote]

I'm not trying to debate here, but I ran across this in the GIRM so far:

[quote name='GIRM']12. Therefore, when the Second Vatican Council convened in order to accommodate the
Church to the requirements of her proper apostolic office precisely in these times, it examined
thoroughly, as had Trent, the instructive and pastoral character of the Sacred Liturgy.15 Since no
Catholic would now deny the lawfulness and efficacy of a sacred rite celebrated in Latin, the
Council was also able to grant that “the use of the vernacular language may frequently be of great
advantage to the people” and gave the faculty for its use.16 The enthusiasm in response to this
measure has been so great everywhere that it has led, under the leadership of the Bishops and the
Apostolic See itself, to permission for all liturgical celebrations in which the people participate to
be in the vernacular, for the sake of a better comprehension of the mystery being celebrated.
13

13. Indeed, since the use of the vernacular in the Sacred Liturgy may certainly be considered
an important means for presenting more clearly the catechesis regarding the mystery that is
inherent in the celebration itself, the Second Vatican Council also ordered that certain
prescriptions of the Council of Trent that had not been followed everywhere be brought to
fruition, such as the homily to be given on Sundays and holy days17 and the faculty to interject
certain explanations during the sacred rites themselves.18
Above all, the Second Vatican Council, which urged “that more perfect form of participation in
the Mass by which the faithful, after the priest’s Communion, receive the Lord’s Body from the
same Sacrifice,”19 called for another desire of the Fathers of Trent to be realized, namely that for
the sake of a fuller participation in the holy Eucharist “the faithful present at each Mass should
communicate not only by spiritual desire but also by sacramental reception of the Eucharist.”20[/quote]

I can say, too, that I think it'd be beneficial catechetically if the rumored "have at least a little bit in Latin" requirement were implemented. It'd help to foster some appreciation for our Latin roots. However, I would also say that returning to a pure Latin only Mass wouldn't be good for full, conscious and active participation, nor good for catechesis.


[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1023004' date='Jul 12 2006, 01:35 PM']
I just noticed that it says you're from Detroit Michigan. Some of the worst liturgical experiences I've ever had in my life were in the Detroit area. hmm.. It really isn't that bad everywhere. :(
[/quote]

I've never been to the Detroit area, maybe that's part of the reason for the differences in perception...

Edited by scardella
phatcatholic
Posted

[quote name='JeffCR07' post='1022958' date='Jul 12 2006, 01:08 PM']
In my humble opinion, what is needed in order to rectify the situation is a grassroots movement among seminarians. They need to, collectively, approach the priests in charge of their formation and ask for instruction on how to say the Mass in this particular way. This will allow for a diocese-wide change 10 years down the road, and, when the positive influences of this change are seen by other diocese, imitation may follow. I am hopeful because in many respects this is already being seen - groups like the Society of St. John Cantius are already pushing as a community rather than as individuals for a greater conformity to the actual Conciliar intent.[/quote]
i think this grassroots movement is taking place. i see it here at phatmass, for one. i also see it in the students i come in contact with at Franciscan University. we have grads all over the country, working in parishes and slowly changing the face of American Catholicism. i mean that. its people like us, in universities like FUS, who will make the difference. they are already making this difference. i think this same movement is taking place in seminaries too. young adults are turning more and more back to tradition, and men are entering the seminary b/c they want to be good and faithful priests. loyalty to the pope and to the Church is important to them. i see this more and more every day. my twin brother is in the seminary. he is a part of this movement, and he sees it all around him.

i have hope.

we must have hope.

Posted

I live in Westland, Michigan. I can only think of four parishes within a 45 minute driving distance (that I've been to) that attempt to traditionally follow the GIRM as closely as possible (St. Raphael in Garden City, National Shrine of the Little Flower in Royal Oak, Christ the King in Ann Arbor, and Holy Spirit in Hamburg).

A lot of the stuff you mention, though...doesn't the 2003 USCCB GIRM make it optional? As I said in the thread I started a couple days ago, it seems that many things are left to the discretion of the diocese bishop - and even to the priest.

The orientation of the priest and the torch bearer issues are both news to me...I thought these were things that were formally changed by V2...quotes and citations, please?

Take heart! Remember that the rituals, gestures, and postures of the Liturgy are traditions that have evolved gradually in Church history. Such rituals exist to demonstrate the Catholicity of the Church; the Catholicity of the Church does not exist to demonstrate such rituals. As long as we maintain that understanding we needn't be too depressed.

phatcatholic
Posted

[quote name='Ziggamafu' post='1023100' date='Jul 12 2006, 04:15 PM']
The orientation of the priest and the torch bearer issues are both news to me...I thought these were things that were formally changed by V2...quotes and citations, please?
[/quote]
i am unaware of a document that changes either one of these.

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted (edited)

Phatty,

St. Pete's in Steubie is hardly the way a Novus Ordo Mass should be. It may be more reverent than University Masses, but there are numerous minor abuses at St. Peter's-- and I would definitely not claim that the Mass at St. Peter's in Steubenville is what the Council Fathers envisioned... unless a heck of a lot has changed since I was there.


Anyway,
I've heard there's a great parish in the Detriot area (Assumption, I think) that celebrates a Latin Novus Ordo Mass...


[url="http://www.unavoce.org/dietrich.htm"]Dietrich von Hildebrand on the Mass...[/url]

Edited by Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

[quote name='phatcatholic' post='1023108' date='Jul 12 2006, 02:18 PM']
i am unaware of a document that changes either one of these.
[/quote]

Actually, I meant any documentation that these things are *required*. A link you might like on the topic: [url="http://frcoulter.com/presentations/ad-orientem.html"]on the orientation of priests[/url]

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

Ziggy,

try these links regarding the posture of the priest:
[url="http://www.adoremus.org/0405LiturgicalPrayer.html"]Turning Towards the Lord[/url]
[url="http://www.adoremus.org/12-0101cdw-adorient.html"]Letter on the Position of the Priest from the Vatican[/url]
[url="http://www.adoremus.org/1199-Kocik.html"]REturn to the East[/url]
[url="http://www.adoremus.org/0500-Ratzinger.html"]Ch. 3 of Cardinal Ratzinger's/Pope Benedict XVI's book [u]Spirit of the Liturgy[/u][/url]

phatcatholic
Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' post='1023128' date='Jul 12 2006, 04:31 PM']
Phatty,

St. Pete's in Steubie is hardly the way a Novus Ordo Mass should be. It may be more reverent than University Masses, but there are numerous minor abuses at St. Peter's-- and I would definitely not claim that the Mass at St. Peter's in Steubenville is what the Council Fathers envisioned... unless a heck of a lot has changed since I was there.
Anyway,
I've heard there's a great parish in the Detriot area (Assumption, I think) that celebrates a Latin Novus Ordo Mass...
[url="http://www.unavoce.org/dietrich.htm"]Dietrich von Hildebrand on the Mass...[/url]
[/quote]
well, now that i think about it, Monsignor Yontz is a little wordy w/ his parts, so there probably is some ad libbing goin on there. other than that, what abuses are u aware of?

btw, i still stand by what i said about St. Martin of Tours, and by what is in the rest of my post.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...