Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

[quote name='phatcatholic' post='1023290' date='Jul 12 2006, 10:37 PM']
well, now that i think about it, Monsignor Yontz is a little wordy w/ his parts, so there probably is some ad libbing goin on there. other than that, what abuses are u aware of?
[/quote]
Definite ad-libbing... it's been a while since I've been to St. Peter's, but ad-libbing was getting to be a bit excessive at times while I was there. He didn't always begin with the sign of the cross nor did always reverence the altar with a kiss... they were little things, but little things add up. And ad-libbing (especially during the "Ecce Agnus Dei...") is one of my biggest pet-peeves because it utterly destroys the connection and significance purposely placed in all of the prayers. I'm feeling like I'm leaving something out, but it's been a year since I was at St. Peter's, I don't want to confuse it with the wacky associate at my (former) parish.

stbernardLT
Posted

Can someone please explain this part of the GIRM (299):

"The altar should be built apart from the wall, in such a way that it is possible to walk around it easily [b]and that mass can be celebrated at it facing the people, which is desirable wherever possible.[/b] The altar, should moreover, be placed as to be truly the center toward which the attention of the whole congregation of the faithful naturally turns. The altar is usually fixed and is dedicated."

I thought this meant exactly what is says, but its seems you have a different poinion.

Posted

[quote name='stbernardLT' post='1023831' date='Jul 13 2006, 05:39 PM']
Can someone please explain this part of the GIRM (299):

"The altar should be built apart from the wall, in such a way that it is possible to walk around it easily [b]and that mass can be celebrated at it facing the people, which is desirable wherever possible.[/b] The altar, should moreover, be placed as to be truly the center toward which the attention of the whole congregation of the faithful naturally turns. The altar is usually fixed and is dedicated."

I thought this meant exactly what is says, but its seems you have a different poinion.
[/quote]

Since when does "can" mean "should?"

Again, I am talking about reconciling the GIRM, Sacrosanctum Concilium and the prevading actions of the priest.

homeschoolmom
Posted

Doesn't "can" imply "should" in this case since it's followed by "which is desirable wherever possible"?

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

Not when the Vatican says this:

[quote]Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments

Prot. No 2086/00/L

The Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments has been [b]asked whether the expression in no. 299 of the Instituto Generalis Missalis Romani constitutes a norm[/b] according to which, during the Eucharistic liturgy, the position of the priest versus absidem [facing towards the apse] is to be excluded.

The Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments, after mature reflection and in light of liturgical precedents, responds:

[b]Negative, and in accordance with the following explanation.[/b]

The explanation includes different elements which must be taken into account.

It is in the first place to be borne in mind that the word expedit does not constitute an obligation, but a suggestion that refers to the construction of the altar a pariete sejunctum [detached from the wall] and to the celebration versus populum [toward the people]. The clause ubi possibile sit [where it is possible] refers to different elements, as, for example, the topography of the place, the availability of space, the artistic value of the existing altar, the sensibility of the people participating in the celebrations in a particular church, etc. It reaffirms that the position toward the assembly seems more convenient inasmuch as it makes communication easier (Cf. the editorial in Notitiae 29 [1993] 245-249), without excluding, however, the other possibility.

However, whatever may be the position of the celebrating priest, it is clear that the Eucharistic Sacrifice is offered to the one and triune God, and that the principal, eternal, and high priest is Jesus Christ, who acts through the ministry of the priest who visibly presides as His instrument. The liturgical assembly participates in the celebration in virtue of the common priesthood of the faithful which requires the ministry of the ordained priest to be exercised in the Eucharistic Synaxis. The physical position, especially with respect to the communication among the various members of the assembly, must be distinguished from the interior spiritual orientation of all.[b] It would be a grave error to imagine that the principal orientation of the sacrificial action is [toward] the community.[/b] If the priest celebrates versus populum, which is a legitimate and often advisable, his spiritual attitude ought always to be versus Deum per Jesus Christum [toward God through Jesus Christ], as representative of the entire Church. The Church as well, which takes concrete form in the assembly which participates, is entirely turned versus Deum [towards God] as its first spiritual movement.

It appears that the ancient tradition, though not without exception, was that the celebrant and the praying community were turned versus orientem [toward the East], the direction from which the Light which is Christ comes. It is not unusual for ancient churches to be "oriented" so that the priest and the people were turned versus orientem during public prayer.

It may be that when there were problems of space, or of some other kind, the apse represented the East symbolically. Today the expression versus orientem often means versus apsidem, and in speaking of versus populum it is not the west but rather the community present that is meant.

In the ancient architecture of churches, the place of the Bishop or the celebrating priest was in the center of the apse where, seated and turned toward the community, the proclamation of the readings was listened to. Now this presidential place was not ascribed to the human person of the bishop or the priest, nor to his intellectual gifts and not even to his personal holiness, but to his role as an instrument of the invisible Pontiff, who is the Lord Jesus.

When it is a question of ancient churches, or of great artistic value, it is appropriate, moreover, to keep in mind civil legislation regarding changes or renovations. Adding another altar may not always be a worthy solution.

There is no need to give excessive importance to elements that have changed throughout the centuries. What always remains is the event celebrated in the liturgy: this is manifested through rites, signs, symbols and words that express various aspects of the mystery without, however, exhausting it, because it transcends them. Taking a rigid position and absolutizing it could become a rejection of some aspect of the truth which merits respect and acceptance.

Vatican City, 25 September 2000.

Signed: Jorge Arturo Cardinal Medina Estévez, Cardinal Prefect
Archbishop Francesco Pio Tamburrino, Archbishop Secretary

[/quote]

Posted

Nick,

First, this is not a debate with you so please don't take it as such, but I have heard the arguments that you propose. I would like to respond to them one by one.

Secondly, thanks for taking the time to respond.

[quote]YES, when it is celebrated correctly. have you never been to a "traditional" or "high" novus ordo mass? i have. its beautiful. if you're ever in KY, go to St. Martin of Tours in Louisville, KY. they have the best novus ordo mass i've ever been to in my life. it has the proper combination of the latin and the vernacular, all the music is from the Adoremus hymnal, the tabernacle is front and center, the choir is in a choir loft, only enough EMoHC's as are necessary, they use incense, and bells, and torch-bearers and everything. THAT'S what Pope Paul VI and the Council Fathers envisioned. THAT'S what is faithful to 2000 years of liturgical tradition. and its not dead. you can find it. even St. Peter's here in Steubenville does a fine job (altho i have a special place in my heart for St. Martin's). you must not allow yourself to be scandalized by the poor implimentation of this vision. have hope!! we MUST have hope, it is the quintessential catholic virtue (i'll take hope over protestant "assurance" any day of the week). without it, we fall into the despair that is hidden within your post, and that Luther embraced when he abandoned the Church.[/quote]

The interesting thing about this and goes to support my questioning is that you start of by qualifying your position. [i]...when it is celebrated correctly.[/i] I lived at St. Agnes in St. Paul, MN for 2 years. Yes, I know what it is to have the Mass celebrated according to Sacrosanctum Concilium. I have spoken about this in the past. However, it is the vast minority and certainly not the norm. I am not speaking about the minority, I am speaking about ALL the parishes that surround St. Agnes or St. Martin of Tours.

[quote]it is most definitely needed, and surely not merely an incidental change or a whole lot of nothing. the very conviction you have to celebrate the Mass "in spirit and truth" should cause you to welcome this new translation. afterall, this is a turning back to what was originally intended. is that not what you bemoan, that the mass is not being celebrated as it was intended to be? this new translation, i think, is a most welcomed step in the right direction, and i think it is a hallmark of things to come. our present pope just happens to be that guy who wrote "The Spirit of the Liturgy."[/quote]

The reason that I am embarking on this theological and spiritual line of questioning is that I just finished reading [u]The Spirit of the Liturgy.[/u] I agree that the translation is needed, however, without changing the very ACTION of the Liturgy, what good will the translation do? It is simply a matter of "rearranging the deckchairs." It is my contention that until the ACTION of the Liturgy is renewed, the translation will not mean much to the faithful at large. They will simply question the changing of the words and as we all know the level of catechesis that will go on in MOST parishes is non-existent.

[quote]yes! those "most orthodox parishes" are orthodox at least in part for that very reason: b/c they respect the liturgy and they have not be swayed by this or that aggiornamento liturgist who is always seeking for an "updating" of this "old" and "irrelevant" tradition we hold so dear.[/quote]

Again, I believe that you are begging the question. What about the vast majority of parishes, which are not St. Martin of Tours or St. Agnes?

[quote]indeed, and this is a problem for the majority of our novus ordo parishes. the orientation of the priest is particularly troubling to me, and B16 has voiced his concerns with it as well. i often wonder how facing the people even came to be so prevalent. i am aware of no document that allows it, and apparently (tho i haven't read this for myself) there are places in the Missal where the priest is actually instructed to turn around and face the people for certain parts--which implies that his time should be spent largely facing away from them. i have seen latin laudably retained in a novus ordo mass, but the orientation of the priest is perhaps the only concern that ALL novus ordo parishes must address.[/quote]

Last time I checked, Benedict XVI was Pope. He could mandate a change with "the snap of a finger." There is theological precidence for doing this, BTW. I have listed in the GIRM several times where the priest is to turn and face the faithful. Just do a search.

As far as Latin is concerned.....again, I believe that you are speaking of the vast minority. Think of the rest of the parishes in your diocese, and not simply St. Martin's. How much Latin is really used?

[quote]i disagree w/ this statement. for one, even tho certain people (even many people) have been able to read their own agenda into the document or take certain phrases out of context, that does not mean that the document fails to be definitive. the bible is definitive about many things, yet there is no shortage of novel interpretations. anyone who is not aware of the Tradition in which the Conciliar documents reside is going to read them incorrectly. the documents are meant to be read with this Tradition as a guide, and we have faith that nothing which comes out of an infallible council is contrary to this Tradition.[/quote]

Then why is the document not enforced. The issue that you bring about Scripture is interesting, however, if one deviates from Scripture's message in the way that you are stating then it is a heresy (Sola Scriptura), is that how I am to take moving away from Sacrosanctum Conicilum (Sola Fide or something akin to that heresy?)?

Also, this is not a matter of infallibility. I realize that Vatican Council II was infallible, I have never questioned this, what I am questionig is a discipline. The Liturgy is a disicipline. It can be changed and is changed, however, my issues are when the changes are not authentic and are self-serving to a certain agenda.

[quote]there are in fact many very clear statements, not just the one you quoted. some of them include:

--liturgy is to be taught in seminaries, religious houses of study, theological institutes, and in parishes (no. 15-19).
--more of Scripture is to be read in the Mass (no. 24, 35, 51).
--liturgical books are to be revised (no. 25).
--rites are to be revised so as to reflect a noble simplicity (no. 34, 50, 66, 117).
--introduction of the vernacular in the Mass (no. 36, 54).
--liturgical commissions should be established (no. 44-46, 126).
--the prayer of the faithful is to be restored (no. 53).
--Communion may be granted under both kinds (no. 55).
--permission extended for concelebration (no. 57, 58).
--sacred music is to be taught seminaries, novitiates and houses of study of religious of both sexes, and in other Catholic institutions and schools (no. 115).
--polyphony should not be excluded from liturgical celebrations (no. 116).
--new hymnals should be prepared (no. 117) and new songs composed (no. 121).
--other instruments, besides the pipe organ, admitted to the Mass (no. 120).
--art, vestments, and ornaments should strive after noble beauty rather than sumptuous display (no. 124) and should be moderate in number (no. 125).
--canons and ecclesiastical statutes which governthe provision of material things involved in sacred worship should be revised (no. 128).

other changes were made as well, for example, regarding the other sacraments and sacramentals (ch. 3), the divine office (ch. 4), and the liturgical year (ch. 5). however, one has to remember that, despite all this, Sacrosanctum Concilium is a document of liturgical principles, not directives.....................and principles require application and implementation. of course, it is in the move from principle to application that error can take place, b/c a principle can be applied in many different ways. but, surely Sacrosanctum Concilium can't be faulted for that. it was never intended to be a document like the GIRM.[/quote]

Yes, I realize that this is not the old order of the Mass and I accept these changes that you list, but again, if they are not held to, then what good do they do?

Where have I said that we are to use Sacrosanctum Concilium alone? I have not. I realize that they are priniciples, but I have said use it in conjunction with the GIRM, which are directives. Also if they are simply prinicples, then they are open to interpretation, which goes back to what I said earlier.....
[quote]As we move through the document Sacrosanctum Concilium, there is nothing that is definintive. If I view Sacrosanctum Concilium from a "conservative view," then it is a conservative document, however, if I view Sacrosanctum Concilium from a "liberal view" then it is a liberal document...[/quote]

[quote]actually, no, this doesn't happen in an orthodox parish. i am quite aware of the contents of both the GIRM and SC, and i can tell you that i have been to parishes where these documents have been adhered to faithfully.[/quote]

One or two.....what about the thousands of other parishes. And even in the most orthodox of parishes, there is at least some "ad-libbing" that goes on....

[quote]i would definitely not go so far as to say that the mass is being wholesale "bastardized" by our priests. even in parishes where the music is not always what it should be and there are what i would deem an excessive number of EMoHC's, the priest has been faithful to the missal before him. the point of the new translation is to bring all involved into an even greater faithfulness to this missal. i think that such a move can only be praised. the hope is that, w/ this new translation, a greater sense of faithfulness to the mass can be fostered. it is already good insofar as it is more representative of the original latin, and the potential exists for much more good to be fostered in the hearts of the priests and the faithful.

catechesis should take place along with the implementation of this new translation. there need not be the "mass confusion" that some people envision. its not that hard to explain why this is taking place and what the significance is of the new translation in comparison to the old.................and i have no doubt that this catechesis will undoubtedly take place. and when it does, some people may actually learn for the first time what this mass is really all about. PRAISE GOD for that![/quote]

What else would you call it? How about abusive? And if it is abusive, then why should I have to put up with the abuse? Am I not entitled as a Catholic to an authentic Liturgy according to the Roman Rite?

It is great that you are talking about catechesis, but what about the rest of the Church in America? Are they going to catechize or are they simply going to do what was done after Vatican Council II. I think that some catechesis will happen, but if the vast majority of priests cannot even follow the rubrics, then how am I to trust them in instructing the faithful in the changes to the Liturgy, which they themselves abuse?

[quote]in some places you will, in some places you won't. that is my contention.[/quote]

That speaks directly to my point. Why won't you in some places? Shouldn't it be in all places? It should.

[quote]many reasons have been offered, but none of them should ever posit an inherent deficiency in the Conciliar documents. this i think is arrogant and UN-Catholic. just as it is easy to blame God for all the evil in the world, it is easy to blame the Church for the "crisis" we are experiencing. but, this i simply will not do.

i blame instead the culture we live in, and the lack of catechesis which, if u think about it, actually took place during the PRE-conciliar, Tridentine Church or else that wouldn't have been such a revolution when the documents came out. the people first in charge of implementing the council were pre-conciliar, Tridentine Catholics. maybe the question should be "where did we drop the ball before the Council" not "where did the Council drop the ball" or "where did we drop the ball after the council". the council came on the heals of a cultural upheaval that we are still experiencing today. it should be no surprise that some (or even many) would take the modern philosophies prevalent in their day (i.e.: modernism, secularism, relativism, etc.) and apply them to the Church and her teaching.[/quote]

That is unfair. I have never called into question the Conciliar documents. I have been defending them. It is not UN-Catholic to expect the Liturgy to be celebrated consistently across the world. I am wondering why most priests celebrate the Mass in a self-serving way and not the way the Church intended. Please don't project that upon me. It is a disservice to my position. I am well aware of the need for a reconstitiution of the Liturgy. I accept that. What I am questioning is, the abuse of that reconsititution.

[quote]of course they should be! this is what the new translation is setting out to do! by implementing a new translation that is more faithful to the Latin the Church is doing that very thing you are calling for: "allowing the Mass to be said properly."[/quote]

How is changing the wording to the Gloria and Creed allowing the Mass to be said properly? The Mass is more than the words. It is sum of it's parts. If one part is abused then the whole thing is abused. That is why I am wondering what I am wondering.

Guest JeffCR07
Posted

[quote name='stbernardLT' post='1023831' date='Jul 13 2006, 03:39 PM']
Can someone please explain this part of the GIRM (299):

"The altar should be built apart from the wall, in such a way that it is possible to walk around it easily [b]and that mass can be celebrated at it facing the people, which is desirable wherever possible.[/b] The altar, should moreover, be placed as to be truly the center toward which the attention of the whole congregation of the faithful naturally turns. The altar is usually fixed and is dedicated."

I thought this meant exactly what is says, but its seems you have a different poinion.
[/quote]

Hi st. bernard. I actually know quite a bit about this after having a long discussion with some Dominican Brothers who have studied it. That sentence that you have quoted is ambiguous in its english translation. What the latin text says is [i]not[/i] that it is desirable, whenever possible, to celebrate the Mass facing the people, but rather, that it is desireable, whenever possible, to have a freestanding altar so that Mass can be able to be said facing the people.

This distinction, which seems pretty small at first, is really important. First of all, it means that saying the Mass [i]ad orientem[/i] (towards the east) is the default position. Second, it means that even when it is possible to say the Mass facing the people, it remains optional, and there is no preference for it - there is preference for the option to be open, but not for it to necessarily be taken.

What all that means is that, if people really understood what the GIRM is saying, you would see Mass being said [i]ad orientem[/i] a whole lot more than it is now.

Your Brother In Christ,

Jeff

Posted

[quote name='JeffCR07' post='1024236' date='Jul 14 2006, 09:53 AM']
Hi st. bernard. I actually know quite a bit about this after having a long discussion with some Dominican Brothers who have studied it. That sentence that you have quoted is ambiguous in its english translation. What the latin text says is [i]not[/i] that it is desirable, whenever possible, to celebrate the Mass facing the people, but rather, that it is desireable, whenever possible, to have a freestanding altar so that Mass can be able to be said facing the people.

This distinction, which seems pretty small at first, is really important. First of all, it means that saying the Mass [i]ad orientem[/i] (towards the east) is the default position. Second, it means that even when it is possible to say the Mass facing the people, it remains optional, and there is no preference for it - there is preference for the option to be open, but not for it to necessarily be taken.

What all that means is that, if people really understood what the GIRM is saying, you would see Mass being said [i]ad orientem[/i] a whole lot more than it is now.

Your Brother In Christ,

Jeff
[/quote]


Ding Ding Ding!!!!!!!

Look to what Fides et Ratio said in the last post of the last page.

Posted

[quote name='scardella' post='1023007' date='Jul 12 2006, 01:39 PM']I can say, too, that I think it'd be beneficial catechetically if the rumored "have at least a little bit in Latin" requirement were implemented. It'd help to foster some appreciation for our Latin roots. However, I would also say that returning to a pure Latin only Mass wouldn't be good for full, conscious and active participation, nor good for catechesis.
[/quote]What do you think participation is?



I've found even the most orthodox of Catholic theologians have a wrong idea of participation in the Mass. Most modern Catholics think that means we must be as active as possible, meaning I should be an extra-ordinary minister at every possible moment (I'm purposefully leaving out Acolytes and Altar boys for a moment because that's different) or a reader (has anyone on here actually met a non-seminarian Lector?) or whatever. We must sing every song, etc, etc, etc.



If you fall into any of these views, I recommend Medations Before Mass by Romano Guardini. [url="http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0918477174/sr=8-1/qid=1153120684/ref=pd_bbs_1/002-4805619-9899238?ie=UTF8"]http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/091847717...9899238?ie=UTF8[/url] Sophia press has a good translation and you can get the book for super cheap on Amazon.com.



I think this is a must for any Catholic in the modern world...It was given to me by my spiritual director in one of the most difficult times of my life and has helped and continues to help me before Mass. I will quote some of it eventually, but it really changed my view of participation.



I'll use an example. He mentions the idea of a "dialogue Mass" in which the Mass is in the vernacular, but even then everyone will pull out a missalette to read along because that's the only way they can understand. However, so much has been lost! Holy Writ was meant to be spoken aloud and heard! The Priest (Deacon) and Lector (reader) get up there to read it to us, not for us to "follow along," but for us to listen! And the book mentions so much more that we miss. :) Perhaps I should cite more later, but for not let this suffice. I hope that slowly through this book and other discussion I can show to you how little the language matters for participation, but that Latin gives us something English cannot...It is truly universal and is true to our Church, the Latin Church.



As much as Andy and I will disagree on, we both are certain that the main language of Mass is Latin (this is not the case!!!!! But why should I say anything, everyone knows this to be true), the main music is to be Gregorian Chant and polyphony, and that the Mass is supposed to face East. We know this from both the GIRM and from our current Holy Father who has written much on the subject. :)



[quote]The reason that I am embarking on this theological and spiritual line of questioning is that I just finished reading The Spirit of the Liturgy. I agree that the translation is needed, however, without changing the very ACTION of the Liturgy, what good will the translation do? It is simply a matter of "rearranging the deckchairs." It is my contention that until the ACTION of the Liturgy is renewed, the translation will not mean much to the faithful at large. They will simply question the changing of the words and as we all know the level of catechesis that will go on in MOST parishes is non-existent.[/quote]

Iz a really good book, no?

I read that a couple summers back and found it one of the most spiritually refreshing I've read in a long time.

Posted

Wow, I haven't checked this board in a while and here is this post!! Cam, I have been wondering very similar things about the novus ordo missae. I don't have anything to post except that I will keep reading this thread. ;) I find that regular praying of the rosary really helps while looking at this whole area of the liturgy.

phatcatholic
Posted

Cam, i think we are actually in agreement, bro :thumbsup: maybe the following will help to clarify my position. note again the three questions you are trying to answer:

[quote name='Cam42' post='1022722' date='Jul 12 2006, 09:01 AM']
1. Is the Mass that we celebrate today the Mass that was promulgated by Pope Paul VI in 1969?

2. Is the Mass that we celebrate today the Mass that was envisioned by Council Fathers in Sacrosanctum Concilium?

3. Is the Mass that we celebrate today the Mass that is faithful to the demands of the Church as it stands in light of 2000 years of history?[/quote]
it is my opinion that you cannot make a sweeping generalization one way or the other in response to these questions. you cannot say that ALL of the masses celebrated today represent the vision of the Fathers. however, you also cannot say that NONE of them do. there must be qualifications..........and this i think has always been the case. was there ever a time in the Church when the mass was [b][i]always[/i][/b] and in [b][i]every[/i][/b] instance celebrated with perfect fidelity to the principles of the Church and the rubrics of the day? there is no perfect age in the Church where everything was done perfectly. there will always be places where the mass is not celebrated like it should be, just like there will always be Catholic heretics and there will always be Catholic sinners. this is due to the human component of the Church, one that we simply cannot avoid. of course we always hope (there is that perrenial Catholic virtue again :thumbsup: ) for a greater and greater adherence to the laws and principles that govern liturgical worship, but with a sense of realism, we also know that perfection is not ultimately achieved in the Church until Jesus Christ comes again in glory.

as far as the new translation, i know that changing the words does not relieve us of the improper liturgical practices that still plague us, but it should not necessarily for that reason be rejected. it is still a good to have a translation that is more faithful to the original Latin. there is simply no denying that. however, i also agree with you that w/o proper catechesis this new translation will be of little significance to everyone involved, except as a hindrance, which, to the uninformed, it will undoubtedly appear to be.

now, are the majority of the masses in the United States not as faithful as they could be? it is true that they are not. however, we must not lose hope that every day Catholics and Non-Catholics alike are being converted to the true Catholic faith and that this conversion will result in the enrichment of the Church. we also cannot forget that, despite the abuses that may occur, a valid mass still effects the transformation of the bread and wine into the Body, Blood, Soul, and Divinity of Jesus Christ. while i in NO WAY minimalize the important of faithful adherence to the laws and principles that govern liturgical worship, it is the Eucharist that is the source and summit of our faith, and the culmination of the Mass. i think that whenever we begin to despair over the abuses and other forms of scandal that exist in the Church, we should find strength in the Eucharist, which IS [b][i]always[/i][/b] and in [b][i]every[/i][/b] instance the Presence of Christ for the salvation of the world.

pax christi,
phatcatholic

[quote name='Cam42' post='1024190' date='Jul 14 2006, 09:06 AM']
That is unfair. I have never called into question the Conciliar documents. I have been defending them. It is not UN-Catholic to expect the Liturgy to be celebrated consistently across the world. I am wondering why most priests celebrate the Mass in a self-serving way and not the way the Church intended. Please don't project that upon me. It is a disservice to my position. I am well aware of the need for a reconstitiution of the Liturgy. I accept that. What I am questioning is, the abuse of that reconsititution.[/quote]
well, perhaps i misunderstood you, but you seemed to be saying that part of the problem is due to ambiguity in the text, and i was saying instead that the problem is the culture that we live in.

Posted

The texts are ambiguous? :huh:

Those texts, I think, are some of the most straightforward of the whole council..."Latin is to be retained; Extraordinary Ministers are to be used in absolute necessity; the music ought to be Gregorian chant; the Mass is to be reformed, not re-written..."

Okay, so I paraphrased and may have used one from the GIRM, but it's still pretty straight forward and not followed at all. :(

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

I don't think Cam was saying the texts themselves are ambiguous.

They are presented as ambiguous by those who would seek to twist and ignore them according to their personal designs. (i.e., disobedient and ignorant priests-- they may not all know they're in the wrong, but they darn well OUGHT to)

Posted

I didn't think he was saying such. I was wondering where that accusation came from. :huh:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...