Laudate_Dominum Posted July 13, 2006 Posted July 13, 2006 I realze that this sounds like a stupid and obvious question but a buddy of mine has been doing stuff with a protestant church down the street (ecumenical youth ministry type stuff) and the "bishop" of that church, knowing full well that he is Catholic and has every intention of remaining 100% Catholic, has suggested that he be "ordained" as a protestant pastor so that he can carry out more function in the ministry and for some other reasons having to do with taxes or something. Is it ok under any circumstances for a Catholic to accept protestant "ordination"? The reason I think it might be ok is that what they mean by ordination isn't what we mean by it. It sounds like they just want to pray over him for annointing in his ministry; this is something that lay Catholics do to each other and its legit. It's not like he will supposedly be a priest afterwards, they just believe he will be "empowered" and there will be some legal benefits too somehow. Thanks
brendan1104 Posted July 13, 2006 Posted July 13, 2006 Never. This would be definitely schismatic and sinful. Under no circumstances is this allowed, it is forbidden by both Canon Law and common sense. [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1023229' date='Jul 12 2006, 08:18 PM'] I realze that this sounds like a stupid and obvious question but a buddy of mine has been doing stuff with a protestant church down the street (ecumenical youth ministry type stuff) and the "bishop" of that church, knowing full well that he is Catholic and has every intention of remaining 100% Catholic, has suggested that he be "ordained" as a protestant pastor so that he can carry out more function in the ministry and for some other reasons having to do with taxes or something. Is it ok under any circumstances for a Catholic to accept protestant "ordination"? The reason I think it might be ok is that what they mean by ordination isn't what we mean by it. It sounds like they just want to pray over him for annointing in his ministry; this is something that lay Catholics do to each other and its legit. It's not like he will supposedly be a priest afterwards, they just believe he will be "empowered" and there will be some legal benefits too somehow. Thanks [/quote]
prose Posted July 13, 2006 Posted July 13, 2006 I would assume with an "ordination" comes oathes. Somehow I think this would be contradictory to his faith as a Catholic. I would see if they could confer the title on him without a some sort of "ordination" if it is simply for legal purposes. If it is more than that, he certainly needs to rethink his involvement with any organization that is calling him to compromise his Faith.
Pontifite 7 of 10 Posted July 13, 2006 Posted July 13, 2006 We get it! You think its weird! I agree its weird and would be a confect of interest.
Fides_et_Ratio Posted July 13, 2006 Posted July 13, 2006 I don't think it would ever be considered permissable. ... the whole "taxes" thing sounds a bit fishy to me as well-- is he being paid by them for his youth ministry help, etc.?
jswranch Posted July 13, 2006 Posted July 13, 2006 No. Ordination is a sacrament. You friend has some great intentions, but this step is not permissable. He cannot partake, receive, or distribute sacraments outside of the Church like this. If he has a problem holding to this standard, let him speak to a priest.
scardella Posted July 13, 2006 Posted July 13, 2006 I think it likely to cause scandal, if nothing else. Also, although it doesn't outwardly purport to be a sacrament, what you've described seems like it could be considered a counterfeit sacrament, which would probably border on sacrilege. Geez. Look it all up on [url="http://www.dictionary.com"]http://www.dictionary.com[/url]
Norseman82 Posted July 13, 2006 Posted July 13, 2006 [quote name='scardella' post='1023380' date='Jul 12 2006, 09:40 PM'] I think it likely to cause scandal, if nothing else. [/quote] I think it is a scandal, not so much because of the sacramental issues, but rather on a deeper level: he is assenting to and recognizing a protestant church in an official manner, which would signal that he is also assenting to and cooperating with and recognizing protestant doctrine which somewhere along the line means denial of some Catholic teaching. Even if he does not mean to, "perception is reality", so people could be scandalized by it. Prose alluded to it by mentioning the oaths. It might be better to be a non-ordained employee that does not have to sign a "statement of faith" that has anti-Catholic doctrine in it, or to work in an interdenominational group that is not an arm of any protestant church and rep the Catholic faith there.
Tony Posted July 13, 2006 Posted July 13, 2006 is it ok for an NL pitcher to hit 3rd in the lineup? ok so that was a lame anology.
kateri05 Posted July 13, 2006 Posted July 13, 2006 why would a catholic work for a protestant church in any ministry context? because this is a church right? not a ecumenical organization, but an actual church?
pyranima Posted July 13, 2006 Posted July 13, 2006 If they wish to Pray over him that is fine. if they wish to hire him as a youth minister (Given that he is not to teach anything contrary to the Catholic Faith) then that is fine as well. However for him to take the title of "Pastor" implys he is a priest. and anything with the word "Ordain" he MUST stay away from. if they choose to call him a "youth minister" then that is fine, it does not imply the same thing as ordination or Pastor. they can even title him a Minister period. HOWEVER and this is a HUGE HOWEVER, his superior is to be his Priest. he would be a Lay minister who is working ecumenically with a protestant Church and certian distinctions must be made. for example he would need to ID himself as a Catholic Loyal to the Church, and he must make it very clear that his loyalty is to the Church and that his actions all of them are for reunification purposes and that he is NOT a memeber of that sect, but they have Hired him on Ecumenical grounds. this would not be the first case i have heard of like that, If the sect leader (i.e. their "bishop") accepts that he is a Loyal Catholic and will remain so and that the purpose of hiring him is not to be as a "pastor" but as a Lay Minister of the Roman Catholic (or which ever Catholic Rite he is) Church whos purpose is to reunite the skismatic sect. then there is nothing wrong with it. He must never be asked to teach contra the Faith, and when possible he must be able to teach Catholic Doctrine and Dogma. under these stipulations he may be hired to work Ecumenically, in that case he would be an ambassador. He would be an American Hired by Japan to teach the Japanese English, and to help Make them more "American". if you get the anology.
cmotherofpirl Posted July 13, 2006 Posted July 13, 2006 [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1023229' date='Jul 12 2006, 08:18 PM'] I realze that this sounds like a stupid and obvious question but a buddy of mine has been doing stuff with a protestant church down the street (ecumenical youth ministry type stuff) and the "bishop" of that church, knowing full well that he is Catholic and has every intention of remaining 100% Catholic, has suggested that he be "ordained" as a protestant pastor so that he can carry out more function in the ministry and for some other reasons having to do with taxes or something. Is it ok under any circumstances for a Catholic to accept protestant "ordination"? The reason I think it might be ok is that what they mean by ordination isn't what we mean by it. It sounds like they just want to pray over him for annointing in his ministry; this is something that lay Catholics do to each other and its legit. It's not like he will supposedly be a priest afterwards, they just believe he will be "empowered" and there will be some legal benefits too somehow. Thanks [/quote] The answer is no. It doesn't matter what [i]they[/i] mean by the term "ordination", for us it means becoming a priest. So unless they want to receive instructions from him on converting to Catholicism, he needs to drop the idea. How does he reconcile their ideas with Catholic teaching? Are they also against abortion, contraception, homosexual marriage etc? Do they believe in the Real Presence as well?
pyranima Posted July 13, 2006 Posted July 13, 2006 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1023472' date='Jul 12 2006, 10:36 PM'] The answer is no. It doesn't matter what [i]they[/i] mean by the term "ordination", for us it means becoming a priest. So unless they want to receive instructions from him on converting to Catholicism, he needs to drop the idea. How does he reconcile their ideas with Catholic teaching? Are they also against abortion, contraception, homosexual marriage etc? Do they believe in the Real Presence as well? [/quote] your response is cold and raw. there is nothing wrong with him working for a protestant church, but why dont you try to shed some light on what kind of context would be ok for him to work in. the idea as he said in his first post is that of ecumenical work, so would you agree that as long as he was not ordained that it would be perfectly acceptable to hire im on as an ambassador? [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1023472' date='Jul 12 2006, 10:36 PM'] The answer is no. It doesn't matter what [i]they[/i] mean by the term "ordination", for us it means becoming a priest. So unless they want to receive instructions from him on converting to Catholicism, he needs to drop the idea. How does he reconcile their ideas with Catholic teaching? Are they also against abortion, contraception, homosexual marriage etc? Do they believe in the Real Presence as well? [/quote] your response is cold and raw. there is nothing wrong with him working for a protestant church, but why dont you try to shed some light on what kind of context would be ok for him to work in. the idea as he said in his first post is that of ecumenical work, so would you agree that as long as he was not ordained that it would be perfectly acceptable to hire im on as an ambassador?
jiyoung Posted July 13, 2006 Posted July 13, 2006 It would seem to me that they want him to be ecumenical on their terms by almost claiming him as their own by laying hands on him (=ordination for us). Sounds kinda...iffy.
Laudate_Dominum Posted July 13, 2006 Author Posted July 13, 2006 Yeah, a lot of you had the same initial reaction as I did. The whole situation is funny though. And yes, my buddy is completely Catholic and they know it. Heck, when he was down there yesterday he was wearing an Our Lady of Guadalupe t-shirt. And he makes a holy hour every day, daily Mass, Rosary, etc. He's pretty darn Catholic to say the least. And how I understand it is that this bishop fellow basically wants him to run this ministry, and I suppose in those circles it is proper for the man in charge to be a pastor. My other assumption is that this guy doesn't see it as a problem and wouldn't understand a refusal of so kind an offer. I assume he just sees Catholic as another denomination. My buddy definitely does not have that attitude and sees the so-called ordination as just being commissioned to be the youth pastor, like when they lay hands on someone and basically mock ordain them to be in charge of some ministry at FUS. If you can call lay people ministers (ie. eucharistic ministers) I don't see a problem with calling a lay person a pastor. In a way it's less bad in my eyes because at least its not in a liturgical/sacramental context as is calling lay people E.M.s. I'll see about asking my Bishop, and if it's cool maybe I'll think about becoming a Catholic protestant pastor as well. that'd be phat. When I debate a protestant I can play that card. They'll be like, "you're Catholic, you can't possibly understand the protestant doctrine of blah blah", and I could respond by pointing out that I am in fact a protestant pastor. oh yeah! But in all seriousness I think it is very cool that my friend is able to mingle so tightly with protestants and yet still be totally Catholic and that they accept him and aren't scandalized by his catholicity but in fact want him to have a leadership role in their community. And he's not shy about Catholic doctrine by any means. I've been around him when he's gotten into doctrinal discussion with protestants and he has a gift for explaining the faith in a very personal way that the person he's talking to can understand and relate to. I just point this out because I suppose the assumption would be that my buddy must be a closet Catholic if he is able to be so chill with the protestants but in fact he is one of the most evangelistic Catholics that I know. He was in religious life for a while and has had substantial priestly formation and has a lot of experience giving talks. Once he was at this massive ecumenical conference in Latin America (mostly charistmatic protestants in the crowd) and he gave a phat talk on the Real Presence and Our Lady and people were lovin it. I guess that's one of the main things I've always noticed about this dude, he has a very blunt personality but people accept it. He can say things that no one else could get away with saying and instead of being scorned people tend to like him for it. Anyway, the issue still remains, is it cool for my friend to go along with this pastor business.. hmm..
Jaime Posted July 13, 2006 Posted July 13, 2006 [quote name='kateri05' post='1023415' date='Jul 12 2006, 10:59 PM'] why would a catholic work for a protestant church in any ministry context? because this is a church right? not a ecumenical organization, but an actual church? [/quote] Guilty I was called by a protestant pastor to set up a youth program for his church. It was originally supposed to be a three month gig that turned into several years. They knew me by reputation and they knew that I was Catholic. They do have a portion of the Truth and the kids deserved an effective youth program. It was a very positive experience.
cmotherofpirl Posted July 13, 2006 Posted July 13, 2006 [quote name='pyranima' post='1023501' date='Jul 13 2006, 02:36 AM'] your response is cold and raw. there is nothing wrong with him working for a protestant church, but why dont you try to shed some light on what kind of context would be ok for him to work in. the idea as he said in his first post is that of ecumenical work, so would you agree that as long as he was not ordained that it would be perfectly acceptable to hire im on as an ambassador? your response is cold and raw. there is nothing wrong with him working for a protestant church, but why dont you try to shed some light on what kind of context would be ok for him to work in. the idea as he said in his first post is that of ecumenical work, so would you agree that as long as he was not ordained that it would be perfectly acceptable to hire im on as an ambassador? [/quote] And your response to me is rude. There is nothing wrong with working for a protestant church in a shared ministry, there is everything wrong with being called a [u]pastor[/u] of a protestant church if you are in fact catholic.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now