thessalonian Posted July 13, 2006 Posted July 13, 2006 They have no authority to ordain and so he would be participating in a lie. It would be like recieving their Eucharist. We do not judge them for it but it is a participation in their errors, though it may have some spiritual benefit for them that God honors. I would say definitely not. Tax purposes would not be a justification.
Sojourner Posted July 13, 2006 Posted July 13, 2006 L_D I'm interested to see what your bishop says. I suppose my take on it would be that the rightness or wrongness of it would depend on the individual circumstances. For example, if your friend were going to be ordained as a Presbyterian pastor (which I'm pretty sure they wouldn't do, but for argument's sake let's assume they would) and were going to be leading a congregation and performing all the duties and responsibilities of a pastor for an entire congregation (communion, preaching, baptizing, counsel, etc.) that's a different situation than the one I believe you're presenting. I'd have problems with that. Or, if your friend were being forced to renounce part or all of his faith, that would be a big problem. But neither of these situations appears to be the case. I think it's important to really understand what it is that's meant by the term "ordination" ... it means much different things in different denominations. In this case, it sounds like he's not going to be asked to compromise his beliefs, and he and the church are entering into the agreement each with a solid understanding of the other's position. And it sounds like this request is more an attempt on the part of this church's leadership to affirm and encourage him in his ministry. I for one think that's cool. With all the stories you hear about Protestant and Catholic disagreements, it's great to hear about a situation in which there's this much mutual respect.
CoffeeCatholic Posted July 13, 2006 Posted July 13, 2006 Unfortunately no. For the same reasons i can't recieve "communion" at my parent's Methodist Church, as much as they pressure me that "all can recieve" and "it's only a sign, so it wouldn't stand in the way of your faith". But by my participation in that fakeness, even if they don't call it a sacrement, it would be telling them that i approve of their doctrine. Your friend is in a very unique place, though. Because he can't accept the position of pastor, they are going to be very curious as to why, and he will have the opportunity to explain to them what he believes and why it would be so grave of him to assume to be "ordained" in any manner [not Catholic]. Also, if they do decide to allow him to be a youth minister in an ecumenical manner, then he's at an even GREATER advantage, and one that the "bishop" of this church may or may not like so much once he figures it out. Of course, he would need to keep to teaching mainly what the "bishop" perscribed, and never teach any falsities. But he could also help these kids to understand what being Catholic really means, and why he's so adament about his religion and his faith. MANY protestants have very ill concieved notions of what a Catholic really is. In fact, i think it was Fulton Sheen who said something along the lines of "95% of American Protestants hate the Catholic Church because of what they think they know is truth. But only 3 % know the truth of what the Church teaches and still hate it" I'll have to find that quote again somewhere.... it's obviously much better said by Sheen himself. I think your friend will play a very important role in bringing some lost brothers and sisters back into the fold of our Shepherd, Benedict.
kujo Posted July 13, 2006 Posted July 13, 2006 (edited) I dunno.... Being a "pastor" in a Protestant church doesn't really require much in the way of preparation (you can actually be "ordained" online by [url="http://openordination.org"]clicking here[/url].) or training. As such, many Protestant Churches use the word "pastor" as interchangable with "minister"(youth pastor=youth minister). Anyway, I think it would be kind of weird if he was "ordained" a Protestant Pastor. My question is why? Why does he *have* to be ordained in order to work at this church? If it is unnatural to *not* be a pastor and work at one of these churches, then isn't it also *unnatural* to be a Catholic who works at one of these churches? Edited July 13, 2006 by kujo
Groo the Wanderer Posted July 13, 2006 Posted July 13, 2006 [quote name='kujo' post='1023647' date='Jul 13 2006, 11:03 AM'] I dunno.... Being a "pastor" in a Protestant church doesn't really require much in the way of preparation (you can actually be "ordained" online by [url="http://openordination.org"]clicking here[/url].) or training. As such, many Protestant Churches use the word "pastor" as interchangable with "minister"(youth pastor=youth minister). Anyway, I think it would be kind of weird if he was "ordained" a Protestant Pastor. My question is why? Why does he *have* to be ordained in order to work at this church? If it is unnatural to *not* be a pastor and work at one of these churches, then isn't it also *unnatural* to be a Catholic who works at one of these churches? [/quote] Kujo makes a lot of good points. My wife is Protestant so I have encountered a lot of things firsthand. The term 'pastor' to them does not really mean a whole lot. In the AG/Pentacostal churches, it just means you have 'gotten your papers', which involves about 10 hours of study. In her church, for example, there are 12 peeps called 'pastor', ranging in age ffrom 18 to 50+. Ordination as well carries somewhat lesser weight. Check out the Universal Life 'church'....ordination has no study and costs ye $5. I have had no qualms at all working with her church on very specific and isolate occasions: fixed computers and thier network, helped at carnivals, etc. Under no circumstances would I ever take a title from them ('cept maybe L33t Computer G33k) nor would I accept a paid position on staff. Going further, I would sign nothing, nor testify/take an oath of anything they believe. As far as helping with the yoots, I doubt they would like me to do that...I'd have half of 'em converted the first week! Ecuminism is great...but do NOT compromise your doctrine! WORD!
God Conquers Posted July 13, 2006 Posted July 13, 2006 You don't have to get ordained to get tax benefits for ministry, at least in Canada. If you work for one year full-time for the Church you can get "clergyman status" and get the tax breaks.
Jaime Posted July 13, 2006 Posted July 13, 2006 I really don't understand the fuss over working for a protestant church. I taught nothing that would go against Church teaching nor was I ever asked to
IcePrincessKRS Posted July 13, 2006 Posted July 13, 2006 I don't think its wrong to WORK at a non-Catholic church so long as it doesn't hinder your faith. My sister in law works for a Methodist church pre-school. Its had zero negative impact on her faith, if anything its made her a stronger Catholic. Being "ordained" on the other hand I see as problematic at the very least.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now