Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Seatbelt Blue
Posted

I want to make clear I'm in no way denying the truth of the Real Presence in this post; the Eucharist is, indeed, the source and summit of all Catholic life, and I am a very Eucharist-centered individual. What I'm exploring is how we understand the means by which bread and wine become Body and Blood, and the language we use to express that understanding.

Is the language of transubstantiation still a valid means of expressing the Eucharistic miracle in a post-modern world that rejects the dichotomy it demands?

Can we express the reality of a non-physical ontological change apart from the Aristotelian/Thomistic view of substantial v accidental being?

Can it mean anything to say that, in the Eucharist, the substance of the bread and wine change, while the accidents do not, or is that language itself outdated and irrelevant in modern society?

Is there a better way? Can we express the truth of the Eucharist in a way that makes sense to the world at large, can we frame the argument in a better way? John Paul successfully recast the Catholic sexual ethic into humanist terms -- can we make the Eucharist relevant to postmodern society?

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Seatbelt Blue' post='1025618' date='Jul 16 2006, 05:26 PM']
I want to make clear I'm in no way denying the truth of the Real Presence in this post; the Eucharist is, indeed, the source and summit of all Catholic life, and I am a very Eucharist-centered individual. What I'm exploring is how we understand the means by which bread and wine become Body and Blood, and the language we use to express that understanding.

Is the language of transubstantiation still a valid means of expressing the Eucharistic miracle in a post-modern world that rejects the dichotomy it demands?[/quote]
Post-modernism is a crock and I don't see the necessity of attempting to reformulate doctrine according to a post-modern mentality.

[quote name='Seatbelt Blue' post='1025618' date='Jul 16 2006, 05:26 PM']Can we express the reality of a non-physical ontological change apart from the Aristotelian/Thomistic view of substantial v accidental being?[/quote]
One could try I suppose, but I kind of fail to see the point.

[quote name='Seatbelt Blue' post='1025618' date='Jul 16 2006, 05:26 PM']Can it mean anything to say that, in the Eucharist, the substance of the bread and wine change, while the accidents do not, or is that language itself outdated and irrelevant in modern society?[/quote]
It still makes sense and gets the point across so I guess if it's not broken don't fix it. The language is not outdated or irrelevant, I think the concepts there are very straight forward and that formulation expresses perfectly well what is going on.

[quote name='Seatbelt Blue' post='1025618' date='Jul 16 2006, 05:26 PM']Is there a better way? Can we express the truth of the Eucharist in a way that makes sense to the world at large, can we frame the argument in a better way? John Paul successfully recast the Catholic sexual ethic into humanist terms -- can we make the Eucharist relevant to postmodern society?
[/quote]
Frame the argument in a better way? The substance/accidents thing is not an argument. Nobody is going to be convinced of the Real Presence because you've attempted to explain it. In fact this description does not "explain" the Eucharistic Mystery, it merely describes the miracle to some extent. One does not have to be an Aristotelian or a Thomist to grasp the gist of it. It isn't really say much more than the simple description which says that Christ is truly present, Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity, under the appearance of bread and wine.
This is a dogmatic formulation of a theological mystery and I absolutely abhor the thought of appropriating the pseudo-philosophy of the post-modernists, or basing descriptions of theological realities on post-modern, or post-post-modern categories.

I've met a couple of "Catholic" post-modernists and they just annoyed the poodoo out of me. Caputo ranted on and on about how Aquinas probably wasn't a saint and the Dominicans probably invented all the stories of his piety and such, and that God ought to be called "she" and yadi yadi yah.. It wasn't exactly getting me stoked. Oh, and of course there was a heavy dose of Augustine bashing, undermining of the Catholic Tradition, an agenda of complete revisionism, etc. Yes, we should bend to Heidegger and ought to consider Derrida to be some kind of delphic oracle. Heidegger sure took the liberal protestants places (Bultmann and company) and Derrida is surely a future doctor of the Church (sarcasm).

Quite frankly the Eucharist is absolutely relevant to contemporary society. What needs to happen is that the Faith needs to actually be proclaimed for a change, not revamped. I am totally serious, in my view postmodern thought has very little to offer to Catholic theology. That is what they want anyway. They want us to feel undermined and defensive. Like the Borg Queen they want us to submit willingly to their assimilation (forgive the Star Trek analogy). And quite frankly Catholic philosophy and theology affords a vastly superior world-view. The major problem is that authentic Catholic thought it a bit hard to come by at times.

That's my initial reaction anyway.

Cheers

Seatbelt Blue
Posted

Hey, Laudate, thanks for replying, although, forgive me if I'm misreading you, you seemed to react with some hostility. Such is not necessary; I'm not intent on denying any aspect of Catholicism, but rather, reconsidering how we present ourselves to the world.

I'm something of a student of language and its use -- language is immensely important to our lives, especially as Catholics, because Catholicism as a faith is intensely, even passionately invested in ideas. How we express an idea, though, is not absolutely rooted to the idea itself any more than a story is tied to the text that expresses it.

I want to clarify that I'm not saying that Catholicism should embrace postmodern philosophy; rather, I'm attempting to present the idea that perhaps the Thomistic language is less than clear to today's world, and that we may need to re-evaluate the language involved.

As for your contention that the language is not outdated, I'm not saying -- or least, I did not intend to say -- that it by necessity is. However, I'm concerned that it might be, judging by the incredulity of my nonCatholic friends when the idea is presented to them. Frankly, unless we can express truth in language that people can deal with, we can't express truth to them. On some level we have to "go native" with the truth, frame it in post-modern terms.

(it's worth noting that post-modernism is far more varied and nuanced than its caricature as little else than relativists denying the very concept of truth; it's absolutely possible to express truth to a postmodern world in a postmodern way; indeed, the very notion of evaluating language in the transmission of the idea has postmodern roots, and in that, the second Vatican council contailed elements of postmodern thought, considering as it had as a goal finding new ways to present old ideas, but I digress)

I also have not denied the relevance of the Eucharist, as you seem to imply. What I'm questioning is whether the language we use to present and understand the Eucharist undercuts how much the postmodern mind can appreciate that relevance. The brilliance of the Real Presence is so important -- so bleeding important! -- and I'm very concerned that the language we use might fail to bring to the fore the Eucharist's centrality and importance.

(Personally, I tend to think it may have been a bad idea to pin down exactly what the manner in which the Real Presence enters into the world, so to speak, and lean toward what Orthodoxy calls "pious silence;" but the horse is way out of the gate by now.)

Anyway, this is just exploration of an idea. I've reached no firm conclusions, personally, on how the language has effected perception, and whether or not, then, we need to reforumlate our expression of the truth.

Peace

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

What terms would you have us use?

I think there is some trouble in having us understand where substance and accident somehow "fall short" of explaining transubstantiation in modern terms?

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

I disagree with the idea that the classical description of transubstantiation is outdated for several reasons. The first has to do with the apparent basis of your assertion that it is outdated. Your basis seems to be simply that the language is not automatically intuitive to "modern", presumably secular persons. This is in no way a mark of outdated language in my opinion. The Church has a unique and vast tradition and has its own language and conceptual framework. If you look at Church history I think it is pretty clear that a vast number of doctrinal disputes were largely semantic in nature. The Church has hammered out its definitions and descriptions over many centuries and it is not merely bold, but dangerously presumptuous to assume that one can just recast everything in a new framework.
But the real point was that the test of the validity or 'relevance' of terminology is not whether or not it is intuitive to non-Catholics. Learning the faith always requires some degree of instruction and it always has. Even in the early church the language of Catholic doctrine was distinct from the secular mainstream and initiation involved catechesis and the like.
The reason I consider the substance/accidents thing to be perfectly adequate as a surface description of the nature of transubstantiation is because it really is not difficult to explain and for people to grasp. It is also an authoritative formulation and thus one can be confident that they are truly representing the Church and not simply passing on ideas or concepts foreign to the Faith.

But I have never said that in evangelization one must be limited merely to this little definition in attempting to elucidate the nature and significance of the Eucharist to a non-Catholic. But in this case I don't know that post-modern thought would provide a very appropriate base of inspiration for such an end.
There is a very vast and rich theology of the Eucharist which goes far beyond that simple substance/accidence distinction.

Something that I've seen too much of, and is perhaps my biggest pet peeve, is when people (often times even professors) who have what really constitutes a superficial grasp of authentic Catholic Theology, presume to "improve" and "revise" that Theology. It is foolish.

But attempting to reach people where they're at in one's evangelistic or apostolic endeavors can be quite a noble thing, but I would stress first mastering orthodox theology and then perhaps attempting to express certain things in different words in the hope of reaching people more effectively. There is just a crisis today whereby everyone who's read a little Rahner or Von Balthasar seems to feel qualified and compelled to architect a new Catholicism according to their perceived problems with the way it currently stands. My view is simply that we already have far more in the deposit of faith than most people probably realize and the real way to improve evangelization is to tap into the treasury of wisdom and tradition that we already possess.

This post is not directed at you specifically, it is just that subject matter of this kind gives me flashbacks of dealings with all manner of strange liberal pseudo-Catholics. Wolves in sheeps clothing if you ask me. Please don't interpret my attitude as an attack toward you. I just strongly resent "progressive", "liberal" catholicism. It is a load of carp.

Seatbelt Blue
Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' post='1025669' date='Jul 16 2006, 06:26 PM']
What terms would you have us use?

I think there is some trouble in having us understand where substance and accident somehow "fall short" of explaining transubstantiation in modern terms?
[/quote]

You'll notice my original post is all questions. I don't have answers, nor "would I have you" change anything. Is it difficult to understand I'm trying to explore an idea, not defend or attack one?

My concern is that the concepts of substance and accident don't exist in the modern mind outside of Catholic thought about the Eucharist. The very notion seems to be utterly divorced from our actual experience of reality. And if, in the tradition of John Paul II, we are to explore theology through phenomenology, we must first take as our frame of reference human experience, and not theological abstraction.

Unless we are able to express Catholicism as a faith relevant and rooted in humanity's experience of both the divine and of the created world, I fear -- note, I do not yet believe this, but it concerns me -- that Catholicism cannot begin to confront the crisis of Western humanism -- the very act of cultural abortion, to say nothing of the damnable holocaust of infants that is itself merely a symptom of a larger illness.

If Pope John Paul could recount the Sexual ethic in humanist terms, to explain WHY it's relevant to the lives of the youth of the world, why can we not re-evaluate the language expressing the Eucharist? This is not to tear it down, to destroy it, but to reveal it for the splendor it offers, to keep it as the center of the Catholic experience.

Justified Saint
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1025629' date='Jul 16 2006, 04:49 PM']

This is a dogmatic formulation of a theological mystery
[/quote]

LD, are you suggesting that the classic Aristotelian/Thomistic description of transubstantiation is a matter of dogma? If you are, that doesn't seem right, though I hesitate to question a church scholar. (whimpers in fear :ohno:)

:)

Seatbelt,

The Holy Father Pope Benedict XVI is a student of phenomenology as well, though in his book [i]Introduction to Christianity[/i] he explicitly says that while phenomenology has its uses it couldn't be the basis of a Christology.

Edited by Justified Saint
Seatbelt Blue
Posted

Laudate, thanks for the post. I appreciate your clarification and understand your concerns. I wish to further stress I have drawn no conclusions, nor am I attempting to move theological mountains. But language has always been a great passion of mine, and so I am acutely aware as to how expression affects understanding, and as such, I am very concerned that the Eucharist has been ill-expressed to the modern mind.

I have with you, Laudate, a firm disagreement that the existence of a Catholic technical vocabulary stands at all to justify the obtuse terminology and phrasology we use to understand the Eucharist. The extensive use of jargon can stand as an obstacle and stumbling block to those people exploring the faith, to those on the edges who find that the expression of the faith as enunciated by St. Thomas Aquinas stands at odds with their fundamental human experience, which does not distinguish between accidents and substance, at least in those terms.

At the very least I believe that a philosophical vocabulary expressing ontology over form rather than specialized, arcane vocabulary set down a thousand years ago. Let's not forget that as a culture we tend to reject things formulated even thirty years ago -- are we so rooted to Thomism that we cannot validly express these things in any other way? At the very least, should we not at least be exploring the options? Thomism is a philosophical method, not a part of the deposit of faith -- and because it has been adequate in the past does not mean it necessarily remains so.

(of course, nor does it necessarily mean it no longer is. I believe there is absolutely a place for the Thomistic approach, but perhaps now isn't the moment for its ascendance to be so strictly enforced.)

[quote name='Justified Saint' post='1025688' date='Jul 16 2006, 06:48 PM']

Seatbelt,

The Holy Father Pope Benedict XVI is a student of phenomenology as well, though in his book [i]Introduction to Christianity[/i] he explicitly says that while phenomenology has its uses it couldn't be the basis of a Christology.
[/quote]

Hi, thanks. I admit I have yet to read Benedict's Introduction -- but it was not my intention to propose phenomenology as a basis for a Christology as much as an approach to our existing Christology, a means to express truth to postmodernity. As I've said -- it worked for John Paul II's Theology of the Body.

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

Seatbelt,

You must have some idea of what you're looking for with answers? Like, L_D, I am just unsure why one would assert that the classical terms used by Aristotle and Aquinas don't "fit" in the modern world. Substance and Accident are not religious terms.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Justified Saint' post='1025688' date='Jul 16 2006, 06:48 PM']
LD, are you suggesting that the classic Aristotelian/Thomistic description of transubstantiation is a matter of dogma? If you are, that doesn't seem right, though I hesitate to question a church scholar. (whimpers in fear :ohno:)
[/quote]
It is a formulation that has appeared in dogmatic canons and decrees. Trent is the primary source if you're interested in looking it up. The doctrine of transubstantiation is declared and given formulation along the lines of this substance / accidents distinction.
This does not mean that there is no other way to describe the Eucharistic Mystery, nor does this mean that there is not a very large and profound theology of the Eucharist. The point of the decree was to clarify the Catholic position in contrast with certain protestant doctrines regarding the Eucharist which were explicit denials of Transubstantiation. Actually you mention the "classic aristotelian/thomistic description of transubstantiation", by which I assume you mean the understanding of the miracle involved in the Eucharist according to classical substance metaphysics. The problem is that the word itself, transubstantiation, implies this classical substance metaphysics so I can't imagine there being a description of transubstantiation that deviated from the substance/accidents perspective. I think this is why certain modern heretics, in their attempt to "revise" Catholicism, typically jettison the term altogether. My favourite *gags* being "transignification". Oh yay.

[quote name='Justified Saint' post='1025688' date='Jul 16 2006, 06:48 PM']
Seatbelt,

The Holy Father Pope Benedict XVI is a student of phenomenology as well, though in his book [i]Introduction to Christianity[/i] he explicitly says that while phenomenology has its uses it couldn't be the basis of a Christology.
[/quote]
I was thinking of that earlier actually. The point was going to be that in all such endeavors we ought to look to the Magisterium and the faithful clergy and theologians (as well as saints and doctors) for guidance and inspiration. But most of all such an endeavor ought to be approached with reverence, humility and prayer. Naturally.
People often think of JP2 as being this radical phenomenologist/personalist (rad trads love to play on that) because he explained many things (particular teachings on morality) in a way that was to some extent new and 'modern'. What often isn't stressed enough however, was that JP2's thought was foundationally Thomistic and he never compromised not only doctrines, but even key philosophical underpinnings. You can incorporate phenomenological method into Catholic philosophical reflection, but it is peripheral in many ways to the core metaphysical realism which is in my opinion necessary for maintaining orthodoxy.
That is one of the major problems I've had with the handful of "Catholic" post-modern philosophers that I've encountered. They tend to be openly hostile to realism and metaphysics, at least in any sense of those words which is compatible with Catholicism.

This is a long and complex discussion; I remember getting into this to some extent with Revprodiji a while back, but despite the common view that the Church does not endorse any one philosophy over another etc. and therefore a person's philosophy doesn't really matter as long as they don't contradict dogma is utterly false.
I would say that it is certainly true that the Church doesn't spell out a concrete philosophical system which is canonical and dogmatic, but the Faith, and really Christianity in general, bears with it a certain world-view and a certain philosophical content which does define a scope in which one's philosphical views ought to adhere otherwise there will be adverse effects.
Again, it is a long and complex subject and I'd hate to rant on and on about it because I'm not sure anyone really cares at this point.

Cheers

Seatbelt Blue
Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' post='1025707' date='Jul 16 2006, 07:00 PM']
Seatbelt,

You must have some idea of what you're looking for with answers? Like, L_D, I am just unsure why one would assert that the classical terms used by Aristotle and Aquinas don't "fit" in the modern world. Substance and Accident are not religious terms.
[/quote]

If I had a sense of an answer, it would be dishonest of me to ask the question. I have a notion that I'm exploring, and trying to see if it can stand -- that our present language is inadequate. I posted this on my Xanga looking for answers there as well, but I thought to myself "Phatmass has people educated in the field I've wandered into."

I believe the concepts are themselves divorced from the human experience. Explaining the concept to one not predisposed to the notion that ontology can be seperated from form is doomed to failure. Especially considering that we're trying to explain something fundamentally mysterious, that the presence of our God should be present in such an insignificant thing -- using terminology derived from a man who believed our eyes emit light.

Essentially, the notion that a hat isn't the hat itself, but that the substance hat possesses the attributed we associate with hats, seems opposed to the experience of the world, and in addition, to the Incarnation itself, in light of John Paul's assertion that our humanity is tied up in our physicality, and as such (although I may be misinterpreting), we are not, for instance, a substance inhabiting a form, but that form and substance are themselves intimately tied together. In short, configuration, it would seem, matters.

Stuff counts, to quote George Weigel's fundamental thesis in [i]Letters to a Young Catholic[/i].

With that in mind, the idea that the ontology is seperated from form, that existence is simply ghosts inhabiting machines, and that our humanity is seperate and distinct from our bodies, it seems to follow that even the very distinction between male and female falters.

I hope I've made myself clear.

Justified Saint
Posted (edited)

Seatbelt,

You may find Jean-Luc Marion's book [i]God Without Being[/i] of some use in your attempts to rethink the semantics of the Eucharist. I have really only skimmed this book so I really can't comment on it one way or the other, but Marion speaks of the "Eucharistic hermeneutic" as a "revamped" form of God-talk. Now I imagine that what I have described is suspicion enough for many, but suffice it to say that Marion is more or less a Catholic postmodernist.

I for one am not unsympathetic to Marion's attempt to re-think the semantics of God, and thus I guess by extension also the doctrine of transubstantiation, but as long as such an attempt has some genuine concern behind it and not, as LD said, just trying to "fit in" with (post)modernity.

Edited by Justified Saint
Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Justified Saint' post='1025718' date='Jul 16 2006, 07:16 PM']
Seatbelt,

You may find Jean-Luc Marion's book [i]God Without Being[/i] of some use in your attempts to rethink the semantics of the Eucharist. I have really only skimmed this book so I really can't comment on it one way or the other, but Marion speaks of the "Eucharistic hermeneutic" as a "revamped" form of God-talk. Now I imagine that what I have described is suspicion enough for many, but suffice it to say that Marion is more or less a Catholic postmodernist.

I for one am not unsympathetic to Marion's attempt to re-think the semantics of God, and thus I guess by extension also the doctrine of transubstantiation, but as long as such an attempt has some genuine concern behind it and not, as LD said, just trying to "fit in" with (post)modernity.
[/quote]
Omgosh!!! That's one of those rare books that I dream about at night.. longingly.. oh my.. *snaps back*

And you mentioned [i]Symbolism [/i] the other day.. You've got darn good taste my friend.

Seatbelt Blue
Posted

For the sake of full disclosure, may I reproduce this thread on my Xanga for the consumption of my readers?

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

I would also recommend The Hidden Manna as a good foundational overview of the theology of the Eucharist (takes a historical approach) and perhaps a bit of Bouyer after that..

Although quite frankly if the intent is to communicate something of the meaning of the Eucharist to the hoi polloi, I wouldn't recommend studying this stuff. Well, I recommend studying this stuff because it's very important, but I agree that evangelizing with the Church's full array of jargon would not get you very far.

In my experience the best place to turn for giving expression to these mysteries of Divine Love is to the writings of great saints.
Rather than quoting Trent or Thomas, I would seek inspiration from Francis and Clare, Faustina, Therese, Conchita, Veronica Guilliani, Mother Teresa, Padre Pio, Peter Julian Eymard, De Liguori, Francisco and Jacinta Marto, Maria Maddalena, etc..

Also the Encyclicals of the Popes. There have been a number of profound encyclicals on the Eucharist and certainly the Encyclicals of John Paul II, as well as the documents of Vatican II, speak to modern man as it were.

I just think this would likely be a more wise and fruitful approach than taking on a project of revision. Although certainly you would be putting yourself into your evangelization. Your own experience, ideas and spirituality would inform the whole thing. But it is better to be the disciple than the teacher, for only one is the teacher. There is but one Rabbi, one master.


[quote name='Seatbelt Blue' post='1025721' date='Jul 16 2006, 07:27 PM']
For the sake of full disclosure, may I reproduce this thread on my Xanga for the consumption of my readers?
[/quote]
Doesn't bother me at all. :)

Seatbelt Blue
Posted

LD, I agree with you wholeheartedly. Sounds like the advice I'm always giving to everyone myself -- but as always my arrogance and ambition run away with me.

Thanks for dragging me down to earth.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Seatbelt Blue' post='1025725' date='Jul 16 2006, 07:35 PM']
LD, I agree with you wholeheartedly. Sounds like the advice I'm always giving to everyone myself -- but as always my arrogance and ambition run away with me.

Thanks for dragging me down to earth.
[/quote]
dang, sweet. maybe next time my ambition takes over you'll remind me of this stuff. :)

Posted

What do we understand to happen in the Eucharist? It is something still more mysterious than what happens in an "ordinary" miracle. The one body of Christ, that walked this earth 2000 years ago, is made present to us bodily, existing and operating where we see only small pieces of bread. This presence is of the whole individual body of Christ as he exists but the condition of his body in the sacrament is outside the order of nature. To all appearances and for all natural purposes, such as our nourishment by the bread, it is the accidents of the bread that are operating upon our senses and bodies. Under God's power they continue to act as they would in the natural order, but now virtually as substances themselves. To them too belong the natural consequences of individual physical existence, such as location in a particular time and place.

Christ is present substantially only, and hence not with all the attributes of physical existence as we ordinarily understand them. Though he is really where the host is, he is not contained by the limits of its particular place. He is not therefore physically located in the various places where the sacrament is celebrated. For though he retains his due quantity and place they are only operative as accidents where he exists simply according to a natural mode. In his sacramental presence he exists with his natural accidents, but they are there in a supernatural mode. He is not there with them operative in a natural mode with their natural consequences. That natural mode of place belongs only to the accidents of the bread. Christ's body is present not in such a way as to be limited by the determinate quantity of the bread but by virtue of the fact that the substance of the bread, what was bread, has been converted into his body.

Is it true to say, then, that Christ is "physically" present in the Eucharist? We can perhaps appreciate that we have to be very careful here to define exactly what we mean by "physically". Taken in the sense "by 'physical' here is not meant 'bodily' but 'in the order of actual existence'", Christ is definitely "physically" present. That is generally what people mean by "real presence". Hardly any Catholic would dispute that. The doctrine, if it says anything, says that Christ is really actually present.

Is it correct to say, then, that Christ is "physically" present when we mean that he is present in his human body? Thomists, and those who can appreciate the distinction between substance and accident, have no difficulty with using this expression. For they know that the doctrine says that the substance of Christ's body is present under the appearances of bread. It is true, therefore, to say that Christ is physically, if only according to all that he is in the mode or manner of substance, so present. All the physical (bodily) reality of Christ as man, becomes bodily present, as true as if he were teaching us in the Synagogue in Jerusalem.

Why then can we not see him or hear him with our senses of sight and hearing? Simply because he is there supernaturally (which transcends not only our senses but also our natural reason). To put it in philosophical terms the reason is that the accidents whereby and through which we would normally perceive the substance of his body, are not functioning naturally. So we do not see his body nor do we understand without faith that he is present bodily. Nonetheless, given that faith assures us of the fact, there is no philosophical reason why we cannot say that Christ is physically present, by reason of him being bodily present, according to his (individual) substance.

But we do not want to bind ordinary language to the language of philosophy. If the ordinary person means by "physically" a body that is visible, tangible etc, or a physical substance with all qualities etc functioning in a natural way then we can agree that Christ is not physically present in that complete natural sense. If people's education in science constrains them to consider the natural and the physical purely in terms of what is perceptible by the senses, or observable, then they will tend to equate "physical" existence or presence with the order of accidents, or appearances or "phenomena". In that case, there is more reason to say that Christ is not physically present - for what is meant is that his presence is not able to be detected or verified by natural means of observation. This is something that the person of faith will readily concede.

We will only object if people assert that things can only exist naturally, and are known only through their appearances, or as some believe science to be saying, are known only in their appearances. Such a position is not an open common sense or scientific one, as some would like us to believe. It does not avoid taking a philosophical position. That position generally speaking has the name naturalism; in its grosser forms it may also be called materialism and sensism.

One does not have much chance of communicating the deep significance of transubstantiation to people firmly committed to philosophies such as these, which would exclude the possibility of faith in an a priori fashion and also arbitrarily limit the scope of human reason. It is rather sad that our modern education in science, influenced in no small way by such naturalistic, and ultimately atheistic, philosophies, should prevent many from more fully appreciating the wondrous event that daily takes place in the celebration of the Eucharist.

The age of miracles is past, some want us to believe. This is said when the greatest miracle of all is being performed at every time of the day all around the world. What is lacking, then, is not the miraculous power of God, but faith.

Justified Saint
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1025715' date='Jul 16 2006, 06:10 PM']
It is a formulation that has appeared in dogmatic canons and decrees. Trent is the primary source if you're interested in looking it up. The doctrine of transubstantiation is declared and given formulation along the lines of this substance / accidents distinction.
This does not mean that there is no other way to describe the Eucharistic Mystery, nor does this mean that there is not a very large and profound theology of the Eucharist. The point of the decree was to clarify the Catholic position in contrast with certain protestant doctrines regarding the Eucharist which were explicit denials of Transubstantiation. Actually you mention the "classic aristotelian/thomistic description of transubstantiation", by which I assume you mean the understanding of the miracle involved in the Eucharist according to classical substance metaphysics. The problem is that the word itself, transubstantiation, implies this classical substance metaphysics so I can't imagine there being a description of transubstantiation that deviated from the substance/accidents perspective. I think this is why certain modern heretics, in their attempt to "revise" Catholicism, typically jettison the term altogether. My favourite *gags* being "transignification". Oh yay.
[/quote]

Wow, somehow I totally didn't see your post here -- I just figured you were ignoring my question. :)

Anyway, it had not escaped my notice that the very word "transubstantiation" already seems to suggest the classical metaphysical description of the miracle of the Eucharist in which the word has its origin. Thus perhaps my question could be simply stated: Is transubstantiation a matter of dogma? (which already seemed implied in this thread's first post)

The answer would seem yes, of course, since one canon from the Council of Trent reads:

"{A bunch of important text}...which change the Catholic Church most aptly calls transubstantiation, let him be anathema."

I asked the question because according to James T. Connor in [i]The Hidden Manna[/i]:
[quote]The official teaching of the Church on this matter...has never employed the concepts and terminology of Aristotle to the extent that Aquinas did. It has even generally abstained from using the word [i]accidents[/i].[/quote]

Based on this it seems that one could separate the doctrine of transubstantiation with its Thomistic/classical metaphysical framework. The doctrine does not necessitate a certain kind of description, but I guess you have already said that anyway. :)




[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1025720' date='Jul 16 2006, 06:24 PM']
Omgosh!!! That's one of those rare books that I dream about at night.. longingly.. oh my.. *snaps back*

And you mentioned [i]Symbolism [/i] the other day.. You've got darn good taste my friend.
[/quote]


Even Jean-Luc "I can't get enough of Derrida" Marion? :cool:

Edited by Justified Saint
Posted

I think the point is relevant. Although clergy, scholars, and students of theology are very well acquainted with words like "transubstantiation", the overwhelmingly vast majority of the rest of the Church is not. Although the big words and fancy theological explanations are sound and remain of great use and importance, we must convey these things in ways more easily understood.

How about this?

Let's say you're watching a science fiction movie and a kid named Danny has a spell put on him so that he disappears. Later, you find out that he was mysteriously and mystically sealed into the town tree. When Danny's friends figure this out, they find the evil witch responsible and learn that the tree was destroyed as part of the spell the moment Danny was sealed in the tree's form - only the tree's appearance remained to house Danny's trapped body. The plot unravels with the efforts of Danny's friends to transform the tree back into Danny.

The doctrine itself, instead of merely being illustrated, could be simply explained without the use of the words "accidents" or "transubstantiation". Just substitute the word "metaphysics" for "substance" and "physics" for "accidents". Physically, the host remains bread and wine. But physics do not dictate what a thing [i]is[/i] - they only manifest it. Metaphysics are what dictate identity. Once the children in the above analogy learn the truth, they no longer refer to the tree as a tree, but as "Danny" since they know the tree is no longer there. In the consecration, the whole Body, Blood, Soul, and Divinity of the entire Jesus-the-Person replace the metaphysics of the bread and wine. The physics give form to this metaphysical reality. This is why Christ's [i]physical body [/i] had to ascend to Heaven, beyond time and space; to grant the metaphysical ability to be present in every piece and drop of the Eucharist throughout time...

At least that is my understanding.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...