Laudate_Dominum Posted July 17, 2006 Posted July 17, 2006 Transubstantiation isn't too complicated a word for Harry Potter. They use the word in those books except they've changed the meaning. There a several other Catholic words that have been hi-jacked in the Harry Potter series. If you used the term in discussion with a Harry Potter fanatic they'd likely understand you to be saying that the priest is a magician or a wizard, doing some hocus pocus. And of course there are times when you don't use "big words" (they really aren't difficult words at all, but whatever) to describe Catholic teachings. If I was explaining the Real Presence to a bunch of first graders I would likely use simpler language. But I don't see how it follows from this that the church should abandon her theology of the Eucharist and ought to revise everything according to some new modernist framework. There will always be technical language in theology, and technical language always takes some study to grasp. The language of average joe secular people is not adequate for theology. And the Church's theological vocabulary is beyond any one language and culture. The terms are english versions of latin or greek terminology. By this thinking there should be a dummified theology for americans (well, maybe a few flavours of this too, ebonics and such), and one for france, england, germany, china, etc..) There is absolutely nothing stopping people from explaining the doctrine of the Eucharist without the words accidents or transubstantiation. This is normal actually. But I think it's silly that people are so hung up on these words since they actually are very effective in catechesis. And as a personal preference, if I were being catechizes I would want all the official technical language and stuff. It is kind of insulting to assume that people will find such terms too difficult or "irrelevent". All that irrelevent carp is just liberal progressive propaganda. They have a line of reasoning that sounds plausible and people get roped into thinking that way, but in reality there is nothing reasonable about it. The truths of the faith are timeless and I think it is the most relevent thing in the world actually. I was once a secular type dude and when I started studying Catholicism I never felt that the theology was "irrelevent". That's just a clever way of saying they want to replace it with their own religion. They want to undermine Catholicism and infect it with their strange religious philosophy. They want to replace authentic spritituality with pop psychology and coherent theology with man-centered blasphemy.
Laudate_Dominum Posted July 17, 2006 Posted July 17, 2006 [quote name='Ziggamafu' post='1025823' date='Jul 16 2006, 11:58 PM'] I think the point is relevant. Although clergy, scholars, and students of theology are very well acquainted with words like "transubstantiation", the overwhelmingly vast majority of the rest of the Church is not. Although the big words and fancy theological explanations are sound and remain of great use and importance, we must convey these things in ways more easily understood. How about this? Let's say you're watching a science fiction movie and a kid named Danny has a spell put on him so that he disappears. Later, you find out that he was mysteriously and mystically sealed into the town tree. When Danny's friends figure this out, they find the evil witch responsible and learn that the tree was destroyed as part of the spell the moment Danny was sealed in the tree's form - only the tree's appearance remained to house Danny's trapped body. The plot unravels with the efforts of Danny's friends to transform the tree back into Danny. The doctrine itself, instead of merely being illustrated, could be simply explained without the use of the words "accidents" or "transubstantiation". Just substitute the word "metaphysics" for "substance" and "physics" for "accidents". Physically, the host remains bread and wine. But physics do not dictate what a thing [i]is[/i] - they only manifest it. Metaphysics are what dictate identity. Once the children in the above analogy learn the truth, they no longer refer to the tree as a tree, but as "Danny" since they know the tree is no longer there. In the consecration, the whole Body, Blood, Soul, and Divinity of the entire Jesus-the-Person replace the metaphysics of the bread and wine. The physics give form to this metaphysical reality. This is why Christ's [i]physical body [/i] had to ascend to Heaven, beyond time and space; to grant the metaphysical ability to be present in every piece and drop of the Eucharist throughout time... At least that is my understanding. [/quote] The words metaphysics and substance, physics and accidents are not synonymous. Besides being a very ambiguous presentation I don't see how this change in words is somehow supposed to be more clear or precise than the traditional Catholic formulation. Why coin some new synonymous terms, which would probably just confuse people, when the words substance and accidents are already sufficient? Often times people will avoid the term accidents and use something like substance and appearance. This is absolutely fine, but to say physics and metaphysics is just strange and doesn't make a whole lot of sense. This is a good illustration of the fact that in most cases when people presume to "improve" Catholic theology their solution is far worth than that which they were hoping to improve. And I would be worried about spreading heresy, because someone could easily understand your explanation in a heretical way. I think the surface meaning of it is in fact heretical. And have you read Harry Potter? I think it's amusing that you use a scenario involving spells and changing people into trees in a discussion of transubstantiation.
Ziggamafu Posted July 17, 2006 Posted July 17, 2006 (edited) In many ways, God's use of the physical and mundane world to convey grace in supernatural ways is very much like "magic" - at least so far as our experience and witness of that grace is concerned. The difference, of course, between magic and sacramental grace is that (traditionally defined) "magic" seeks to control God for selfish purposes and "sacramental works" seek to be controlled by God for selfless purposes. Still, the experience is very "magical" and the term seems fitting in cautionary instances where these mysterious interactions between God and his Mystical Body take place... I see nothing heretical about what I said. The Eucharist, physically, remains bread and wine. This is what the term "accidents" means; look at our eucharistic Lord under a microscope, study his form, and you will always and only be examining the physics of bread and wine. On the contrary, I wonder if it might not be heresy to say that Christ is physically present in the Eucharist. Aside from negating the very purpose of being consumed under these signs (to avoid the scandalous and grotesque appearance of cannibalism) this challenges the need for Christ's return from the Father's Right Hand. I did in fact use an explanation involving "magic" and the like with Harry Potter in mind. That would seem to fit Seatbelt's reasoning behind this thread as the Potter series is well known and loved by so many people. Oh, and by the way: [quote]met·a·phys·ics ( P ) Pronunciation Key (mt-fzks) n. (used with a sing. verb) Philosophy. The branch of philosophy that examines the [b]nature of reality[/b], including the relationship between mind and matter, [b]substance[/b] and attribute, fact and value. [/quote] When we are speaking of something beneath or transcending the physical we are speaking of the metaphysical. And the words "physics" and "metaphysics" are far more generally understood than the theological terms, even if they are used occassionally in pop culture. Edited July 17, 2006 by Ziggamafu
Laudate_Dominum Posted July 17, 2006 Posted July 17, 2006 This is what of the most absurb conversations I've ever had. The use of Transubstantiation in Harry Potter is offensive and anti-catholic. Substance is an aspect of metaphysics but they are not synonymous. You said, "The Eucharist, physically, remains bread and wine", on the surface this is heretical. What I think you mean is "accidentally"; there is a difference. Harry Potter, and the average uncatechized secular person are not the standard by which Catholic Theology is shaped. This is actually a very offensive discussion to me because it has absolutely no appreciation for the wisdom of the Church and her 2,000 year theological tradition. Knock yourself trying to give watered down explanations of the faith, I'll stick with the real deal. I'm out.
Fides_et_Ratio Posted July 18, 2006 Posted July 18, 2006 ... we have to be VERY (very, very, very, very) careful in defining and using terms. This is reason I am hesitant to change the language regarding the Eucharist. The present terms are rather precise. Perhaps our difficulty in explaining the Eucharist to others lies in our definitions, if we don't have a firm grasp on the meanings of the words we use, we will elaborate confusion, not Catholic truth.
Franimus Posted July 18, 2006 Posted July 18, 2006 hmn.. I have no clue what "accidents" or "metaphysics" are... but I'm by no means secular or uneducated. (well, maybe slightly theologically uneducated... but that's why i'm here) I think that being able to explain mysteries such as the Eucharist is plain terms, even if you have to use only analogies, is very beneficial for evangelizing. Personally, I tend to say things such as "Bread and wine are changed into Body and Blood, but maintain the [u]appearance[/u] and effects of bread and wine" I also agree in that the wording is extremely important, and thus it is extremely important that this thread receives proper attention to detail.
Laudate_Dominum Posted July 19, 2006 Posted July 19, 2006 [quote name='Franimus' post='1026608' date='Jul 18 2006, 05:34 AM'] hmn.. I have no clue what "accidents" or "metaphysics" are... but I'm by no means secular or uneducated. (well, maybe slightly theologically uneducated... but that's why i'm here) I think that being able to explain mysteries such as the Eucharist is plain terms, even if you have to use only analogies, is very beneficial for evangelizing. Personally, I tend to say things such as "Bread and wine are changed into Body and Blood, but maintain the [u]appearance[/u] and effects of bread and wine" I also agree in that the wording is extremely important, and thus it is extremely important that this thread receives proper attention to detail. [/quote] Exactly, I totally agree. And that's why I think framing the discussion in terms of the inadequacy of Catholic doctrine on the subject is totally false. The technical language is very precise and important, and the subject of evangelizing is pretty different altogether. It makes a lot more sense to explain the Eucharist in terms of bread and wine becoming the Body and Blood of Christ whilst maintaining the appearance of bread and wine then it does to say that the metaphysics and physics have changed or some such thing. If one needs a precise technical definition I'd suggest authentic Catholic theology and doctrine. Thanks Fran.
Aloysius Posted July 19, 2006 Posted July 19, 2006 I think modern physics actually support the idea of Aristotelian metaphysics, because they've made us more certain than ever about how certain we are about the nature of things. if the substance of every partical of bread down to the quarks was suddenly altered but it still maintained the same atomic structure and electron values per molecule, it would still act just like bread to us.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now