Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Immaculate Conception vs. Birth pain (Rev 12:2)


Recommended Posts

Posted

Does anyone have a quote proving the Church considered Rev 12:2 before defining Mary's Immaculate Conception? Has the Church/Father defined how we are to read this section of scripture? I seem only to find orthodox interpretations/links that do not include a reference.

Quite often, the apologetic response is, "While Rev 11-12 refers to Mary, it also refers to Israel, Eve, and the Church. So, the birth pains do not apply to Mary here since we already know she is immaculately conceived," etc. Some circular logic occurs.

My very pregnate, tired, irritable and pregnate wife is craving a response. :disguise:

Posted (edited)

I don't believe the Church teaches as a matter of doctrine that Mary was without birth pangs. If she could feel sorrow (as she did at the foot of the Cross), and she could die before her Assumption (as the Eastern Churches believe), then she could most certainly feel pain during childbirth.

Our Lord himself was without original sin, yet he still bore the effects. The same is true of Our Lady. Although, it is possible she did not feel birth pangs, but this would be a special miracle for the joyous occasion, rather than out of necessity for her immaculate state.

St. Paul speaks of having "birth pangs" in his Apostolic ministry. It doesn't have to be literal, especially in the book of Revelation which is largely symbolic.

Edited by Era Might
goldenchild17
Posted

Some people also say that because the woman in Revelation also refers to Israel and to the Church, that the birth pangs are a reference to one of them in some way. I'll see what else I find.

Posted

Era's right. Even though they didn't have O.S. its affects still applied to both Jesus and Mary. They both aged, for example (obviously it's clearer with Mary, since she lived longer than Jesus' 33 years, but you still get it). Following that to its logical conclusion, we can assume that she experienced birth pains.

As for the scripture, I'm pretty useless. :unsure:

Posted

well, the problem is that Eve suffered birth pains due to the fall. If Mary was sinless, then she should not have birth pains.

[quote name='Era Might' post='1029586' date='Jul 23 2006, 03:14 PM']I don't believe the Church teaches that Mary was without birth pangs. If she could feel sorrow (as she did at the foot of the Cross), and she could die before her Assumption (as the Eastern Churches believe), then she could most certainly feel pain during childbirth.

Our Lord himself was without original sin, yet he still bore the effects. The same is true of Our Lady. Although, it is possible she did not feel birth pangs, but this would be a special miracle for the joyous occasion, rather than out of necessity for her immaculate state.

St. Paul speaks of having "birth pangs" in his Apostolic ministry. It doesn't have to be literal, especially in the book of Revelation which is largely symbolic.
[/quote]
So, you are saying Mary, the Immaculate Conception, ever sinless, could of had birth pains even though birth pains are a punishment from the fall Gen 3:16?

Ok, I can use this, but can you back it up with a source, prefferably from a person who's name begins with "S" (ie saint).

Posted

Death was also a result of original sin, but that's not a problem for the Eastern Churches who believe Mary died. Like DAF pointed out, she also aged and was sorrowful. All sorrow is the result of original sin.

[quote name='jswranch' post='1029693' date='Jul 23 2006, 11:02 PM']Ok, I can use this, but can you back it up with a source, prefferably from a person who's name begins with "S" (ie saint).
[/quote]
A source about what specifically?

Posted

[quote]well, the problem is that Eve suffered birth pains due to the fall. If Mary was sinless, then she should not have birth pains.[/quote]
Back it up. There are two levels to original sin. There's the actual sin, or concupiscence that we are all born with, and then there's the effects, the consequences of it that we inherit from who we call Adam and Eve.
Mary and Jesus, being fully human, both experienced the consequences of original sin that all people experience (that is, aging and death, etc), but what's so amazing is that God exempted Mary and Jesus (himself) from the actual sin-they didn't inherit concupiscence.

Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1029695' date='Jul 23 2006, 08:03 PM']
A source about what specifically?
[/quote]

It would be great to find a source to back this up:

[quote]The Church doesn't teach that Mary was without birth pangs. If she could feel sorrow (as she did at the foot of the Cross), and she could die before her Assumption (as the Eastern Churches believe), then she could most certainly feel pain during childbirth.[/quote]

For all others, this argument is a source of the problem.

[url="http://www.acns.com/~mm9n/Mary/M8.htm"][u]Here is a quote from an anti-catholic website[/u]:[/url]
[quote]As anyone can see, the concept of Queen of Heaven is an abomination to Our Lord.

Rev 12:1 And there appeared a great wonder in heaven; a woman clothed with the sun, and the moon under her feet, and upon her head a crown of twelve stars: And she being with child cried, travailing in birth, and pained to be delivered.
This presents a major problem. In establishing the immaculate conception of Mary and to her sinless ever virgin life "Protoevangelium of James" describes in detail the birth of the baby without pain and without hymen of Mary being broken in graphic detail. Mary: Full of Grace at Catholic Answers presents the Catholic teaching on this matter from the writings of early church fathers and shows that because Mary bore Jesus without pain, it proved that Mary was free from original sin.
But the Rev 12 woman gave birth to her child "cried", "travailing" and "pained". Evidently this woman was still under the original sin and the curse of pain
Gen 3:16 Unto the woman he said, I will greatly multiply thy sorrow and thy conception; in sorrow thou shalt bring forth children; and thy desire shall be to thy husband, and he shall rule over thee.[/quote]

my response now includes:
1. Birth pains is not a result of the fall. An increase in birth pain is a result. Therefore Mary would have felt birth pains.
2. The CC does not teach woman of Rev 12 is Mary. It teaches it is Mary, Eve, Israel and the Church.
3. It is a vision/parable, not a clear cut depiction. It does not apply exactly to any one model.

Mateo el Feo
Posted

[quote name='DAF' post='1029653' date='Jul 23 2006, 08:27 PM']
Era's right. Even though they didn't have O.S. its affects still applied to both Jesus and Mary. They both aged, for example (obviously it's clearer with Mary, since she lived longer than Jesus' 33 years, but you still get it). Following that to its logical conclusion, we can assume that she experienced birth pains.[/quote]
In the [i]Summa Theologica[/i], St. Thomas Aquinas takes the position that Mary experienced no pains during the Nativity:
[url="http://www.newadvent.org/summa/403506.htm"]Whether Christ was born without His Mother suffering? (link)[/url]

He cites both St. Augustine and St. Jerome in support of his position. In particular, he quotes the following from St. Augustine:[quote]In conceiving thou wast all pure, in giving birth thou wast without pain.[/quote]

Also, there are a few threads at Catholic.com that discuss this topic:
[url="http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=&q=mary+pain+childbirth+site%3Acatholic.com"]http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=&q=m...%3Acatholic.com[/url]

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted (edited)

Edit

Edited by Raphael
Posted

jswranch,

I'm not sure what you need a citation for. That the Church doesn't teach Mary was without birth pangs? I think it would be on someone to prove that she DOES teach that. There is nothing in the promulgation of the Immaculate Conception about her birth pangs, and the Church has no problem with people believing that she died.

If she could bear one effect of original sin (death), then there is nothing to prevent her from experiencing another effect (birth pangs).

To the best of my knowledge, the Church doesn't teach as a matter of doctrine that Our Lady was without birth pangs. If I am wrong, then I will obey the teaching of the Church. Just as a note, the Church does teach as a matter of doctrine that Our Lady was a virgin DURING Our Lord's birth.

Posted

The birth pangs for the Woman in Revelation may not just be physical *gasp* and she has more then just that one child who is swept up by God's hand.

She still is related to Mary.

My favorite part of the story might be the water canon.

Posted

It's definitely an allusion to Mary. Notice how the very next chapter starts off with a vision of the Ark, which had been lost to the Jews. Mary is the Ark of the New Covenant. St. John was making the connection.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1030165' date='Jul 24 2006, 07:36 PM']
It's definitely an allusion to Mary. Notice how the very next chapter starts off with a vision of the Ark, which had been lost to the Jews. Mary is the Ark of the New Covenant. St. John was making the connection.
[/quote]
Ah, but it has always been understood as both Mary and the Church...and so has the Ark. ;)

Posted

I have no problem with multiple interpretations. But I think the connection with Mary is pretty clear.

Israel was also an ark. The messiah came forth from their loins.

Posted

Era,
Back to my original question for my wife: she wants to know if, during the formulation of the dogma of the immaculate conception, the early church considered and answered this appartent conflict.

I have tried explaining the "fusion imagery," but she wants to see that the church has considered it before its proclamation.

  • 4 weeks later...
Lounge Daddy
Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1030177' date='Jul 24 2006, 08:09 PM']
I have no problem with multiple interpretations. But I think the connection with Mary is pretty clear.

Israel was also an ark. The messiah came forth from their loins.
[/quote]
did Scott Hahn cover this in a book or a talk of his?
I may wanna check it out...
I thought I saw maybe a book on tape a few years ago - I dunno

Recommendations?

Posted

Yah, "Hail Holy Queen". Mark Shea is working on a book I think about Mary that should be good.

jswranch,

Ok, I get the question now. That I'm not sure of. You might want to check out "Mary and the Fathers of the Church" as well as "Mary in the Middle Ages" by Luigi Gambero. He examines the development of mariology in Church history.

[quote]In his book Mary and the Fathers of the Church, Fr. Luigi Gambero presented a comprehensive survey of Marian doctrine and devotion during the first eight Christian centuries. Mary in the Middle Ages continues this journey up to the end of the fifteenth century, surveying the growth of Marian doctrine and devotion during one of the most important eras of Christian history: the Middle Ages.

Fr. Gambero presents the thoughts, words, and prayers of great theologians, bishops, monks, and mystics who witnessed to and promoted the dedication of the Christian people to the Mother of God. Each chapter concludes with readings from the works of these important authors. Many of these texts have never before been translated into English. More than thirty great figures each receive an entire chapter, including such giants as the St. Anselm, St. Bernard, St. Anthony of Padua, St. Bonaventure, St. Albert the Great, St. Thomas Aquinas, St. Brigid of Sweden, and Raymond Lull.[/quote]
[url="http://www.ignatius.com/ViewProduct.aspx?SID=1&Product_ID=2495&AFID=12&"]http://www.ignatius.com/ViewProduct.aspx?S...mp;AFID=12&[/url]

Posted (edited)

[quote] [u]The Church doesn't teach that Mary was without birth pangs.[/u][/quote]

Neat WEASLE words......PANGS....instead of PAIN......I caught ya however....

[quote]Even before the terms "original sin" and "immaculate conception" had been defined, early passages imply the doctrines. [color="#660000"][b]Many works mention that Mary gave birth to Jesus without pain. But pain in childbearing is part of the penalty of original sin (Gen. 3:16). [u]Thus, Mary could not have been under that penalty. [/u][/b][/color]By God’s grace, she was immaculate in anticipation of her Son’s redemptive death on the cross. The Church therefore describes Mary as "the most excellent fruit of redemption" (CCC 508). [/quote]

[url="http://www.catholic.com/library/Mary_Full_of_Grace.asp"]http://www.catholic.com/library/Mary_Full_of_Grace.asp[/url]

Almost slithered that little SUCKAH in here didn't you?

Maybe YOUR parsish never taught that, but the CHURCH DID, and for CENTURIES too.

:idontknow:

--->--->> If anyone CARES for a proper biblical exegesis of that passage, remember, Revelation has 404 passages, of which 278 are DIRECT allusions to the old testament ... in order to understand Revelation, you MUST find the OPENING THOUGHT, that Revelation CLOSES .

Using that basic principal, shall we look for the parallel passages that detail WHAT IT MEANS?

[quote]

Genesis 37:5 (KJV) And Joseph dreamed a dream, and he told [it] his brethren: and they hated him yet the more.

6 And he said unto them, Hear, I pray you, this dream which I have dreamed:

7 For, behold, we [were] binding sheaves in the field, and, lo, my sheaf arose, and also stood upright; and, behold, your sheaves stood round about, and made obeisance to my sheaf.

8 And his brethren said to him, Shalt thou indeed reign over us? or shalt thou indeed have dominion over us? And they hated him yet the more for his dreams, and for his words.
[u]
9 And he dreamed yet another dream, and told it his brethren, and said, Behold, I have dreamed a dream more; and, behold, the sun and the moon and the eleven stars made obeisance to me.

10 And he told [it] to his father, and to his brethren: and his father rebuked him, and said unto him, What [is] this dream that thou hast dreamed? Shall I and thy mother and thy brethren indeed come to bow down ourselves to thee to the earth?[/u]

11 And his brethren envied him; but his father observed the saying.

12 And his brethren went to feed their father's flock in Shechem.

13 And Israel said unto Joseph, Do not thy brethren feed [the flock] in Shechem? come, and I will send thee unto them. And he said to him, Here [am I].

14 And he said to him, Go, I pray thee, see whether it be well with thy brethren, and well with the flocks; and bring me word again. So he sent him out of the vale of Hebron, and he came to Shechem.[/quote]

The "Woman" is Israel. Joseph dreamed that his seed would produce the Messiah, which it did.

Edited by Eutychus
Posted

[quote name='Eutychus' post='1046214' date='Aug 18 2006, 05:16 PM']Neat WEASLE words......PANGS....instead of PAIN......I caught ya however....
[url="http://www.catholic.com/library/Mary_Full_of_Grace.asp"]http://www.catholic.com/library/Mary_Full_of_Grace.asp[/url]

Almost slithered that little SUCKAH in here didn't you?

Maybe YOUR parsish never taught that, but the CHURCH DID, and for CENTURIES too.

:idontknow:
[/quote]
Just to let you know, you're one post away from going on my ignore list.

But, I will answer, for the sake of discussion and truth.

There was nothing "slithered" in there. "Pang" and "pain" mean the same thing, except "pain" is a more general concept, whereas "pang" is more acute. The "pain" of childbirth is a particular "pang".

The website you referenced was not giving a quote from the Catechism. That relevant portion was from Catholic Answers. The quote from the Catechism was "the most excellent fruit of redemption". Not that there's anything wrong with what CA is saying. It's a statement of history to say that there is early Christian literature referring to a painless birth. And from that, one can consider the concept of Immaculate Conception. Nevertheless, it is not a point of Catholic doctrine that Mary was without birth PANGS or birth PAIN. It is a theological speculation that has some foundation in a Catholic doctrine, the Immaculate Conception. But the doctrine of the Immaculate Conception does not REQUIRE that Mary was without birth PAIN or birth PANGS.

God bless.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...