Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Immaculate Conception vs. Birth pain (Rev 12:2)


Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote]Just to let you know, you're one post away from going on my ignore list. [/quote]


Yeah, it is embarrassing when you get nailed like that, isn't it?


[quote]The website you referenced was not giving a quote from the Catechism. That relevant portion was from Catholic Answers. [/quote]


So, CATHOLIC ANSWERS is now an UNRELIABLE source for information on the Catholic Church? Has anyone told Keating that yet?

Posted

[quote name='Eutychus' post='1046224' date='Aug 18 2006, 05:29 PM']Yeah, it is embarrassing when you get nailed like that, isn't it?[/quote]
Well, I'm sorry you have to act like a child in the name of God. Congratulations are in order, I guess. You are the first person ever on my ignore list.

I hope to meet you in Heaven some day.

God bless.

Posted

Mary did not suffer any of the pains of childbearth as already noted by Aquinas, and several other Church Fathers. I think it was described best(though I am lacking a direct qoute right now) "as though water was falling out of a glass" or some such.

Its very interesting to note thoat in the Koran it specifically brings up Mary suffering unberably so much so that she even wished that she would not have to bear this child. This of course is blasphemy

phatcatholic
Posted

this article very effectively shows that Mary is the woman (or at least one possible way to identify the woman) from Rev 12:
[url="http://matt1618.freeyellow.com/woman.html"]http://matt1618.freeyellow.com/woman.html[/url]

also, note the appendix at the end about the birth pains/pangs of the woman.

for more on Mary as our spiritual mother, see this entry:
[url="http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat/101"]http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat/101[/url]

pax christi,
phatcatholic

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Tarcisius' post='1046257' date='Aug 18 2006, 06:18 PM']Mary did not suffer any of the pains of childbearth as already noted by Aquinas, and several other Church Fathers.[/quote]
Interestingly, Aquinas argued against the Immaculate Conception. Do you know where he talks about this subject? I'd be interested in reading his argument.

Edited by Era Might
Posted

What I was saying has less to deal with the Immaculate Conception(dealing with the birth of Mary) and more to do with the birth of Christ. Apparently Aquinas did not go along with the arguments that some people are using that it was because she was born without sin that she wouldnt have to suffer the pains of childbirth.

Ill have to look for it because I cant remember off the top of my head where he talks about it.

Posted

Yah I know. That's why it would be interesting to see his argument. My guess is he probably attributed as a miracle for the unique event, the light of the world shining.

Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1046227' date='Aug 18 2006, 01:30 PM']
Well, I'm sorry you have to act like a child in the name of God. Congratulations are in order, I guess. You are the first person ever on my ignore list.

I hope to meet you in Heaven some day.

God bless.
[/quote]

So much for the hard ones...huh?

[quote]
Interestingly, Aquinas argued against the Immaculate Conception. [/quote]

The ENTIRE bible argues against this Roman Catholic FAIRY TALE.

[quote]Ro 5:12
Wherefore, as by one man sin entered into the world, and death by sin; and so death passed upon all men,[color="#333333"] for that all have sinned:[/color][size=4][/quote]

ALL. Note all. Mary is part of ALL.

[quote]1Ti 4:7

[u]But refuse profane and old wives' fables,[/u] and exercise thyself rather unto godliness.

2Ti 4:4

And they shall turn away their ears from the truth, [u]and shall be turned unto fables.[/u]
[/quote]

Just one more example of superstitious FABLES the stuff of silly women, being elevated to DOGMA.

[quote]2Ti 3:6
For of this sort are they which creep into houses, and lead captive silly women [/quote]

Posted

if it is a suspendable offense to talk negativley about Preists/ Bishops/ Popes etc etc/ then why are people allowed to get away with sullying the name/importance/purity/grace/etc etc of Our Mother.

Posted

[quote name='Tarcisius' post='1046341' date='Aug 18 2006, 05:09 PM']
if it is a suspendable offense to talk negativley about Preists/ Bishops/ Popes etc etc/ then why are people allowed to get away with sullying the name/importance/purity/grace/etc etc of Our Mother.
[/quote]


Yeah! Ban this guy....if he ever shows up!

[quote]Interestingly, Aquinas argued against the Immaculate Conception.[/quote]

cmotherofpirl
Posted

This is a question, not a debate so its being moved to another board. :)

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

If Paul meant "all" like ALL... have babies sinned? Did Jesus sin?

St. Paul was speaking to the Roman Jews trying to encourage them to welcome the Gentiles to their worship by starting them off from the same base-- namely, that both Jews and Gentiles are guilty of sin. St. Paul was not making a final judgment on the state of each and every person who has and who ever will exist in the universe. Babies have not sinned because they are incapable of personal sin until they reach the age of reason. Jesus Christ, true God and true MAN, did not sin. And in preparation for her special role as mother of the savior, Mary, the Mother of Jesus Christ was kept free from the stain of Original Sin by a singular grace of God given her at the very moment of her conception, and by a further grace was kept free from any stain of sin thereafter.

Mateo el Feo
Posted

[quote name='Eutychus' post='1046307' date='Aug 18 2006, 06:37 PM']Just one more example of superstitious FABLES the stuff of silly women, being elevated to DOGMA.[/quote]Not content at only playing the anti-Catholic, Eutychus tries his hand at misogyny.

Mateo el Feo
Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1046289' date='Aug 18 2006, 06:08 PM']
Interestingly, Aquinas argued against the Immaculate Conception. Do you know where he talks about this subject? I'd be interested in reading his argument.[/quote]Here are some of the questions in the Summa Theologica. Main link: [url="http://www.newadvent.org/summa/402700.htm"]The sanctification of the Blessed Virgin (link)[/url].

Here's a little discussion regarding St. Thomas and the Immaculate Conception: ([url="http://www.cin.org/users/james/questions/q052.htm"]Link[/url])

Also, quoting from the Catholic Encyclopedia article on the Immaculate Conception ([url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/07674d.htm"]link[/url]):[quote]St. Thomas at first pronounced in favour of the doctrine in his treatise on the "Sentences" (in I. Sent. c. 44, q. I ad 3), yet in his "Summa Theologica" he concluded against it. Much discussion has arisen as to whether St. Thomas did or did not deny that the Blessed Virgin was immaculate at the instant of her animation, and learned books have been written to vindicate him from having actually drawn the negative conclusion. Yet it is hard to say that St. Thomas did not require an instant at least, after the animation of Mary, before her sanctification. His great difficulty appears to have arisen from the doubt as to how she could have been redeemed if she had not sinned. This difficulty he raised in no fewer than ten passages in his writings (see, e. g., Summa III:27:2, ad 2). But while St. Thomas thus held back from the essential point of the doctrine, he himself laid down the principles which, after they had been drawn together and worked out, enabled other minds to furnish the true solution of this difficulty from his own premises.[/quote]

Mateo el Feo
Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1046289' date='Aug 18 2006, 06:08 PM']
Interestingly, Aquinas argued against the Immaculate Conception. Do you know where he talks about this subject? I'd be interested in reading his argument.[/quote]Here are some of the questions in the Summa Theologica. Main link: [url="http://www.newadvent.org/summa/402700.htm"]The sanctification of the Blessed Virgin (link)[/url].

Here's a little discussion regarding St. Thomas and the Immaculate Conception: ([url="http://www.cin.org/users/james/questions/q052.htm"]Link[/url])

Also, quoting from the Catholic Encyclopedia article on the Immaculate Conception ([url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/07674d.htm"]link[/url]):[quote]St. Thomas at first pronounced in favour of the doctrine in his treatise on the "Sentences" (in I. Sent. c. 44, q. I ad 3), yet in his "Summa Theologica" he concluded against it. Much discussion has arisen as to whether St. Thomas did or did not deny that the Blessed Virgin was immaculate at the instant of her animation, and learned books have been written to vindicate him from having actually drawn the negative conclusion. Yet it is hard to say that St. Thomas did not require an instant at least, after the animation of Mary, before her sanctification. His great difficulty appears to have arisen from the doubt as to how she could have been redeemed if she had not sinned. This difficulty he raised in no fewer than ten passages in his writings (see, e. g., Summa III:27:2, ad 2). But while St. Thomas thus held back from the essential point of the doctrine, he himself laid down the principles which, after they had been drawn together and worked out, enabled other minds to furnish the true solution of this difficulty from his own premises.[/quote]

  • 2 weeks later...
Lounge Daddy
Posted (edited)

[quote name='jswranch' post='1029693' date='Jul 24 2006, 12:02 AM']
well, the problem is that Eve suffered birth pains due to the fall. If Mary was sinless, then she should not have birth pains.
So, you are saying Mary, the Immaculate Conception, ever sinless, could of had birth pains even though birth pains are a punishment from the fall Gen 3:16?
[/quote]

I remember reading an issue of LayWitness several years ago that had a large article about Mary that included a focus on Mary's pain-free delivery of Jesus...
It suprised me, because this was the first time I heard this suggested... and this teaching is not brought up much at all - not even in most Catholic schools.

But this is an authentic Catholic understanding (though maybe not so common today)… as far as I understand.
I also find this line of thought – Mary’s painless delivery of Jesus – very fascinating.

Edited by Lounge Daddy
Posted

[quote name='Lounge Daddy' post='1053608' date='Aug 30 2006, 10:56 AM']
I remember reading an issue of LayWitness several years ago that had a large article about Mary that included a focus on Mary's pain-free delivery of Jesus...
It suprised me, because this was the first time I heard this suggested... and this teaching is not brought up much at all - not even in most Catholic schools.

But this is an authentic Catholic understanding (though maybe not so common today)… as far as I understand.
I also find this line of thought – Mary’s painless delivery of Jesus – very fascinating.
[/quote]
If you like this topic, re-reading "The Protoevangelium of James" will knock you socks off.

Lounge Daddy
Posted

[quote name='jswranch' post='1054272' date='Aug 31 2006, 09:14 AM']
If you like this topic, re-reading "The Protoevangelium of James" will knock you socks off.
[/quote]
huh... ya I just read it. It seems... odd.
That's the best word I can think of for it right now.

[quote]It is Mary that was reared in the temple of the Lord, and I obtained her by lot as my wife. And yet she is not my wife, but has conceived of the Holy Spirit. And the widwife said to him: Is this true? And Joseph said to her: Come and see. And the midwife went away with him. And they stood in the place of the cave, and behold a luminous cloud overshadowed the cave. And the midwife said: My soul has been magnified this day, because mine eyes have seen strange things -- because salvation has been brought forth to Israel. And immediately the cloud disappeared out of the cave, and a great light shone in the cave, so that the eyes could not bear it. And in a little that light gradually decreased, until the infant appeared, and went and took the breast from His mother Mary. And the midwife cried out, and said: This is a great day to me, because I have seen this strange sight. And the midwife went forth out of the cave, and Salome met her. And she said to her: Salome, Salome, I have a strange sight to relate to thee: a virgin has brought forth -- a thing which her nature admits not of.[/quote]

Also ...Fascinating is another word… and interesting
Cool stuff

[url="http://www.newadvent.org/fathers/0847.htm"]I found it at the Catholic Encyclopedia ...right HERE[/url]

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...