Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='prose' post='1033664' date='Jul 29 2006, 12:10 PM']
I think it is funny that if the same thing happened to Madonna many people here would be just blasting her about how terrible she is.

But if it happens to Mel Gibson everyone is much faster to forgive and forget.[/quote]
I think the difference has to do with intentions. I believe Mel suffers from demons like all of us and wants to be a better person. Madonna suffers from demons and figures out how she can make a profit from them.

Ash Wednesday
Posted (edited)

I find that to be oversimplifying things a bit, so I can't say I entirely agree. There's little benefit in one soul being viewed as always redeemable and forgiven, and the other as being beyond hope.

I am curious to hear what Arroyo and Gibson had to talk about.

Edited by Ash Wednesday
Lounge Daddy
Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1033729' date='Jul 29 2006, 03:44 PM']
Mel has issued an apology:
I commend him for a very honest act of repentance. He admitted that what he did was wrong and despicable, and asked for forgiveness.

May God help him with his alcoholism.
[/quote]

[quote name='littleflower+JMJ' post='1033750' date='Jul 29 2006, 04:48 PM']
ditto to that. it is one thing that is difficult to overcome. :(
[/quote]

double ditto to that
:mellow: and major prayers for Mel and his wonderful family

Posted

My respect for Mel Gibson as a man has gone through the roof. God always writes straight with crooked lines. He has issued another apology:

[quote]There is no excuse, nor should there be any tolerance, for anyone who thinks or expresses any kind of Anti-Semitic remark. I want to apologize specifically to everyone in the Jewish community for the vitriolic and harmful words that I said to a law enforcement officer the night I was arrested on a DUI charge.

I am a public person, and when I say something, either articulated and thought out, or blurted out in a moment of insanity, my words carry weight in the public arena. As a result, I must assume personal responsibility for my words and apologize directly to those who have been hurt and offended by those words.

The tenets of what I profess to believe necessitate that I exercise charity and tolerance as a way of life. Every human being is God’s child, and if I wish to honor my God I have to honor his children. But please know from my heart that I am not an anti-Semite. I am not a bigot. Hatred of any kind goes against my faith.

I’m not just asking for forgiveness. I would like to take it one step further, and meet with leaders in the Jewish community, with whom I can have a one on one discussion to discern the appropriate path for healing.

I have begun an ongoing program of recovery and what I am now realizing is that I cannot do it alone. I am in the process of understanding where those vicious words came from during that drunken display, and I am asking the Jewish community, whom I have personally offended, to help me on my journey through recovery. Again, I am reaching out to the Jewish community for its help. I know there will be many in that community who will want nothing to do with me, and that would be understandable. But I pray that that door is not forever closed.

This is not about a film. Nor is it about artistic license. This is about real life and recognizing the consequences hurtful words can have. It’s about existing in harmony in a world that seems to have gone mad.[/quote]
"God have mercy on me, a poor sinner."

Posted

Mel says he doesn't know where those words came from? C'mon. If he said them he obviously feels that way. It is amazing how alcohol acts as truth serum sometimes. It is easier to say the things you really mean when you are drunk.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Joey1976' post='1035484' date='Aug 1 2006, 11:24 AM']
Mel says he doesn't know where those words came from? C'mon. If he said them he obviously feels that way. It is amazing how alcohol acts as truth serum sometimes. It is easier to say the things you really mean when you are drunk.
[/quote]
Isn't it also the case that when you're drunk, your reason and your inhibitions leave?

There are people who had a racist upbringing, but using their reason, they know it's wrong, and using their will, they inhibit themselves from acting on racist tendencies. If they get drunk, though, those things may come out, even though they know they are false, because that reason that has kept them from acting has been let down. Just the same, there are people in dark nights who can only cling to reason and say that God is present, even though they don't feel His presence. If they were to get drunk (we'll say accidentally), they might slip in that regard and make some comment that sounds quite atheistic, but they don't mean it...it's just a fear or emotion or the like getting out. Man's reason and will are what make him a moral agent, not his subconscious feelings and fears.

That said, I don't know much about Mel Gibson's upbringing or beliefs, but I don't think it's fair to speak so condemningly against him.

Posted

[quote name='Joey1976' post='1035484' date='Aug 1 2006, 12:24 PM']Mel says he doesn't know where those words came from? C'mon. If he said them he obviously feels that way. It is amazing how alcohol acts as truth serum sometimes. It is easier to say the things you really mean when you are drunk.
[/quote]
So we should take the babble of every drunk in a bar as their deeply held beliefs?

I guess there's an aweful lot of Americans who really really love total strangers. Every drunk I've ever met, it was love at first sight, or at least they kept telling me. "I love you man!"

Ash Wednesday
Posted (edited)

I can understand some of the trepidation people will have about Mel's apology. There is the saying, in vino veritas, i.e. a lot comes to light about a person when you are drunk. With that being said, I personally think Mel probably deep down has his struggles coming to terms with what his father raised him to believe, and what he wants to believe himself. It sounds to me like he obviously has personal things to sort out, and I hope that he can really move forward in reconciling wrongs made. If he isn't in full communion with the Church (that I don't know), I hope that maybe this experience will change that. I fear that he will be punished very severely by the public for this and be permanently blacklisted in hollywood no matter what, considering how severely he was criticized during the making of the Passion for perceived knocks against the jews. But in the end hopefully something good will come of all this.

Edited by Ash Wednesday
Posted

[quote name='prose' post='1033664' date='Jul 29 2006, 12:10 PM']
I think it is funny that if the same thing happened to Madonna many people here would be just blasting her about how terrible she is.

But if it happens to Mel Gibson everyone is much faster to forgive and forget.

He could have killed someone. That isn't a minor sin. He could have taken someone's life away because he [i]chose[/i] to drink and drive. That isn't something easy to brush over.
[/quote]


The difference is, people like Madonna are unrepentant sinners who just dont care. Mel Gibson can just go to confession, and be totally forgiven and clean in God's eyes. The point is, every time a Christian sins and it becomes public cameras are shoved in our faces. What Mel gibson has done cannot be compared to half of the blasphemies and out right disgusting things commited by those other heathens.

Posted

[quote name='Raphael' post='1035495' date='Aug 1 2006, 09:33 AM']
Isn't it also the case that when you're drunk, your reason and your inhibitions leave?

There are people who had a racist upbringing, but using their reason, they know it's wrong, and using their will, they inhibit themselves from acting on racist tendencies. If they get drunk, though, those things may come out, even though they know they are false, because that reason that has kept them from acting has been let down. Just the same, there are people in dark nights who can only cling to reason and say that God is present, even though they don't feel His presence. If they were to get drunk (we'll say accidentally), they might slip in that regard and make some comment that sounds quite atheistic, but they don't mean it...it's just a fear or emotion or the like getting out. Man's reason and will are what make him a moral agent, not his subconscious feelings and fears.

That said, I don't know much about Mel Gibson's upbringing or beliefs, but I don't think it's fair to speak so condemningly against him.
[/quote]

Exactly, your inhibitions leave so you say things that you normally wouldn't say with a sound mind but you are thinking them. Those words didn't just pop into his mouth. Those thoughts had to be in his head. And when you are drunk they come out. just go to a bar and you see it all the time. When a guy talking to a hot girl is sober and then put some beers in him and his inhibitions go down and now he is saying all kinds of sexual stuff that he wouldn;t have said otherwise..but he had to be thinking them for them to come out. They don't just come out of nowhere. I could list a hundre more examples.

Posted (edited)

While Mr. Gibson was wrong in what he did (in both getting drunk and his behavior while intoxicated), he was able to admit that. People say all kinds of asinine things in a state of intoxication, which is one reason why it is a good idea to go easy on the booze.

However, the media is blowing this all way out of proportion, and treating Mel in a most hateful way, saying the most hateful things imaginable about him. ([url="http://www.slate.com/id/2146880/?GT1=8483"]Here's a particulary disgusting example from Slate.[/url] Be warned, it's upsetting.)
These liberals engage in the most virulent bile and slander, saying things about him which should not be said about anybody. And they return to their insanely hateful, virulent bashing of [i]The Passion[/i] and Mel's religion, saying Mel's drunken episode reveals the true hatefulness behind that movie. (When they aren't condemning it as homosexual porn, which is odd, because normally such cultural lefty types would have nothing but high praise for something as "artistically bold" as a gay porn movie about Jesus Christ!)

(I always find it ironic that the Left is always accusing everybody on the right of "hate", yet people on the Left rather consistantly talk in the most hateful terms of anyone they oppose.)

This seems to me to reveal the real reason why these people are so bent on crucifying Mel - it's because he's a "Right-wing Christian" (the ultimate sin for the Hollywood Left).

If some other hollywood celeb had done the exact same thing, it is doubtful there'd be such a huge outcry - this would merely be seen as yet another example of a drunken celeb making an ass of himself, and would be winked at, and forgotten.
Even anti-Semitic remarks are tolerated to a certain degree from black-militant types in the hip-hop world. But someone of Mel Gibson's political-incorrectness is not to be tolerated in tinsel-town, and the liberals gleefully are seeing this as their golden oppotrunity to "get Mel."
In being a "conservative" Christian, in public, Mel Gibson has committed the ultimate crime in the eyes of the Left, and must be punished.

Edited by Socrates
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Era Might' post='1035496' date='Aug 1 2006, 09:35 AM']
So we should take the babble of every drunk in a bar as their deeply held beliefs?

I guess there's an aweful lot of Americans who really really love total strangers. Every drunk I've ever met, it was love at first sight, or at least they kept telling me. "I love you man!"
[/quote]


Do you really think comparing "i love you man" which is a very common phrase, to anti-semitic remarks is even comparable. You just proved my point. Everyone says i love you man when they are drunk, no one ever says anti semitic remarks when they are drunk. It is not a common thing to say when people are drunk. That is why it had to be deep seeded to come out.

So you are saying if you or me or someone else got drunk, there is a chance we would hurl off anti-semitic remarks just because we are drunk? I don't think so, but there is a very good chance we would say i love you man. It is not even comparable.

Edited by Joey1976
Posted

I think everybody is missing the point here...

Aside from the DUI and stuff, what has Mel Gibson done wrong here? I mean, as ignorant and bigoted as his comments were, last time I checked, they were protected under the Constitution.

It may be wrong, immoral, disgusting, despicable, and disappointing, but anti-Semitism (along with any other form of racism) [b]IS NOT A CRIME[/b] so long as your personal beliefs do not violate the rights of another person.

Not to sounds like a broken record, but this is just the liberal-media trying to stir the pot. They tried to nab him when The Passion came out, but they failed because Jews from all over the world said that the accusations were unfounded. Now they've nabbed him and they won't stop until they ruin him. It's sad, really.

Posted

when you are drunk, your subconscience mind takes over... similar to a dream state except it's being acted out awake in the real world.

considering the views of Mel's father, it is very likely he was indoctrinated from youth to be racist; ergo those thoughts automatically occur to him in his subconscience.

but the subconscience is not the totality of the person; not even the whole workings of the brain are the totality of the person. he himself as a person decides what he really wants to believe; and if in a sober state he respects Jews, denies anti-semitism, and refuses to act on the diseased racist part of his subconscience his father passed onto him, then I believe we should give him the benefit of the doubt.

Posted

[quote name='Joey1976' post='1035879' date='Aug 1 2006, 10:35 PM']
Do you really think comparing "i love you man" which is a very common phrase, to anti-semitic remarks is even comparable. You just proved my point. Everyone says i love you man when they are drunk, no one ever says anti semitic remarks when they are drunk. It is not a common thing to say when people are drunk. That is why it had to be deep seeded to come out.

So you are saying if you or me or someone else got drunk, there is a chance we would hurl off anti-semitic remarks just because we are drunk? I don't think so, but there is a very good chance we would say i love you man. It is not even comparable.
[/quote]
Yes, that's what people do when they're drunk. They say stupid things. There is no "common" thing to say for an alcoholic. They say all kinds of crazy things. They become a completely different person. I don't know if you have any alcoholics in your family, but people who do will tell you stories about the crazy things that are said when drunk. One commenter at a blog mentioned how her father would accuse her mother and grandmother of plotting to kill him when he got plastered.

And maybe something is deep seated. You know what? We all have deep seated problems in our life. That's GOOD that the evil in our subconscious is not something we indulge when healthy and sober. Mel Gibson is NOT an anti-Semite. He has never expressed anything like this before, ever, and when he got sober, he immediately disavowed what he said. You don't disavow something you supposedly believe so deeply.

When a drunk grabs a women inappropriately, but has NEVER done that before in his sober life, and was ashamed and repentant of it the next, do we consider him a rapist? Of course not.

The whole tragedy of alcoholism is that it takes over. It makes people do things that they don't want to do. It makes them hurt their families and hurt themselves. It's a disease, and Mel Gibson suffers from it.

God help us all.

Guest Rick777
Posted

We all should just pray for him. :unsure: :sign:

heavenseeker
Posted

poor but very rich Mel. I will pray for him.

Posted

It must have taken humility for him to apologize. As much as I hate anti-Semitism, it is very hard to deny what you were brought up with and I can't believe how hard people are on him. If Paris Hilton said something like this, people would be dissmissive. it's because Mel Gibson said this that he gets in trouble.


And Slate got it wrong about what he said about his wife. He said that it would smell of elderberries if she didn't make it, that he's not sure, he didn't say, oh she's going to hell.

thessalonian
Posted (edited)

The man expresses public remorse. Yes, he may still have underlying attachment to sin. But he turns toward Christ and forgiveness after his sin. In this we must support him and pray for him. Is there any of us who do not sin or who may have a relapse to a past addiction?

As for his traditionalism, God will judge him in that regard.

Edited by thessalonian
Posted

An interesting read from [url="http://www.worldmagblog.com/blog/archives/025764.html"]Rabbi Lapin[/url] I came across:


[quote]As for the remarks Gibson made while intoxicated, ancient Jewish wisdom informs us that one way we can know what a person is really like is by how he behaves when he is drunk. From this we can safely assume that Mel Gibson doesn't think much of Jews.

However there is another nugget of ancient Jewish wisdom emphasizing that we owe atonement for that which lies in our hearts, only to God. If I have an unworthy thought in my heart about you, I need to make good with God but I don't owe you an apology unless I act upon that thought. We humans are morally obliged to make good to other people only for those things we do, and not for any thoughts we have in our minds.

ALSO

My question for Jews, especially the heads of the alphabet organizations is this: "Which is more likely to lead to increased affection and respect for Jews everywhere? Recognizing that human prejudices exist and working respectfully and amicably to change people's minds and hearts, or grabbing headlines by strident accusations full of self righteousness and intolerance?"[/quote]

Also, I've read another intersting article by [url="http://markshea.blogspot.com/2006_07_01_markshea_archive.html#115436209155685314"]Mark Shea[/url] on Mel Gibson's "true self".

honestly, I hope he he's successful in rehab. I will be praying for him.

The rest of us should be grateful that our failings will never (hopefully) reach the front page or the top of the hour news.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...