Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='Joey1976' post='1035879' date='Aug 1 2006, 06:35 PM']
Do you really think comparing "i love you man" which is a very common phrase, to anti-semitic remarks is even comparable. You just proved my point. Everyone says i love you man when they are drunk, no one ever says anti semitic remarks when they are drunk. It is not a common thing to say when people are drunk. That is why it had to be deep seeded to come out.

So you are saying if you or me or someone else got drunk, there is a chance we would hurl off anti-semitic remarks just because we are drunk? I don't think so, but there is a very good chance we would say i love you man. It is not even comparable.
[/quote]

I've done and said some deeply regrettable things when I was drunk. When I was 17 I said I was a devil worshiper to scare some person but was the first in line Saturday at confession kicking myself in the head for being a drunken idiot. I've gotten into many fights when I was drinking. I used women. I stole and vandalized. I'm sure I've said some unsavory remarks as well. It is NOT an excuse it’s an understanding that we do things not of our true selves. We are responsible 100% but it is not who we truly are. Maybe you are all too young but alcohol can make [i]anyone[/i] into an antiwhatever, racial, sexist, violent, irrational, idiot.

[quote name='Socrates' post='1035876' date='Aug 1 2006, 06:33 PM']
While Mr. Gibson was wrong in what he did (in both getting drunk and his behavior while intoxicated), he was able to admit that. People say all kinds of asinine things in a state of intoxication, which is one reason why it is a good idea to go easy on the booze.

However, the media is blowing this all way out of proportion, and treating Mel in a most hateful way, saying the most hateful things imaginable about him. ([url="http://www.slate.com/id/2146880/?GT1=8483"]Here's a particulary disgusting example from Slate.[/url] Be warned, it's upsetting.)
These liberals engage in the most virulent bile and slander, saying things about him which should not be said about anybody. And they return to their insanely hateful, virulent bashing of [i]The Passion[/i] and Mel's religion, saying Mel's drunken episode reveals the true hatefulness behind that movie. (When they aren't condemning it as homosexual porn, which is odd, because normally such cultural lefty types would have nothing but high praise for something as "artistically bold" as a gay porn movie about Jesus Christ!)

(I always find it ironic that the Left is always accusing everybody on the right of "hate", yet people on the Left rather consistantly talk in the most hateful terms of anyone they oppose.)

This seems to me to reveal the real reason why these people are so bent on crucifying Mel - it's because he's a "Right-wing Christian" (the ultimate sin for the Hollywood Left).

If some other hollywood celeb had done the exact same thing, it is doubtful there'd be such a huge outcry - this would merely be seen as yet another example of a drunken celeb making an ass of himself, and would be winked at, and forgotten.
Even anti-Semitic remarks are tolerated to a certain degree from black-militant types in the hip-hop world. But someone of Mel Gibson's political-incorrectness is not to be tolerated in tinsel-town, and the liberals gleefully are seeing this as their golden oppotrunity to "get Mel."
In being a "conservative" Christian, in public, Mel Gibson has committed the ultimate crime in the eyes of the Left, and must be punished.
[/quote]

You hit the nail on the head. This is the kind of fodder that makes them salivate. Gibson is wrong on every level but the machine that is plastering this with every picture, opinion and commentary known to man is fully operated by those who do not like what Mel professes(Christianity). Gibson could not have screwed up any worse with his rants after all the hoopla of antisemitism with "The Passion". It is sad to witness.

[quote name='prose' post='1033588' date='Jul 29 2006, 07:31 AM']
I am sorry, but I don't think Mel Gibson is the perfect example for any Catholic to follow. The man would have a "I do not rep the Church" symbol in here for sure. He is totally a way-past-normal traditionalist. He built his own church in his yard and insists Mass be done the pre-vatican way because he doesn't believe any other way is valid.
So, in short, yes, I will pray for him. That he can come back to the Church and live his faith truly and as a good example to other Catholics.
[/quote]

Do you know whether Cardinal Mahoney denied him permission to have his own chapel?

Posted

Era droppin' wisdom once again...


[quote name='Era Might' post='1035908' date='Aug 1 2006, 08:08 PM']
Yes, that's what people do when they're drunk. They say stupid things. There is no "common" thing to say for an alcoholic. They say all kinds of crazy things. They become a completely different person. I don't know if you have any alcoholics in your family, but people who do will tell you stories about the crazy things that are said when drunk. One commenter at a blog mentioned how her father would accuse her mother and grandmother of plotting to kill him when he got plastered.

And maybe something is deep seated. You know what? We all have deep seated problems in our life. That's GOOD that the evil in our subconscious is not something we indulge when healthy and sober. Mel Gibson is NOT an anti-Semite. He has never expressed anything like this before, ever, and when he got sober, he immediately disavowed what he said. You don't disavow something you supposedly believe so deeply.

When a drunk grabs a women inappropriately, but has NEVER done that before in his sober life, and was ashamed and repentant of it the next, do we consider him a rapist? Of course not.

The whole tragedy of alcoholism is that it takes over. It makes people do things that they don't want to do. It makes them hurt their families and hurt themselves. It's a disease, and Mel Gibson suffers from it.

God help us all.
[/quote]

Posted (edited)

Maybe the fact that a certain country was bombing (Catholic) Lebanese civilians at the time the man was drinking had something to do with the comments which came out.

Edited by Donna
Posted

More of the story came out.

The officer Mel said those things to is Jewish.

So now, instead of it seeming that Mel has a deep seated hatred for Jews that just burst out in an unfocused frenzy...

Mel said some ignorant and hateful things to personally insult the officer who was arresting him for being drunk and stupid.

If the officer was female, gay, short, fat, asian, black, or latino, Mel very well could have said other ignorant and hateful things to personally insult the officer arresting him for being drunk and stupid. The way is was expressed in the news, it made it seem as the Jewish insults came from out of the blue, from a foundation of anti-Semitism, instead of stupidity and ignorance enhanced with a alcohol lobotomy.

Posted

And what proof is there that Mel knew he was Jewish? Not that it matters, of course. It would make more sense if he knew he was Jewish, because that's what mean drunks try to do, hit you where it hurts.

By the way, Mel's publicist is also Jewish.

Posted

Prof that Mel knew he was Jewish? What?

Officer Mee was interviewed on TV and said he was Jewish. Do we know the whole conversation?
Did Mel ask if he was Jewish? Did it come up in Mel's drunken conversation?

Of course it desn't matter at a certain level other than the way it's been presented in the news that Mel's deepseated anti-Semitism burst forth in a drunken rage without any hint of reason other than blind his blind hatred for Jews allowed him to burst forth with vile words. Seen in the light that vile words were being used to hurt the officer that was rightfully arresting Mel isn't an excuse, but a reason other than seething hatred that couldn't be controlled when he was drunk.

Posted (edited)

Oh ok. I misunderstood what you meant.

I just think we need to give up the armchair psychoanalysis. Mel went off on a drunken babble about Jews, and denounced that babble, and anti-Semitism in general, when he sobered up the next day. Whether he knew the officer was Jewish is incidental, IMO. The important point is that Mel renounced what he said when sober. The honest thing to do is to take the man at his word, and leave it alone. That's how I feel about it anyway.

Edited by Era Might
Posted

[quote name='Anomaly' post='1038993' date='Aug 7 2006, 09:05 AM']
Prof that Mel knew he was Jewish? What?

Officer Mee was interviewed on TV and said he was Jewish. Do we know the whole conversation?
Did Mel ask if he was Jewish? Did it come up in Mel's drunken conversation?

Of course it desn't matter at a certain level other than the way it's been presented in the news that Mel's deepseated anti-Semitism burst forth in a drunken rage without any hint of reason other than blind his blind hatred for Jews allowed him to burst forth with vile words. Seen in the light that vile words were being used to hurt the officer that was rightfully arresting Mel isn't an excuse, but a reason other than seething hatred that couldn't be controlled when he was drunk.
[/quote]

why do you care? I don't see why people make such a huge deal about this.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...