the_rev Posted August 1, 2006 Posted August 1, 2006 (edited) When protesting abortion, do you feel it is appropriete to display images of aborted fetuses? In the Lord, Ed Edited August 3, 2006 by inDEED
Lahecil Posted August 1, 2006 Posted August 1, 2006 I think that's never appropriate, especially since it's usually only used for shock value.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted August 1, 2006 Posted August 1, 2006 I think it can be effective. Many people don't realize what abortion looks like and naively assume that it's something clean and harmless. Many people don't even think of war realistically until they've seen it, and then they are very much against it. However, it should be used carefully so that it doesn't come across as having the mere purpose of disgusting people.
Colleen Posted August 1, 2006 Posted August 1, 2006 You might ask people if you could show them what an abortion looks like. That may prove more effective than just holding up pictures.
homeschoolmom Posted August 1, 2006 Posted August 1, 2006 I'm not a fan-- especially when away from abortion "clinics." I don't want to be strolling down the street with my kids and have images of aborted children splashed in our faces.
CoffeeCatholic Posted August 1, 2006 Posted August 1, 2006 <b>never</b> in front of a mill (clinic) never in front of children younger than puberty and NEVER without literature and information about healing from abortion being passed out as well BUT, since my conversion came with a picture of an aborted child, I know that it does convert hearts and minds. All it takes is the picture, and that person might be 100 feet away, so a conversation is out. Some places that they are permissable: At protests while protesting protests (aka, "March for 'women's lives'", that's when i was converted) when giving informational talks to groups This is someone who has died a grussome death. AND it's a picture of their death, not of their life. Imagine if you went to a funeral of someone who died in a car crash and instead of pictures of them playing volleyball and at birthdays, you had all the crimescene photos of the crash. This is simalar. You wouldn't have a memorial of their death, but their life. However, if your friend was a victim of murder, perhaps you would have some form of memorial with the crime scene footage to get the attention and outrage necessary to mobilize support, but my guess is it wouldn't be at the funeral, would it?
Norseman82 Posted August 1, 2006 Posted August 1, 2006 (edited) It's a lot more appropriate than photos of Mother Theresa or the Pope. Abortion is not just a "Catholic" thing and it's important to force people to see what the real issue is, which is murder, which is something that transcends religions. Edited August 1, 2006 by Norseman82
Era Might Posted August 1, 2006 Posted August 1, 2006 I'll take an icon of Our Lady of Guadalupe over gruesome photos any day.
thessalonian Posted August 1, 2006 Posted August 1, 2006 (edited) People need to be woken up to the FACT that there is a human life in the womb. Mankind does not want to be faced with the reality and horror of sin and so we sweep it under the rug and hide it from view. BRING IT OUT IN TO THE DAYLIGHT I SAY! Therefore I think for adults it is quite appropriate to show them images of fetuses. A book I read some time ago showed a garbage bag full of them outside an abortion clinic. If this is shocking then so be it. Their hearts need to be shocked back in to rythm. Their souls are dead. Get out the figurative paddles I say. I would not show them to young children however. Edited August 1, 2006 by thessalonian
jswranch Posted August 1, 2006 Posted August 1, 2006 I can see arguments for and against the pics. Our pro-life ministry with the diocese is so strongly against shocking pictures, that when the Fundies carry them, we go to the opposite side of the street.
onlygrace08 Posted August 1, 2006 Posted August 1, 2006 I saw a man once who was wearing a t-shirt that had a cartoon like drawing of a baby's body parts and cut up and dismembered. At the bottom, it said, "kinda looks like murder huh?" It really made an impact. I think the pictures can be effective but, I don't think they should be used [i]everywhere[/i]. God Bless Anna
melporcristo Posted August 1, 2006 Posted August 1, 2006 [quote name='Era Might' post='1035534' date='Aug 1 2006, 08:13 AM'] I'll take an icon of Our Lady of Guadalupe over gruesome photos any day. [/quote] Amen! Many use it at the Clinic I go pray at; some of the residents are appaled but then ask us questions. Many of the locals come and talk about how they don't like the clinic and how it's good they saw the pictures to remind them of what goes on in the clinic. But according the national statistics, the tactic doesn't work with women going into the clinic. +JMJ+ Mel
thessalonian Posted August 1, 2006 Posted August 1, 2006 [quote name='jswranch' post='1035569' date='Aug 1 2006, 12:11 PM'] I can see arguments for and against the pics. Our pro-life ministry with the diocese is so strongly against shocking pictures, that when the Fundies carry them, we go to the opposite side of the street. [/quote] And the fundies go to the other side of the street figuratively when we have crusifixes in our church. Is not the crusifix of the same kind of "offense" as these pictures? Really, look at it next time? Yet the Church puts it in front of us in every Catholic Church as a symbol of the great love that God has for us. Further the Chuch is not shy about it when non-catholics enter our churches either. We do not take it down or cover it for cross denominational weddings for instance. I think there is some food for thought here regarding the topic at hand. Once again man likes to sweep sin under the rug.
Tarcisius Posted August 1, 2006 Posted August 1, 2006 I think the only problem with it is that it is disrespectful to the innocent dead. I dont think this is something that couldnt be lived with however if the signs actually did anything. Since they are practically ineffective though I think the real problem with using them is that those who do think they are doing everything they can when they could be doing so much more.
thessalonian Posted August 1, 2006 Posted August 1, 2006 On what basis do you say they are ineffective? Do you have statistics to prove that they are ineffective?
Tarcisius Posted August 1, 2006 Posted August 1, 2006 I base it on the fact that abortion is not slowing down, that places where signs are put up does not dramatically, if at all affect anything. Wheras other proven methods have a 100% affective rate.
thessalonian Posted August 1, 2006 Posted August 1, 2006 [quote name='Tarcisius' post='1035666' date='Aug 1 2006, 03:45 PM'] I base it on the fact that abortion is not slowing down, that places where signs are put up does not dramatically, if at all affect anything. Wheras other proven methods have a 100% affective rate. [/quote] So you have checked every place where signs have been put up and places where they have not. Would you care to post your data so that we can all see it and assess it? Hmmmm. Other proven methods have a 100% affective rate? How can that be since abortion is not slowing down? Abortion clinics in some places (i.e. fargo and bismark) have been shut down. That's pretty effective. 0 abotions performed. I know that people there used such photos. If one child is not aborted at a clinic because someone showed that murder took place by a picture of a dead fetus, I call that success.
Norseman82 Posted August 2, 2006 Posted August 2, 2006 I basically was apathetic on the abortion issue until I saw the gruesome pictures and I could no longer ignore the reality of what abortion really is.
zwergel88 Posted August 2, 2006 Posted August 2, 2006 (edited) I think that in most cases, people just do it for shock value, and it only causes further polarization between the two sides of this debate, which will not be helpful at all in ending abortion. Edited August 2, 2006 by zwergel88
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now