Dooset83 Posted August 2, 2006 Posted August 2, 2006 Hmm, this is a good question. I would say no because you don't want to seem like a hypocrite displaying foul images when we our selves protest (or should at times) foul images of anything else on the tv or in movies. I'm sure prayer and faith in the Lord will help you reveal a true and effective way of protesting abortion. How about a sign that says "I'm Catholic and Pro Choice. You CHOSE to play with fire, you got burnt. Let the children of God LIVE!". I’m sure there are ways to cut people to the heart on this one. Peace and goodness my friend.
Socrates Posted August 2, 2006 Posted August 2, 2006 I've been in rather lengthy arguments about the posting of aborted baby pictures with a pro-lifer who was rather vehemently against their use. (This was after I posted pictures on a debate here with a pro-abort who kept using legalistic euphemisms to avoid the issue of what abortion actually is) I can see her side, but still believe pictures have their value, though they may not be the most appropriate thing in all circumstances. How people will react, I think, will depend on the individual person. I know that as a kid, growing up in a pro-life family, seeing such pics definitely helped drive home the horror of what abortion really is, and helped make me more fervently opposed to it as the crime against humanity that it is. However, I realize that shoving pictures of bloody babies in women's faces at a clinic is not the best way to change their minds. However, I'd say they are definietly valuable in debate, and ahve more impact than abstract arguments. The pro-abort side relies on smoke-screens of euphemisms and lies - talking ad-nauseum about "choice," "women's rights," personal autonomy," "legal personhood," etc., rather than facing the fact that abortion is indeed the murder of a human being. [quote name='zwergel88' post='1035822' date='Aug 1 2006, 06:11 PM'] I think that in most cases, people just do it for shock value, and it only causes further polarization between the two sides of this debate, which will not be helpful at all in ending abortion. [/quote] I'm not sure what you mean by "shock value," but sometimes people need to be shocked into seeing the truth of what abortion really is. People get so comfortable talking about abstractions, that they lose sight of the horrific reality of abortion. As long as people refuse to acknowledge that abortion is the murder of human being, but rather call it a "woman's right" or a "woman's choice," little progress will be made toward ending abortion. [quote name='Dooset83' post='1035848' date='Aug 1 2006, 06:48 PM'] Hmm, this is a good question. I would say no because you don't want to seem like a hypocrite displaying foul images when we our selves protest (or should at times) foul images of anything else on the tv or in movies. I'm sure prayer and faith in the Lord will help you reveal a true and effective way of protesting abortion. How about a sign that says "I'm Catholic and Pro Choice. You CHOSE to play with fire, you got burnt. Let the children of God LIVE!". I’m sure there are ways to cut people to the heart on this one. Peace and goodness my friend. [/quote] These "foul images" show the foul truth about abortion which "pro-choicers" would have us all ignore. They are not like pornography which insites people to lust, or entertainment which celebrates foulness.
Dooset83 Posted August 2, 2006 Posted August 2, 2006 [quote] These "foul images" show the foul truth about abortion which "pro-choicers" would have us all ignore. They are not like pornography which insites people to lust, or entertainment which celebrates foulness.[/quote] That maybe true and if it is, why not post posters of what a person looks like when they commit suicide? I heard they're having issues with that over in Ireland and many other places.
VeniteAdoremus Posted August 2, 2006 Posted August 2, 2006 I'd prefer a picture of a living fetus at the stage of development of ye typical baby in danger. Add the text 'this is your baby now', or something. But then again I've never been a fan of gruesome pictures. And never, EVER when there are young children around.
thessalonian Posted August 2, 2006 Posted August 2, 2006 (edited) [quote name='zwergel88' post='1035822' date='Aug 1 2006, 07:11 PM'] I think that in most cases, people just do it for shock value, and it only causes further polarization between the two sides of this debate, which will not be helpful at all in ending abortion. [/quote] Crucifixes cause a similar polarization. Do you suggest we take them down as well? Men want to sweep sin under the rug. They do not want to see the horror of what they do. The debate will not end by continuing to remove men's sins from before their eyes. Men react in a sinful manner, i.e. St. Stephen's stoning in acts 8 BECAUSE they are convicted of their sin. He used harsh language in tellling them how they crucified the Son of God. This is not something that should be avoided as Stephen, at the real risk of death, did not. Note, we know of only one convert from his martyrdom. But he was the greatest evangelist perhaps that ever lived. Edited August 2, 2006 by thessalonian
jmjtina Posted August 2, 2006 Posted August 2, 2006 I agree, every circumstance is different. You must know the community you will be praying at. But as I was thinking about this, the public is scared of pictures but not of the reality that is happening behind closed doors. We'll like to keep it nice and tidy behind a curtain so it doesn't upset us. The media agrees with you. It is too graphic. Abortion clinics also think that the sight of healthy children are inappropriate too. The abortion clinic we pray at has a sign that says "No children allowed". Ironic isn't it? People don't even like the posters "Abortion Kills Children" because of the word kill. Images to the right community can be very powerful.
Lil Red Posted August 2, 2006 Posted August 2, 2006 [quote name='Socrates' post='1035851' date='Aug 1 2006, 08:01 PM']As long as people refuse to acknowledge that abortion is the murder of human being, but rather call it a "woman's right" or a "woman's choice," little progress will be made toward ending abortion.[/quote]well said [quote name='jmjtina' post='1036227' date='Aug 2 2006, 09:26 AM']But as I was thinking about this, the public is scared of pictures but not of the reality that is happening behind closed doors. We'll like to keep it nice and tidy behind a curtain so it doesn't upset us. The media agrees with you. It is too graphic. Abortion clinics also think that the sight of healthy children are inappropriate too. The abortion clinic we pray at has a sign that says "No children allowed". Ironic isn't it? People don't even like the posters "Abortion Kills Children" because of the word kill. Images to the right community can be very powerful.[/quote]agreed who was it that said "America will not stop abortion until it sees abortion for what it truly is" (or something like that)
franciscanheart Posted August 2, 2006 Posted August 2, 2006 I don't really know where I stand on the issue. I've never been a fan of the huge signs but I think pictures in a pamphlet can sometimes be effective. One of the best stories I heard was not one that involved gruesome pictures. It involved addressing people as mothers and fathers and talking about the realities of what they were doing to their child.
Era Might Posted August 2, 2006 Posted August 2, 2006 Pornography is also schocking, but I don't need to show it to people to get across why it's wrong. I think pictures of abortion can have their place in a one-on-one conversation. But plastering them on the side of the street doesn't get across the right message to women who are going to have an abortion of hope, not condemnation and disgust.
prose Posted August 3, 2006 Posted August 3, 2006 Must be that time of year again... The abortion picture debate is up. This was extensively debated in the debate forum a while back. I will see if I can find the link.
chris Posted August 3, 2006 Posted August 3, 2006 (edited) Pictures, can have their places. And, sometimes they don't. Appealing to emotion is all that the pictures tend do, most of the time. You need to appeal to the womans sense of what is right and what is not profitable to her health and/or her christain life. Somtimes picture can help her realize that...Sometime it can anger them. I had a BIG poster of a mutilated child after its abortion, and a blurb explaing what they do to babies after abortions. There was a Christain woman who was against abortion, to the fullest extent and she told me that sometimes picture only hurt...Sometimes its words that we can use to move.... Edited August 3, 2006 by Convert4888
Tarcisius Posted August 3, 2006 Posted August 3, 2006 [quote]So you have checked every place where signs have been put up and places where they have not. Would you care to post your data so that we can all see it and assess it? Hmmmm. If one child is not aborted at a clinic because someone showed that murder took place by a picture of a dead fetus, I call that success.[/quote] Yes uh I have checked every place known to man, My assistant will be forwarding the data forwith for your assesion. What is your Problem????? [quote]Other proven methods have a 100% affective rate? How can that be since abortion is not slowing down?[/quote] Because those methods are being ignored and underused, like i stated. [quote]Abortion clinics in some places (i.e. fargo and bismark) have been shut down. That's pretty effective. 0 abotions performed. I know that people there used such photos.[/quote] yea....well fargo was known for being an abortion hotspot....I wouldnt put my money on it being the photos that did it though. If they were, great, but i think time has proven that throwing up photos doesnt close clinics, and it certainly doesnt save the lives of the children whose mothers walk right by. [quote]If one child is not aborted at a clinic because someone showed that murder took place by a picture of a dead fetus, I call that success.[/quote] Most definitley its a good thing, just what I was talking about though, is the person throwing up those signs thinks they are doing all they can by saving that one baby, when they could be doing more, guaranteeing 20 or so kids at least one more day.
thessalonian Posted August 3, 2006 Posted August 3, 2006 (edited) You know what, I see the horrors of the Israeli Lebanese war daily on TV and in the internet. Bodies of men, women, and children. The news puts this on in part I would assume because in some way it should bring about an end to the war by facing us with the stark reality of it. Why are we not protesting the news putting these pictures on? The news from time to time shows pictures of those who have been murdered in our own streets. No, I think it is the same thing and we Catholics should be in favor of people seeing the reality and results of sin. It is for shock value and it should be. ABORTION IS MURDER FOLKS! [quote]Yes uh I have checked every place known to man, My assistant will be forwarding the data forwith for your assesion. What is your Problem?????[/quote] My problem is I disagree with you and ask you to support your position and I get handwaving and generalities. We cover up the reality of sin when in truth we need to expose it to the light where people cannot avoid it. Abortion itself is the covering up of sin. Men do not repent when their sins are hidden so that they do not have to look upon them. Edited August 3, 2006 by thessalonian
Tarcisius Posted August 3, 2006 Posted August 3, 2006 i think your problem is avoiding what i am actually saying and instead asking for things that you know dont exist and dont matter.
KnightofChrist Posted August 4, 2006 Posted August 4, 2006 [quote name='Lahecil' post='1035403' date='Aug 1 2006, 07:37 AM'] I think that's never appropriate, especially since it's usually only used for shock value. [/quote] If showing abortion to the people is not appropriate, nethier is abortion itself. If people are shocked by what they see in these photos then they are shocked by truth, and should stop this unholy holocaust.
KnightofChrist Posted August 4, 2006 Posted August 4, 2006 (edited) [quote name='Era Might' post='1036559' date='Aug 2 2006, 04:31 PM'] Pornography is also schocking, but I don't need to show it to people to get across why it's wrong. I think pictures of abortion can have their place in a one-on-one conversation. But plastering them on the side of the street doesn't get across the right message to women who are going to have an abortion of hope, not condemnation and disgust. [/quote] Pornography is 100% sinful both the act and the photos, showing someone the truth of abortion would not be sinful, would it? I do not think so, and I do not like even comparing the two. I know of 5 woman/girls that have seen these images on the sides of streets and because of them, swear to never have or let their friends have an abortion, so the message does work. The images show the complete truth, and for most the truth is very hard to see, but that doesnt mean the truth should not be shown. Edited August 4, 2006 by KnightofChrist
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now