Resurrexi Posted August 11, 2006 Posted August 11, 2006 (edited) I have read two or more of the aformentioned Catechisms, namely, the Baltimore Catechism and the Catechism of St. Pius X. Also, I am currently reading the Catechism of the Council of Trent. Ignore this thread I accidently made two and I had messed up on this one anyway. Edited August 11, 2006 by StThomasMore
Resurrexi Posted August 11, 2006 Author Posted August 11, 2006 errr, I guess the other thread just like this one got deleted instead.
cmotherofpirl Posted August 12, 2006 Posted August 12, 2006 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1041395' date='Aug 11 2006, 09:44 AM'] I have read two or more of the aformentioned Catechisms, namely, the Baltimore Catechism and the Catechism of St. Pius X. Also, I am currently reading the Catechism of the Council of Trent. Ignore this thread I accidently made two and I had messed up on this one anyway. [/quote] When are you going to get around to the one currently in use?
Resurrexi Posted August 12, 2006 Author Posted August 12, 2006 (edited) [quote]When are you going to get around to the one currently in use?[/quote] All those catechisms are currently in use. The Baltimore Catechism is still the offocial catchism for teaching children in the United States in both Catholic schools and religious ed programs. The Catechism of St. Pius X is certainly a good catechism to teach lay adults all they need to know simply and promptly. As for the Catechism of the Council of Trent, any good priest of theologian is required to have read it, as have all Church Scholars. You don't need any catechism besides the Baltimore Catechism if you are a child. You don't need any other catechism but the Catechism of St. Pius X if you are a lay adult. You don't need any catechism besides the Catechism of the Council of Trent if you are a priest or theologian. There is no need to read the CCC/CCCC, which, though the newest, is in no way more authoritative than the former offocial scholarly catechism (i.e. the Catechism of the Council of Trent). Now, if what you mean by that was "when are you going to read the most modern and recently written catechism?" then my answer is: I maybe will read the CCC and/or the CCCC when I have finished reading Summa Theologica, the documents of the dogmatic Oecumenical Councils, the Douay-Rhiems and have learned Ecclesiastical Latin fluently. And even then, it's only a maybe. Edited August 12, 2006 by StThomasMore
Fidei Defensor Posted August 12, 2006 Posted August 12, 2006 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1041801' date='Aug 11 2006, 08:36 PM'] never. [/quote] You really should read it, whether or not you like it. It's approved, so you should atleast have read it once. No one is blaming you for liking a different style of teaching, but that doesn't mean the current catechism is bad.
Resurrexi Posted August 12, 2006 Author Posted August 12, 2006 [quote] QUOTE(StThomasMore @ Aug 11 2006, 08:36 PM) * never. You really should read it, whether or not you like it. It's approved, so you should atleast have read it once. [/quote] Errr, I kinda edited my post if there's any confustion. I will probably never read it, and will never find reason to read it. It is no more approved than the Catechism of the Council of Trent (which, BTW, I consider more authoritative becuase it was the extention of a dogmatic Oecumenical Council rather than a Pastoral one) [quote] No one is blaming you for liking a different style of teaching, but that doesn't mean the current catechism is bad. [/quote] I'm not saying it's bad (and it's not any more the current catechism than the Roman Catechism is) but it is tediously long, ambiguous and probably badly translated from Latin to English, like the Mass is. Maybe if I ever learn Latin I will read it in Latin (though I see that the Latin version on Vatican.va doesn't have the letter 'j' and does not use 'ae' or 'oe' as one letter and does not have the accent marks, which greatly irks me)
cmotherofpirl Posted August 12, 2006 Posted August 12, 2006 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1041826' date='Aug 11 2006, 10:05 PM'] Errr, I kinda edited my post if there's any confustion. I will probably never read it, and will never find reason to read it. It is no more approved than the Catechism of the Council of Trent (which, BTW, I consider more authoritative becuase it was the extention of a dogmatic Oecumenical Council rather than a Pastoral one) I'm not saying it's bad (and it's not any more the current catechism than the Roman Catechism is) but it is tediously long, ambiguous and probably badly translated from Latin to English, like the Mass is. Maybe if I ever learn Latin I will read it in Latin (though I see that the Latin version on Vatican.va doesn't have the letter 'j' and does not use 'ae' or 'oe' as one letter and does not have the accent marks, which greatly irks me) [/quote] You are not qualified to decide if one catechism is more authoritive than another [ and its not]. ...and ff you have not bothered to read the current authoritative catechism, you are certainly not qualifed to pronounce it long, tedious etc or anything else. Why don't you actually read it BEFORE dismissing it, then you personal opinoin of it would carry more weight.
Resurrexi Posted August 12, 2006 Author Posted August 12, 2006 I've read a few parts of it, and found it long and ambiguous. Can anyone tell me how the translation is, becuase I don't know, but most modern translations of anything related to Catholicism smell of elderberries (i.e. the translation of the Missa Normativa and the Breviary)
Charms717RM1 Posted August 12, 2006 Posted August 12, 2006 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1041845' date='Aug 11 2006, 09:36 PM'] Can anyone tell me how the translation is, becuase I don't know, but most modern translations of anything related to Catholicism smell of elderberries (i.e. the translation of the Missa Normativa and the Breviary) [/quote] Ok, so earlier you admitted that you have yet to learn Latin. If that's so, how would you know that modern translations smell of elderberries? Because someone told you?
Resurrexi Posted August 12, 2006 Author Posted August 12, 2006 I know some basic prayers and phrases etc. I'll tell you how i know the modern translations smell of elderberries. There are some prayers that are the same in the Novus Ordo and in the Traditional Latin Mass. I know that my TLM Missal is going to have an orthodox and traditional translation of the Latin. The parts that are the same in the Novus Ordo in Latin and in the Latin Traditional Latin Mass are translated differently in my missal than in the Novus Ordo translation. Also, anyone who is not and idiot knows that et cum spiritu tuo does not me and also with you. I'm thinking either the person who translated the Mass comitted a sacrilige on purpose or couldn't translate Latin to save his life.
ReinnieR Posted August 12, 2006 Posted August 12, 2006 does it matter if we're catechized or not? my point is what will you get out of this poll?? your poll is not really about if we're catechized or not. your poll is about which catechism we're reading.
Resurrexi Posted August 12, 2006 Author Posted August 12, 2006 it does matter if you are catechised or not becuase it is a mortal sin not to be
FutureSoror Posted August 13, 2006 Posted August 13, 2006 Late elementary-Middle school: St. Joseph's Baltimore Catechism. Highschool: The CCC.
Noel's angel Posted August 13, 2006 Posted August 13, 2006 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1042197' date='Aug 12 2006, 11:10 PM'] it does matter if you are catechised or not becuase it is a mortal sin not to be [/quote] Since when? Remember, God doesn't judge us on how much we know, but how we treat others. You should read the book 'Imitation of Christ'. It says:"Verily, when the Day of Judgement comes, we shall not be examined on what we have read, but what we have done; nor how learnedly we have spoken, but how religiosuly we have lived.....He is truely great, who is great in charity." It also says: "If thou should see another openly sin, or commit some heneious crime, yet thou oughtst not to esteem thyself better: because thou knowest not how long thou mayest remain in a good state." It is not for you to point out others sins. It is better to be a good person and not have read a million and one catechisms than to have read them and point out others failings. When you are perfect yourself, and have read the latest Catechism, then maybe you will be able to judge others.
Resurrexi Posted August 13, 2006 Author Posted August 13, 2006 It is a mortal sin to be willfully ignorant of the truths which the Holy Catholic Church teaches. That's in every examination of concience. It means it's a mortal sin not to have read a Catholic Catechism
Noel's angel Posted August 13, 2006 Posted August 13, 2006 (edited) I have many friends who are very knowledgable about what the Church teaches but have never read a whole Catechism. You haven't read the current Catechism, I recall. Maybe you should give that a go, instead of ignoring what it says. BTW, let's look at what is necessary for something to be a mortal sin. In order for a sin to be mortal, it must meet three conditions: * Mortal sin is a sin of grave matter * Mortal sin is committed with full knowledge of the sinner * Mortal sin is committed with deliberate consent of the sinner Now, I now that one of my friends have thought to themselves 'I know it is a grave matter not to have read a Catechism, but heck I'm going to deliberately not read one.' You know what IS amortal sin: sins against charity. Remember that. Edited August 13, 2006 by Noel's angel
Resurrexi Posted August 13, 2006 Author Posted August 13, 2006 Not all sins against charity are mortal sins. It is a spiritual work of mercy to admonish sinners. YOU DO NOT HAVE TO READ THE WHOLE 'CATECHISM OF THE CATHOLIC CHURCH'. There are plenty of catechisms which do the job. Even the 60 page Baltimore Catechism No. 1 would be enough to get you out of mortal sin. It is just as current and in use for younger people as the CCC is for adults. There was never a time when the Baltimore Catechism became out of date or not approved for religious ed calsses. It is ridiculous to think it's not a mortal sin to not know the Faith. In Latin, when interpreted correctly, it teaches the same things as the Catechism of the Council of Trent, so I don't and never will need to read the CCC.
morostheos Posted August 13, 2006 Posted August 13, 2006 I have never read a Catechism in its entirety, does that mean I am in a state of mortal sin until I do? I definitely believe that I know in good part what the Church teaches, I have taken theology classes and was a Catholic campus minister at a university. I use the CCC mainly as a reference text, and have not read it front to back. Would you say reading a catechism is the only way to learn the Faith? What about people who are unable to read?
Noel's angel Posted August 13, 2006 Posted August 13, 2006 When did I say it wasn't a mortal sin not to know about the faith? Secondly, your are thriteen and you claim to know so much about a Church that has been around for 2000 years. Thirdly, you claim to know all about Latin translations, yet you know little Latin yourself. Stop picking faults at others. You are young and have so much to learn. I am young myself and I know that my knowledge of the Church is a drop in the ocean compared to others but I have a deep faith and respect for God and His Church. All this stuff about the Novus Ordo and Latin and inscence and altar boys is a symbol of pride. Remember, you do not have the authority to say what is correct and what is not. Nor do I. But I abide by the Church's current teachings on such things. I'm sorry that you see only what you want to see when it comes to the Church. I hope in due time your eyes will be opened and you will humbly accept that the Novus Ordo as celebrated throughout the world is perfectly valid.
Resurrexi Posted August 13, 2006 Author Posted August 13, 2006 (edited) [quote]When did I say it wasn't a mortal sin not to know about the faith? [/quote] what I enterpret you saying it's ok not to read a Catholic catechism. [quote]Secondly, your are thriteen and you claim to know so much about a Church that has been around for 2000 years. [/quote] I think I know more than most 13 year olds (I'm not bragging, every thirteen year old should be expected to know as much as me, but the Church is in a cricis right now and catechism programs smell of elderberries and kids learn nothing. Trust me, I went to one for three years and they didn't even try to teach us the teachings of the Church.) [quote]Thirdly, you claim to know all about Latin translations, yet you know little Latin yourself. Stop picking faults at others. You are young and have so much to learn.[/quote] Taking from what I know from the translations of the Novus Ordo Missae and the New Breviary (the translations are both heterodox, though the Latin originals are very orthodox and traditional), I'm just going to assume the same about all other translations of new offocial Catholic documents, books and liturgies, though I will never say anything bad about the Latin originals, the only authoritative copies of the documents. The translations are often just the translatiors opinions that read nothing like the original really reads. I never said I didn't have much to learn, though. [quote]I am young myself and I know that my knowledge of the Church is a drop in the ocean compared to others but I have a deep faith and respect for God and His Church[/quote] As do I. [quote] All this stuff about the Novus Ordo and Latin and inscence and altar boys is a symbol of pride. [/quote] no it's not. It's respect for God the Son physically present Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity in the Holy Eucharist. [quote]Remember, you do not have the authority to say what is correct and what is not. Nor do I. But I abide by the Church's current teachings on such things.[/quote] I also don't have authority, and I also abide by the Church's teachings which do not change. [quote]I'm sorry that you see only what you want to see when it comes to the Church.[/quote] That's not true. [quote]I hope in due time your eyes will be opened and you will humbly accept that the Novus Ordo as celebrated throughout the world is perfectly valid.[/quote] I believe that the offoical text of the Novus Ordo Missae, which is in Latin, is not only valid and licit, but also beautiful. I am not obliged to believe any of those things about the translations of the Missa Normativa from Latin, though I do believe the translation in English is valid because the words "This is my Body" and "This is [the Chalice of] my Blood" are said quoting God the Son. [quote] I have never read a Catechism in its entirety, does that mean I am in a state of mortal sin until I do? I definitely believe that I know in good part what the Church teaches, I have taken theology classes and was a Catholic campus minister at a university.[/quote] Have you read any Catholic catechism entirely? The CCC isn't the only one out there, and you don't have to ever even have to read it. Were the theology classes orthodox? Edited August 13, 2006 by StThomasMore
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now