Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

RIAA and MPA


Especially MPA. I dont support stealing or violating copyrights but when they say u cant make tabs and go shutting down these websites. ITS PATHETIC. What are they gonna do arrest you if you listen to a song and figure out how to play it??? its absurd, These copyright laws are getting more and more extreme.


:maddest: :maddest: :maddest: :maddest: :maddest: :maddest:

Posted

What gets me is that when a public establishment (like a bar/restaurant) has a TV on, and they are televising a sporting event, and the event plays a song, the public establishment is shaken down to pay royalties to the music industry.

Posted

That was a pretty random post.

:huh:

Posted

[quote] What are they gonna do arrest you if you listen to a song and figure out how to play it??? [/quote]


give it a few years, the excuse will materialize

Posted (edited)

"Excuse me sir/madem, but I believe you were humming a close representation of Pop Vomit's latest hit 'I think I can sing.' This is a serious infraction and you are asked to appear in court."

Anyone remember "Fair Use" laws, where if you owned it you could do just about anything with it as long as you didnt distribute.... yeah.

EDIT: How long before listening to music too loud is counted as distribution

Edited by 2xbob
Posted

at my high school radio station we used to do "album hour" once a week for the purpose of people being able to record the entire album off the radio... we lost interest in it, but then my shift partner dj and i ressurrected it one summer recently... wahaha... we didn't run into any problems, fortunatly..

heh, and at this radio station the general manager sells us blank cds for $1 each so that we won't steal cds we like and will burn ourselves a copy instead

Theologian in Training
Posted

[quote name='Franimus' post='1046535' date='Aug 20 2006, 06:26 AM']
at my high school radio station we used to do "album hour" once a week for the purpose of people being able to record the entire album off the radio... we lost interest in it, but then my shift partner dj and i ressurrected it one summer recently... wahaha... we didn't run into any problems, fortunatly..

heh, and at this radio station the general manager sells us blank cds for $1 each so that we won't steal cds we like and will burn ourselves a copy instead
[/quote]

Truth be told, that is also considered illegal. I just use iTunes. The thing, about this whole copyright issue, that bothers me, is the fact that it is illegal to rip YOUR OWN PURCHASED DVD for archival purposes. The way I look at it if you have enough space on your harddrive and would rather use a remote to sort through your DVD's rather than digging through piles, there should not be anything wrong with it. Of course, I don't do it, because it is illegal, but it really bothers me, since I actually own the DVD, or maybe that is the point, they are trying to get across that we do not own anything, they own it all....how's that for paranoid :detective:

The other thing that gets me is the fact that they will not allow for you to download TV shows because you have to buy a DVD collection instead. However, what about the fact that the only way you can get HD shows is by having an HD box (if you want to pay) or an HD antenna which enables you to get free over the air HD? I have yet to see any HD DVD TV Shows.

I abide by the law, since it is the law, but I don't think it is just or fair.

My .02

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='Franimus' post='1046535' date='Aug 20 2006, 05:26 AM']
at my high school radio station we used to do "album hour" once a week for the purpose of people being able to record the entire album off the radio... we lost interest in it, but then my shift partner dj and i ressurrected it one summer recently... wahaha... we didn't run into any problems, fortunatly..

heh, and at this radio station the general manager sells us blank cds for $1 each so that we won't steal cds we like and will burn ourselves a copy instead
[/quote]
:shock: That's totally illegal.

If anyone sings "Happy Birthday" in a movie, play or whatever, they have to pay royalities to the estate of the copywrite holder. That's why restaurants make up their own birthday songs to make the waitstaff sing.

Posted

In Canada it is legal to copy CDs. Just not to distribute.

In fact, we pay a tax on CDs that goes to the entertainment industry.

I honestly don't know much about it. :idontknow: But I don't feel guilty at all about burning CDs. I would if I earned money from distributing them, but I don't so.. whatever ;)

My views differ from most of PhatMass.

Posted

[quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1046575' date='Aug 20 2006, 07:41 AM']
If anyone sings "Happy Birthday" in a movie, play or whatever, they have to pay royalities to the estate of the copywrite holder.
[/quote]

Then one of my cousins owes somebody from the movie "Parenthood" royalties for singing a certain song beginning with "When you're sliding into first..." in the middle of a restaurant on Thanksgiving Day when he was 8 or 9...

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='Norseman82' post='1046644' date='Aug 20 2006, 10:48 AM']
Then one of my cousins owes somebody from the movie "Parenthood" royalties for singing a certain song beginning with "When you're sliding into first..." in the middle of a restaurant on Thanksgiving Day when he was 8 or 9...
[/quote]
Unfortunately, that song belongs to the public domain.

Posted

[quote name='Theologian in Training' post='1046573' date='Aug 20 2006, 07:26 AM']
I abide by the law, since it is the law, but I don't think it is just or fair.

My .02
[/quote]
you need not follow an unjust law, as a theologian in training you should know this :smokey:

Posted

Look I mean I have no problem with the law that says that you can't copy cds and give em to ur freinds to keep etc cause yeah tahts stealing-- same goes with file sharing etc. But I mean come on they're gonna shut down tab sites and lyrics sites. Its pathetic. Then they're real smug about it. I was reading that on one of their websites- like they were giving answers to FAQs and some of the answers were real smug and smart.

I still look up lyrics to see if theres too many swears or such in a cd I wanna buy or something. And I'll look up tabs for a song if I own it.

Theologian in Training
Posted

[quote name='notardillacid' post='1046710' date='Aug 20 2006, 01:09 PM']
you need not follow an unjust law, as a theologian in training you should know this :smokey:
[/quote]

Yes, but then it becomes relative to how one interprets a just law ;)

Posted

Theologian, if I'm not mistaken you can store your cds and dvds on your computer. It's just illegal to make copies to give someone else.

Music is a luxury though Notardillacid... so we need to follow those kinds of laws even if they seem unfair. Just because it seems ridiculous doesn't mean it's unjust. Unfair, sure, but surely not unjust. I think it's rather damgerous to use the term justice so lightly.

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

I believe it would be legal, unless explicitly stated otherwise, to rip a DVD to your hard drive for personal use. It's called space-shifting. Unfortunately, DVDs are loaded with anti-piracy blocks to literally keep you from doing this, as it can be used for illegal purposes I suppose.

Theologian in Training
Posted

Actually, I did a lot of research on this a while ago when I was really annoyed with this whole thing. The only way to rip a DVD, whether you own it or not, is by decrypting the CSS (content scrambling system). There was a whole big thing about websites linking to a program called DeCSS, which, quite simply, decrypts the CSS. Any program you use to rip a DVD would use this technology, thereby, circumventing the CSS and, in turn, making your average movie lover (who spends good money on these movies) a criminal.

If you research it, you will see that merely by using any program like that is considered illegal. The difference between CD and DVD is that CD's don't have the same encryption scheme embedded within them that DVD's do.

It annoys me to no end!

Posted

I don't care if you rip cds or dvds for your personal use, i don't think it is wrong. you bought the thing, so u can use it

Posted

What ticks me off is the protections they put on DVD's and software now. Like Sony, or Starforce, things that gain root level access to your computer without telling you and then, in an effort to combat people from mounting images mess with Window's IDE stuff until your optical drive doesn't work any more. Well, at least if your system is hacked and messed up or you optical drives fail to work because Starforce trashed them the big wigs can sleep well at night knowing that you aren't copying their software/music/movies.

I hate those laws that prohibt the ripping of DVD's. Because of the protections on them, like Theo said, you can't rip them. Which bugs me because I would much rather have them on my harddrive and save the power that would be used to read the optical drive when I don't need to. It really really bugs me.

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

[quote name='Theologian in Training' post='1046780' date='Aug 20 2006, 03:36 PM']
If you research it, you will see that merely by using any program like that is considered illegal.
[/quote]
You are correct. I cannot stand copyright laws...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...