aalpha1989 Posted August 21, 2006 Posted August 21, 2006 I really don't see anything wrong with burning CD's, as long as you don't sell them. Sometimes my friends burn CD's for me...I wouldn't buy the CD anyway so it's not like I'm stealing money from the artist. And anyway copyright laws are all about money they aren't really about what is right/wrong, it's about how the artist doesn't think that the millions they already have are enough.
Iacobus Posted August 22, 2006 Posted August 22, 2006 [quote name='aalpha1989' post='1047153' date='Aug 21 2006, 09:35 AM'] I really don't see anything wrong with burning CD's, as long as you don't sell them. Sometimes my friends burn CD's for me...I wouldn't buy the CD anyway so it's not like I'm stealing money from the artist. And anyway copyright laws are all about money they aren't really about what is right/wrong, it's about how the artist doesn't think that the millions they already have are enough. [/quote] While I have little room to talk as I have borrowed music from friends and play other peoples music on the network at school, I think I understand their logic. At least in theory. In reality, I think (but then again I am a bit of a commie), that it is all about profit. The "I wouldn't buy it anyway so it isn't like they are losing money" logic makes sense, a bit. Because you aren't really costing the recording company any money (you aren't making them give you CDs to copy to) and it isn't like you would have otherwise bought it so you aren't "denying them profit." However, it is a bit like an idea. When you have an idea or an argument that you create, you "own" that idea. Nobody can use your idea if they obtained the idea from you without giving you credit. When I work with people in chemistry in groups and one of them helps me or I help them they are required, by the prof and the school, to write on the paper exactly what help was given to them and what not. It is because the help comes, partly, in the form of ideas which they are then using to complete their homework. They were not the owners of that intellectual property so when they use it they must cite it. It isn't all about being able to "source check." So that is the idea. The music on the CD is the property of the recording company, they own the ideas form the music. So when you take their copywrited work from them you are stealing their ideas and not repaying them for it. At least I would like to be cited or paid for my work, but then again, I have a bit of an ego...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now