Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Emotions and Divine Immutability


Recommended Posts

Posted

The fathers would have not felt either way about open theism. They would have thought the issue was unnessasary to debate. Really, that it is bad theology and does not matter.

but hey, thats the fathers.

Posted

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1135444' date='Dec 5 2006, 07:54 AM']
The fathers would have not felt either way about open theism. They would have thought the issue was unnessasary to debate. Really, that it is bad theology and does not matter.

but hey, thats the fathers.
[/quote]

I disagree strongly about this statement. If you look at the works of the Fathers like Origen, the Cappodocians and Augustine they were constantly trying to defend the transcendence of God for innumerable reasons. One of the main reasons for the Arian controversy is because Arius said that the Son's generation introduced change in the Godhead, same thing with the Eunomian and Apollinarian controversies, same thing with the Eutychian controversy actually...God's immutability was viciously defended by the Fathers, sometimes literally.

However, thats not my point.

My point is that you should stop trying to understand, not just for the sake of your finals, but for the sake of your spirit in general. It sounds like you're developing an illness of heart and an illness of soul and that is the opposite of what God would wish for you. As the good priest said this whole mess your mind in seems to be the creation of the evil one.

I can empathise with the difficulties you're having. You were schooled in Open Theism in a formative period of your life, ditching it is like ditching half of what you know about Christianity. Yet one has to accept these things sometimes. Catholicism is the in for the penny in for the pound type religion. When I came back to the Church I had to abandon many of the notions about God that I had formed incorrectly due to my lack of proper catechesis (and the influence of oriental philosophy upon me), whilst learning to accept new ones e.g. The Trinity. It is a shock to the system. It feels like you are suddenly spinning around with your full weight on your ankle hoping that it wont collapse beneath you painfully...
...but it has to be done.

Just look at the life of St Augustine who had to make a sharp break with all those elements of Platonism that did not suit the Church (so much so that people say he had a second conversion in the 390s, an idea being challenged by Carol Harrison in her new book 'Rethinking Augustine's early Theology'). But he believed that he may understand being illuminated inwardly by the light of faith rather than trusting solely in his powers of intellection.

You cannot take it with you. Thats something you're sooner or later going to have to accept just like many of the great saints that have come before you e.g. St Ambrose, St Augustine, St Hilary of Poitiers and so many others up to the present day. Rather than reading our responses perhaps it would be better for you to let read about their lives and their willingness to abandon their previously held convictions for sake of the kingdom of God?

Posted

That was incredbility helpful Myles.

To be honest, the reason I responded so quick to the Father comment is my initial research into the fathers was for some kind of anything involving openess. I couldnt find it. I spoke to a respected protestant patristic professor (*who thinks very little of TWT, btw) and he says the fathers would have thought it bad theology and not worried about it.

but he isnt catholic, I throw my trust at this board.

I think you are correct in the example of the saints. Augustine is someone I am familiar with and he worked through the marks left by his former philosophy. I think I need to do that as well, but I need something to put into now. A big problem I am having is just that I can not "buy into" it. If someone asked me "what is the purpose of prayer" I would answer in an open theistic way, same with theodicy, same with God's relational nature. I need to learn the answers to those questions in the way the church taught. But at the same time not losing what I have. That is the dangerous ground I am treading. But it is a test. If I trust the Church I continue knowing He is right and She will help me. A battle between grace and pride.

I am going to read through the TWT and other threads during break. I am going to ask some very simple questions, but I am going to try to defeat this. Not at the academic level, but at the simplest one. Frank Sheed says this is one of the more difficult aspects of the faith to understand. But I would like to give him a run for his money.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1135475' date='Dec 5 2006, 07:18 AM']
That was incredbility helpful Myles.

To be honest, the reason I responded so quick to the Father comment is my initial research into the fathers was for some kind of anything involving openess. I couldnt find it. I spoke to a respected protestant patristic professor (*who thinks very little of TWT, btw) and he says the fathers would have thought it bad theology and not worried about it.

but he isnt catholic, I throw my trust at this board.

I think you are correct in the example of the saints. Augustine is someone I am familiar with and he worked through the marks left by his former philosophy. I think I need to do that as well, but I need something to put into now. A big problem I am having is just that I can not "buy into" it. If someone asked me "what is the purpose of prayer" I would answer in an open theistic way, same with theodicy, same with God's relational nature. I need to learn the answers to those questions in the way the church taught. But at the same time not losing what I have. That is the dangerous ground I am treading. But it is a test. If I trust the Church I continue knowing He is right and She will help me. A battle between grace and pride.

I am going to read through the TWT and other threads during break. I am going to ask some very simple questions, but I am going to try to defeat this. Not at the academic level, but at the simplest one. Frank Sheed says this is one of the more difficult aspects of the faith to understand. But I would like to give him a run for his money.
[/quote]

I suggest that you allow your thread to be a break. I know the spiritual syndromes you are showing...I've had them myself (and often do). The priest is right. Surrender it for your own good. :)

Ever read "A Wrinkle in Time"? If you have, then you know that Charles Wallace fell to "it" because he believed pridefully that he could defeat "it" with his mind...Satan is much quicker and smarter than we are. Satan is a much greater theologian than any man. Let it go and put your trust in the Church. Eventually God may show you the solution, but don't try to force it.

Posted

Ok, I will avoid the thread...good idea,


BUT, y'all need to tell me EXACTLY what to read over break.
Let me be influenced....

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1135514' date='Dec 5 2006, 10:26 AM']
Ok, I will avoid the thread...good idea,
BUT, y'all need to tell me EXACTLY what to read over break.
Let me be influenced....
[/quote]
[u]A Map of Life[/u], by Frank Sheed
[u]Yes or No?[/u], by Peter Kreeft
[u]Understanding the Scriptures[/u], by Scott Hahn (textbook)

:mellow:

Guest JeffCR07
Posted

Taking time during break to sit down and contemplate [i]On the Harmony of Foreknowledge, Predestination, and Grace of God with Free Choice[/i] by St. Anselm might help?

Also, like Myles and Raph, I totally know what you are going through. I had to drop a [i]lot[/i] of philosophical and theological assumptions and views that I had been trained in when I really committed to communion with the Church. It really is such a hard situation, but you said it exactly right: it is a battle between grace and pride. I'll definately keep you in my prayers, please keep me in yours!

Your Brother In Christ,

Jeff

Posted

[quote name='Raphael' post='1135538' date='Dec 5 2006, 10:27 AM']
[u]A Map of Life[/u], by Frank Sheed
[u]Yes or No?[/u], by Peter Kreeft
[u]Understanding the Scriptures[/u], by Scott Hahn (textbook)

:mellow:
[/quote]


tryin to sell me more txt books..;) I have read Thelogy and Sanity and Theology for beginners by Sheed, about 7 kreeft books and mucho Hahn books. My overall "catholicisity" is very strong and craving. If it was not, I would have been gone a long time ago. Are any of those books specific to this issue?


[quote name='JeffCR07' post='1135557' date='Dec 5 2006, 10:54 AM']
Taking time during break to sit down and contemplate [i]On the Harmony of Foreknowledge, Predestination, and Grace of God with Free Choice[/i] by St. Anselm might help?

Jeff
[/quote]


Being that St. Anselm was not an early church father I have very little of his writings. Is there a digital copy somewhere? Being that in the original TWT thread you cited him often I am sure he helped develop your understanding.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1135715' date='Dec 5 2006, 05:35 PM']
tryin to sell me more txt books..;) I have read Thelogy and Sanity and Theology for beginners by Sheed, about 7 kreeft books and mucho Hahn books. My overall "catholicisity" is very strong and craving. If it was not, I would have been gone a long time ago. Are any of those books specific to this issue?
[/quote]
No. I think you need a break from this issue. I thought maybe you'd care to look at some of the texts I think helped me to see the interconnectivity of doctrine you so admire.

Guest JeffCR07
Posted

you can get free pdf files of a solid translation of all of Anselm's work off the webpage of Professor Jasper Hopkins. If you have trouble, I can just email you the file

Posted

My mind does not rest until at rest...it is a sickness.
trust me, I need to pound it out, develop a foundation. Answer my questions. Know what I mean.

jeff...I think you have mentioned him before, but a website would be great help

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1136088' date='Dec 6 2006, 12:02 AM']
My mind does not rest until at rest...it is a sickness.
trust me, I need to pound it out, develop a foundation. Answer my questions. Know what I mean.
[/quote]

Yes, I know exactly what you mean. I've lost much sleep over many things. Stop this tendency now before you begin to lose faith. There have not been many theologian saints in the last few centuries and the reason is because for many, theology has been merely an academic and rational pursuit. Take time to rest and use your heart. Theology cannot be done so forcefully. You must use theology to seek God. Allow yourself to slow down. Focus on the coming of Christ the King and pray that He enlighten you this Christmas, but do not try ravenously to fulfill your hunger for knowledge. Seek to develop instead a hunger for the truth and beauty and glory that comes from knowing, loving, and serving God.

I don't mean to lecture you...we just share a common sickness, I think, and I am giving you a heads up about what comes ahead.

Posted

Short question cause my mind wont put this down..

"If" God "knows/sees" our future acts completly, and knows us perfectly, and can influence humanity. Where is our free will in salvation if God knows our outcomes to ever push and pull.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1138098' date='Dec 8 2006, 12:48 PM']
Short question cause my mind wont put this down..

"If" God "knows/sees" our future acts completly, and knows us perfectly, and can influence humanity. Where is our free will in salvation if God knows our outcomes to ever push and pull.
[/quote]
I'm going to answer by posting a conversation I had with an old friend. I hope it helps. I'm in red, she's in blue.

[color="#FF0000"]God is outside of time, since time is a created thing. He doesn't really see things happening before they happen, or even after they happen...to Him, everything that happens in time is in the present. He sees it as it's happening, but He can see all the "happening" at once. So He sees what we do with our free will...just all at once. Since He sees it all at once, we would perceive Him as seeing the future, but it's only the future to us, not to Him. So really, we're not bound to what He sees, but rather, He sees what we freely do. Moreover, an analogy...if one man on top of a building sees another man walking into a manhole on the street, we don't say that he caused that other man to fall in, but only that he saw it happen. So knowledge of what is going to happen doesn't restrict what's going to happen at all.[/color]
[color="#000099"]so god knows everything, just has no timeline for it?[/color]
[color="#FF0000"]lol...well...He knows when things happen in time, He just sees all time at once. I suppose you could compare it to looking at a ruler in front of you. If you had the capacity to concentrate on every point of the ruler at once, you would be seeing them all at once. If we colored one of the points (I realize that a point has no geometric size, but bear with me) and it moved along the ruler, you would see it moving, but since you saw all of time at once, every moment (in its time) along its movement would be visible to you at the same time (in your time). now, of course, God technically has no time. One of the weaknesses of theology is that analogies aren't perfect, lol[/color]
[color="#000099"]right[/color]
[color="#FF0000"]It's a hard concept to grasp, but that's it. All of time is immediately visible to God. To Him, I am present as a baby, a teenager, an adult, an old man, and, God willing, a saint in heaven.[/color]
[color="#FF0000"]however, I am not yet, to me, an old man or a saint[/color]
[color="#000099"]so he sees your whole life, but not as it happens, just all at once[/color]
[color="#FF0000"]Well, both, really, lol...you see, "as it happens" refers to a change in time, and all changes in time occur in time, so He does see it as it happens, but He sees the before, during, and after of every "happening" all at once[/color]
[color="#000099"]ok, so he sees it as it happens and as a whole[/color]
[color="#FF0000"]yes, each detail and every detail, all at once, because His "point in time" (although He's really outside of time) is fixed. I would sort of compare it to time-elapsed photography...if we could take God's memory (if God had memory) and examine it, I think it would look like that
and yet, it would also be crystal clear...not at all blurry
lol
the fact that the human mind fails to grasp it, and yet, that it somehow makes sense, generally indicates that it's accurate with reference to God, lol
Now, then we have God's intervention in time, but that's not so hard to understand. God works in time, but also sometimes doesn't intervene. He does this because He knows how everything will turn out in the end and He knows exactly what to do for the best. Notice, however, that He never forces anyone to do anything...He may put people in difficult situations, but He never possesses them or anything.
He only controls things in such a way so as not to hinder human freedom. He may provide you with fewer choices, but you can always choose to go with Him or against Him.
God only intervenes in our lives in a way so as to present us more opportunities to grow closer to Him. He knows that He is the fulfillment of our every desire, so like a good teacher, He keeps giving us extra chances.[/color]

Anyway, the point is that God's knowledge of what we will do doesn't mean it's set-in-stone. He knows it not because He stood at the beginning of time and looked forward and saw all that would happen as if it was fate, but because He stands at the side of time and sees things as they happen and He stands at the end of time and sees things as they happened. He gives us choices and we decide. He knows what we will decide, but that's not because He had prior knowledge. He did have prior knowledge, but only because He's eternal. His knowledge from seeing all that would happen is His the same as His knowledge from seeing how we've made it happen.

Futher, knowledge of what will happen doesn't equal causation of that future event. If I am permitted to see that I will win the lottery tomorrow, that doesn't mean that my seeing that future necessarily caused me to win the lottery...the numbers were randomly selected...my knowledge of them had nothing to do with what numbers would come up. The same way, God knows what we will decide. The determining principle in decision-making is in man.

A ---> B

A=internal choice
B=act

God sees A and B from all eternity, thus allowing Him to see what would happen, but He still didn't make it happen that way...He sees us make it happen that way. The decision is in us. What you're proposing is this:

God knows A, therefore, B.

In reality, it's really:

A ---> B.
A, therefore, B.
Oh, and God knows it.

Guest JeffCR07
Posted

Rev, all of Anselm's treatises can be found [url="http://cla.umn.edu/sites/jhopkins/"]here[/url]

The De Concordia is what you want (it is the very last treatise of his on the list). Please take your time with it - don't rush through it. Anselm, like many other Doctors of the Church (and perhaps more than most) often blurs the line between meditation, contemplation, prayer, and philosophy. As such, any cursory reading or speed-read will just be a waste of time.

Please know that you are in my prayers, and I am confident that, with the guidance of the Holy Spirit, you will get through this time of trial. May the Peace of Christ be with you!

Your Brother In Christ,

Jeff

Posted

I'm really late on this thread, but maybe can offer something a little worthwhile on what's come before.

On experience of God: a lot of posts talk about God "experiencing" or having "experiences." I think that's out of bounds. It sounds as though something is being done to God, with God as a passive subject. Nothing happens to God. God does all that is. The only other actors, us and the angels, "do" analogously and in a way that is wholly contingent on God's primary "doing." We might be an efficient cause, but only God can be the Final Cause.

On God having emotions: some of this discussion seems to point to God's "emotion" as analogous to ours, but that's backwards. It's our wrath, love, etc. that are analogous to God's. Likewise, the word "passion" is particularly dangerous because it means something that is done to you, something that happens beyond your control, or something you suffer. We can predicate it of God, as long as we remember the analogy.

On stoicism: The Christian (and Jewish) concept of an unchangeing God is emphatically NOT stoic. The stoic idea rejects even analogous passion in God...God can't care or He wouldn't be God. Much of the Reformed tradition slides this direction as well....Calvin, e.g., as though God caring about us infringes upon His sovereignty.

It's striking to me that these points, as well as almost all the previous posts, revolve around one central point of confusion, and that is the analogy of being. Here's what I mean: the stoic and the open theist look opposite, but they are two sides of the same mistake. They collapse the analogy of being, and fall to either side. Either God experiences/feels like we do, or not at all. Only the Analogy of Being can break this awful bind.

Think of Parmenides arguing with Heraclitus. "Being is, therefore nothing in the universe ever changes, change is impossible." "No, everything changes, there is nothing that does not change, the only thing that Is is change itself." That's the same double bind.

Our relation to God is analogous the way a painter's painting is related to the painter as his creation. There is no substantial analogy...none of the painter's substance has been transferred away from him to the painting. So we're not neoPlatonists or "emanationists." However, something of the painter can be known in the painting. How much? Not much. But something TRUE. Seeing "Starry night" without knowing anything of it's creator, you would be at a loss for words to describe what you've learned about him from his work, right? And yet you really would know him more than before.

analogy is always present. Even in defining it, e.g., "whatever similarity exists, a greater dissimilarity exists", we are analogously defining analogy! Because the terms "similar" and "dissimilar" can only analogously be applied between God and creation.

i don't know if this helps, but reading through the thread I think it might be helpful to identify the real point of difficulty, and I think that's it. So maybe that would be a helpful direction for further efforts. Just my $0.02

Posted (edited)

I was trying to say so much I completely forgot about the Christological component. Just something I would add to what's come before, that talking about Christ's two natures can never be done without remembering the unity of His Person. He was one divine Person, and I haven't seen this distinction in the discussion so far. How it plays out in formulation: Christ's divine nature did not suffer. Divine nature can't. Christ's human nature did suffer. Here's the kicker: The divine Person suffered.

Only the person/nature distinction upholds (sorry, here it comes again) the analogy of being. And consequently, by the communication of idioms, we can say that God suffered. He suffered in a human nature, which He had taken to Himself. So divine nature remains perfectly divine, and yet God really experiences suffering. (This is also an important corrective to my last post.)

rev, it's not that I think you need me to tell you this stuff. From what I remember, you probably already know all this and could quite possibly formulate it more clearly. But sometimes when your mind is spinning out of control like a tire on ice, it helps to grab one bit and say "stop...look at this, get some traction."

Edited by beatty07
  • 3 weeks later...
Posted

Ok, so God is immutable, never changing.

What difference does it make if God "experiences" time at once. When he created us, since we are not eternal there had to be a "moment" in which he created us and experienced all of time at once(*according to what is expressed here) or if he experiences our time graduatly as it develops and progresses?

Guest JeffCR07
Posted

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1153389' date='Jan 1 2007, 04:07 AM']
Ok, so God is immutable, never changing.

What difference does it make if God "experiences" time at once. When he created us, since we are not eternal there had to be a "moment" in which he created us and experienced all of time at once(*according to what is expressed here) or if he experiences our time graduatly as it develops and progresses?
[/quote]

This would only be true if God existed in time, but He does not. If we understand God to be outside of time, then everything that God [i]does[/i] is done in one perfect act that is outside of time just like He Himself is. This single act is simultaneously the act of Creation, Incarnation, Sanctification, and all else that God does. There is no "moment" when God created that followed some previous "moment" when it was just God. God is outside of all conceptions of time.

Your Brother In Christ,

Jeff

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...