N/A Gone Posted January 3, 2007 Author Posted January 3, 2007 Jeff, we might need to do a couple rounds here. even one moment is still a moment, There was a moment when we did not exist, then there is a moment when we did exist. Before that existence God did not experience us, after our existence he experienced all we experience(in your model of everything at once) but that means that there was a moment in which he did not experience something that he later did. also, the creation and fall of the angels is another thing that did not happen in our created world, but is something that shows God experiencing a change. If God is eternal, and what God is never changes we can mutually hold to that. But I do not see how we can have a God that experiences time at once. The essence of time is that it is not at once. It is a progression. Small events here show that God has to have experienced progression. But then there are also aspects such as the incarnation, and the numerous old testaments interactions that appear to have God regret, or change his mind. Im starting to wonder here if aspects of openess might not be as closed off as I am led to believe Why doesnt the catechism speak on this?
Guest JeffCR07 Posted January 4, 2007 Posted January 4, 2007 hahaha, you know me, I'm always willing to go as many rounds as you want or need! : The problem is that you are trying to imagine time as being somehow outside of creation. You are seeing the moment of creation as somehow being contained "within" the broader context of time. Try imagining that time is [i]part of[/i] Creation. Time began when creation began. As such there could be no "before" in a temporal sense precisely because there was no time logically prior to the act of Creation. notice how I said "logically" prior. This is a critical distinction to make. Something can be logically prior without being temporally prior (prior in time). In the same way that God the Father is logically prior to God the Son (since the latter is begotten of the former) it does not follow that there was ever a "moment" in time when the Son did not exist. In the same way, there was never a moment in time "before" God created - it was [i]the[/i] beginning. Your Brother In Christ, Jeff
N/A Gone Posted January 4, 2007 Author Posted January 4, 2007 Jeff, I dont see how this answers my objections. God still "experiences" something that has not always been. WHether this is for a moment, or progressively the fact is he still experiences something. I dunno, maybe I need to read your response again. I just dont know how this isnt just semantics. As if the problem was there and over time someone has worked hard enough to fit it together, but it doesnt seem like the natural working.
Guest JeffCR07 Posted January 4, 2007 Posted January 4, 2007 I think the answer to your question (and this is my fault for not bringing it out earlier) can be found in the distinction made by the Fathers and Scholastics of [i]sub species aeternae[/i]. That is, God "experiences" but he experiences all things under the aspect of eternity. Thus, God eternally experiences all of Creation, Redeption, Sactification, etc. as one eternal "present." Thus, although all things, considered under the aspect of time, "began," under the aspect of eternity they have always existed, since it was always true that, in time, they would begin. Because God experiences things under the aspect of eternity, he experiences all things as eternally created by him, but he does not experience their creation within time. Rather, he experiences it from eternity. Your Brother In Christ, Jeff
Guest JeffCR07 Posted January 4, 2007 Posted January 4, 2007 Rev, while I was doing thesis research I ran across a quote from Professor Dominic J. O'Meara's [i]Plotinus: An Introduction to the Enneads[/i] that may help. If you are familiar with Plotinus at all, you will know that O'Meara is one of the top scholars of Neoplatonism alive today. Here is what he has to say that I think is very relevant to the issue at hand: [quote]It should be noted finally that the derivation of divine intellect from the One must take place outside of time, since time is produced by soul which derives from intellect...There can be no beginning or end to the derivation of intellect. It does not happen at a particular moment. To speak of the One as giving rise to divine intellect would be misleading if we are to imagine this as taking place in the framework of time and space, occurring at a moment such as those moments marking lower processes of derivation or production. Divine intellect exists as an eternal, that is extra-temporal, expression of the One. O'Meara, pg. 65[/quote] This is much the same in logic as the issue we are discussing. It would be wrong to say that there was a "moment" when God created (and thus a "moment" when God experiences us) because "moments" occur in time, and so would demand that there be a preceeding "moment" (as you have been arguing) in which God did [i]not[/i] experience us. This, however, arises not from a problem with the theory of God's extra-temporal nature, but rather, the problem is located in our not being careful enough when we attempt to describe such a nature. Perhaps this will help bring my previous points into better focus. Since God exists outside of time, it is wrong to think of God experiencing "moments." Rather, God experiences all things eternally as one. Your Brother In Christ, Jeff
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now