Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Rcia-related Question


Recommended Posts

Posted

I have friends who are currently in RCIA -- she's Catholic, but has never been confirmed (or something like that) and he's currently undecided as to his faith affiliation. Last night a mutual friend of ours called me after she had dinner with this couple ... although I haven't talked to the couple personally, our mutual friend told me she was really disturbed by some of the things the couple has been told by their priest.

The most disturbing thing they told her is that the priest told the husband that he doesn't have to believe in Jesus, but that as long as he lives a "good life" and believes in something larger than himself he can be saved. They told her that the priest said this was Catholic teaching stemming from Vatican II. The mutual friend is Christian, but not Catholic, and she was understandably appalled at this.

I feel like I should address the situation somehow, but I don't want to be disrespectful to this priest (particularly since I'm getting this third-hand). And, I don't want my friends to end up way more confused than they started out. Ideas?

Posted

You need to make it clear to your friend that there isn't even a quesiton of the validity of that man's statements. Make it clear to her that the Church has rock solid beliefs. Priests like that undermine the Church's claim of exclusivity, and it sends her mixed messages.

I'm really getting sick of people abusing V-2 to justify their sick, twisted, and perverted ideas.

Posted

[quote name='Sojourner' post='1064292' date='Sep 16 2006, 03:26 PM']
I have friends who are currently in RCIA -- she's Catholic, but has never been confirmed (or something like that) and he's currently undecided as to his faith affiliation. Last night a mutual friend of ours called me after she had dinner with this couple ... although I haven't talked to the couple personally, our mutual friend told me she was really disturbed by some of the things the couple has been told by their priest.

The most disturbing thing they told her is that the priest told the husband that he doesn't have to believe in Jesus, but that as long as he lives a "good life" and believes in something larger than himself he can be saved. They told her that the priest said this was Catholic teaching stemming from Vatican II. The mutual friend is Christian, but not Catholic, and she was understandably appalled at this.

I feel like I should address the situation somehow, but I don't want to be disrespectful to this priest (particularly since I'm getting this third-hand). And, I don't want my friends to end up way more confused than they started out. Ideas?
[/quote]

I dunno. Can't really say I disagree with this priest..., but that's all I'm gonna say about it :D: :cool:

Posted

The point still remains that your personal opinion doesn't matter. That priest is supposed to be teaching ex corde Ecclesia always, which clearly he's not interested in.

Charity would probably dictate that you confront that priest.

Posted

Charity might dictate that, but distance makes such a confrontation difficult. Plus I'm a big chicken.

Posted

[quote name='DAF' post='1064330' date='Sep 16 2006, 04:25 PM']
The point still remains that your personal opinion doesn't matter. That priest is supposed to be teaching ex corde Ecclesia always, which clearly he's not interested in.[/quote]

Yeah, I was saying that I agree with him that that is Church teaching post Vatican II. And THAT is all I will say about it :D:

Posted

And I was saying that he should be teaching ex corde Ecclesia always (i.e., the Church didn't teach that carp out of V-2)

:spike:

Posted (edited)

Get your friend a copy of the Cathechism and show him the relevant parts relating to the Church's relationships with non-Christians (somewhere near paragraph 840-850, I think).

Edited by Norseman82
Posted

I'm not sure 840-850 is the section you want for this. 839-841 say the Jews and Muslims share in the plan for salvation and they don't believe in Jesus. Maybe try another section that would fit better?

Posted

[quote name='Sojourner' post='1064292' date='Sep 16 2006, 03:26 PM']
...

The most disturbing thing they told her is that the priest told the husband that he doesn't have to believe in Jesus, but that as long as he lives a "good life" and believes in something larger than himself he can be saved. They told her that the priest said this was Catholic teaching stemming from Vatican II. The mutual friend is Christian, but not Catholic, and she was understandably appalled at this.

I feel like I should address the situation somehow, but I don't want to be disrespectful to this priest (particularly since I'm getting this third-hand). And, I don't want my friends to end up way more confused than they started out. Ideas?
[/quote]
Okay, I have a few clarification questions/comments to make:

1) Was this actually RCIA or a Catholic information session? Now, don't everyone go falling off their soapboxes at once, hear me out. Granted, the theological credence of the teachings ought to be the same, but it seems as if the instructor is at less of a fault if this is merely an informative session, rather than part of initiation into the Church. (Please understand, I am not condoning what this priest may have said.)

2) There is teaching from Vatican II that speaks about salvation inside and outside of the Church. In defense of the priest, he may have simply told this may that salvation is possible outside of this church, [b]IF[/b] a person (through no fault of their own) is unaware the truth of the Catholic Church. The priest's apparent appeal to "living a good life" is consistent this the teaching that God speaks to all persons, by their very creation, through grace. So........ while there is the possibility that a person may be saved outside of formal membership of the Catholic Church, such salvation is not certain (or even considered possible) for those individuals who take the "No thanks Rome, I think I'll do things my way" approach.

Now, as far as addressing this situation, [i]please [/i]don't go over to these people's homes with gift-wrapped copies of the Catechism (now, perhaps the [b][url="http://www.usccbpublishing.org/productdetails.cfm?sku=5-450"]US Catholic Catechism for Adults[/url][/b] recently out by the USCCB, but that's neither here nor there). It is also, as you mentioned charity... I agree that exhibiting such virtue (as well as that of prudence) is important here. Bring the conversation up with your dinner-host friend and see if you can glean any additional information from her. Also, if this man and woman are your friends as well, [i]ask [u]them [/u]about this![/i] Bring up the topic of RCIA and see how things are going. That will produce a much more fruitful conversation than "I think your priest is wrong, etc etc etc." (Not that you would go about it in such a fashion.)

Well, keep us posted! :)

Posted

goldenchild. I really expected more from you. Are you joking or do you really not understand the concept here?

To quote our holy father in an interview with Peter Seewald

How many ways are there to God?

"As many as there are people. For even within the same faith each man's way is entirely personal one. We have christ's word: I am the way. In that respect, there is ultimately one way, and everyone who is on the way to God is therefore in some sense also on the way are identical in terms of consciousness and will, but, on the contrary, the one way is so big that it becomes a personal way for each man"

another thing is Pope Bennedict's understanding of Lauterkeit which is that in all religions there are men of interior purity who through their myths somehow touch the great mystery and find the right way of beng human.

So the idea isnt that other systems of faith are valid. But that someone can still be touched by grace, still find salvation while in those systems. Not because of those systems, and not always in spite of those systems. CS Lewis and other theologians have wrote that in the other myths of the world there are partial truths, those truths can led to a pursuit of other truths, and sanctyfying grace.

Vat 2 teaches a few things here. In regard to protestants it is the understanding that in their eccesiologies there are variance of truths that can lead to sanctyfying grace. The key is to find those truths and be open to the seeking of more truth. Not to be in these systems because they feel that it is enough. For to truely seek truth will bring you to more truth.

oh...btw,


why does it seem that RCIA is very flawed? I know there are only a few people I talk to. I never went through it, but i have rarely heard good things about it.

Posted (edited)

I understand the concept. I just don't think it's right. Otherwise I never would've switched faiths. And I think based on this part of the catechism, that this priest was not off-base in what he said.

Edited by goldenchild17
Posted

I am sorry friend, I dont know your background or how you switched from what faith to what.


and the priest was hugely off. It has nothing to do with a denial of Christ. or simply being good. but by discovering the sanctyfing grace. Plenty of people are good people but do not have grace. Thats a product of modernism

Posted

[quote]I am sorry friend, I dont know your background or how you switched from what faith to what.[/quote]

From Novus Ordo to Sedevacantist. Long story, not allowed to go into it on these boards.

[quote]and the priest was hugely off. It has nothing to do with a denial of Christ. or simply being good. but by discovering the sanctyfing grace. Plenty of people are good people but do not have grace. Thats a product of modernism[/quote]

Do Jews and Muslims discover sanctifying grace? How?

Posted

I think we need to be careful here. The preist might well have spoken the Catholic teaching correctly but I have heard this teaching twisted in to what the woman's husband said so many times that it's not even funny.

" told the husband that he doesn't have to believe in Jesus, but that as long as he lives a "good life" and believes in something larger than himself he can be saved"

I highly doudt the priest told the man "HE doesn't have to believe in Jesus" saying that perhaps he could quit believing in Jesus or that someon who has been given the grace to believe in Jesus doesn't have to believe in Jesus. The teaching is simply that if someone does not beleive in Jesus we cannot judge them and leave that to God. So before you go confronting the priest I would take a deep breath and hope that his words are simply being misunderstood as non-catholics so easily do especially in this area. Then go and have a respectful dialogue with him.

Posted

[quote name='goldenchild17' post='1065748' date='Sep 18 2006, 01:23 AM']
From Novus Ordo to Sedevacantist. Long story, not allowed to go into it on these boards.
[/quote]

I admit, I know absolutely nothing about any of the "groups" some education on them would be great. Like, are these groups heretical or schismatic? Or are they viable catholic expressions? Thank you for help on this.


[quote]Do Jews and Muslims discover sanctifying grace? How?[/quote]


The individual people can discover grace. Not the people overall. These communities do have parital truths. The world itself has partial truths. In romans Paul is able to convict the gentiles because they should be able to be moved towards grace simply by creation. Now, if a lil islamic boy is raised islamic and is faithful to his faith and truely submits to truth and responds to it. I feel that grace can be found. The Holy Spirit moves all of creation towards Him. People in these systems can be moved by the spirit. Not because of these systems. Not inspite of them. As catholics we have more truth. We have the sacraments and the dogmas of truth. We have more truth expressed for us to react towards. But the key is still the reaction to grace expressed.

once again, I am not a militant. If I am wrong or someone who knows more speaks I will submit.

Posted

You may be asking the wrong guy. They are schismatic. That is why he is not allowed to go in to it. CAUTION.

Posted

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1065663' date='Sep 17 2006, 11:48 PM']
Vat 2 teaches a few things here. In regard to protestants it is the understanding that in their eccesiologies there are variance of truths that can lead to sanctyfying grace. The key is to find those truths and be open to the seeking of more truth. Not to be in these systems because they feel that it is enough.[b] For to truely seek truth will bring you to more truth.[/b]
[/quote]
(Emphasis added) Revp, thanks for your helpful contribution. You said what I wanted to say, but in clearer terms.

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1065663' date='Sep 17 2006, 11:48 PM']
oh...btw,
why does it seem that RCIA is very flawed? I know there are only a few people I talk to. I never went through it, but i have rarely heard good things about it.
[/quote]
I've read and studied the rite. It's not perfect, but it is (in my humble opinion) [i]beautiful[/i]. I mean, you could come from the viewpoint that there was nothing like this before Vat II, so something is better than nothing. It's also [u]very hard[/u] to impliment [b]well [/b]in parishes. My area of ministry experience is not in RCIA directly, but when I've looked, I haven't found much in the area of pastoral aides to help with RCIA. Additionally, sometimes there is a fundamental lacking in the area of education and training for those leading RCIA and RCIC.

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1065845' date='Sep 18 2006, 10:23 AM']
The individual people can discover grace. Not the people overall. These communities do have parital truths. The world itself has partial truths. In romans Paul is able to convict the gentiles because they should be able to be moved towards grace simply by creation. Now, if a lil islamic boy is raised islamic and is faithful to his faith and truely submits to truth and responds to it. I feel that grace can be found. [b]The Holy Spirit moves all of creation towards Him. People in these systems can be moved by the spirit. Not because of these systems. Not inspite of them. [/b]As catholics we have more truth. We have the sacraments and the dogmas of truth. We have more truth expressed for us to react towards. But the key is still the reaction to grace expressed.

once again, I am not a militant. If I am wrong or someone who knows more speaks I will submit.
[/quote]
[b]AMEN[/b]

Posted

thanks for having my back thess....there are still some basic catholic things that I do not know about or have been exposed to yet.

thank you for the props short nun. It is great to know i could have helped

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...