Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Rcia-related Question


Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1065845' date='Sep 18 2006, 10:23 AM']
I admit, I know absolutely nothing about any of the "groups" some education on them would be great. Like, are these groups heretical or schismatic? Or are they viable catholic expressions? Thank you for help on this. [/quote]

According to the Vatican it's heretical. It's really a different Church that claims to be the true Catholic Church. As such we don't overly care much that the Vatican considers us heretical. In actuality, according to pre-Vatican II teaching such a belief is not at all contrary to the Catholic faith and we shouldn't be considered heretical. But it is what it is.

Again though, as Thess was so quick to point out ;), I am considered schismatic by V2 and by phatmass so as per dUST's rules at this time I am not permitted to discuss this stuff. Even though all other non-Catholic faiths are allowed to...

[quote]The individual people can discover grace. Not the people overall. These communities do have parital truths. The world itself has partial truths. In romans Paul is able to convict the gentiles because they should be able to be moved towards grace simply by creation. Now, if a lil islamic boy is raised islamic and is faithful to his faith and truely submits to truth and responds to it. I feel that grace can be found. The Holy Spirit moves all of creation towards Him. People in these systems can be moved by the spirit. Not because of these systems. Not inspite of them. As catholics we have more truth. We have the sacraments and the dogmas of truth. We have more truth expressed for us to react towards. But the key is still the reaction to grace expressed.

once again, I am not a militant. If I am wrong or someone who knows more speaks I will submit.[/quote]

I would agree in principle. This could fall under the idea of legitimate invincible ignorance. But I just don't think this catechism, or other teachings especially those from Vatican II documents relate this in the correct manner. To say Muslims or Jews (there is no specification of a muslim individual or Jewish one) share in God's plan for salvation I think is incorrect.

Edited by goldenchild17
Posted

the language of "sharing in God's plan for salvation" begs to be misinterpreted by everyone. I tend to trust and not worry about it too much. I have used the passage many times to simply show we dont hate islam

Posted

Yeah it's possible that it could be interpreted rightly. I'm just not sure how. Besides I have serious issues with the idea that church language can ever be "ambiguous" which is the reasoning given behind just about every post-Vatican II document that I can think of. But as you say there is a possibility of orthodoxy. I guess I just have taken the other route based on context and whatnot.

Posted

shornun answered the original question of this thread correctly. i'm closing this now.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...