dabukthumpa Posted January 9, 2004 Author Posted January 9, 2004 Polor Bear: Yes - strictly speaking, the Divine Liturgy of St. John Chrystotom is more ancient than that of the Tridentine (if your speaking of the codified Mass of Pope St. Pius V after Trent). But If your familier with Joseph Jungmann - and the History and Development of the Roman Rite - He would disagree with you - in terms of The Divine Liturgy of St. John Chrystotom being more ancient than the Roman Rite itself.
cmotherofpirl Posted January 9, 2004 Posted January 9, 2004 Yep, the poll should be removed. We don't pit catholic vs catholic here.
dabukthumpa Posted January 9, 2004 Author Posted January 9, 2004 I am a bit disturbed by some of the short replies, and sarcastic remarks made toward me. As a fellow Catholic Christian - I would expect to be treated with kindness. It is ok for some of us to come to different conclusions - but to almost accuse me of not being in line with the Church - and then to imply that I do not respect the Church's way of prayer. That really hurts.
p0lar_bear Posted January 9, 2004 Posted January 9, 2004 I said it was older than the Tridentine rite, not the Roman Rite... I agree with cmom, this should be removed.
dabukthumpa Posted January 9, 2004 Author Posted January 9, 2004 Aesthetically - many things can be superior than others. Truth, Beauty and Goodness are objective realities that the Catholic Church has always upheld. For Example there is no question that the Sistine Chapel is far more beautiful than the Popel Paul VI Auditorium. Of even than the Chapel in my own Church. The Chapel here at home and the Sistine Chapel are both that Chapel. But I can make a perfectly good argument that the Sistine Chapel is Aesthetically more beautiful than the Chapel in my Church here at home. The Same can apply for the differnt forms of the Liturgy. I am not argueing against the validity - simpley the beauty of their forms in which they are expressed.
BLAZEr Posted January 9, 2004 Posted January 9, 2004 I am a bit disturbed by some of the short replies, and sarcastic remarks made toward me. As a fellow Catholic Christian - I would expect to be treated with kindness. It is ok for some of us to come to different conclusions - but to almost accuse me of not being in line with the Church - and then to imply that I do not respect the Church's way of prayer. That really hurts. Get over it. We're not angry with you, we are, however tired of these discussions. In fact, if you had taken the time to read the Phorum guidelines you would have seen that any Traditional vs. Novus Ordo talk is forbidden in this Phorum. We have seen this discussion digress into insane bickering about senseless things. We have seen good catholics and non-catholics scandalized by these Catholic against Catholic disputes. This discussion is akin to me saying: Do you think that the Divine Mercy Chaplet is more aesthetically appealing than the Rosary? And then arguing that the Chaplet is more appealing and more attractive. I could use the same arguments. I've seen people insert all sorts of heresies into the Rosary. I've seen people say "Nature" rosaries and "hootnanny" rosaries. I've seen the rosary used to defend abortion (check out CFFC on that one, they're nuts, granted). All of these discussions do not serve a good end. And, they're silly. The beauty of the Lord's Sacrifice cannot be reduced to aesthetics. The most beautiful part of the mass is the part you CAN'T see.
dabukthumpa Posted January 9, 2004 Author Posted January 9, 2004 The Tridentine is the Roman Rite. Also - I don't see what the problem is. Why you feel the poll has to be removed, I don't know. Let people vote. It is perfectly ok. I am interested in why most people have voted undecided. I think it is good poll to have on.
marielapin Posted January 9, 2004 Posted January 9, 2004 thumpa - please don't be alarmed by the reactions you are getting by asking an asthetic question. The reason you are getting the reactions is because in the past there have been some hot and heavy arguments here started by trads about the invalid nature of the Novus Ordo. I'm sure the folks that have been around here a long time just went into defense mode, that's all. Everyone here that I know of is obedient to the Church, no matter our preferences. And by the way, I've never been to a Tridentine Mass, as I cannot find one locally. But I would love to attend one!
dabukthumpa Posted January 9, 2004 Author Posted January 9, 2004 I am talking about aesthetics in general - not appealing. I am talking about objective beauty. I can understand - if you have had problems before. But I am not trying to Pit - any Traditional against Novus Ordo business. but It is a fair question - and I think answered truthfully - would help to dispell many of the negative feelings toward the Rich Tradition of the Church's past -and would even help us come to a place where we can see the Novus Ordo Mass done with more reverence - and uplifting devotion - from priests, laity, within the prayers, the music, the architecture etc.)
p0lar_bear Posted January 9, 2004 Posted January 9, 2004 The Tridentine Rite refers to the Roman Rite developed after the Council of Trent. The English word “Tridentine” is derived from the Latin word Tridentum, the ancient name of the city now known as Trent. This poll should be removed because it is contrary to the guidelines and at least implies disrespect for the liturgy of the Church (even if you did not intend it to).
BLAZEr Posted January 9, 2004 Posted January 9, 2004 BTW, I would like to go on record as saying "I prefer the Tridentine Rite" And "I think the Liturgy of St. John Chyrsostom is the Bestest!" And "I still think the Novus Ordo is amesome!!"
Ash Wednesday Posted January 9, 2004 Posted January 9, 2004 (edited) I don't know if I've ever been to a Tridentine mass (so I voted "undecided"). I should remedy that. I was at the Vatican in 98, and I don't think that was a Tridentine mass. It was Novus Ordo said in Latin and Italian. (I think?) The first Latin mass I ever attended was at St. Etheldreda's in London. It brought tears because it was so beautiful. (Or maybe because the incense was strong) The saddest abuse of the mass I've ever seen was in Ireland. The mass was 35 minutes long and the priest said it like an auctioneer, only with less enthusiasm. Edited January 9, 2004 by Ash Wednesday
cmotherofpirl Posted January 9, 2004 Posted January 9, 2004 I am talking about aesthetics in general - not appealing. I am talking about objective beauty. I can understand - if you have had problems before. But I am not trying to Pit - any Traditional against Novus Ordo business. but It is a fair question - and I think answered truthfully - would help to dispell many of the negative feelings toward the Rich Tradition of the Church's past -and would even help us come to a place where we can see the Novus Ordo Mass done with more reverence - and uplifting devotion - from priests, laity, within the prayers, the music, the architecture etc.) Your poll does not imply any of that, does it? Maybe thats what you intended, but it is certainly not reflected in the poll. It is misleading. If you which to discuss objective beauty, maybe you should start a thread on that instead.
dabukthumpa Posted January 9, 2004 Author Posted January 9, 2004 I do not think the question goes agianst the guidelines. Also I have made that clear. And in no way does it imply disrespect for the Liturgy of the Church. It simply asks a totally valid question. Both Forms of Mass are valid, they meet the same ends, yet one can be inferior in regards to the depth of it's beauty -and the manner in which it signifies the truths being professed. I have not broken any rules, and I would hope you all would be interested in the final results of what people have to say.
dabukthumpa Posted January 9, 2004 Author Posted January 9, 2004 There is no other way for me to ask the question - for which I was interested in the results for. Also - it is good to hear that some - (1) prefer the Tridentine Rite (I would ask why?) and (2) that someone else has at least been to a Mass said in Latin and it brought "tears to her eyes" (not from the incense I am sure - but from the reverence and manner in which that particular Mass was celebreated).
Thomas Michael Posted January 9, 2004 Posted January 9, 2004 (edited) There's been a few English Nov-O Masses I've been to that brought ME to the verge of tears... where the atmosphere, the music, the lighting and everything totally jelled, producing a beautiful and very touching ceremony. It's all basically a matter of taste, I guess. I think the Novus Ordo is getting a bunch of bad press because some liturgical abuses went unchecked through the years, resulting in a form of Mass that's not performed the way it was intended. At any rate, I think we're on our way to the back alley with this... Edited January 9, 2004 by Thomas Michael
dabukthumpa Posted January 9, 2004 Author Posted January 9, 2004 Thomas Michael - I would argue that it is not just a matter of taste. But rather Beauty itself is objective. Some things are just objectively more beautiful than others. You can have two of the same thing (like people for instance) and one can be Objectivly more beautiful than the other - or superior in beauty. This is what I am seeking by asking the question. I argue that the Tridentine Mass is objectively more beautifully superior than the Novus Ordo Mass.
dabukthumpa Posted January 9, 2004 Author Posted January 9, 2004 Also, i would add that it is not about getting lucky and hoping all the elements have jelled. This should never have to be. Rather it is about the Form of the Mass itself.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now