Budge, Cite Your Source

[Winchester]

I was going to let this go, but heck, since we're talking about tactics....

I believe I shall level the accusation at Budge that she types (or cuts and pastes) things in such a manner as to present a lie. A lie is something less than the truth. Putting this supposed "tactic" on the board intimated that it was an accepted tactic among apologists. Not showing a balanced view gave lie to the proper pursuit of apologetics.

Please counter, Budge, or tell us you did not mean to present this as a legitimate tactic, somehow endorsed by us or in wide pracitce among the honorable. That you did not mean to impugn Catholics as a whole. I'll believe you if you say it, but I'd like to be sure.

[Winchester]

Bumpity bump.

[Veritas]

[quote name='Winchester' post='1076084' date='Sep 26 2006, 06:03 PM']
Bumpity bump.
[/quote]

Ba.... Bump, Ba...Bump...

[SJP]

bump

[Winchester]

Bump

[SJP]

BU BU BU BU BUMP!! BUMP BUMP BUMP BUMP

[Winchester]

bump

[Cam42]

I think that this thread has more bumps than any in near memory.

BTW, BUMP.

I'd like to see a response to this thread, an honest one.

[Veritas]

+

Hmmm....

[Thy Geekdom Come]

There once was a poster named Budge
and onto the forum she'd trudge,
she'd call you too subtle,
and away she would scuttle,
and her topics you'd just have to [b]NUDGE[/b].

[Winchester]

After being called childish for not liking answers, I'd like the opportunity to actually be childish after I don't like this one.

J'accuse!!! Budge was being intentionally deceptive.

[Veritas]

[quote name='Winchester' post='1079758' date='Sep 29 2006, 07:54 PM']
After being called childish for not liking answers, I'd like the opportunity to actually be childish after I don't like this one.

J'accuse!!! Budge was being intentionally deceptive.
[/quote]

?

[Winchester]

[quote]From Catholic Apologist Technique List.
Cant you folks come up with better then this?
* 3: Accusation of hate technique


Insist vehemently that your opponent is full of hate.
It is always advisable to paint your opponent as hateful.
This technique should always contain a reference,
to your extreme caringness and the limitless bounds of your great humility.
[/quote]

I asked Budge to cite the source.
Unfortunately, she was banned for something or other and could not answer.
Budge is no longer banned, she still has not cited her source, althought someone else supposedly took blame, I should like to find out where Budge got it. I submit that Budge has not responded because she was being intentionally deceptive in representing this as some sort of legitimate book and a widely accepted tacic. I submit that she has employed propaganda in the worst form. She has yet to cite her source, has had ample opportunity to cite it. I am making a bold accusation---I shall of course retract it if Budge can give some explanation as to her intent.

[Veritas]

[Winchester]

Budgie, your credibility is on the fast track to the sewage treatment plant.