Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

There are many points on which I believe Open Theism is either extremely dangerous (proximate to heresy) or explicitly heretical. The first example I gave in the original TWT thread pertained to the formal dogma that [b]"God knows the future, including the free acts of his creatures, with an infallible certitude"[/b].

If I may quote myself:

[i]A categorical denial of any of the following propositions would constitute explicit heresy:

- Time had a beginning
- Time has an end
- God transcends space and time

To explicitly deny these statement would be heresy.

[b]"God knows the future as perfectly and absolutely as He knows the past; this certainly includes all free acts of creatures." - Dogmatically Decreed[/b]

Molinism is not heretical, or per se proximate to heresy, because its theory of scientia media (middle knowledge) is in the realm of God's providence and does not in any way constitute a denial of scientia simplicic intelligentia or God's sovereign knowledge (of all history) nor does it do violence to the understanding of God's transcendence.


Basically, it is Christian truth that everything which is not God, was created out of nothing. This includes temporality which is a constituent of finite being. This can be affirmed regardless of how one conceives of time, so long as this conception recognizes the difference between finite or contingent being, and eternal, infinite being. In other words between Creator and creation.[/i]

Let the games begin.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1081021' date='Oct 1 2006, 04:54 PM'][i]- God transcends space and time [color="#FF0000"]*[/color] [/i][/quote]
[color="#FF0000"]*[/color] Of course the correct understanding of this does not contradict the reality that God is active and manifest in the created order.

Posted

Where did you get those Dogmas from? What Pope defined them?

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='StThomasMore' post='1081217' date='Oct 1 2006, 07:50 PM']
Where did you get those Dogmas from? What Pope defined them?
[/quote]
The stuff in bold is derived from multiple conciliar statements, the most recent being the first vatican council which said of God: "[i]All things are open and laid bare to His eyes, even those which will be brought about by the free agency of creatures[/i]" - session III.

[i]"Omnia enim nuda et aperta sunt oculis eius, ea etiam, quae libera creaturarum actione futura sunt."[/i]

The context of this dogma is the dogma of God's timeless vision which states that God knows all things past, present and future with an absolute and perfect knowledge (called [i]scientia visionis[/i]).

The dogma of God's [i]scientia visionis[/i] does not cause tension with the dogma of human freedom as the fathers make clear, as do later latin formulations which rightly distinguish [i]necessitas antecedens[/i] and [i]necssitas consequens[/i]. Namely, the future free actions that God sees in His timelessness do not follow from antecedent necessity but rather by consequent necessity. This is the inner logic of Augustine's analogy of remembering. This analogy simply states that just as our remembering of past actions does not serve as a cause of those actions, so is it that God's [i]scientia visionis[/i] is not a cause of necessity to the actions known. Unlike 'God according to Open Theism', we do not believe that God is surprised.

There are also a vast number of statements pertaining to the beginning and end of time. In fact just prior to the vatican I quote above the council speaks of "[i]the beginning of time brought into being from nothing[/i]".

Posted

Sean, as a friend and lil brother I will plea modesty here. I have tried hard to develop a more catholic understanding in theology and I have tried hard to flood out my TWT. But I cant. (*hence why this thread) but in that understanding I am not sharp on the lingo as I was in the past on this. I will be speaking to you in regards to my soul and how it is processing this dialogue. I do not see this as a debate for me to prove open theism works. Open theism in its developed is a protestant doctrine. My goal is to make mine the teachings of the Church. We are dialoguing "me" not openess. But rather the Openess that has made my metaphysic for so long.


[quote]There are many points on which I believe Open Theism is either extremely dangerous (proximate to heresy) or explicitly heretical.[/quote]
-well, i think your feet smell. Whats your point? (**ok, just kidding, i will keep this serious. thank you once again)

-A thing to remember about this, and many protestant doctrines is that they are not doctrines in the pure sense of the word. They can vary to the individual based on the epistemology of that individual. How I see open theism, or rather openess principles (**boyd wanted me to rename it a while ago) can and do change from person to person. Boyds openess is different than mine, as it is different for the other major openess theologians. As a catholic my desire is to either develop a non-heretical version of openess. Or do answer the questions that openess attributes answers for me. Openess was essential to the developed of my faith and the issue of theodicy is at hand.

[quote]The first example I gave in the original TWT thread pertained to the formal dogma that [b]"God knows the future, including the free acts of his creatures, with an infallible certitude"[/b].[/quote]

Of course the semantics and varient understanding of a passage might be an issue. But I agree with you here on this. The difference is how he knows the free acts of his creatures. Classic openess will say that God knows the future because it is closed. The present cause it is happening. and the future as all the options open that are yet to be settled. A major issue here is that Boyd has classically condemned, and thus brought me up, in the greek concept of God out of time. As the unmoving thinker. The idea that change harms, and the perfect being would be unchanged. Boyd denies time. This has been a tough thing for me, cause as I try to seperate the two. I cant. I can think of a God uneffected by time. That does not change his mind, that does not experience emotions. My scriptural understanding and philosophical understanding contridicts this on a large scale as you seen in the TWT thread.


[quote]If I may quote myself:

[i]A categorical denial of any of the following propositions would constitute explicit heresy:

- Time had a beginning
- Time has an end
- God transcends space and time

To explicitly deny these statement would be heresy. [/quote]

-Define time and this beginning and this end. What happens with creation? What happens to us? I am sure that I agree with you, I just want to make sure.

-God transcends time and space. This will need to be worked on. I dont believe in time travel. Because I dont believe in time as anything more than recorded change. it is non-dimensional. Metaphysics on a large scale affirms this as a possible understanding. I will affirm that God is not bound by space or time. What I mean by bound is under the effects of. God does not age, he is beyond the effects of time. But experience is not a depravity of time. It is a logical outcome of relation.

[quote][b]"God knows the future as perfectly and absolutely as He knows the past; this certainly includes all free acts of creatures." - Dogmatically Decreed[/b][/quote]

--This might need a better understanding. As I sited above. God does have complete knowledge. There is nothing that exists that God does not know. (**remember the monkey?) but he knows the past as closed, and the future as options. There is no option that exists that God doesnt know. But knowing these as different does not make them wrong. He knows me as a 23yr old right now. In the future he will (hopefully) know me as an old man. The change in the way he knows does not change that fact that he knows me perfectly. God knowing the options or potentials that will become settled does not change what God knows, but just the development of the thing he knows. If we are self causing in our actions to even the slightest degree then it is not settled until we settle it. Either consciously, or unconsciously.

[quote]Molinism is not heretical, or per se proximate to heresy, because its theory of scientia media (middle knowledge) is in the realm of God's providence and does not in any way constitute a denial of scientia simplicic intelligentia or God's sovereign knowledge (of all history) nor does it do violence to the understanding of God's transcendence.[/quote]

--Go into more detail on this please. Boyd Sites Molinism often. To the degree that Open theism is often called Neo-molinism. I want to know how you think I am harming God's transcendence or soverign knowledge

[quote]Basically, it is Christian truth that everything which is not God, was created out of nothing. This includes temporality which is a constituent of finite being. This can be affirmed regardless of how one conceives of time, so long as this conception recognizes the difference between finite or contingent being, and eternal, infinite being. In other words between Creator and creation.[/i][/quote]

well written. But unless I am missing a point I do not see what is the issue here. Respectfully.

[quote] Of course the correct understanding of this does not contradict the reality that God is active and manifest in the created order.[/quote]

I think this is an essential thing to remember. Thank you for including this. To simply write off old test interactions of emotion and regret and changing His mind can not be written off as an anthropromorphism. Jewish scholarship is strongly opposed to this idea. (**Dr. Joe Sprinkle)

[quote]The stuff in bold is derived from multiple conciliar statements, the most recent being the first vatican council which said of God: "[i]All things are open and laid bare to His eyes, even those which will be brought about by the free agency of creatures[/i]" - session III.[/quote]

woah..how did i miss this gem. Brother, that is a very open thestic view. "which will be brought about" self-causation, to a degree, brings about the settling of future events. it is not settled until the free agent brings about his share of the causation.

**no latin please. I dont speak it.

[quote]The context of this dogma is the dogma of God's timeless vision which states that God knows all things past, present and future with an absolute and perfect knowledge (called [i]scientia visionis[/i]).[/quote]

-I agree with this. The issue is "how" or "in what form"

[quote]The dogma of God's [i]scientia visionis[/i] does not cause tension with the dogma of human freedom as the fathers make clear, as do later latin formulations which rightly distinguish [i]necessitas antecedens[/i] and [i]necssitas consequens[/i]. Namely, the future free actions that God sees in His timelessness do not follow from antecedent necessity but rather by consequent necessity. This is the inner logic of Augustine's analogy of remembering. This analogy simply states that just as our remembering of past actions does not serve as a cause of those actions, so is it that God's [i]scientia visionis[/i] is not a cause of necessity to the actions known. Unlike 'God according to Open Theism', we do not believe that God is surprised.[/quote]

--Anselm, right? Saying that God knows the events we will make because of an equation of how we relate to outside sources that God knows (*chaos theory) makes us an equation. Nothing more. We have no "free" will. "freedom" in the will would possess to a degree self-causation. Our outcomes are not determined until our self-causation has in part determined it.
We can reflect on the past because it is settled. It can not change. We do not possess the ability to change it in any way. God is not surprised in open theism. He has complete understanding of all the possiblities. Thus can not be suprised. But we can choose an option different from what he would have wanted. and can experience sadness or regret in this (*as the OT clearly shows) God is not caught off guard or surprised.

[quote]There are also a vast number of statements pertaining to the beginning and end of time. In fact just prior to the vatican I quote above the council speaks of "[i]the beginning of time brought into being from nothing[/i]".[/quote]

yes, but what is time?

LD, What open theism have you read? Besides TWT thread? Within the variances of openess it is only relevent to stick to Boydian and my understanding of it. Also, unlike the TWT times. I have fallen out of favor to a degree with Boyd so he might not be avaliable for specific questions like last time. (**sad situation, smells of elderberries major)

Posted

dude..i am gonna draw you a picture...Seriously..I think i can explain my issue. I will try to do it tommorow and get it to you. on here

answer my comments also, if you want. thanks bro. This means alot.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

As ironic as this may sound, I don't have time at the moment to respond in full, but allow me to post a few tidbits that reflect the Catholic world-view.

The questions of the metaphysical nature of time pertain to natural theology or philosophy, but the question here pertains to orthodoxy. Obviously these subjects are related, but the one is not necessary to arrive at the other.

Here are a few catechism quotes which express the truths relating to the dogmas outlined in my first post, these are hardly esoteric doctrines but are truths of the Christian Faith that are so common place as to be almost taken for granted.

[b]Beginning of time:[/b]
[i]338 Nothing exists that does not owe its existence to God the Creator. The world began when God's word drew it out of nothingness; all existent beings, all of nature, and all human history are rooted in this primordial event, the very genesis by which the world was constituted and time begun.[/i]

[b]End of time:[/b]
[i]1042 At the end of time...[/i] (and many more)

[b]God beyond time:[/b]
[i]205 God calls Moses from the midst of a bush that burns without being consumed: "I am the God of your father, the God of Abraham, the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob."9 God is the God of the fathers, the One who had called and guided the patriarchs in their wanderings. He is the faithful and compassionate God who remembers them and his promises; he comes to free their descendants from slavery. [b]He is the God who, from beyond space and time[/b], can do this and wills to do it, the God who will put his almighty power to work for this plan.[/i]

[i]600 [b]To God, all moments of time are present in their immediacy.[/b] When therefore he establishes his eternal plan of "predestination", he includes in it each person's free response to his grace: "In this city, in fact, both Herod and Pontius Pilate, with the Gentiles and the peoples of Israel, gathered together against your holy servant Jesus, whom you anointed, to do whatever your hand and your plan had predestined to take place."395 For the sake of accomplishing his plan of salvation, God permitted the acts that flowed from their blindness.396 [/i]

[i]212 [b]He transcends the world and history[/b]. He made heaven and earth: "They will perish, but you endure; they will all wear out like a garment. . . .but you are the same, and your years have no end."25 In God "there is no variation or shadow due to change."26 God is "HE WHO IS", from everlasting to everlasting, and as such remains ever faithful to himself and to his promises. [/i]

[i]42 God transcends all creatures. We must therefore continually purify our language of everything in it that is limited, image-bound or imperfect, if we are not to confuse our image of God--"the inexpressible, the incomprehensible, the invisible, the ungraspable"--with our human representations.16 Our human words always fall short of the mystery of God. [/i]

[i]43 Admittedly, in speaking about God like this, our language is using human modes of expression; nevertheless it really does attain to God himself, though unable to express him in his infinite simplicity. Likewise, we must recall that "between Creator and creature no similitude can be expressed without implying an even greater dissimilitude";17 and that "concerning God, we cannot grasp what he is, but only what he is not, and how other beings stand in relation to him."18 [/i]

You would probably enjoy the CCC: Part I, Section II, Chapter I, Article I. Particularly the fourth and fifth subsections which have the following paragraph headings:
- God creates by wisdom and love
- God creates "out of nothing"
- God creates an ordered and good world
- God transcends creation and is present to it.
- God upholds and sustains creation.
- Providence and secondary causes
- Providence and the scandal of evil.


These sections of the catechism express catholic orthodoxy on many of the matters that I believe open theism is wrong about. You won't find a refutation of open theism, or even a long explanation of the teachings, but I think it is important because you seem to still have this idea that open theism can be reconciled with Catholic teaching.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1082152' date='Oct 2 2006, 02:56 PM']
LD, What open theism have you read? Besides TWT thread?
[/quote]
- Numerous articles by various authors
- Two books:
a. "The Openness of God", by Clark Pinnock, John Sanders, Richard Rice, William Hasker and David Basinger
b. "God of the Possible", by Gregory Boyd

Oh, and the TWT thread which is no small matter since it is easily book length. ;)

I admit that I could benefit from reading more Boyd, but I don't think that I'm entirely incompetent in criticizing his views.

What have you read which directly challenges open theism? Besides TWT thread? I'm thinking about scooping up some books to that effect. I've heard that "God's Lesser Glory" by Bruce Ware is pretty good.

Posted

In all charitableness(**is that a word?) Bruce Ware is a hateful moron when it comes to TWT.

I have debated the leader in anti-opentheism. In John Piper when I was in high school. As far as a functional protestant belief I have never found reason to oppose it.

I need to get those pictures from you. i think I figured something out, but i am having problems explaining it without a white board.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1088023' date='Oct 9 2006, 11:15 PM']
In all charitableness(**is that a word?) Bruce Ware is a hateful moron when it comes to TWT.

I have debated the leader in anti-opentheism. In John Piper when I was in high school. As far as a functional protestant belief I have never found reason to oppose it.

I need to get those pictures from you. i think I figured something out, but i am having problems explaining it without a white board.
[/quote]
I figured the guy (Ware) wouldn't necessarily be objective about it, but neither is Boyd from what I've seen. I just think it would be fun to get as many perspectives as possible. It can't hurt right? :idontknow:

Besides, even if the guy is a hateful moron, he might still have an interesting point or two.

I actually read some anti-open theist articles (by calvinists from what I could tell) and I thought they were pretty pathetic. Not that I disagree with them in that open theism is in error, but what they were arguing for was at least as erroneous as that which they were attacking. I consider open theism to be more attractive than calvinism at least. :hehehe:

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

woah..how do I forgot about this. I will get to it this weekend. PROMISE

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

[url="http://www.christusvictorministries.org/main/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=48&Itemid=99999999"]http://www.christusvictorministries.org/ma...Itemid=99999999[/url]

nice lil diddy..wanna kill it please?

let me do my pictures now. bloody midterms.

Posted

[img]http://photos-517.ak.facebook.com/ip002/v49/136/109/107600017/n107600017_30009517_9686.jpg[/img]

You have God, and you have time contained within God. Time is linear, God is beyond that.

[img]http://photos-518.ak.facebook.com/ip002/v49/136/109/107600017/n107600017_30009518_87.jpg[/img]

Time has a beginining and and End, pretermined, all of time is on a linear scale and we are in the middle somewhere, the past is as closed as the future, settled and we are just living a script

[img]http://photos-519.ak.facebook.com/ip002/v49/136/109/107600017/n107600017_30009519_439.jpg[/img]

Time is still contained within God, all the options and possible are experienced and known to God. They are not determined yet, because we have not done them yet. God can still "know" what we will do based on his perfect knowledge of all the factors, (*this is a very anti-TWT statement btw)


ok L_D, Phatty..

educate me

Posted

not even a joke on the drawings..;)

Posted

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1107109' date='Oct 31 2006, 10:32 PM']
not even a joke on the drawings..;)
[/quote]

I think that they look like Australia...

Posted

News flash...

while the apostasy of Revprodeji is not yet settled, rumor has it he thinks God is australian

Guest JeffCR07
Posted

the immediate problem that I have with this position, rev, is that it still contradicts the dogmatically decreed statement that "God knows the future, including the free acts of his creatures, with an infallible certitude"

Now, your argument hinges on the fact that God knowing future possibilities will account for this statement, but I'm not convinced. First (and perhaps foremost) that is clearly not the interpretation intended for the statement by the Council Fathers. Second, it seems that open theism would render "certitude" meaningless. By definition, if a thing is possible without being necessary, then that thing is not certain. Open theism maintains that God knows "future" actions as possible, but not as necessary. As such, it follows that God does not know, with infallible certitude, which future action will be taken through the free acts of his creatures. In this way, it seems that Open Theism has to do a number of very impressive backflips if it is to be understood in a way that does not contradict the above infallible teaching, and even if it is possible (which I doubt) I wonder if it would really even be recognizable as open theism once it has come out on the other side...

Your Brother In Christ,

Jeff

Posted

Hey Jeff, its been a while.

I am more concerned with reconcilling my theology with catholicism than to make open theism work. Im not even quoting open theism as much as just trying to progress thru my own logic. Hence why I am using the term "twt" or "openess" instead.

Posted

Quick question..

What is TWT?

Posted

[quote name='Quietfire' post='1110079' date='Nov 3 2006, 05:02 PM']
Quick question..

What is TWT?
[/quote]
trinity warfare theodicy

as for why open theism is called that, i have no idea.

btw, Jeff, can you post here the conciliar statements you are referring to?

thanks,
nick

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...