Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

The red is a fundi, makes Budge seem nice. Im the blue. How would you continue this article?


[quote][color="#FF0000"]Am I ever gonna get a reply big guy?

I was "waived" from RealGM for my last anti-Catholic thread I posted.

Funny thing was, it wasn't bad at all!

I saw the yahoo article saying the vatican condemned some African bishop for getting married and was going to excommunicate him and all I did was post the article and then quote the Bible stating that Bishop's MUST be "the husband of one wife" and that this is just one more proof that the RC religion is NOT Biblical Christianity but a cult.[/color]

[color="#3366FF"]You know that is bad exegesis...the bishop must "only" have one wife is the wording. the RC has not always had celebate priests/bishops that is a practice and could at sometime in the future change if they wanted it to.

I am working with the reply. I have 18 credits, and my internship right now..plus, newlywed actitivties.

If you wanna have some fun here is a website for you

www.phatmass.com

It is a catholic-college age website that has interdenominational debates. There are some fundis on there, but no one with your heat. If you want give it a shot. You would have a chance to debate with hundreds of lil "revprodeji's"

tell me what you think. I would like the chance to dialogue with you on there if realgm banned you. Its hard for realgm to control its audience. But www.phatmass.com is good. Make sure you call yourself Dr. Jefferson so i know who you are. [/color]

[color="#FF0000"]Thanks for the reply.

No, that is NOT "bad exegis". A Bishop MUST BE the "husband of only one wife". He is not permitted to be a polygamist, nor a celibate, the meaning is quite clear.

For the Vatican to excommunicate a Bishop for obeying the Bible and being the "husband of one wife" is just another of the long list of "proofs" that they are an unBiblical cult. It is as simple as that.

Read your own reply Jon and tell me if you don't see a the reply of a deceived cultist in it.

You said, "the RC has not always had celebate priests/bishops that is a practice and could at sometime in the future change if they wanted it to."

This is the kind of mind-numbing nonsense I hear from Mormons and Jehivah's Witnesses all the time.

I think I will stick with the NEVER-CHANGING word of God and not wait around for some fallible, satanic group of human infidels to "change their minds", yet again. .... amaing!

As for your reply ... I will wait patiently. I remember taking 21 credits one semester in juniour college ... I know how that can be, so there is no hurry!

As for the Phatmass ... haha, I may try it out when I have some more time. I am hoping to get a computer at home next week as Tonga just got a new high-speed satellite connection and has made it available to residential customers. it will be great not to have to go to town and drop a bung of money just to use the internet![/color][/quote]

***forum actin funny?

Posted

Well, you could go any number of ways.

You could be trite and reread your response and say, "Nope. Doesn't sound cultist to me." You could do the whole "need for interpreters" route. You could jump into the Greek if you have knowledge of it. You could remind him that the Catholic church created, defended and defined the Bible.

Posted

(paraphrase as necessary)

Dear Dr. Jefferson,

Let us look at these scriptures again. I suppose you do not mind if we use the KJV along side a few other versions of scripture to get the fullness of the Greek:
1 Tim 3:2
KJV
A bishop then must be blameless, the husband [b]of one wife[/b], vigilant, sober, of good behaviour, given to hospitality, apt to teach

NIV
Now the overseer must be above reproach, the husband of [b][u]but[/u] one wife[/b], ...

NLT
So an elder must be a man whose life is above reproach. He must be[b][u]faithful[/u] to his wife[/b].[a] ...

(NLT footnotes:[i]Or must have only one wife, or must be [b]married only once[/b][/i])

Our options from these various translations of scripture we could pick

husband
-of one wife
-faithful to his wife
-of but of one wife
-married only once

From these you insist a bishop [b]must have one wife[/b]. Sorry, I am just not seeing it.

Now, a question for you... Was the apostle Paul married? No. Was he a 'bishop'? Yes. Can you explain why Paul was not following the scripture he wrote? Could it be he was not required to have a wife before being ordained to such office?

Finally, you may not know it, but this bishop being excommunicated is a moonie... ie a member of the Unification Church started by Rev. Sun Myung Moon, [url="http://biblia.com/christianity2/3b-moonies.htm"][u]who professes he is God incarnate and denies Jesus is divine[/u].[/url] If you want to run around defending members of a church who believe salvation for men comes through "Having sex with a girl who had sex with Moon," then go ahead. I do not recommend it.

Posted

nice...thanks.

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

I don't understand how Scripture could be interpreted as saying a Bishop absolutely must be married. It seems inadaquate when compared to statements of Jesus about life in a celibate state for all who can accept it.

Posted

Quick thought:

He is married to but one wife: the Church. If he were married in the traditional sense as well, he'd be split between the Church and a woman.

Posted

[quote name='scardella' post='1087579' date='Oct 9 2006, 02:34 PM']
Quick thought:

He is married to but one wife: the Church. If he were married in the traditional sense as well, he'd be split between the Church and a woman.
[/quote]
Yes it is good logic that you understand. However it would not work with Prots. These ideas are part of the mystical experience of Christianity, which they lost long ago. Besides, Peter was married.

Posted

[quote name='jswranch' post='1087625' date='Oct 9 2006, 04:36 PM']
Yes it is good logic that you understand. However it would not work with Prots. These ideas are part of the mystical experience of Christianity, which they lost long ago. Besides, Peter was married.
[/quote]

It is true, nonetheless.

To continue to be trite, there's no evidence that Peter's wife was still living. It seemed rather odd that they mention his mother-in-law but never mention his wife. Furthermore, those words weren't penned until he was near death, and certainly, they weren't certified as part of "The New Testament" until well after his death.

Guest Štefan from Europe
Posted

Hi,
this is my first post so be patient. In response to the fundi I would point out to the rest of the Paul's quote. Here it is:
[i]2 It behoveth therefore a bishop to be blameless, the husband of one wife, sober, prudent, of good behaviour, chaste, given to hospitality, a teacher,
3 Not given to wine, no striker, but modest, not quarrelsome, not covetous, but
4 One that ruleth well [u]his own house[/u], [u]having his children[/u] in subjection with all chastity.[/i](Tim 3,2-4)

Soooooo, I know that this is not a scholar reasoning, but fundies aren't scholars. We will play their game. From the verse 2 we see, that a bishop [b]must[/b] be a husband of a wife. BUT reading further we see, that bishop [b]must also have a house and some children[/b]! Bishop without a house and children isn't a bishop! Goodbye bishop Peter(no children), goodbye bishop Paul(no wife, children nor house), goodbye bishop Timothy(no wife, children). Goodbye good men! Maybe she will see how silly her arguments are. And if she agrees that a bishop must have also a house and children - well then she is a lost case.

Posted

[quote name='Štefan from Europe' post='1087711' date='Oct 9 2006, 05:28 PM']
Soooooo, I know that this is not a scholar reasoning, but fundies aren't scholars. We will play their game. From the verse 2 we see, that a bishop [b]must[/b] be a husband of a wife. BUT reading further we see, that bishop [b]must also have a house and some children[/b]! Bishop without a house and children isn't a bishop! Goodbye bishop Peter(no children), goodbye bishop Paul(no wife, children nor house), goodbye bishop Timothy(no wife, children). Goodbye good men! Maybe she will see how silly her arguments are. And if she agrees that a bishop must have also a house and children - well then she is a lost case.
[/quote]
:lol_roll: Great point.

Welcome.

Posted (edited)

The question for Protestants (most) is where are their Bishops? Where are their celebates also? 1 Cor 7 and Matt 19 clearly indicate that some are called to celibacy. The Episcopalian/anglicans and lutherans are all that I know that have any kind of a celibate prescence. Some Baptists and the two denominations mentioned have bishops. If they want to be nit picky critical, they need to look at themselves as well.


We must also consider that early on a married population was all that there was to choose leaders from. Celibacy, requiring the grace of God to fullfill was not common.

Edited by thessalonian
Posted

He wrote back..but of course goes off topic and tries to pick on the RC....

[quote]Dear Jon,

Here are my replies in a quick point by point setup, as I am short on time:

1.) I don't "compare versions" as I'm not up for playing God and picking and choosing which version suits me.

2.) The NLT is a heretic version and I have no respect for it whatsoever.

3.) The obvious meaning is that a Bishop must be the husband of only one wife.

4.) Let me ask you a question .... WHAT does this mean to a RC? If you say that it means he must be the husband of one literal, physical woman, then all your Popes are unBiblical heretics. If you say that it means he must have been married only one time, but at least one literal time, then again all your Popes are unBiblical for they were never married. If you say that it ONLY has a spiritual meaning and that being that a Bishop must have as his ONLY wife, the body of Christ, then you make Peter out to be an imposter, for he had a LITERAL, PHYSICAL wife! There simply is no possibility to make RC doctrine fit with the Scriptures, as is the case with all cults when they are really pinned down on an issue.

5.) To answer your question, I would say YES, the apostle Paul WAS married. Paul is the one who wrote this, therefore he wouldn't disobey it himself. Now, whether or not he was a widow, or literally and presently married (like Peter) but never mentioned his wife, we do not know. This question is alot like the Jesus-hippies who defend their long hair, despite it being specifically prohibited (1 Cor. 11). They don't realize that the one who saw the risen Lord (Paul) is also the one who wrote that for a man to have long hair is a SHAME ....anyone who can honestly say that Jesus had long hair and Paul would still write this is amazingly conflicted.

6.) Yes, I know the man is a "Moonie" and I know all about their twisted little idolatrous cult. However, that is beside the point. Had the vatican excommunicated the man for being a Moonie, I would be applauding them. However, they instead excommunicated him for following the Bible in one particular area. This is not a one-time occurence either. The Vatican has a history of accepting idols, false religious beliefs, pagan superstitions and rituals, while condemning true Biblical obedience.

Well, I gotta run .... email soon.[/quote]

Posted (edited)

Dr. Jefferson,
Thankyou for your thoughtful response. Let us call this "The Discussion the Six Points." I hope to respond in like kind so we can ensure we stay on topic.

1. [i]I don't "compare versions" as I'm not up for playing God and [u]picking and choosing which version suits me[/u]. [/i]

I see your decision in [u]choosing[/u] the translation of the KJV over the NIV or NLT as [u]picking the version that suits you[/u]. This is not an issue of 'playing God.' As we neither speak Greek and Hebrew as exactly the New Testament writters would have nor do we have the exact transcripts of the orginal, we are forced to read it in the new language (modern English)... by [u]choosing or picking a translation[/u].

2.) [i]The NLT is a heretic version and I have no respect for it whatsoever.[/i]

If you dislike the NLT we can still look at some of the other versions 1 Tim 3:2.
KJV: the husband of one wife

NIV: but one wife

MSG: committed to his wife

TNIV: faithful to his wife

CEV: be faithful in marriage

NIRV: faithful to his wife
Yet you pick and choose to believe that, despite all the biblical scholars listed above working in these Protestant translations, the correct translation is [b]must[/b] be married.

3. [i]The obvious meaning is that a Bishop must be the husband of only one wife.[/i]

I agree, a bishop cannot be the husband of multiple wives. However, I disagree that a bishop must be married before his ordinatation. Again, you add the word "must." Why do you add the word "must" to your understanding? [u]None[/u] of the translations have added it! If this is so obvious, they why have none of the bible scholars inserted the word 'must'?

My interpretation by the Holy Spirit leads me to believe this verse is not requiring Bishop's to be married. Your interpretation does. If Sola Scriptura is true in that the HS leads each reader to the correct interpretation, then how can you tell me I am wrong compared to your interpretation? Are you infallible?

4. [Truncated] [i]WHAT does this mean to a RC? ... There simply is no possibility to make RC doctrine fit with the Scriptures, as is the case with all cults when they are really pinned down on an issue.[/i]

(Please stop calling us Roman Catholics, as not all Catholics are Roman but can be Marianite, Eastern etc.)

This passage says he is not to be a man of multiple wives (ie polygamy or remarried after divorce which is just another form of polygamy). The verse is not saying he must be married before ordination.

Do you not realize that Paul was writting to Greeks deep in the Hellenistic culture which allowed polygamy? They allowed men to get married, divorce, then remarry contrary to the words of Jesus.

5. [i]To answer your question, I would say YES, the apostle Paul WAS married. Paul is the one who wrote this, therefore he wouldn't disobey it himself. [/i]

If I read you correctly, Paul 'had' to married because 1 Tim 3:2 said a bishop 'must' be married. I see two errors. First, 1 Tim 3:2 is not a matter of must. Second, Paul made himself celibate for the kingdom (MT 19:12). We know this from 1 Cor 7:7. You have built up your own private doctrine from 1 Tim 3:2, and now you are forcing this doctrine against 1 Cor 7:7.


6. Ok, you understand Moonies. Perhaps you do not understand how Archbishop Millingo got himself in trouble in the first place. He got involved in the Moonies, spoke out against some of the Catholic teachings and got married. That landed him some disciplinary sanctions... ie he got fired and ordered no longer to function as a bishop. He also could not practice any of the sacraments under the threat of excommunication. After all this warning, he ordained a few priest against orders. He then automatically got himself excommunicated. My point is that he did come under sactions for siding with the moonies and he was not excommunicate for getting married but for other offenses: ordaining Moonies to the Catholic priesthood.

John

Edited by jswranch
Posted (edited)

Might I add that point 1 and point 2 are in conflict with one another?

Point 5: There's no evidence in the bible that he's married.

Edited by scardella
Posted

[quote name='scardella' post='1089157' date='Oct 11 2006, 01:08 PM']
Might I add that point 1 and point 2 are in conflict with one another?

Point 5: There's no evidence in the bible that he's married.
[/quote]

My point 1&2 or his?

Point 5, Paul was celibate. Are you asking about this?

Posted

[quote name='jswranch' post='1089454' date='Oct 11 2006, 06:20 PM']
My point 1&2 or his?

Point 5, Paul was celibate. Are you asking about this?
[/quote]

I was talking about his points, not yours. Your points are great, now that I've actually checked the scripture you referenced. I had forgotten what 1 Cor 7:7 (and context) said off-handedly when I originally read it.

Posted

Something important to also point out.

The Catholic Church does not excommunicate anyone, she cannot.

We excommunicate ourselves.
Again, that whole 'choice' thingy.

That Bishop was sanctioned, as was correct form. He was warned.

He, the Bishop in question, then decided to ignore the sanction and ordain without having the authority to do so and therefore...automatically excommunicated himself from the Church.

The Church didnt excommunicate him, he excommunicated himself.

Posted

[quote name='Quietfire' post='1091568' date='Oct 14 2006, 12:20 PM']
...The Catholic Church does not excommunicate anyone, she cannot.
....
[/quote]
:idontknow: Say again? Are we speaking about the same church?

Posted

A person excommunicates themselves from the Church.

Unless I am wrong, the Church continuously will warn us when we are dangerously close to separating ourselves from the her. It is we who push the envelope and finally throw the switch.

She doesnt arbitrarily go around excommunicating people,until after we first do it through our words and actions.
She simply announces the obvious.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...