Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

The church does both. First, it does warn us of when we are about to excommunicate ourselves. Second, it also excommunicates people by power of binding and losing. The bible has multiple other accounts of this action as a function of the church.

The Code of canon law and other studdies are very complex on the subject of excommunication. For this discussion, it boils down to two types (this is a grossly simplified version):

latae sententiae- where the offender excommunicates themselves. This applies, for example, to those who have gotten 're-married' without and anullment. If you do this, you are excommunicated, but you will not go to a church trial nor will you receive a letter from a bishop etc.

ferendae sententiae- where the offender is excommunicated by the church. Trials can apply. There have been a number of folks who have received this form of excommunication in the last 20 years.

(a third type may be 'anathema' in which the Pope has a formal liturgy)

Check out the code of canon law:
[url="http://www.ourladyswarriors.org/canon/c1311-1363.htm#par2668"]http://www.ourladyswarriors.org/canon/c1311-1363.htm#par2668[/url]

EWTN article
[url="http://www.ewtn.com/vexperts/showmessage.asp?number=481429&Pg=Forum9&Pgnu=2&recnu=39"]http://www.ewtn.com/vexperts/showmessage.a...=2&recnu=39[/url]

Posted (edited)

Yes, I understand what you are saying but the arguement that I was seeing was that the Church just gets p.o.'d and then excommunicates a person. (the bishop for eg.)as if he did nothing wrong to receive it. That bishop was warned. His actions showed that he cared not that he was perilously close to separating himself from the Church. HE excommunicated himself.

My arguement is that No. She cannot just arbitrarily excommunicate a person.

Your response jswranch, is that Im wrong.
Show me where She has decided to just excommunicate someone for no reason and then I will stand corrected.

My first post may have been taken too literally in that the Church has no authority to do such a thing. But since this was in the spirituality board and not debate, I thought all would understand my statement....my apologies. But I still know of no person whom the Church excommunicated who didnt first excommunicate themselves from Her by word or action(deed).


It is we who first cause offense, and in the end...it is we who excommunicate ourselves from the Church.

Edited by Quietfire
Posted

There is a great article in Crisis.

[url="http://www.crisismagazine.com/october2006/ryland.htm"]The Gift: A Married Priest Looks at Celibacy[/url].

It answers most questions and the priest author is a convert who is married.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Quietfire' post='1093087' date='Oct 16 2006, 01:33 PM']
Yes, I understand what you are saying but the arguement that I was seeing was that the Church just gets p.o.'d and then excommunicates a person. (the bishop for eg.)as if he did nothing wrong to receive it. That bishop was warned. His actions showed that he cared not that he was perilously close to separating himself from the Church. HE excommunicated himself.

My arguement is that No. She cannot just arbitrarily excommunicate a person.

Your response jswranch, is that Im wrong.
Show me where She has decided to just excommunicate someone for no reason and then I will stand corrected.

My first post may have been taken too literally in that the Church has no authority to do such a thing. But since this was in the spirituality board and not debate, I thought all would understand my statement....my apologies. But I still know of no person whom the Church excommunicated who didnt first excommunicate themselves from Her by word or action(deed).
It is we who first cause offense, and in the end...it is we who excommunicate ourselves from the Church.
[/quote]

I suppose we are on two sides of the same coin and our discussion is based on a misconception. The church only excommunicates those who sin in a grave matter. Sometimes this can also come from a lack of action to fulfill an obligation. I am not sure the offense is always clear to the offender and the rest of the Church before sanctions are completed.

Edited by jswranch
Posted

hey...my thread, no hijack..;)

anyway, he wrote back..he just commented where he felt fit in my email. His comments are in [color="#FF0000"]red[/color].

[quote]Dr. Jefferson,
Thankyou for your thoughtful response. Let us call this "The Discussion the Six Points." I hope to respond in like kind so we can ensure we stay on topic.

1. I don't "compare versions" as I'm not up for playing God and picking and choosing which version suits me.

I see your decision in choosing the translation of the KJV over the NIV or NLT as picking the version that suits you. This is not an issue of 'playing God.' As we neither speak Greek and Hebrew as exactly the New Testament writters would have nor do we have the exact transcripts of the orginal, we are forced to read it in the new language (modern English)... by choosing or picking a translation.

[color="#FF0000"]I don't agree at all. The entire "Bible version debate" is an issue of underlying manuscripts and not "translation" whatsoever. From my research, I have no doubt that the KJV was "translated" from the original manuscripts which contained God's true word, while the other "versions" were translated from entirely different, corrupted and cultic manuscripts. I don't choose the KJV because I like the thees and thous, I choose it because I reject the modern day counterfeits!

Furthermore, if we are going to have a solid discussion, we need to use ONE "version" as if we use many, there will never be any way to come to an agreement whatsoever, as you will always be able to dance around the obvious truths of Scripture![/color]

2.) The NLT is a heretic version and I have no respect for it whatsoever.

If you dislike the NLT we can still look at some of the other versions 1 Tim 3:2.
KJV: the husband of one wife

NIV: but one wife

MSG: committed to his wife

TNIV: faithful to his wife

CEV: be faithful in marriage

NIRV: faithful to his wife
Yet you pick and choose to believe that, despite all the biblical scholars listed above working in these Protestant translations, the correct translation is must be married.

[color="#FF0000"]Read my above reply.

However, no matter what to be the husband of one wife, or be it "but one wife", or "faithful to his wife", or "faithful in marriage" ... WHATEVER ONE YOU WANT TO HIDE BEHIND .... they all show that a Bishop MUST be married .... there is no way around that!!!!!!!!![/color]
3. The obvious meaning is that a Bishop must be the husband of only one wife.

I agree, a bishop cannot be the husband of multiple wives. However, I disagree that a bishop must be married before his ordinatation. Again, you add the word "must." Why do you add the word "must" to your understanding? None of the translations have added it! If this is so obvious, they why have none of the bible scholars inserted the word 'must'?

[color="#FF0000"]Ummm .... READ your own "version" quotes .... they are all speaking of MARRIAGE .... it is plain as day![/color]

My interpretation by the Holy Spirit leads me to believe this verse is not requiring Bishop's to be married. Your interpretation does. If Sola Scriptura is true in that the HS leads each reader to the correct interpretation, then how can you tell me I am wrong compared to your interpretation? Are you infallible?

[color="#FF0000"]Wow!

This would be like me saying that after reading "resist not evil", I was lead by the Holy Spirit to think it actually means, "go on a crusade and torture and murder the evil-doers" .... NONSENSE!

You can twist the Scriptures to mean whatever you want them to, as most cultists do, and you can even hide behind the "Holy Spirit (you sure it was a HOLY spirit that told you this nonsense?)" all you want, but the Scriptures are CLEAR, there is no privare interpretation needed![/color]
4. [Truncated] WHAT does this mean to a RC? ... There simply is no possibility to make RC doctrine fit with the Scriptures, as is the case with all cults when they are really pinned down on an issue.

(Please stop calling us Roman Catholics, as not all Catholics are Roman but can be Marianite, Eastern etc.)

[color="#FF0000"]Okay, I will just say Catholic from now on, however refrain from saying that "catholic" means Universal, for you know that is not how I am using it in this discussion.[/color]

This passage says he is not to be a man of multiple wives (ie polygamy or remarried after divorce which is just another form of polygamy). The verse is not saying he must be married before ordination.

[color="#FF0000"]WOW .... RE-READ THE VERSE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! [/color]

Do you not realize that Paul was writting to Greeks deep in the Hellenistic culture which allowed polygamy? They allowed men to get married, divorce, then remarry contrary to the words of Jesus.

Yup, I am aware of that. However, this doesn't change the clear meaning of the verse whatsoever and you know it!

5. To answer your question, I would say YES, the apostle Paul WAS married. Paul is the one who wrote this, therefore he wouldn't disobey it himself.

If I read you correctly, Paul 'had' to married because 1 Tim 3:2 said a bishop 'must' be married. I see two errors. First, 1 Tim 3:2 is not a matter of must. Second, Paul made himself celibate for the kingdom (MT 19:12). We know this from 1 Cor 7:7. You have built up your own private doctrine from 1 Tim 3:2, and now you are forcing this doctrine against 1 Cor 7:7.

[color="#FF0000"]It is not a private doctrine as the Bible says a Bishop is to be married (husband of one wife, faithful in marriage, etc., etc., etc.,)! Paul was not in a physical marriage at the time he wrote to the Corinthians, this is clear, however to say he was not widowed (which you are claiming) is to indeed "build up a private doctrine"![/color]


6. Ok, you understand Moonies. Perhaps you do not understand how Archbishop Millingo got himself in trouble in the first place. He got involved in the Moonies, spoke out against some of the Catholic teachings and got married. That landed him some disciplinary sanctions... ie he got fired and ordered no longer to function as a bishop. He also could not practice any of the sacraments under the threat of excommunication. After all this warning, he ordained a few priest against orders. He then automatically got himself excommunicated. My point is that he did come under sactions for siding with the moonies and he was not excommunicate for getting married but for other offenses: ordaining Moonies to the Catholic priesthood.

That is not what the press reported. They simply said he was excommunicated for getting married. Had the Vatican wanted to avoid this, they could have easily stated that he was ecommunicated for apostasizing to the Moonie religion, however they did not!

[color="#FF0000"]You seriously defend your cult as vehemently as any Mormon or JW or even SDA (and they can get downright ugly in defense of EGW), I will give you that ... but ... it is still just an unBiblical, man-made religious cult.

I look forward to your reply.[/[/color]quote]

he is actually kind of nice in this one..

last year I got in trouble at my school because he sent me an email about the whore of babylon and my school site-fiddler picked up the "whore" part on their porn blocker..oyoy

Posted (edited)

[quote]You seriously defend your cult as vehemently as any Mormon or JW or even SDA [/quote]

So what's with the !!!!!!!!!? :idontknow: as in he defends his own personal opinion more vehemently than you.

"Trust not in your own understanding" Prov 3:5.

Edited by thessalonian
PadrePioOfPietrelcino
Posted

If he says the belief that paul was never married is built upon private interpretation, then surely the belief that he was widowed is just the same built on private revelation.

If as he claims all scriptures are clear then why are there so many denominations who can stand toe to toe with scriture battles and stand on opposite sides of an issue? Man's intellect gets in the way when we read ANYTHING, why would it change with scripture? That is why we need the Church to stand as the pillar and foundation of Truth, and help us understand the message from God.

Wasn't the KJV translated from the latin??? maybe I'm wrong, but how is that the original language?

Posted

Dr. Jefferson,
(or should I call you Dr. 'Must' :) )

1. [u]Bible versions/translations[/u]

[i]I don't "compare versions" as I'm not up for playing God and picking and choosing which version suits me. [/i]

Yet you still pick a version and have choosen the KJV as it seems to suit your taste.

[i]I don't agree at all. The entire "Bible version debate" is an issue of underlying manuscripts and not "translation" whatsoever. From my research, I have no doubt that the KJV was "translated" from the original manuscripts which contained God's true word, while the other "versions" were translated from entirely different, corrupted and cultic manuscripts. I don't choose the KJV because I like the thees and thous, I choose it because I reject the modern day counterfeits![/i]

First, perhaps from all your research, you would have discovered by now that it is impossible for the KJV to have been ' "translated" from the original manuscripts' because the originals were destroyed over 1500 years ago. Apparently not. This fact may be new to you, but what the translators of the KJV have to choose from is copies of copies of copies which you claim to be the 'original manuscripts.' Not all the surviving manuscripts match. BTW the only version of scripture we have based on the acutall orginals and written by a guy who learned all the old Greek and Hebrew idioms from the actual speakers was a Catholic priest name Jerome. He stitched together the Latin Vulgate.

Second, no one translation/version of scripture is perfect. We can select an educated guess from which one is currently the 'best.' Another problem with the doctrine of 'one version onlyism' you support is that you and I do not know ancient Greek or Hebrew. Multiple versions assist us in knowing the sensitive ins and outs of that era. For example, the KJV Gen 2:7 reads 'living soul' while the Amplified reads 'living being.' Another place the word 'bath' or 'washing' changes upon version/translation. By studying all possible, viable versions/translations, we can get to know the writters true intent. As in English, a word or phrase may have multiple translations. In spanish the term "throw the house out the window," equals "roll out the red carpet" in English: imagine what a German reader would make of this.

Third, the current KJV differs from the first KJV. Why do you trust the one you have? The first version was based on the Catholic Latin Vulgate.

Fourth, I will not infallibly trust a sole translation of the bible to the authority of a practicing homosexual like King James. Why would you?

[i]Furthermore, if we are going to have a solid discussion, we need to use ONE "version" as if we use many, there will never be any way to come to an agreement whatsoever, as you will always be able to dance around the obvious truths of Scripture![/i]

First, if the 'truths' were so obvious, why dont the scripture scholars agree? Are all the scholars who differ from you heretical? Does this not make you the infallible pope of your own faith?

Second, if you want to use one version, we would have to use Greek. Then, we would both have to agree on a correct use not of Greek, but ancient Greek. We can hardly do this with Old English.

I suppose we could use the Latin Vulgate? :)

2.) [u]Translations of 1 Tim 3:2.[/u]
of one wife

but one wife

committed to his wife

faithful to his wife

be faithful in marriage

faithful to his wife

Yet you pick and choose to believe that, despite all the biblical scholars listed above working in these Protestant translations, the correct translation is must be married.

[i]Read my above reply.

However, no matter what to be the husband of one wife, or be it "but one wife", or "faithful to his wife", or "faithful in marriage" ... WHATEVER ONE YOU WANT TO HIDE BEHIND .... they all show that a Bishop MUST be married .... there is no way around that!!!!!!!!![/i]

Sir, you have added the word 'must' to the bible. You have added to the Word of God to support you man-made doctrine. You are the one hidding.

We can accuse each other all day of hidding. If 'must' is the correct understanding, why did none of the early church believe it? Celibacy flourished for bishops in the early church!!!!!

3. [u]'Obvious' meaning[/u]
[i]The obvious meaning is that a Bishop must be the husband of only one wife. [/i]

If the 'obvious' meaning of 'of one wife' is 'must have a wife,' then why haven't any of the bible translations/versions published as such? Why do they publish different things?

[i]Ummm .... READ your own "version" quotes .... they are all speaking of MARRIAGE .... it is plain as day![/i]

Yes they are. And you point is????

My interpretation by the Holy Spirit leads me to believe this verse is not requiring Bishop's to be married. Your interpretation does. If Sola Scriptura is true in that the HS leads each reader to the correct interpretation, then how can you tell me I am wrong compared to your interpretation? Are you infallible?

[i]Wow!

This would be like me saying that after reading "resist not evil", I was lead by the Holy Spirit to think it actually means, "go on a crusade and torture and murder the evil-doers" .... NONSENSE![/i]

The situation you presented is nonsense. So is your interpretation of 1 Tim 3:2.

[i]You can twist the Scriptures to mean whatever you want them to, as most cultists do, and you can even hide behind the "Holy Spirit (you sure it was a HOLY spirit that told you this nonsense?)" all you want, but the Scriptures are CLEAR, there is no privare interpretation needed![/i]

Scriptures are clear. No one but you and your cult see the wourd 'must.' You are the one who is twisting scripture to your own meaning. I am certain it was THE Holy Spirit. I do believe it was some spirit (not necessarily a Holy one) that brought you to your nonsense.


4. [u]Polygamy vs. manditory marriage[/u]

(Please stop calling us Roman Catholics, as not all Catholics are Roman but can be Marianite, Eastern etc.)

[i]Okay, I will just say Catholic from now on, however refrain from saying that "catholic" means Universal, for you know that is not how I am using it in this discussion.[/i]

No can do. The word 'catholic' means universal. Using it contrary to the greek according to your request would be just furth nonsense.

This passage says he is not to be a man of multiple wives (ie polygamy or remarried after divorce which is just another form of polygamy). The verse is not saying he must be married before ordination.

[i]WOW .... RE-READ THE VERSE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! [/i]
I have repeatedly. Still never says 'must.' Perhaps you should study the culture and times Paul was involved with so you can understand what he is talking about.


Do you not realize that Paul was writting to Greeks deep in the Hellenistic culture which allowed polygamy? They allowed men to get married, divorce, then remarry contrary to the words of Jesus.

[i]Yup, I am aware of that. However, this doesn't change the clear meaning of the verse whatsoever and you know it![/i]

Sure it changes the meaning to some extent! First, it still does not say 'must.' Second, to reject the know context of a ruling is scholastic ignorace.

5. [u]The Celibacy of Paul[/u]

[i]To answer your question, I would say YES, the apostle Paul WAS married. Paul is the one who wrote this, therefore he wouldn't disobey it himself.[/i]

If I read you correctly, Paul 'had' to married because 1 Tim 3:2 said a bishop 'must' be married. I see two errors. First, 1 Tim 3:2 is not a matter of must. Second, Paul made himself celibate for the kingdom (MT 19:12). We know this from 1 Cor 7:7. You have built up your own private doctrine from 1 Tim 3:2, and now you are forcing this doctrine against 1 Cor 7:7.

[i]It is not a private doctrine as the Bible says a Bishop is to be married (husband of one wife, faithful in marriage, etc., etc., etc.,)! Paul was not in a physical marriage at the time he wrote to the Corinthians, this is clear, however to say he was not widowed (which you are claiming) is to indeed "build up a private doctrine"![/i]

First, Dr. Robinson, THIS IS THE MOST ERRANT THING YOU HAVE EVER SAID!!! 1Cor was written in spring of 57 AD. 1 Tim was written in 65AD. He was celibate before he wrote 1 Tim. This means he was unmarried at the time of writting 1 Tim.

Second, you are the one who asserts Paul was ever married!!! You have no scripture to support. The only thing you use is your logic alone 'must' doctrine not seen in scripture.

Third, if 1 Tim 3:2 meant 'a bishop must be of one wife' then Paul violates his own rule by being a widower. He is no longer married!!!!

6. [u]Millingo, Moonies, excommunication, correct way for the Vatican to 'correctly' present its self imge [/u]

...My point is that he did come under sactions for siding with the moonies and he was not excommunicate for getting married but for other offenses: ordaining Moonies to the Catholic priesthood.

[i]That is not what the press reported. They simply said he was excommunicated for getting married. Had the Vatican wanted to avoid this, they could have easily stated that he was ecommunicated for apostasizing to the Moonie religion, however they did not![/i]

Uhhhh... is what any public figure like the Pope publishes in a press report and what the media actuall tells you on TV always going to be the same? How about you doing some real homework and actually reading the excommunication document for yourself. We members of the Universal Hierarchy (Catholic Church) immediately knew he had excommunicated himself even without the Vatican making any ruling. You would know this also if you actually were knowledgeable about the subject you are rejecting ... instead you are relying on what you think the Catholic Church is and teaches.

[i]You seriously defend your cult as vehemently as any Mormon or JW or even SDA (and they can get downright ugly in defense of EGW), I will give you that ... but ... it is still just an unBiblical, man-made religious cult.[/i]

I stand on the Word of God, and not some cheap knock off of this Word which, built on a sandy foundation of Sola Scriptura and Sola Fide has split thousands of times into its own little cults.

I hereby accuse you, Dr. Robinson, of being part of an unBiblical, man-made religious cult. You represent some form of Protestantism which has:

-Tossed 7 books of the bible based on what some Jews who rejected Christ profess, even though the early church used them.

-Ignored the writtings of the Christians who knew the teachings of the Apostles personally from about 80 AD on.

-Belived doctrines contrary to scripture which have been invented for the first time in the last few hundred years just like all the old heretics such as the Gnostics, Doceitists, Arians, Manicheans, Donatists...etc. They too broke from the Universal Hierarchy by attempting to support their new doctrines from the bible.

I have no idea who the SDA or what the EGW is, but you certainly have gotten ugly in defense of your cult's beliefs.

[i]I look forward to your reply[/i]

I look forward to your response. I am having fun! :D:

I usually refrain from responding to questions in such a harsh tone, but it seems this might be the only thing which might actually get you to read my replies. Besides, if you can dish it out, I figure you can take it without getting sore.

Posted

i keep tryin to get him to come here. thanks guys

Posted

anyone have an official article about the moonies issue?

Posted

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1094954' date='Oct 18 2006, 12:49 PM']
anyone have an official article about the moonies issue?
[/quote]

just google it. He makes the best description for the anti-christ since Mohammad.

son_of_angels
Posted

Actually, even the action of excommunication "binds" a person to their sin, in order to bring about a fervent repentence. The Church does not have a passive role, and even "ipso facto" or "latentiae sententiae" excommunications derive their effect from the positive action of the Church.
In fact, consider this. If a ruler chooses to go to war against a nation protected by the Church, even if for just cause, it could still be grounds for his excommunication. This was the case with many extremely effective Popes' excommunications. The Church has the right to demand the loyalty and obedience of its members, and an ordinary means of accomplishing this is excommunication.

Posted

stop the catholic vs catholic...focus on the issue at hand..;) Is this discussion going anywhere or is it in circles?



[quote][color="#FF0000"]Dear Jon,

Okay here I go ... I will reply in RED within the context of your email, like before.

The replies may not be as in-depth as I had hoped for, I am just swamped with work lately. I am in the process of closing a huge real estate deal here and it is time consuming, couple that with the fact my wife hasn't been feeling to great lately (is #6 on the way?) and my children have a B-Day party to attend today and, and, and .... well, this reply will have to do for now (haha).

Also ... when should I expect your reply to my reply (That's a tongue twister-haha) of your Real Presence article?[/color]


Jon Mcgurran <prodeji.development@gmail.com> wrote:
Dr. Jefferson,
(or should I call you Dr. 'Must' )

[color="#FF0000"]Haha ... I will get to the MUST thing in a bit, and I can assure you, you will feel pretty silly![/color]

1. Bible versions/translations

I don't "compare versions" as I'm not up for playing God and picking and choosing which version suits me.

Yet you still pick a version and have choosen the KJV as it seems to suit your taste.

[color="#FF0000"]NO, the KJV doesn't "suit my taste", I stick with it, because I believe it to be the perfectly preserved and error-free word of God and the other versions to be corrupt counterfiets based on entirely different underlying manuscripts. Believe me, if the research showed that the CEV or NIV was the correct Bible and the KJV was based off of cultic manuscripts, I would gladly abandon it!

Having ONE concrete rule of faith is NOT the easy path, for it doesn't leave any "wiggle room". Believe me, I used to play with versions and mess with the Greek and Hebrew to. I would preach from about 6 different versions and all the people would think I was so intelligent when I would expound on the Greek, blah, blah, blah. However, it wasn't until I realized that God actually had a true and preserved word and that I needed to OBEY it at all costs that I grew closer to the lord then ever before. No longer could I pick and choose and play God, now I had to just OBEY, whether I liked it or not! Do you have the guts to just OBEY, or do you enjoy being your own God?[/color]

I don't agree at all. The entire "Bible version debate" is an issue of underlying manuscripts and not "translation" whatsoever. From my research, I have no doubt that the KJV was "translated" from the original manuscripts which contained God's true word, while the other "versions" were translated from entirely different, corrupted and cultic manuscripts. I don't choose the KJV because I like the thees and thous, I choose it because I reject the modern day counterfeits!

First, perhaps from all your research, you would have discovered by now that it is impossible for the KJV to have been ' "translated" from the original manuscripts' because the originals were destroyed over 1500 years ago. Apparently not. This fact may be new to you, but what the translators of the KJV have to choose from is copies of copies of copies which you claim to be the 'original manuscripts.' Not all the surviving manuscripts match. BTW the only version of scripture we have based on the acutall orginals and written by a guy who learned all the old Greek and Hebrew idioms from the actual speakers was a Catholic priest name Jerome. He stitched together the Latin Vulgate.

[color="#FF0000"]Wow, you are one brainwashed cultist aye? I suggest you do a little research into the Bible version debate and especially into exactly WHY Tyndale and later the KJV translators REJECTED the Vulgate, before you go spewing what you have been taught.

By the way, I never claimed the KJV was translated from the actual "originals", for that would be ludicrous ... there was NEVER a complete translation from the actual originals, as even God threw away His own word and REWROTE IT at one point (look it up!). However, I do claim thjat the KJV was translated from TRUE COPIES of the ORIGINALS and not from corrupted occultic manuscripts like the other versions!

There are TWO manuscript families bro and you would do well to look into that and find out WHICH family your "Bible" was translated from![/color]

Second, no one translation/version of scripture is perfect. We can select an educated guess from which one is currently the 'best.'

[color="#FF0000"]Sorry but this is satanic NONSENSE!

If you want to believe the scholars over the Lord who said he would preserve His word forever and that He would exalt it ABOVE His own name, go ahead ... me, I will believe God and call the scholars LIARS!

I truly feel sorry for you, you are a bright kid, but you have been deceived into believing the lies of men, rather then just siding with God and taking the assult that comes with it. You read and preach from a book you don't even believe is perfect, you choose to believe in a God that was omnipotent enough to create the world and everything in it and yet impotent enough to lie to us about His word and not even preserve it perfectly so that we could read it, a God who commanded us to never change even one word of His and then played the insane hypocrite by hiding that very word from men so they had no idea what it was .. how sad.[/color]

Another problem with the doctrine of 'one version onlyism' you support is that you and I do not know ancient Greek or Hebrew. Multiple versions assist us in knowing the sensitive ins and outs of that era.

[color="#FF0000"]More scholarly nonsense! Noone needs to know one bit of Greek or Hebrew, that is precisely why God had it traslated into English! Besides, even the vast majority of Hebrew and Greex lexicons are based off the corrupt cultic manuscripts, so who needs em', NOT ME![/color]

For example, the KJV Gen 2:7 reads 'living soul' while the Amplified reads 'living being.' Another place the word 'bath' or 'washing' changes upon version/translation. By studying all possible, viable versions/translations, we can get to know the writters true intent.

[color="#FF0000"]Nonsense! Your mangling of the married Bishop thing proves that no amount of versions can help a person know the author's true intent, they can only confuse them further. The only reason why someone would prefer 10 versions over one, is to play God and be disobedient![/color]

As in English, a word or phrase may have multiple translations. In spanish the term "throw the house out the window," equals "roll out the red carpet" in English: imagine what a German reader would make of this.

[color="#FF0000"]SO WHAT ... KNOW YOUR BIBLE AND YOU WON';T THINK SUCH SILLY THINGS![/color]

Third, the current KJV differs from the first KJV. Why do you trust the one you have? The first version was based on the Catholic Latin Vulgate.

[color="#FF0000"]Now you are resorting to outright LIES? WHY? Is this what you, like the Jehovah's Witnesses, call "justifiable lying"?

The KJV was NEVER based on the vulgate and it does not "differ" from the original in any meaningful way.[/color]

Fourth, I will not infallibly trust a sole translation of the bible to the authority of a practicing homosexual like King James. Why would you?

[color="#FF0000"]Wow ... if I were you I would read the good ole ten commandments again and sincerely repent. Nothing like bearing false witness against someone to try and prove your point, now is there?

Or maybe we should make a game of this and say that if King James was a sodomite, so was King David (many skeptics have asserted this) and that you or a pedophile (it's not fun being falsely accused of something is it? But at least you are alive to defend yourself, unlike the godly King james you just bore false witness against).

Go look in a mirror padre and repent .... SINCERELY![/color]

Furthermore, if we are going to have a solid discussion, we need to use ONE "version" as if we use many, there will never be any way to come to an agreement whatsoever, as you will always be able to dance around the obvious truths of Scripture!

First, if the 'truths' were so obvious, why dont the scripture scholars agree? Are all the scholars who differ from you heretical? Does this not make you the infallible pope of your own faith?

[color="#FF0000"]A) Because they are based on DIFFERENT underlying manuscripts!

B) No, just ignorant

C) Of course not, it makes the word of God my standard of truth[/color]

Second, if you want to use one version, we would have to use Greek. Then, we would both have to agree on a correct use not of Greek, but ancient Greek. We can hardly do this with Old English.

[color="#FF0000"]Nonsense, as the Greek and Hebrew lexicons are based off the corrupted manuscripts and are useless anyhow.

We both speak English, so let's use English![/color]

I suppose we could use the Latin Vulgate?

[color="#FF0000"]Or the NWT (Jehovah's Witness Bible)[/color]

2.) Translations of 1 Tim 3:2.
of one wife

but one wife

committed to his wife

faithful to his wife

be faithful in marriage

faithful to his wife

Yet you pick and choose to believe that, despite all the biblical scholars listed above working in these Protestant translations, the correct translation is must be married.

[color="#FF0000"]Okay, are you ready to have me make you look like an ignorant cultist?

Firstlyther theyt use the words "faithful to his WIFE", "faithful in MARRIAGE", or "of one WIFE"!

Secondly, while I know that RC's are not big on context, as they like to mangle the Bible, if you would read the entire context of 1Timothy 3, you will notice TWO things:

1.) Verse 4 shows that a Bishop must not only be MARRIED but must have children, as he must prove himself as a faithful husband, father and head of the household! This is the same in Titus as well!

2.) Verse 2: states that a Bishop *** MUST BE *** blameless,vigilant, sober ... THE HUSBAND OF ONE WIFE, etc., etc., etc.,. The clear meaning is that a Bishop MUST be these things, they are not suggested, they are absolutely 100% MANDATORY! You wouldn't have the guts to say that a Bishop is just supposed to be "not given to wine", but it was acceptable is he is a drunkard, NO WAY! However, like a good little cultist, you do have the guts to say that a Bishop is just kinda weakly exhorted to be married and have kids, but that it is okay if he is a celibate single ....... SICK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

You really need to open you eyes and realize that you are in a CULT and that you have been deceived into accepting man's word over God's! I just hope that happens before you die and enter the lake of fire.[/color]

Read my above reply.

However, no matter what to be the husband of one wife, or be it "but one wife", or "faithful to his wife", or "faithful in marriage" ... WHATEVER ONE YOU WANT TO HIDE BEHIND .... they all show that a Bishop MUST be married .... there is no way around that!!!!!!!!!

Sir, you have added the word 'must' to the bible. You have added to the Word of God to support you man-made doctrine. You are the one hidding.

[color="#FF0000"]HAHAHA ... and you are the one who either cannot read, lies on purpose, or is so brainwashed that you cannot read the full context of a passage of Scripture!

A Bishop **** MUST BE **** blameless, vigilant, sober, THE HUSBAND OF ONE WIFE, etc., etc., etc.,![/color]

We can accuse each other all day of hidding. If 'must' is the correct understanding, why did none of the early church believe it? Celibacy flourished for bishops in the early church!!!!!

[color="#FF0000"]No it did not! Celibacy flourished in the false, Babylonian/Jewish religion called Roman Catholicism! It NEVER flourished in the early church. Even in the dark ages, when a RC monk left the cult for true Biblical Christianity and became a Bishop, he married![/color]

3. 'Obvious' meaning
The obvious meaning is that a Bishop must be the husband of only one wife.

If the 'obvious' meaning of 'of one wife' is 'must have a wife,' then why haven't any of the bible translations/versions published as such? Why do they publish different things?

[color="#FF0000"]Again, take your eyes of your idols and get your mind unBrainwashed and maybe you will see that this is exactly what it says!

By the way, just to help you see the light alittle clearer and since you seem to like to play with versions here is the beginning of verse two in many other versions:

******************************************************************************
A bishop then MUST BE (KJV)
Now the overseer MUST BE (New International Version)
An overseer, then, MUST BE (New American Standard Bible)
Therefore an overseer MUST BE (English Standard Version)
******************************************************************************

WOW .... DO YOU LOOK SILLY OR WHAT?

Sir, in all seriousness, I am just sparring with you, the little sarcasms are just my way of toying with you as Elijah toyed with the false priests of Baal.

It would be a travesty if you refuse to repent and get right with the Lord because you don't like my tactics, for my tactics have nothing to do with the truth.

The Lord knows the way I am and He has consistently sent STRONG-MINDED people to me, people who can stand a hard head-on challenge and see the truth, repent of their sins and turn to God. Are you one of these people, or will you stand before God one day and say, "well, um, I didn't turn to the truth because um, I didn;t like the way T did things, um, it's his fault", only to hear, "DEPART FROM ME YE CURSED"?

I SINCERELY HOPE NOT!

I need to stop here, my wife just called the internet cafe and said I need to get home for the B-Day party .... more next week, Lord willing.

You are SINCERELY on my heart and in my prayers Jon and I hope you will heed this warning.

Love in Christ Jesus,

T[/color][/quote]


woah...I like how he damns me about 3 times, and finishes "in Christs love."

Posted

Too bad he did not respond to 4,5, and 6.

Guest Štefan from Europe
Posted

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1097204' date='Oct 21 2006, 01:28 AM']
stop the catholic vs catholic...focus on the issue at hand..;) Is this discussion going anywhere or is it in circles?
woah...I like how he damns me about 3 times, and finishes "in Christs love."
[/quote]

When reading his responses I felt strong compulsion to vomit. :(

Posted

[quote name='jswranch' post='1097269' date='Oct 20 2006, 07:11 PM']
Too bad he did not respond to 4,5, and 6.
[/quote]


should that be my reply?

Posted

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1097805' date='Oct 21 2006, 02:47 PM']
should that be my reply?
[/quote]

I have a few ideas, but I am waiting for my grumpy meter to lower a bit. I have a few historic details I wish to toss out, but I want to wait.

In the mean time, go ahead and ask for numbers 4-6.

Posted

That something that I don't really understand. Fundis say "that's not Biblical Christianity." Well duh, the Bible is a gift of the Church, not vice versa. He's saying we don't meet a standard that isn't even valid.

Posted

As cool as that is, he does not have that worldview and the point is invalid in any dialogue

Posted

His last reply convinces me that he's seriously deluded... Basically, if you disagree with him, you're automatically wrong. If he cannot admit that different people can read the exact same words and come to different conclusions, it's not really worth arguing with him any further. He himself admits that he really isn't interested in coming to the truth.

What he really needs is a big fat whack over the head. (I'm thinking of the time St. Louis de Montfort beat the crud out of a drunkard who had insulted Our Lady...)

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...