SJP Posted November 1, 2006 Posted November 1, 2006 I was reading an address by Archbishop J. Michael Miller (Secretary for the Vatican's Congregation for Catholic Education) In the address he stated: "those involved in Catholic schools, with very few exceptions, should be practicing Catholics committed to the Church and living her sacramental life." Can someone give me an example of when the Vatican would find it acceptable for a non-Catholic to be teaching in a Catholic School? The Official position according to the Vatican would be appreciated, but comments/ideas are welcome as well.
Veritas Posted November 1, 2006 Posted November 1, 2006 + Non-Catholics teaching in Catholic schools, or non-Catholics working for Catholic parishes -one of my biggest pet peeves. Try John Paul II [i]Ex Corde Ecclesiae[/i]
Sojourner Posted November 1, 2006 Posted November 1, 2006 I go to a Catholic school, but several of my profs are not Catholic. It doesn't bother me in the least. Perhaps it's different at a grad school level, though. I like it, actually, because part of the goal of having a religiously diverse faculty is to encourage respectful discussion and debate about religion.
Church Punk Posted November 1, 2006 Posted November 1, 2006 SJP, is speaking of the High School/ Grade School level, as he is a teacher in training.
MRSannie Posted November 1, 2006 Posted November 1, 2006 GGGRRR High school, multiple teachers aren't even Christians! One 'Catholic' RELIGION teacher told his class HE didn't really believe in Purgatory, but that was up to them to decide.....GRRRRR $7000 a year for that carp....
Lounge Daddy Posted November 1, 2006 Posted November 1, 2006 [quote name='MRSannie' post='1107081' date='Oct 31 2006, 10:55 PM'] GGGRRR High school, multiple teachers aren't even Christians! One 'Catholic' RELIGION teacher told his class HE didn't really believe in Purgatory, but that was up to them to decide.....GRRRRR $7000 a year for that carp.... [/quote] Ya, that stuff hacks me off too.
Colleen Posted November 1, 2006 Posted November 1, 2006 I think it's very different between the elementary/high school and the college level. I had a non-Catholic teacher teaching religion when I was in gradeschool who admitted that she really didn't know what she was talking about. Needless to say, I didn't learn much from her. Although having an unorthodox Catholic teaching religion at that level is just as bad, if not worse. When you're in college and you have a solid background in Catholic teaching, it's easier to deal with non-Catholic teachers. At that age, you're not as impressionable as an elementary or high school kid. You are able to recognize the differences in their way of thinking from what is taught by the Church. In gradeschool, though, you're still learning the basics of the faith, and very often students are given a skewed or completely wrong impression of Catholic teaching.
N/A Gone Posted November 1, 2006 Posted November 1, 2006 How about a catholic teaching for a non-catholic school? Or a catholic with a protestant degree teaching in a catholic situation.. I should be leading a church..oyoy
Kosh Posted November 1, 2006 Posted November 1, 2006 That's why our Catholic Highschool is the best. Only solid catholic teaching!
aalpha1989 Posted November 1, 2006 Posted November 1, 2006 What if those teachers are teaching subjects such as speech? Or german? or technologies? Do those teachers need to be Catholic? I'm asking because those subjects at my school are taught by non-catholics. as well as band.
Fixxxer Posted November 1, 2006 Posted November 1, 2006 I dont think all the teachers at my school are catholic, and i really dont care.
scardella Posted November 1, 2006 Posted November 1, 2006 In my experience, I find that it's usually better to have a Catholic teacher rather than a non-Catholic one. It certainly is a must that (orthodox) Catholics be teaching religion. I took AP English, and the teacher was a little bit off. We wound up reading completely offensive things in our English class, as if literature were somehow exempt from morals. I think objective stuff is usually difficult to inject deranged worldviews... [i]Mathematical Proof that God is Evil![/i] Just use the Pythagorean theorem! As a note: history is anything but objective.
Guest SocialhazardforHim Posted November 1, 2006 Posted November 1, 2006 [size=3]Interesting topic. I went to a Catholic high school, and a majority of the best teachers we had (and still have) were not Catholic. For our AP English class, we had to read Isabelle Allende's "House of the Spirits." The book, in the genre of magical realism is a worldwide best seller but also on the banned book list. It contains negative Catholic references, an abortion scene, and sex. If you have never read the book:[/size] [i]A Synopsis:[/i] “The House of Spirits is probably Allende's most famous and important book. In it, she chronicles the life of a family, as the patriarch grows from a child to an elder, with the world changing all around him while he tries to keep it the same. Through the lenses of the Trueba family, we follow the portion of Chilean history that eventually leads to the 1973 coup. Of course, the author is niece of Salvador Allende, the socialist president democratically elected that was removed from power and killed by Pinochet. The book is based on clashes; old versus young, communists vs conservatives, landlords vs tenants….In the end, the distinctions that originally separated young from old, conservatives from communists, are removed, as both sides realize the futility of their disputes in the face on an authoritarian regime.” (www.amazon.com) [i]Author’s comments about her works’ contents:[/i] “My mother is actually my only critic: she is my first and most serious critic. We have had some real knock-down battles about what to include and exclude from my books! She is the first person to read my work and she is a very sensitive and intelligent reader. But most important: she feels free to tell me anything and everything! She is especially concerned with my use of language‹not just with the development of plot or the portrayal of different characters…. ….So she focuses on your use of language. Does she have any characteristic criticisms? My explicitness! She doesn't like sex scenes! I censor all those scenes when I show her the early draft‹I take them all out. I also cut out all passages about the Pope and the church in that draft. Then I put some of them back in. She never reads the final version or the published book itself, so she never encounters the sex scenes or the anti-Catholic criticism.” (http://lanic.utexas.edu/project/etext/llilas/tpla/9901.html) [size=3]Is this book a good idea to include in the curriculum of a Catholic School?[/size]
kateri05 Posted November 1, 2006 Posted November 1, 2006 how do you model authentic catholicism to youth (grade/hs level) when the people doing the modelling aren't authetnically catholic? you can NOT teach a faith you aren't living, be you non-Catholic or badly catholic. three cheers for st monica academy in pasadena where we take an oath of fidelity to the magisterium!
stbernardLT Posted November 1, 2006 Posted November 1, 2006 Being a catholic should be a prerequisite for teaching at a Catholic school. I know a teacher who was teaching out of the "purpose driven life" We need to get a better handle on most of our catholic schools before they lose the catholic part.
Romans1513 Posted November 1, 2006 Posted November 1, 2006 One of my favorite teachers in my (Catholic) high school was... ... Jewish. And a para-rabbi at that. He was an English teacher. He had nothing but the utmost respect for Catholicism, he simply wanted to be able to teach somewhere that he could be open in talking about God and religion. He told us about the practices of Judaism on occasion, but it was NEVER disrespectful to Christianity as a whole or Catholicism, and it never made anyone want to convert either. We prayed in class every day at the beginning of class, just as in our other classes. He was a pretty awesome teacher, and possibly more "Catholic" (devout, orthodox, etc.) than some of my other high school teachers... I definitely think that the religion teachers should be Catholic. (and not Buddhist/Catholic or "liberal" Catholic like a couple of mine were) As for the other subjects, a Catholic teacher should be preferred, and more so in some subjects than others probably (European history, biology, etc.). But I don't think its wrong to have a non-Catholic teacher as long as they are respectful and the principal/president/whatever beleives that they will be a valuable addition to the school.
homeschoolmom Posted November 1, 2006 Posted November 1, 2006 What if you have to hire a new math teacher. Your choices are: Awsome Catholic/mediocre math instructor vs. Not anti-Catholic Christian/fantastic math instructor? These are your two choices (because you're running a Catholic school that only pays a pitance and math teachers who are willing to work for peanuts are hard to come by.... )
Goetian Posted November 1, 2006 Posted November 1, 2006 In my view, if you're going to teach at a religiously affiliated school, you should be willing to teach its views as the God-given truth. This doesn't necessarily mean you have to believe them yourself, but I can't imagine why anyone who isn't Catholic would want to teach orthodox Catholicism as absolute truth. Why would non-Catholics even be interested in teaching at Catholic schools? Does it pay more, or are they just interested in recruiting young impressionable minds to their own views? I have a professor who preaches communism all the time. It's obnoxious.
Romans1513 Posted November 1, 2006 Posted November 1, 2006 [quote name='Goetian' post='1107365' date='Nov 1 2006, 10:25 AM'] In my view, if you're going to teach at a religiously affiliated school, you should be willing to teach its views as the God-given truth. This doesn't necessarily mean you have to believe them yourself, but I can't imagine why anyone who isn't Catholic would want to teach orthodox Catholicism as absolute truth. [/quote] Some teachers don't have to teach the Church's views--like Homeschoolmom's example of a math teacher. [quote] Why would non-Catholics even be interested in teaching at Catholic schools? Does it pay more, or are they just interested in recruiting young impressionable minds to their own views? [/quote] Like I said, "he simply wanted to be able to teach somewhere that he could be open in talking about God and religion." I also had a Protestant calculus teacher who loved being able to teach at a school where class could start with prayer everyday. The only time we talked about Catholicism vs. Protestantism was when she had a question about Catholicism. Obviously Catholic schools don't pay more. Thats what makes them so great a lot of the time- the teachers are there because they want to be and not for the money. But Catholic schools are a LOT different from public schools, and they have a lot of other advantages besides pay. Trust me, I went to public through 8th grade and Catholic for high school. Huge difference.
CrossCuT Posted November 1, 2006 Posted November 1, 2006 [size=1]HEHEHE! What a funny thread! At the Catholic highschool I graduated from, my freshman year, my english teacher was Lutheran. And she would have us read out of her Lutheran bible in the mornings before class. [/size]
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now