Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Non-catholics Teaching In Catholic Schools.


Recommended Posts

Groo the Wanderer
Posted

[quote name='SJP' post='1106964' date='Oct 31 2006, 09:25 PM']
Can someone give me an example of when the Vatican would find it acceptable for a non-Catholic to be teaching in a Catholic School? The Official position according to the Vatican would be appreciated, but comments/ideas are welcome as well.
[/quote]


Hmm...only the cafeteria ladies and the janitors come to mind....


NOT a slam on them, as they are CRITICAL to the operations of a school, but they are not in positions to poison the developing faiths of our widdle kiddos...

[quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1107343' date='Nov 1 2006, 09:51 AM']
What if you have to hire a new math teacher. Your choices are:

Awsome Catholic/mediocre math instructor

vs.

Not anti-Catholic Christian/fantastic math instructor?

These are your two choices (because you're running a Catholic school that only pays a pitance and math teachers who are willing to work for peanuts are hard to come by.... )
[/quote]


Choice C: keep looking


:blush:

Posted

I haven't read all the posts, but here is my 2 cents...

I think that there is a need for good teachers in any system. In the Catholic system I think that if that need can't be filled by Catholics, it should at the very least be filled by Christians. The problem is that people (now you won't believe this) LIE on their resumes. So you never know until they are employed who they really are. I knew a girl once who went through RCIA just so that she could apply for jobs teaching at both the public and Catholic school system.

I had a discussion with my hubby about this. I would rather my children be un-informed in school than mis-informed. So I am seriously thinking about public school.

Some youth in my group are actually given assignements in their religion class to research non-catholic religions. They don't even know their OWN faith and they are being encouraged to study others.

Gah.

Makes me sick.

homeschoolmom
Posted

They will be misinformed in public school, too.

Posted

But at least not by teachers parading around teaching religion in what is supposed to be a Catholic class.

homeschoolmom
Posted

Yes, that's true. It's more likely to be a history class.

Posted

I wish that I could homeschool.....

I looked into it for a while, but, frankly, I think it takes a special kind of person. I think I would be too.... distracted all the time to do it well. I am scatterbrained a lot.

That's why I am a youth minister!! ;)

Guest detocquevillesdaughter.com
Posted

The ideal situation is to have only Catholics teaching in Catholic schools. Sometimes, though, you can't find a Catholic teacher with the credentials you need for teaching a certain subject -- math, for instance. The problem is, though, that in a Catholic school religious instruction doesn't happen only in "religion" class. A Catholic perspective should be evident in science class and social studies -- throughout the whole curriculum.

It's also part of what in eduspeak is known as the "hidden" or unwritten curriculum -- the way things are done, the way people treat each other, what the priorities and expectations are. So really, Catholic teaching is going on all day.

Another problem, though, is Catholic teachers who don't really know much about their faith. It can be tricky to measure that in the hiring interview.

Posted

exactly detocqueville! as someone who went thru 12 years of catholic school AND taught in an archdiocesan school with this problem, its really the hidden learning that is most important and impactful on a student.

so when the question of something comes up and you have a) a non catholic, B) a catholic who couldn't give a hoot or c) an antiCatholic then there's trouble.

Posted

I was thinking of applying to teach history at some Catholic schools in my area. I don't really see the problem with it to be honest.

MissScripture
Posted (edited)

Well, after attending Catholic school for 14 years (well, I'm in my 15th year at college...kindergarten through college, now), I have to say some of my best teachers were not Catholic. It's sad that it is the truth, but the teachers who were Catholic were often times more respectful of Catholicism than the "Catholic" teachers (including and in some cases especially the religion teachers). When Pope Benedict was elected, I heard the teachers in the hallway belittling him (they weren't even too keen on Pope John Paul II, because he was, according to them, "anti-woman" because he wouldn't allow women to become priests). I talked to everyone I could think of to try to fix that, and nothing happened.
So, in my opinion, there's nothing wrong with non-Catholics teaching in Catholic schools, and may even be beneficial in some cases, sad as that may be.

Edited by MissScripture
Posted

[quote name='SocialhazardforHim' post='1107157' date='Nov 1 2006, 12:17 AM']
[size=3]Interesting topic. I went to a Catholic high school, and a majority of the best teachers we had (and still have) were not Catholic. For our AP English class, we had to read Isabelle Allende's "House of the Spirits."

The book, in the genre of magical realism is a worldwide best seller but also on the banned book list. It contains negative Catholic references, an abortion scene, and sex.

If you have never read the book:[/size]

[i]A Synopsis:[/i]
“The House of Spirits is probably Allende's most famous and important book. In it, she chronicles the life of a family, as the patriarch grows from a child to an elder, with the world changing all around him while he tries to keep it the same. Through the lenses of the Trueba family, we follow the portion of Chilean history that eventually leads to the 1973 coup. Of course, the author is niece of Salvador Allende, the socialist president democratically elected that was removed from power and killed by Pinochet.
The book is based on clashes; old versus young, communists vs conservatives, landlords vs tenants….In the end, the distinctions that originally separated young from old, conservatives from communists, are removed, as both sides realize the futility of their disputes in the face on an authoritarian regime.” (www.amazon.com)

[i]Author’s comments about her works’ contents:[/i]
“My mother is actually my only critic: she is my first and most serious critic. We have had some real knock-down battles about what to include and exclude from my books! She is the first person to read my work and she is a very sensitive and intelligent reader. But most important: she feels free to tell me anything and everything! She is especially concerned with my use of language‹not just with the development of plot or the portrayal of different characters….
….So she focuses on your use of language. Does she have any characteristic criticisms?
My explicitness! She doesn't like sex scenes! I censor all those scenes when I show her the early draft‹I take them all out. I also cut out all passages about the Pope and the church in that draft. Then I put some of them back in. She never reads the final version or the published book itself, so she never encounters the sex scenes or the anti-Catholic criticism.” (http://lanic.utexas.edu/project/etext/llilas/tpla/9901.html)

[size=3]Is this book a good idea to include in the curriculum of a Catholic School?[/size]
[/quote]
My friend posted this yesterday, and I was curious what your thoughts were on this, as she was also curious. I personally think this book has no place in a Catholic school. Perhaps this deserves it's own topic?

Posted

I don't know how I feel about this. Though, I do think it's worse to have a crazy "let's walk the labyrinth together" Catholic teacher than a teacher who everybody knows doesn't rep Catholicism. Junior year was rough that way...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...