Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Terri Schiavo Major Focus In Flordia's Governor's Race


Recommended Posts

Posted

Tallahassee, FL (LifeNews.com) -- The debate about Terri Schiavo isn't over even though the disabled woman was euthanized a year and half ago. Her name is coming up in the Florida gubernatorial debate as the candidates fight over what their position really was during the height of the legal battle surrounding her life.

Attorney General Charlie Crist battles pro-abortion Rep. Jim Davis for the right to replace pro-life Gov. Jeb Bush, who fought to save Terri's life.

Crist has been backpedaling on his position on Terri's life and said in a debate Monday night that he spoke up against a Congressional bill that allowed Terri's parents to take their lawsuit to prevent her euthanasia death to federal courts.

But his response drew outrage from Terri's former husband Michael.

“It made my jaw drop,” Michael told the Palm Beach Post. “The man lied through his teeth.”

“The man ran from this like the plague. And now he’s going to say he spoke up? He did not. He didn’t say a word," Michael, who has endorsed Davis, said of Crist.

But Crist told the newspaper that he did speak up and said he told his colleagues in the Attorney General's office he didn't think the government should get into the battle between Michael and Terri's parents. Governor Bush said Crist told him he opposed getting involved.

He also said he made sure his office didn't get involved on either side of the dispute.

"We had the opportunity in the attorney general's office to do many things to push that in a direction and we did not, which speaks volumes," Crist said. "People understood very clearly where I stood on that issue."

Meanwhile, Davis ripped into Crist and said he "misrepresented" his position on Terri Schiavo during the key days leading up to her death. Davis also said he strenuously fought against Terri's parents' effort to save their daughter's life.

"I was up there fighting George Bush and the entire United States Congress, both political parties, and Charlie Crist was unwilling to take a position," Davis told the Gainesville newspaper.

Terri's family hasn't spoken out about Crist recently, but, during the primary campaign, Terri's father Robert Schindler wrote an editorial criticizing Crist.

“Florida Atty. Gen. Charlie Crist let my daughter die. He had it within his authority to save her life, but he turned a blind eye to her suffering,’’ Schindler wrote.

Polls show Crist leading Davis. Florida Right to Life, the statewide pro-life group, has not endorsed Crist but has informed voters that he would be better on pro-life issues than Davis, whose voting record in favor of abortion is long-standing.

Posted

Euthanized? I thought they removed the feeding tube.

Posted

[quote name='KizlarAgha' post='1108281' date='Nov 1 2006, 09:45 PM']
Euthanized? I thought they removed the feeding tube.
[/quote]

When you remove a feeding tube and make it against the law for anyone to provide sustainance to another human it is called euthanasia. I call it legalized murder.

xTrishaxLynnx
Posted

It bothers me that my Psychology professor really advocates 'pulling the plug' if someone's brain and body are only performing basic functions (breathing, pulse, etc)

Posted

I have to say I'm curious (and contrary to what Socrates will say later, I don't mean any offense). Why is it that "pulling the plug" is wrong? First of all, people being kept alive by medical means is something that wouldn't have been possible fifty or one-hundred years ago. It's unnatural in the sense that people who would ordinarily have died are "living" on with minimal signs of life. In some cases, these people aren't breathing for themselves any longer. Secondly, if you believe in a God and a heaven, why would you want them to live ten or fifteen years as a vegetable, knowing that their soul will go to heaven anyway? Is it simply the hope for a miracle?

I'm not sure what I'd want in that situation. If I believed in an afterlife, I wouldn't mind my plug being pulled. However, I don't, so I'm drawn to the idea of extending my life as long as is humanly possible. I dunno, it just seems odd that not leaving someone as a vegetable is considered Euthanasia by Christians.

Posted

Giving food and water isn't the same as extraordinary care. She was dehydrated to death.

Posted

[quote name='notardillacid' post='1108494' date='Nov 2 2006, 02:30 AM']
Giving food and water isn't the same as extraordinary care. She was dehydrated to death.
[/quote]

Ok, so what's the standard though? Is it just food and water?

Posted

Food and water seem pretty standard to me

Posted

[quote name='notardillacid' post='1108500' date='Nov 2 2006, 03:05 AM']
Food and water seem pretty standard to me
[/quote]

I just meant what's the Church's required amount of aid to be given to someone? You've said food and water, fair enough. Does the Church require that you allow machines to breathe for the person? What about a machine that pumps blood for the person? I'm not trying to poke holes, I just don't know the Church's official requirements.

Posted

the technical criterion is that we are required to stay alive by ordinary means, but not necessarily by extra-ordinary means.

it is generally agreed upon by Catholic moral theologians that food and water, even if administered through a tube, is ordinary means. I am not aware of any legitimate Catholic bio-ethicist who does not hold food and water as ordinary means.

I believe respirators can be considered extra-ordinary; probably once you start needing machines to completely take the place of your vital organs you have crossed the line into potentially extra-ordinary means. the mouth and esophagous being bypassed to bring the food to your vital organs, however, is not an extra-ordinary means.

the line is debateable, to a certain extent, as to what is ordinary and what is extra-ordinary. but there is not much debate on whether it is ordinary to use machines to feed a person.

Posted

Go the to the St. Pete Diocese website and read what Bishop Robert Lynch said about Teri. He wrote a number of articles. In summation, food and water are basic rights and normal care unless the person has a living will stating other desires in the instance of long term dependence on a feeding tube. In this particular case, there was no living will so the fight was what the parents and the spouse both claim was Teri's will. Bishop Lynch was loathe to have the government step in and make the decision and take away the right and responsibilty of the spouse, even though the spouse very well may have been abusing his right and responsibilty. It wasn't (and isn't) a simple issue, unless you are a simpleton.
Florida law really protects people to have Living Wills and such, that does not have the Governemnt over-reach it's boundaries. There was/is great doubt regarding the motives of Teri's husband, but there are limits to what legally could be done without opening a legal pandora box and letting the Government get too involved.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='Anomaly' post='1108711' date='Nov 2 2006, 12:20 PM']
Go the to the St. Pete Diocese website and read what Bishop Robert Lynch said about Teri. He wrote a number of articles. In summation, food and water are basic rights and normal care unless the person has a living will stating other desires in the instance of long term dependence on a feeding tube. In this particular case, there was no living will so the fight was what the parents and the spouse both claim was Teri's will. Bishop Lynch was loathe to have the government step in and make the decision and take away the right and responsibilty of the spouse, even though the spouse very well may have been abusing his right and responsibilty. It wasn't (and isn't) a simple issue, unless you are a simpleton.
Florida law really protects people to have Living Wills and such, that does not have the Governemnt over-reach it's boundaries. There was/is great doubt regarding the motives of Teri's husband, but there are limits to what legally could be done without opening a legal pandora box and letting the Government get too involved.
[/quote]

A feeding tube in not and extraordinary means of sustaining life.

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1108733' date='Nov 2 2006, 12:39 PM']
A feeding tube in not and extraordinary means of sustaining life.
[/quote]Sorry, but one of the Princes clearly disagrees.

"[quote]In these most difficult cases, our Church teaching is that there should be a presumption in favor of providing medically assisted nutrition and hydration to all patients as long as it is of sufficient benefit to outweigh the burdens involved to the patient.

If Terri’s feeding tube is removed, it will undoubtedly be followed by her death. If it were to be removed because the nutrition which she receives from it is of no use to her, or because it is unreasonably burdensome for her and her family or her caregivers, [b]it could be seen as permissible.[/b] But if it were to be removed simply because she is not dying quickly enough and some believe she would be better off because of her low quality of life, this would be wrong.

This situation is tragic. I strongly recommend that
1. in the presence of so much uncertainty and dispute about her actual physical state, all parties pursue a clearer understanding of her actual physical condition;
2. Terri’s family be allowed to attempt a medical protocol which they feel would improve her condition;
3. Excessive rhetoric like the use of “murder” or the designation of the trial judge or appellate judges as “murderers” not be used by anyone from our Judeo-Christian tradition. This is a much harder case than those who use facile language might know.[/quote]

Posted

The late great Pope disagrees

[quote]In comments March 20 [2004] before the World Federation of Catholic Medical Associations, the Pope stated that patients who are permanently comatose are “always human” and “never become ‘vegetables’ or ‘animals.'" He went on to say that nutrition and hydration should be provided indefinitely even if there is no hope of a patient's recovery.[/quote]

[url="http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/4669899/"]http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/4669899/[/url]

[quote]On March 20, 2004, Pope John Paul II addressed participants at a four-day conference sponsored by the Pontifical Academy for Life and the International Federation of Catholic Medical Associations. He addressed the issue of artificial hydration and nutrition in patients suffering from the neurological condition known as the “persistent vegetative state.” He said, “I feel an obligation to reaffirm vigorously that the intrinsic value and the personal dignity of every human being does not change no matter what the concrete situation of his life.” He later said that a human being “never becomes a ‘vegetable’ or an ‘animal.’”

If patients are not dying, he said, artificial nutrition and hydration must be considered “in principle, ordinary and proportionate and, as such, morally obligatory, insofar as and until it is seen to have attained its proper finality, which in the present case consists in providing nourishment to the patient and alleviation of his suffering.”

Unfortunately, media reports about this statement have inadvertently contributed to the confusion about whether using feeding tubes is morally obligatory. News stories amplified hysteria about this very technical speech. His words should not be interpreted out of context.

To help provide that context, in July 2004, an international group of Catholic scholars met to discuss the use of artificial hydration and nutrition in a variety of medical conditions, particularly in light of the papal speech. These faithful, orthodox scholars, convened by the Canadian Catholic Bioethics Institute in Toronto, reached the following conclusions:

“The papal speech needs to be understood in the context of the Catholic tradition. The words ‘in principle’ do not mean ‘absolute’ in the sense of ‘exceptionless’ but allow consideration of other duties that might apply. Therefore, what the papal statement really means is that, for permanently unresponsive patients who are not otherwise dying, tube feeding should be presumed to be ordinary and proportionate (and as such, morally obligatory) unless its use would conflict with other grave responsibilities or would be overly burdensome, costly or otherwise complicated.” (The complete text of this statement has been published in the National Catholic Bioethics Quarterly 4 [2004], pp. 773-82.)

It is a common misconception of Catholic tradition that popes can say whatever they want and it becomes dogma. In reality, popes are also bound by our common tradition, in the trust that this tradition, through the work of the Holy Spirit, bears the truth that popes are called to expound. Popes may apply this tradition and speak to new issues, clarify aspects of the tradition that have raised new doubts or extend the body of dogma beyond what tradition has previously addressed. But they cannot jettison that tradition. Thus, the international colloquium, as described above, interpreted the papal speech in the light of that tradition.

To provide further context, it is critical to note that the papal speech of March 2004, while raising issues of concern regarding the care of all patients, was delivered at the end of a conference regarding the care of persons in the persistent vegetative state. (I prefer the term used by the Australians, “post-coma unresponsiveness,” and will use it in the rest of this article).

This condition was the focus of that speech. It is the condition from which Terri Schiavo suffered. It is a very rare neurological condition in which a person starts in a coma that is often caused by inadequate cardiopulmonary resuscitation for someone whose heart has stopped. In such cases, after six months of intensive care, patients may come off the ventilator, be able to open their eyes and breathe on their own, have cycles of wakefulness and sleep, plus perform reflexive actions such as yawning. But the severe brain damage causes a total inability to interact with other people, speak, understand or perform purposeful movements such as eating or walking.

Such persons, if treated with a feeding tube and intensive nursing care, can sometimes live for months or years. When they die, it is typically due to complications of feeding-tube treatment, such as pneumonia caused by food placed in the stomach going up the esophagus (foodpipe) and down into the lungs.

Thinking about using feeding tubes in a rare condition such as post-coma unresponsiveness is very different from thinking about using feeding tubes in more common diseases such as cancer, AIDS, Alzheimer’s disease, Lou Gehrig’s disease or Parkinson’s disease. Tube feeding in these types of patients will often result in great burden, no net benefit and multiple complications.

In very many such cases, tube feeding will meet the criteria by which it could be considered extraordinary or morally optional. These diseases continue to progress and get worse—no matter what treatment is offered. Complications such as pneumonia are much more common when feeding tubes are used for such patients.

Patients with dementia sometimes pull the tubes out and would need to be restrained in order to be fed. In fact, in these conditions it has even been difficult to show that the use of feeding tubes actually makes the patients live longer. Clearly, in many such cases, the burdens of treatment can be judged disproportionate with respect to the benefits, and the treatment could therefore be judged extraordinary or morally optional.[/quote]
[url="http://www.americancatholic.org/Messenger/Jan2006/Feature1.asp#F2"]http://www.americancatholic.org/Messenger/...Feature1.asp#F2[/url]

Posted

So whom to believe, whom to believe?
Isn't Bishop Lynch part of the Magesterium? Was the Pope speaking 'ex-cathedra'?

Posted

Interesting - especially what the pope had to say about it.

Posted

moral theologians like the two above are to continue the debate; until it is settled by the magisterium faithful Catholics should set up living wills; and should be advised to highly consider the pope's advice and not refuse food and hydration.

and whatever anyone says, that husband will face the flames of God's wrath for not permitting Terri communion while he was allowing her to starve.

I don't propose that it is a simple question, but one ought to tread carefully when dealing with basic food and hydration issues: you cannot stop feeding someone if the only thing that is keeping them alive is food. that is absolutely not permissable, and any moral theologian who says it is permissable had better be able to offer a very very good argument, the good bishop's argument above is not sufficient to me. the burden of proof is on someone to show how food and hydration can ever be considered extra-ordinary. and Catholics ought to be in the disposition of accepting food and hydration as being natural means until proven otherwise. the jury's still out: so side on the side of caution and prudence, on the side of life, and on the side of the pope unless absolutely totally proven otherwise.

Posted

[url="http://www.dioceseofstpete.org/news.php?NID=9"]http://www.dioceseofstpete.org/news.php?NID=9[/url]

Above is the link to what Bishop Lynch, who is much more familiar with Teri's case, had to say about this particular case.

Read both twice and you will see the ambiguity of the 'clarification'. I don't think the Pope disagrees with Bishop Lynch in this instance, buy who's to know? It's a matter of opinion.

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1108770' date='Nov 2 2006, 01:23 PM']
moral theologians like the two above are to continue the debate; until it is settled by the magisterium faithful Catholics should set up living wills; and should be advised to highly consider the pope's advice and not refuse food and hydration.

and whatever anyone says, that husband will face the flames of God's wrath for not permitting Terri communion while he was allowing her to starve.

I don't propose that it is a simple question, but one ought to tread carefully when dealing with basic food and hydration issues: you cannot stop feeding someone if the only thing that is keeping them alive is food. that is absolutely not permissable, and any moral theologian who says it is permissable had better be able to offer a very very good argument, the good bishop's argument above is not sufficient to me.
[/quote]
Ah. The cocksureness of the young. Maybe you should write a letter to the Bishop and correct him?

Posted

oh please. the good bishop did not address how sustaining life with food and hydration could be considered extra-ordinary means. the pope clearly said food and hydration is always ordinary means. I'm not being cocky or arrogant at all, I am being humbly obedient to the wisdom of those much more educated than myself, much more authoritative than the good bishop, and much more experienced directly with health problems than you or I.

anyway, I just re-read what the bishop said, and as far as I see it it would only be permittable to remove the feeding tube if Terri was dying anyway. if the food and hydration were the only things sustaining life, and life was being sustained, then not providing them (so long as the means are available to provide them) is immoral.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1108779' date='Nov 2 2006, 01:30 PM']
oh please. the good bishop did not address how sustaining life with food and hydration could be considered extra-ordinary means. the pope clearly said food and hydration is always ordinary means. I'm not being cocky or arrogant at all, I am being humbly obedient to the wisdom of those much more educated than myself, much more authoritative than the good bishop, and much more experienced directly with health problems than you or I.
[/quote]
Did you read the Bishop's entire article before you disagreed. I only excerpted part of it. Don't you think the Bishop is more educated then you, and he was Teri's Bishop and knew the family and was involved in the case for many years.
And isn't the Pope a Bishop among Bishops? Isn't his 'supremacy' only relevant in the machinations of running the Church?

I'll help you out,
[quote]Our Catholic Church has traditionally viewed medical treatment as excessively burdensome if it is “too painful, too damaging to the patient’s bodily self and functioning, too psychologically repugnant to the patient, too suppressive of the patient’s mental life, or too expensive.” [cf. “Life, Death and Treatment of Dying Patients: Pastoral Statement of the Catholic Bishops of Florida, 1989]

Our Catholic teaching is also clear that “nourishment or hydration may be withheld or withdrawn where that treatment itself is causing harm to the patient or is useless because the patient’s death is imminent, as long as the patient is made comfortable. In general, the terms ‘death is imminent’ and ‘terminally ill’ imply that a physician can predict that the patient will die of the fatal pathology within a few days or weeks, regardless of what life prolonging methods are utilized.” [Statement of Florida bishops cited above]

Terri Schiavo’s case is especially difficult because her actual medical situation is in dispute. The court has determined based on the medical evidence which was presented to it that she is in a “persistent or permanent vegetative state,” commonly referred to as PVS. Her husband agrees with this. Her parents and other family members do not. Physicians who have examined her also have opposing opinions. It is currently assumed that Terri cannot swallow food naturally. All agree, however, that there is extensive and permanent damage to her brain but it is not clear whether the medically assisted nutrition and hydration is delaying her dying process to no avail, is unreasonably burdensome for her, and contrary to what she would wish if she could tell us.[/quote]

Edited by Anomaly

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...