Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Terri Schiavo Major Focus In Flordia's Governor's Race


Recommended Posts

Posted

sorry, I just edited my post after reading that.

I am not sure whether the bishop does disagree with the pope or not. It is slightly ambiguous. I am sure that the pope's argument is more compelling and convincing to me than any argument I have ever seen which attempts to say food and hydration can be considered extra-ordinary means.

The quote the bishop used: “nourishment or hydration may be withheld or withdrawn where that treatment itself is causing harm to the patient or is useless because the patient’s death is imminent, as long as the patient is made comfortable. In general, the terms ‘death is imminent’ and ‘terminally ill’ imply that a physician can predict that the patient will die of the fatal pathology within a few days or weeks, regardless of what life prolonging methods are utilized.” I agree with this statement. But Terri was, in the doctor's opinion, in a "persistent vegitative state" and in the family's opinion in a slightly better condition than that; no one said she was dying however. She was not dying: the only thing keeping her alive was food and hydration, the only way she would have died was from witholding food or hydration. This means she was just as entitled and required to receive food and hydration morally as any human being on earth, so long as the means were possible.

Posted

Whatever.
Since you've got it so right, maybe you should be a Bishop. So I should disobey the Bishop if I was the Catholic doctor?

Posted

Pope John Paul II issued a statement directed at the events in Tampa. It was one of his last statements and occurred right around the time that the last appeal failed. I will try to find it.

Posted

[quote name='Anomaly' post='1108796' date='Nov 2 2006, 01:45 PM']
Whatever.
Since you've got it so right, maybe you should be a Bishop. So I should disobey the Bishop if I was the Catholic doctor?
[/quote]
:huh: should you disobey the pope?

your logic (that I am being cocky and arrogant as if I knew better than a bishop) falls apart because I am merely citing the opinion and teaching of many much more learned than myself.

moreover, when a bishop disagrees with you you have no problem saying just how much smarter you are than him; you have no right to tell me, agreeing with a pope and principals of Church teaching as I see them, that I am being arrogant as if I knew more than the bishop.

as it stands as a principal of Catholic doctrine, one ought to be given food and hydration if that is the only thing keeping them alive (because then they are in the same category as the rest of humanity) so long as the means to give it to them is readily available. in the Shiavo case, she was not dying and the family had more than enough money to continue feeding her; it was unjust to starve her of nutrition and sustinence.

if the bishop disagreed with this (there was a bit of political correct ambiguity, I couldn't exactly tell) then he'd be disagreeing with the quote he himself offered and he'd be wrong.

anyway, it's been fun being accused of being young, cockey, arrogant, and then being offered the episcopate; but I'd rather deal with the issue at hand that you have not addressed in your last three or four posts... the fact of the matter is that Catholic teaching says that ordinary means must be used to keep one alive; and under usual conditions (the means are available, the person is not dying anyway) food and hydration are ordinary means. your attempt to deter my study of moral theology on the basis that I should never think I can ever really know any moral principal is futile.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...