Matty_boy Posted November 13, 2006 Posted November 13, 2006 [url="http://www.dailymail.co.uk/pages/live/articles/news/news.html?in_article_id=416003&in_page_id=1770"]Outrage as Church backs calls for severely disabled babies to be killed at birth.[/url] By NEIL SEARS Last updated at 22:00pm on 12th November 2006 The Church of England has broken with tradition dogma by calling for doctors to be allowed to let sick newborn babies die. Christians have long argued that life should preserved at all costs - but a bishop representing the national church has now sparked controversy by arguing that there are occasions when it is compassionate to leave a severely disabled child to die. And the Bishop of Southwark, Tom Butler, who is the vice chair of the Church of England's Mission and Public Affairs Council, has also argued that the high financial cost of keeping desperately ill babies alive should be a factor in life or death decisions. The shock new policy from the church has caused outrage among the disabled. A spokeswoman for the UK Disabled People's Council, which represents tens of thousands of members in 140 different organisations, said: "How can the Church of England say that Christian compassion includes killing of disabled babies either through the withdrawing or withholding of treatment or by active euthanasia? "It is not for doctors or indeed anyone else to determine whether a baby’s life is worthwhile simply on the grounds of impairment or health condition." The church's surprise call comes just a week after the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecology sparked fury by calling for a debate on the mercy killing of disabled infants. But it has been made in a carefully thought out official Church of England paper written by Bishop Butler for a public inquiry into the ethical issues surrounding the care of long premature or desperately ill newborn babies. The inquiry, by the Nuffield Council on Bioethics, began two years ago and its findings are due to be published in London - but the church's contribution to the debate has been leaked in advance. The Nuffield Council, an independent body which issues ethical guidelines for doctors, began the inquiry to take account of scientific advances which mean increasingly disabled and premature babies can technically be kept alive. In practice, doing so can be controversial - with the three months premature Charlotte Wyatt a case in point. The Portsmouth baby weighed just 1lb at birth, and had severe brain and lung damage. Doctors wanted to be allowed to leave her to die, but her parents successfully campaigned through the courts against them. Now that the child is three, however, and could be cared for at home, her parents have separated and are considered unsuitable to look after. In future cases doctors may work to guidelines proposed by the Nuffield inquiry. In the Church of England's contribution to the inquiry, Bishop Butler wrote: "It may in some circumstances be right to choose to withold or withdraw treatment, knowing it will possibly, probably, or even certainly result in death." The church stressed that it was not saying some lives were not worth living, but said there were "strong proportionate reasons" for "overriding the presupposition that life should be maintained". The bishop's submission continued: "There may be occasions where, for a Christian, compassion will override the 'rule' that life should inevitably be preserved. "Disproportionate treatment for the sake of prolonging life is an example of this. The church said it would support the potentially fatal withdrawal of treatment only if all alternatives had been considered, "so that the possibly lethal act would only be performed with manifest reluctance." Yet the Revd Butler's submission makes clear that there are a wide range of acceptable reasons to withdraw care from a child - with the cost of the care among the considerations. "Great caution should be exercised in brining questions of cost into the equation when considering what treatment might be provided," he wrote. "The principle of justice inevitably means that the potential cost of treatment itself, the longer term costs of health care and education and opportunity cost to the NHS in terms of saving other lives have to be considered." The church also urges all the parties involved in care for critically ill babies should be realistic in their expectations, demands, and claims. The submission says: "The principle of humility asks that members of the medical profession restrain themselves from claiming greater powers to heal than they can deliver. "It asks that parents restrain themselves from demanding the impossible.": UK Disabled Peoples Council spokeswoman Simone Aspis said the group's members were appalled that the Church was joining doctors in calling for disabled babies to be left to die. "It appears that the whole debate on whether disabled babies are worth keeping alive is being dominated by professionals and religious people without any consultation with disabled people," she said. Out of babies born at just 22 weeks of pregnancy or less, 98 per cent currently die. In Holland babies born before 25 weeks are not given medial treatment.
Fulton Sheen Warrior Posted November 13, 2006 Posted November 13, 2006 +JMJ+ Pope Paul VI has proven himself to be quite the prophet in what would happen in a contraceptive society. How far will we take our disrespect for life? For the sake of His sorrowful Passion.......
ardillacid Posted November 13, 2006 Posted November 13, 2006 [quote name='RC_' post='1119137' date='Nov 13 2006, 05:12 PM'] I'm glad I'm not an Anglican. [/quote] How about English?
RC_ Posted November 13, 2006 Posted November 13, 2006 [quote name='notardillacid' post='1119150' date='Nov 13 2006, 06:29 PM'] How about English? [/quote] That goes without saying.
Winchester Posted November 13, 2006 Posted November 13, 2006 [quote]The bishop's submission continued: "There may be occasions where, for a Christian, compassion will override the 'rule' that life should inevitably be preserved. [/quote] I'd read the whole document before coming to a conclusion because it sounds like it might be reasonably worded. I see no quote from the Bishop calling for euthanasia, although I see it asserted in the article. Does anyone here not support DNR orders?
Balthazor Posted November 13, 2006 Posted November 13, 2006 DNR? I am sorry what is that...where I am from it means Department of Natural Resoures?
Winchester Posted November 13, 2006 Posted November 13, 2006 Do Not Resucitate. It's a legal order to withhold CPR. Really, if you need CPR, you're dead, anyway. I think this is a call to sometimes avoid extraordinary means of preserving life.
Birgitta Noel Posted November 14, 2006 Posted November 14, 2006 Yeah, I commented on this earlier. Even from the beginning there are false statements. Most Christians DON'T believe that life should be preserved at all costs. One may find treatment to be overly burdensome. Not that their life is burdensome, but that the treatment necessary to preserve/extend it is. So, while euthanasia is of course unacceptable, it seems that the nuance is getting lost in the tenor of this article which is not at all surprizing. Also, in addition to DNR orders there are some hospitals which are adopting, AND which means "Allow Natural Death" basically no heroic measures.
LuchaporElRey21 Posted November 14, 2006 Posted November 14, 2006 That is so utilitarian. It just reeks.
philothea Posted November 14, 2006 Posted November 14, 2006 [quote name='The Little Way' post='1119290' date='Nov 13 2006, 08:16 PM'] Yeah, I commented on this earlier. Even from the beginning there are false statements. Most Christians DON'T believe that life should be preserved at all costs. One may find treatment to be overly burdensome. Not that their life is burdensome, but that the treatment necessary to preserve/extend it is. So, while euthanasia is of course unacceptable, it seems that the nuance is getting lost in the tenor of this article which is not at all surprizing. Also, in addition to DNR orders there are some hospitals which are adopting, AND which means "Allow Natural Death" basically no heroic measures. [/quote] Agreed; the article isn't accurate in portraying Christian beliefs, and the proposed ideals aren't all that radical. They're not talking about offing babies who aren't perfect. They're talking about not spending huge money to try to save babies who are likely to die anyway, who -- at best -- will be severely disabled. This was never an issue before modern technology. Honestly, I wonder about demanding extraordinary measures off a state-run tax-funded system (like the UK has) at all. I know that's heartless of me, but I think if you're going for the long odds, maybe you should pay for it yourself...
cmotherofpirl Posted November 14, 2006 Posted November 14, 2006 No. Docters in Britian ARE calling for active euthenasia of disabled babies which they already do in the Netherlands. from Lifesite "The recommendation included both active euthanasia, directly killing a newborn, and passive euthanasia, which would included cases where lifesaving medical treatment would be withheld. "
philothea Posted November 14, 2006 Posted November 14, 2006 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1119425' date='Nov 13 2006, 10:54 PM'] No. Docters in Britian ARE calling for active euthenasia of disabled babies which they already do in the Netherlands. from Lifesite "The recommendation included both active euthanasia, directly killing a newborn, and passive euthanasia, which would included cases where lifesaving medical treatment would be withheld. "[/quote] Well obviously that's totally wrong. But that's the doctors, not what the Anglican document was advocating! As far as I could tell. The article was using a leaked version of a purported document, so who knows what anyone is really saying. Disabled babies are so hard to keep alive anyway. Active euthanasia is just... nuts.
Winchester Posted November 14, 2006 Posted November 14, 2006 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1119425' date='Nov 13 2006, 10:54 PM'] No. Docters in Britian ARE calling for active euthenasia of disabled babies which they already do in the Netherlands. from Lifesite "The recommendation included both active euthanasia, directly killing a newborn, and passive euthanasia, which would included cases where lifesaving medical treatment would be withheld. " [/quote] Are we talking about doctors or Bishops? I'm talking about bishops.
jswranch Posted November 14, 2006 Posted November 14, 2006 (edited) [quote name='RC_' post='1119137' date='Nov 13 2006, 04:12 PM'] I'm glad I'm not an Anglican. [/quote] I'm glad I'm not an Anglican anymore. This is an ugly flashback to the Anglicans breaching the hole in the dam for contraception. Edited November 14, 2006 by jswranch
jswranch Posted November 14, 2006 Posted November 14, 2006 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1119425' date='Nov 13 2006, 09:54 PM']Docters in Britian ARE calling for active euthenasia of disabled babies which they already do in the Netherlands. [/quote] This is the grave danger of socialized medicine in today's modernist (culture of death) world. If the govt picks up the tab, then they can decide who does not get care and who does not. In an apocolypical world (provided the anti-dote TOB is not fast enough) then only Catholic hospitals will be the safe haven for such cases. Even now, I am not certain a free use Catholic hospital would be allowed in Canada, UK or Netherlands. It is illegal to pay for care in Canada. Anyone know better?
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now