cmotherofpirl Posted November 14, 2006 Posted November 14, 2006 [url="http://www.lifesite.net/ldn/2006/nov/06111303.html"]http://www.lifesite.net/ldn/2006/nov/06111303.html[/url]
Thy Geekdom Come Posted November 14, 2006 Posted November 14, 2006 [quote name='Winchester' post='1119178' date='Nov 13 2006, 06:50 PM'] Really, if you need CPR, you're dead, anyway. [/quote]
homeschoolmom Posted November 14, 2006 Posted November 14, 2006 [quote name='jswranch' post='1119581' date='Nov 14 2006, 03:45 AM'] This is the grave danger of socialized medicine in today's modernist (culture of death) world. If the govt picks up the tab, then they can decide [b]who does not[/b] get care and [b]who does not[/b] . In an apocolypical world (provided the anti-dote TOB is not fast enough) then only Catholic hospitals will be the safe haven for such cases. Even now, I am not certain a free use Catholic hospital would be allowed in Canada, UK or Netherlands. It is illegal to pay for care in Canada. Anyone know better? [/quote] typo or phophetic statement??
Matty_boy Posted November 14, 2006 Author Posted November 14, 2006 If we adopted this guy's standards of compassion, we could axe him for out of compassion who have to listen to him. I think that would prove him right though. It's like SE7EN.
Winchester Posted November 14, 2006 Posted November 14, 2006 [quote name='Raphael' post='1119646' date='Nov 14 2006, 08:54 AM'] [/quote] When your heart stops, you are considered dead. You can't get any worse because you're not coming back without assistance (we're not talking "skipping a beat.) While not completely accurate, it is true enough. CPR is only performed on those who have stopped delivering blood to the body. When your heart stops, your breathing soon follows. Cell death doesn't occur immediately (dead dead.) Let's call it "mostly dead."
Sojourner Posted November 14, 2006 Posted November 14, 2006 [quote name='Winchester' post='1119723' date='Nov 14 2006, 10:34 AM'] When your heart stops, you are considered dead. You can't get any worse because you're not coming back without assistance (we're not talking "skipping a beat.) While not completely accurate, it is true enough. CPR is only performed on those who have stopped delivering blood to the body. When your heart stops, your breathing soon follows. Cell death doesn't occur immediately (dead dead.) Let's call it "mostly dead." [/quote] There's a big difference between mostly dead and all dead. Mostly dead is slightly alive. Once they're all dead, though, you can go through their pockets and look for loose change.
Winchester Posted November 14, 2006 Posted November 14, 2006 Ha! And I'm not as callous as it appears. Okay, yes I am, but I know other people aren't. That's pretty important. You have to treasure life, because at any moment, you could lose it in a freak gasoline fight accident.
Sojourner Posted November 14, 2006 Posted November 14, 2006 too true, brother, too true I've come to realize that my chiseled abs and stunning features are no protection against such a fate.
123 Posted November 14, 2006 Posted November 14, 2006 (edited) My parents are Anglican, they have establish all the Church of England traditions. However, their church body is saddened and outraged by what is going on. Edited November 14, 2006 by GloriaIesusChristi
Quietfire Posted November 14, 2006 Posted November 14, 2006 Dont they realize though that accepting something like this is such a positive nod to the culture of death? Today, we euthanize only children that WE deem as severly retarded and would "most" likely not survive anyway. Within five years, they will be secretly euthanizing ANY child that "may" have a handicap and thus strain our oh so precious resources. By the 10 year mark it will be the secret everyone is in on but no one will talk about. "Oh, dont worry dear. If the doctors feel that your baby isnt 100%, they will take care of it for you and you wont have anything to worry about."....."Oh, dearie. That baby was just so sick and the doctors really tried but "it" died anyway."
Sojourner Posted November 14, 2006 Posted November 14, 2006 Who are you tryin' to get crazy with, ese? Don't you know I'm loco?
RC_ Posted November 14, 2006 Posted November 14, 2006 [quote name='Quietfire' post='1119786' date='Nov 14 2006, 01:41 PM'] Dont they realize though that accepting something like this is such a positive nod to the culture of death? Today, we euthanize only children that WE deem as severly retarded and would "most" likely not survive anyway. Within five years, they will be secretly euthanizing ANY child that "may" have a handicap and thus strain our oh so precious resources. By the 10 year mark it will be the secret everyone is in on but no one will talk about. "Oh, dont worry dear. If the doctors feel that your baby isnt 100%, they will take care of it for you and you wont have anything to worry about."....."Oh, dearie. That baby was just so sick and the doctors really tried but "it" died anyway." [/quote] Yep...and don't forget about people severly injured in accidents. They'll be lumped into the same incinerator.
cmotherofpirl Posted November 15, 2006 Posted November 15, 2006 When Doctors Want to Kill Handicapped Newborns Interview With Neonatologist Carlo Bellieni SIENA, Italy, NOV. 14, 2006 (Zenit.org).- According to British press reports the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynecology has asked that doctors be allowed to let seriously disabled newborns die. The Royal College sent its request to the Nuffield Bioethics Council, the body in charge of examining the ethical issues involved in the new developments of biology and medicine. The latter, an influential private commission, is about to publish a report on critical decisions in fetal and neonatal medicine. Opposition to the Royal College request has been expressed in the United Kingdom by the British Council of Disabled People. To better understand the issue and its implications of a bioethical nature, ZENIT interviewed neonatologist Carlo Bellieni, director of the Neonatal Intensive Therapy Department of the Le Scotte University Polyclinic of Siena. Q: What do you think of the request of the United Kingdom's Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists? Bellieni: The request to do away with newborns with serious disabilities, does not leave any pediatrician insensitive, namely, those who tomorrow will be called to carry out the "eliminations." But it is not new: Already in 2002 Michael Gross wrote in Bioethics that there is "a general endorsement of neonaticide subject to a parent's assessment of the newborn's interest broadly defined to consider physical harm as well as social, psychological and or financial harm to related third parties." And it is always by the "interest of third parties" that one begins to understand what might be hidden behind a pietistic intention "to put an end to the child's sufferings." Q: What are the most disturbing aspects of the British proposal? Bellieni: Three things disturb pediatricians. One, having to become executioners of a death sentence. We are not doctors for this, especially at a time when the death sentence is stigmatized by an increasing number of states. Two, having to consider the patients themselves as non-persons. There are authors who say that newborns are not persons because they still do not have self-awareness, precisely a requirement for this sensation -- affirmations amply denied by science and experience. Three, having to consider the handicapped not as a life to help and respect but, with a phobic attitude, as a second-tier life. Q: Some British doctors have said that no one must be scandalized because a late abortion is similar to active euthanasia. What is your opinion in this respect? Bellieni: I was not surprised by this news. I understand the horror but I do not understand the astonishment. Whoever has studied anatomy and biology, whoever is an expert in human physiology, knows very well that there is no substantial difference between the fetus and the newborn, other than small modifications in the blood circle. Therefore, one cannot understand why it's horrible to kill a newborn but not to kill a fetus. Unless one believes that the filling of the lungs with air has a "magic" effect, capable of transforming the DNA or the individual's conscience! The photo of the small dead fetus within the murdered mother, published a few months ago by an Italian newspaper, made an impression not because a corpse could be seen -- sadly we have also seen recently on TV and in newspapers many dead children in war and no one has protested -- but because the reality was shown: that a fetus is nothing other than a child that has yet to enjoy the exterior air. And, every mother knows that this is true, as any one knows whose job it is to look after the very small fetuses that have come forth prematurely from the maternal womb, called "premature children." Surgeons who operate on fetuses that are still in the womb, also know this. I repeat: The tragedy is that it surprises us, whereas a cultural endeavor must be initiated, made up of research and serious writing, and not only of "reactions" to the latest "transgression," to the latest horror. The real bioethical effort of today is not to affirm a vague feeling of mercy toward one's neighbor -- television programs are also full of tears -- but to look for the evidence, the reality; to affirm that an embryo is an embryo and not just a cell, that a fetus of a few hundred grams feels pain, that the DNA shows that every one's life begins at conception. In short, it is like demonstrating that a flower is a flower and not a vase! ZE06111421
philothea Posted November 15, 2006 Posted November 15, 2006 Dr. Bellieni is wonderfully eloquent. Thanks for posting that.
misereremi Posted November 15, 2006 Posted November 15, 2006 Ditto to the pihilothea's post above. The death anniversary of my friend's premature baby falls this week and this makes me think of all the good doctors there still are here, and how they would strongly oppose this euthanasia. (and not even from a religious but a professional standpoint) We watched as so many of them tried to keep baby Chanae (RIP) alive, despite the fact she may have had to live with serious disabilities. And this was on the national health service. I pray that doctors will continue to value every life and fight hard to save every life, just as these doctors did.
cmotherofpirl Posted November 16, 2006 Posted November 16, 2006 Respectable Baby Killing Support builds for legalizing euthanasia for ill and disabled newborns. By Wesley J. Smith The push to permit infanticide has entered the mainstream. The Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecology (RCOG) has recommended that a debate be had about whether to permit “deliberate interventions to kill infants.” The recommendation, which was widely reported in the media, was in response to a query from the Nuffield Council on Bioethics concerning ethical issues pertaining to health care which prolongs the life of newborns. It was at the urging of the RCOG that euthanasia of infants was added to the topics that the council would consider. As reported by the London Times, the RCOG’s recommendation states: A very disabled child can mean a disabled family. If life-shortening and deliberate interventions to kill infants were available, they might have an impact on obstetric decision-making, even preventing some late term abortions, as some parents would be more confident about continuing a pregnancy and taking a risk on outcome. The article goes on to quote a number of British doctors and professors who support euthanasia. Consider carefully what has happened here. A prestigious medical association has seriously suggested that killing some babies because they are seriously ill or disabled might be ethically acceptable and, at the very least, is worthy of considered and respectable debate. It is about time that people start paying attention to this. Those who think that legal infanticide is unthinkable and preposterous are being naïve. Infanticide advocacy is no longer limited to rogue bioethicists, such as Princeton University’s notorious Peter Singer, who has famously argued that parents be given as much as a year to decide whether to keep or kill their babies. In fact, it has been some time since Singer was the dominant voice of infanticide advocacy. In recent years, articles aimed at normalizing the killing of disabled babies have appeared in some of the world’s most established medical publications. For example, the March 10, 2005, edition of the New England Journal of Medicine published an article by Dutch physicians who have admitted to having euthanized 15-20 disabled infants. The NEJM provided them with a respectable forum in which to propose formal regulations to govern what amounts to eugenic infanticide. The so-called “Groningen Protocol” (named after the Dutch hospital where the infanticides took place) posits three categories of killable infants: babies “with no chance of survival”; infants with a “poor prognosis and [who] are dependent on intensive care”; and “infants with a hopeless prognosis,” including those “not depending on intensive medical treatment but for whom a very poor quality of life…is predicted.” Such journal articles were reported on approvingly in the mainstream media. For example, the July 10, 2005, New York Times Magazine published a column by frequent contributor Jim Holt proposing the merits of the Groningen Protocol. Holt suggested that the decision to kill ill or disabled babies should be governed by “a new moral duty,” namely, “the duty prevent suffering, especially futile suffering.” The debate over infant euthanasia is usually framed as a collision between two values: sanctity of life and quality of life. Judgments about the latter, of course, are notoriously subjective and can lead you down a slippery slope. But shifting the emphasis to suffering changes the terms of the debate. To keep alive an infant whose short life expectancy will be dominated by pain — pain that it can neither bear nor comprehend — is, it might be argued, to do that infant a continuous injury. At first blush, this might seem reasonable, but Holt’s game of semantics does not provide him with traction on the slippery slope. The concept of suffering is not limited to pain, but must also take account of “quality of life,” as more liberal advocates of infanticide would surely point out. More insidiously, Holt’s advocacy could lead to a perceived duty to kill disabled babies since he argues that not killing a disabled baby could be to inflict injury upon the child. Such arguments are really a veneer for the real issues, which are money and commitment. Disabled infants are expensive to care for, particularly if they don’t die young, and they require all sorts of attention. The nub of the issue isn’t about our supposed inability to alleviate the suffering of infants — a false supposition— but rather, about our not wanting to spend the financial and emotional resources it would take to do so. This position is clearly central to the RCOG’s statement — and was explicitly ratified in a November 9, 2006, editorial in The Economist calling the RCOG’s call to debate infanticide “brave” and urging that infanticide be seriously considered because “Disabled children are nine times more likely than others to end up in the care of the state.” Infanticide, alas, has become a respectable notion, at least among some elite opinion makers. History shows that this is how baby killing begins — by convincing ourselves that there is such a thing as a human life not worth living, and hence, not worth protecting. By calling for a serious debate about infanticide, the RCOG has badly subverted the foundational moral principle that each and every human being has equal moral value simply and merely because he or she is human. — Wesley J. Smith, a frequent contributor to NRO, is a senior fellow at the Discovery Institute, an attorney for the International Task Force on Euthanasia and Assisted Suicide, and a special consultant to the Center for Bioethics and Culture. His website is www.wesleyjsmith.com. [url="http://article.nationalreview.com/?q=NzQ4ODllNzE2YTcxNTIzNzgzNDc5NGQ1YTk1Njk4NTA="]http://article.nationalreview.com/?q=NzQ4O...GQ1YTk1Njk4NTA=[/url]
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now