Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Eragon


Recommended Posts

Catholictothecore
Posted

Eragon is a movie being released this year based on an awesome book by Christopher Poalini. Does anyone here know when it is being released? All I've seen for it is a copy of the book with the movie art and photos.

Posted

sometime in December

I already have plans to watch it with a friend of mine who also loved the book.

Catholictothecore
Posted

Eragon rocks. Not so good as Tolkien or Rowlings, but excellent just the same.

Theunknown101
Posted

[url="http://www.worstpreviews.com/media.php?id=103&place=trailer"]Here[/url] are some trailers. Well, you watch them only if you have Quicktime...

Posted

[quote name='Catholictothecore' post='1119875' date='Nov 14 2006, 01:10 PM']
Eragon rocks. Not so good as Tolkien or Rowlings, but excellent just the same.
[/quote]
I thought the second book was better. He did more to make the story his own. In the first book, it was obvious that he'd been heavily influenced by writers such as Ursula LeGuin, Tolkien, etc. Still a good read, though.

Posted

Ugg...I thought the first book was pretty decent, if derivative, but the second book was Narcissic (sp?) trash. Eragon becomes a half-elf atheist vegetarian and gets everything handed to him on a silver platter....

It just irritated me. A lot. I'm reserving judgement on the series until Empire, though.

I think the movie comes out on Dec. 19.

Theunknown101
Posted

Yeah, I don't really like the idea of a "good dragon." Weren't dragons the symbol of the Devil in the Middle Ages?

Posted

Well, Theunknown, symbols can have more than one meaning...in the Bible, the lion is both Christ--I think one of his titles is "The Lion of Judah"--and Satan, who is described as a prowling lion. Satan is a serpent in the garden, but Christ also told his disciples to be "wise as serpents"--not to mention the bronze serpent he had Moses erect. Satan is sometimes called a dragon, but at the end of the book of Job, God uses a creature called "Leviathan", which is describing using dragon-like traits such as scales, fiery breath, etc., as an emobodiment of his awesome power.

As a fantasy writer myself, I can tell you that part of the genre is that writers define things like symbolism within their own world--dragons are a fantasy creature, and can be used in different ways in different settings/worlds o' fantasy. Eragon uses them pretty consistently as icons of good, and attempts to enslave and make dragons do evil are shown as particularly twisted. I've read other books in which dragons are evil or simply wild creatures with no moral dimension. It depends on the world the fantasy writer constructs and what symbolisms are introduced within that context.

Admittedly, there are a few symbols which are so powerful that they really can't really be used in different contexts--crucifixion is the main one that occurs to me. You can't really have a character be crucified or end up in a situation like crucifixion without recalling Christ's sacrifice.

I don't think that's true for dragons, though, simply because Mediaeval artists used them as a convienient symbol for Satan.

Posted

My kids, and my wife each read the first book last summer - and they are reading the seond book right now...
my family seems to love the books so far :coo:

and thanks for sharing your view, Jalazar

Theunknown101
Posted

[quote name='Jalazar' post='1120445' date='Nov 15 2006, 12:50 AM']
As a fantasy writer myself, I can tell you that part of the genre is that writers define things like symbolism within their own world--dragons are a fantasy creature, and can be used in different ways in different settings/worlds o' fantasy. Eragon uses them pretty consistently as icons of good, and attempts to enslave and make dragons do evil are shown as particularly twisted. I've read other books in which dragons are evil or simply wild creatures with no moral dimension. It depends on the world the fantasy writer constructs and what symbolisms are introduced within that context.


[/quote]

You're a fantasy writer? I though I was the only one here...well, there maybe dragons & wyverns in my story, but they get killed off pretty quick. My mom doesn't really like us doing anything with good dragons.

Posted

Cool! Nice to meet another devotee of that most noble art :smokey:.

Posted

I'd never heard of Eragon before I found out about the film, but it seems alright, although John Malkovich's acting looks pretty bad.

Theunknown101
Posted

[quote name='Jalazar' post='1120574' date='Nov 15 2006, 11:00 AM']
Cool! Nice to meet another devotee of that most noble art :smokey:.
[/quote]


Well the stories are not serious a whole lot, they're more comedy.

Posted

I made a fantasy story too. And that's also a comedy.

Posted

philothea is actually also a fantasy writer


she has a book that she has been trying to get published. I don't think it's made it yet but she's working on it.

  • 4 weeks later...
Guest Rick777
Posted

Just saw it. I have to say it was pretty good.

Posted

I hope it’s good… but I have doubts.
I’m just finishing the first book myself – and I have seen stills from the movie, and I wasn’t too pleased.

When a movie takes a story from a book, uses the title of the book… but then disregards very basic things like character descriptions, etc… I think it’s pretty wrong to the point of being offensive.

I know I sound petty – but the Urgals who in the book are large strong creatures with long twisting horns protruding right above their ears.
What do I see in the “Urgals” in the movie? A bunch of goofy snarling men …no horns.

The elf Aria is specifically described as having raven-black hair in the book.
In the movie? A chick with red hair… and not even pointy ears! Not even pointy ears? Who portrays an elf with no pointy ears?

What dumb fool made this movie?
I dig the book – I couldn’t put it down, and I will begin reading the second one next week.
But I am in no hurry to see the movie.

Posted

[quote name='Theunknown101' post='1120204' date='Nov 14 2006, 06:53 PM']
Yeah, I don't really like the idea of a "good dragon." Weren't dragons the symbol of the Devil in the Middle Ages?
[/quote]

oh pish! what wasn't the symbol of the devil in the middle ages?

this movie had better be good and not just a special effects show off. i really liked both books and cannot wait for the movie and the third

Posted
:(

Movie did NOT follow the book.

That was the quickest movie ever!!!!

RUSH, RUSH, RUSH!!!!!!! :maddest:

Let's forget about Rowan's story, Aria's story, Murtaugh's story and just make one up!!!!! :pinch:

What did I expect?

However, a friend who didn't read the book thought it was cool. :wacko:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...