Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Eragon


Recommended Posts

Guest Rick777
Posted

[quote name='jmjtina' post='1144155' date='Dec 17 2006, 12:57 AM']

However, a friend who didn't read the book thought it was cool. :wacko:
[/quote]

From what I'm hearing from the people who actually read the book, I'm kinda glad I didn't. :sweat:

Posted

[quote name='jmjtina' post='1144155' date='Dec 17 2006, 01:57 AM']
:(
Movie did NOT follow the book...
What did I expect?
However, a friend who didn't read the book thought it was cool. :wacko:
[/quote]

Ya... that's what I was afraid of.
I guess I'll just rent it... maybe.

Posted

yeah it was not well done.


The book was not stellar ... but it was still fun. The movie ... I was pretty consistently conscious of the holes in the plot, and the places it varied from the book. The screenplay was not good.

littleflower+JMJ
Posted

To have jmjtina an unhappy camper means they messed up pretty bad. :hehe:

  • 2 weeks later...
sarcasmguy126
Posted

read the books, saw the movie

the movie was [i]good[/i] but not great...but maybe that's just cause i felt cheated that they cut so much out of the book.

i wish i KNEW when they were coming out with book #3

the only REAL problem i have with the series is that the witch/herbalist Angela is not portrayed as "bad"...therefore, apparently, since Eragon does not object to her telling his fortune, she must be "good"...and she uses the same sort of magic as the good guys ( a la Harry Potter?) while the movie only features a very brief fortune-telling scene, it still irritates me that, while the evil Shade is said to be possessed with demons, this witch (witches REALLY only use powers not of God, therefore evil powers from Satan or demons) is labeled as 'good" because she helps the good guys

though every fantasy story has to have some higher power, my preference for the Eragon series would be that good and evil be more clearly defined. in addition, is it a good thing to be able to read and control minds, or break into them, like the characters--good AND bad--often do? it begs to question where exactly this power they all use comes from--a "good" being or a bad one?

as for the movie itself, the dialogue was poor in places, the special effects were fantastic (although the Urgals look like men rather than monsters), and the cast was okay, except that I expected better from John Malkovich, but Jeremy Irons was pretty good. i guess it was just too short, and left enough out to cause book fans to say it was "okay". as for the whole series, the spiritual powers and religious stuff is rather questionable, even though it's more LOTR than Harry Potter in regards to definitions of good and evil

let me know what y'all think about this!

Posted

it's more STar wars......

killing off all the dragonriders, (like the jedi's) for power, then having the offspring of a traitor come and "balance" the good and evil,

More Star Wars knock-off than anything........IMHO

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...