Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

I'm haveing to read the Tao Te Ching for my freshmen comp class and then write a paper over it. It really makes a lot of sense, the Chiniese(sp?) had this stuff figured out 2500 years ago :blink: thats just awesome. So much of the Tao is simple comon sense stuff that is so basic that we just dont think about them. I find it cool how so many teachings from this book can be tied in with christian teachings.

:unsure: is it possable to be both a christian and a taoist? :unsure:

:sign: and :japanese:

KnightofChrist
Posted

No, because in taoism [u]every[/u] good thing is partly evil, every evil thing is partly good, Ying and Yang and all that. Which would mean God, Jesus Christ is partly evil... and that is well just dead wrong.

Dont be seduce by taoism, it is a false religion, sure it may have some elements of truth but it does not have the fullness of Truth which only the Catholic Church holds. And if you put your faith in Christ 100% and follow His Church you need nothing taoism has to offer.


Your Brother in Christ,
KoC

Posted

[quote name='heavenseeker' post='1123473' date='Nov 19 2006, 05:48 AM']
I'm haveing to read the Tao Te Ching for my freshmen comp class and then write a paper over it. It really makes a lot of sense, the Chiniese(sp?) had this stuff figured out 2500 years ago :blink: thats just awesome. So much of the Tao is simple comon sense stuff that is so basic that we just dont think about them. I find it cool how so many teachings from this book can be tied in with christian teachings.

:unsure: is it possable to be both a christian and a taoist? :unsure:

:sign: and :japanese:
[/quote]

It is not possible to be both Christian and Taoist. For a start Taoism as a whole is not contained within the Tao Te Ching there are many other books and beliefs that make up the Taoist faith. Moreover, even the Tao Te Ching itself has within it many points that simply cannot be harmonised with Catholic orthodoxy.

Before I reverted to Catholicism I read the Tao Te Ching thinking that it may lead me down the path to philosophical enlightenment (indirectly it did as dissatisfaction with Lao Zi's [i]answers[/i] led me ultimately to continue my journey which ended in returning to the Church). I agree with you that it is a captivating book and many points are merely prudent pieces of advice on the other hand you needn't journey far into the Tao Te Ching to find objectionable material if you are a Christian.

From the off there are problems. At best you can interpret chapter 1 of the Tao Te Ching as making [i]the ultimate[/i] impersonal at worst you can interpret it as preaching pantheism. Chapter 2 continues this trend when it seeks to relativise everything as a mere product of perception, good and evil, being and non being, all of this the book claims are mere labels imposed upon the nameless by the knowing mind. Again to Catholic faith and philosophy, which insists upon objective truths beyond subjective perceptions, this doctrine is impossible to accept.

I could continue but to be honest I dont particularly fancy going through the Tao Te Ching and commenting upon what a Catholic cannot accept in each chapter. If you want to read a work written in a similar vein as the Tao Te Ching without compromising your Christianity I [b]strongly/highly[/b] recommend [url="http://www.gutenberg.org/files/14328/14328-h/14328-h.htm"]The Consolation of Philosophy by Boethius[/url]. In my opinion, one of the greatest works of philosophy ever penned, and certainly one of the best books I've ever read. Moreover, it has the added bonus of being short, which is always a plus point methinks. :P: Plodding through pages and pages to find someone's point is not my cup of tea...

Posted

KnightofChrist, I think you're working off the popular view of Taoism, not what it actually teaches. The ideas of Yin and Yang are a good deal more complex than just "good" and "evil"--I think it may also be masculine and feminine energy or something like that.

I haven't read any of the work in question...most of my knowledge of Chinese philosophy comes from reading about it, not actually reading it. Is it by Confucius?

I'd say it's not possible to be a Christian and a Taoist, because Taoism is its own religion, but it is very possible and even praiseworthy to be a Christian and have a deep respect for Confucian/other Chinese philosophy. Confucianism might actually be the single best non-Christian system of morality I've ever heard of.

I, personally, have a great respect for the Japanese [i]bushido[/i], the samurai code of conduct. I don't accept every principle (it's a code of conduct, not a religious system), but there's a great deal of good stuff to be gleaned from it, including some very profound insights into what composes virtue.

KnightofChrist
Posted

[quote name='Jalazar' post='1123643' date='Nov 19 2006, 11:47 AM']
KnightofChrist, I think you're working off the popular view of Taoism, not what it actually teaches. The ideas of Yin and Yang are a good deal more complex than just "good" and "evil"--I think it may also be masculine and feminine energy or something like that.

I haven't read any of the work in question...most of my knowledge of Chinese philosophy comes from reading about it, not actually reading it. Is it by Confucius?

I'd say it's not possible to be a Christian and a Taoist, because Taoism is its own religion, but it is very possible and even praiseworthy to be a Christian and have a deep respect for Confucian/other Chinese philosophy. Confucianism might actually be the single best non-Christian system of morality I've ever heard of.

I, personally, have a great respect for the Japanese [i]bushido[/i], the samurai code of conduct. I don't accept every principle (it's a code of conduct, not a religious system), but there's a great deal of good stuff to be gleaned from it, including some very profound insights into what composes virtue.
[/quote]


[quote]source belief.net "What Taoist Believe"

T[u]he reality of good and evil is that [color="#FF0000"]all[/color] actions contain some aspect of each.[/u] This is represented in the t'ai chi, more commonly referred to as the yin-yang symbol. Any action would have some negative (yin) and some positive (yang) aspect to it. Taoists believe that nature is a continual balance between yin and yang, and that any attempt to go toward one extreme or the other will be ineffective, self-defeating, and short-lived. When people interfere with the natural balance by trying to impose their egoistic plans, they will not succeed; rather, the non-egoistic person allows nature to unfold, watching it ebb and flow from good to bad and back again.[/quote]

Having respect for is one thing, paticing parts of another gods principles is another and that is forbidden by God the Father, and the Church. Any other faith that has good points is a element of truth, however the Church has the fullness of truth. With this fullness of truth we do not need other faiths.

Posted

well i knew you couldn't be both if you take it to the full extreme and treat it as a religion. What i was trying to get at and should have made this more clear is to be Catholic and use taoism as a code of conduct along side of it.

as for the ying and yang goes, it is a simble of ballance in the world and has little to do with good and evil. But to play off of the view of it simbalizing good and evil, I don't believe that it means that everything that is good is also somewhat evil. I think what it means is that every good is counter ballenced by an evil, every light has a shadow, every birth has a death, so on and so forth.

Posted

There are a number of lines or even chapters in the Tao te Ching that made me think "oh, that's a nice way to put that." In other words, any truth there is already contained in Christ. But it's perfectly fine to think that someone else formulated it in an attractive or illuminating way. My only caution would be, do you know your Christian faith well enough to avoid being seduced by poetic falsehoods that are in the Tao?

It's ridiculously hard to even say what the Tao teaches, the translation is very problematic. Every translation is an interpretation, but in the case of Chinese poetry, even moreso. I'm told.

Groo the Wanderer
Posted (edited)

I prefer General Tso's Chicken myself....

you can have that and still be Catholic :drool:

Edited by Groo the Wanderer
Posted

Amen, beatty. I like bushido because it focuses on practical virtue and formulates its wisdom in a nicely masculine way that's very helpful to me. I'm not a solider or anything, but it's very cool to read a system of morality written for a warrior caste.

It helps that bushido isn't a theological or religious system--just a moral one.

Posted

[quote name='heavenseeker' post='1124034' date='Nov 20 2006, 05:17 AM']
well i knew you couldn't be both if you take it to the full extreme and treat it as a religion. What i was trying to get at and should have made this more clear is to be Catholic and use taoism as a code of conduct along side of it.

as for the ying and yang goes, it is a simble of ballance in the world and has little to do with good and evil. [u]But to play off of the view of it simbalizing good and evil, I don't believe that it means that everything that is good is also somewhat evil. I think what it means is that every good is counter ballenced by an evil, every light has a shadow, every birth has a death, so on and so forth.[/u]
[/quote]

But this is false. Not every good is counter balanced by evil because evil is not a balance of anything but actually a privation. Evil is what occurs when good is lacking, it is not a substance it is the absence of a substance. This is most perfectly epitomised in God who is essentially being, goodness and everything else and who has no opposite or equal.

My advice: Read Boethius from the link I gave you.

PS) Not all good contains some evil and vice versa. Good and evil are illusions of the knowing mind according to Taoists, illusions which evaporate when one attains to union with the great void through spiritual cultivation and meditation.

Posted

Myles Domini: I'm not saying you're wrong, or that Boethius isn't good, but just saying "Go read Boethius" isn't really answering the question. Man does not live on a single work of philosophy alone, after all. Just saying "all your philosophical needs reside in Boethius" seems kinda like saying "Why read all those fantasy novels? Just read The Lord of the Rings!" Most people who make a habit of reading read more than one book.

I'm sorry if that sounds harsh....

I have read the Consolation of Philosophy--I wrote a paper on it, in fact--but it didn't strike me as the definitive philosophical work which eliminates the need for any other.

Again, I'd say that heavenseeker should hold to what is good in the Tao Te Ching, use it to help him lead a Christian life, and reject what is bad. Spiritual questions can be discussed with a trusted priest or spiritual director. Reading Confucian philosophy doesn't strike me as any different from reading Aristotle, who was also a pagan.

Posted

[quote name='Jalazar' post='1124593' date='Nov 20 2006, 11:45 PM']
Myles Domini: I'm not saying you're wrong, or that Boethius isn't good, but just saying "Go read Boethius" isn't really answering the question. Man does not live on a single work of philosophy alone, after all. Just saying "all your philosophical needs reside in Boethius" seems kinda like saying "Why read all those fantasy novels? Just read The Lord of the Rings!" Most people who make a habit of reading read more than one book.

I'm sorry if that sounds harsh....

I have read the Consolation of Philosophy--I wrote a paper on it, in fact--but it didn't strike me as the definitive philosophical work which eliminates the need for any other.

Again, I'd say that heavenseeker should hold to what is good in the Tao Te Ching, use it to help him lead a Christian life, and reject what is bad. Spiritual questions can be discussed with a trusted priest or spiritual director. Reading Confucian philosophy doesn't strike me as any different from reading Aristotle, who was also a pagan.
[/quote]

I do not believe that I at any point suggested that [i]The Consolation[/i] was definitive. However, it seemed an apropriate place to guide Heavenseeker who seemed to be interested in the 'anecdotes' of the Tao Te Ching above and beyond the ontological conclusions contained therein. After all, having read [i]The Consolation[/i] yourself you will agree that Boethius expounds the vanity of worldly concerns and the need for self-discovery in a similar vein, no? What differs in their investigation is the conclusions Boethius and Lao Zi reach and it is certainly true that the former shares more consonance with Christianity than the latter. I hope he doesn't mind me saying so but Heavenseeker, from what he gleamed from the Tao Te Ching about the nature of good and evil, does not seem to have the formation in the faith to look at philosophy with the discerning eye you suggest. Accordingly, I suggested a safer option that (in my opinion) is every bit as powerful as the Tao Te Ching. Namely, Boethius.

Posted

[quote name='heavenseeker' post='1124034' date='Nov 19 2006, 11:17 PM']
well i knew you couldn't be both if you take it to the full extreme and treat it as a religion. What i was trying to get at and should have made this more clear is to be Catholic and use taoism as a code of conduct along side of it.
[/quote]

Where as I know nothing of the other religion, I can say that if you live by the laws of the church and if you live the Catholic faith then you should have no need or desire for any other code of conduct or guide lines. You should need nothing more than the faith you have and that alone.
That's not to say "Faith alone" as if believing will get you to Heaven, you must also have actions to go along, but I think you got my point.

Posted (edited)

[quote]is it possable to be both a christian and a taoist?[/quote]

For your own soul's sake, no you can't. Believe me there is deep spirtual stuff in taoism that will suprise you. Even if you play favorites with Catholicism and Taoism, there is still mentalities that could very possibly blind you spiritually.

Edited by GloriaIesusChristi
Posted

Here's a question for y'all: Do you think it would be wrong to read Aristotle and use his philosophy to help you in living a Catholic life?

If he's reading the Tao Te Ching for school and finds that it states a principle of natural law or morality particularly well, why shouldn't he let that inspire him?

I'd say "Christian and a Taoist" is going too far, and I'll admit I don't know much about Taosim in particular, but good things can be gleaned from pre-Christian philosophy. See Aristotle above. He had a great influence on St. Thomas Aquainas' thinking, just like Plato influence St. Augustine.

Caution is required, definitely, and he should be careful to always study Taoism in the light of the truth. But that doesn't mean everything in Taoism is false, or that it doesn't state some moral principles well.

Theologian in Training
Posted (edited)

This reminds me of the time a professor told me she believed it was possible to be a Catholic Buddhist, while I tried to explain to her the incompatibilities that clearly exist. It was only when I showed her writings from both John Paul II and the Dali Lama who agreed that though there are similarities, in the end, Catholicism and Buddhism cannot work side by side, there has to be a choice eventually as to which one you wish to practice. She told me Buddhists were unhappy with JPII for writing that.

While it is true that there is an element of truth in every religion, we, as Catholics believe that the fullness of truth exists within the Catholic Church. (I know some of you disagree with this, but, as we read in Lumen Gentium, the Church subsists in the Catholic Church).

I once had a spiritual director who taught all the major religions and showed the value and the greatness that each contained. However, he also showed how they fell short in one area or another, he then ended with teaching Catholicism to show how it made up where the others were lacking.

Don't get me wrong, I do believe that there is benefit in understanding and knowing other religions and faiths, but I think the inherent danger lies in trying to insert elements of those into the Catholic faith. A great example of this going way too far is former Dominican priest Matthew Fox who decided that the Mass had so much more potentia sol why not add elements of Wicca or Native American traditions, and while we are at it to spruce up the music with a little techno and then call it "Techno-Cosmic Mass."

See, the true danger is not in the studying, but it is in your original question: "Can someone be both a Christian and a Taoist?" because it seeks to make Catholicism a mix of everything rather than a religion on its own. I believe many New Agers used to do just that in order to draw from all backgrounds in order to find a Catholicism that worked for them.

So, I would echo everyone else in saying it is fine to read and study, but be careful in trying to adopt certain elements and trying to make them Catholic.

BTW, to those who admit that you don't know much about Taoism, I would recommend you learn more about it before endorsing it. It can be very hard to engage in discussion when all sides have not been understood.

Just my very long winded .02

God Bless

Fr. Brian

Edited by Theologian in Training
Posted (edited)

ok, i feel like you all got the wrong impression on that i meant being taoist in the sense as a religion but its not what i meant. Yeah i know that in some parts of the world thats how it is treated but its not the only way of doing it. I agree that not all parts of the Tao are true but that is a very small part from how i understand it. The way i read it about 90-95% of the Tao Te Ching ties in wit hour Catholic teachings.

I believe that it is possable to use non-christian teachings like that of the Tao to sorta help one understand their christian faith and help relate it to others(i know that makes no sense to you guys but it does to me). Like if you were talking to someone that avoides talking about the christian faith because they dont believe what we do then to be like "ok then try to look at it this way" and then point out how it has the same or very simular teaching to that of christianity. In a way like St. Augustine, and St. Thomas Aquainas were influenced.

Anyways I didn't think this would turn into a debate or have somany people think i meant being taoist in the way that it was interpritated.

Edited by heavenseeker
son_of_angels
Posted

I have read and studied the Tao Te Ching, and there are definitely some attractive points to it...

1. It acknowledges that there is a level of purely potential being which supports the existence of everything, which connects all things together.
It seems to me that this accords with Christianity and Platonism.

2. It focuses on the need for meditation and ascetism, for a withdrawal from the world, and for a contentment with simply being, something also present in Christian monasticism.

As for the whole evil/good thing....In a way, this can be reconciled with Catholic teaching. All moral acts are contingent upon a single moral principle, which, while it must be acknowledged in order to have logical continuity between moral norms, nonetheless cannot be deduced without an acknowledgment that God created man "and saw that it was good." Or, as Kant put it, "treat other people always as an end and never simply a means." So, what I'm saying is that there all moral principles are contingent upon one, decreed moral principle that has no origin other than the Will of God, and therefore all actions can be moral in one sense, and immoral in another. It would require the perfect union with the will of God to make an action absolutely moral, and even an evil action could be seen as moral, removed enough in effect from the action itself. Hence the relevance of evil is not to others, but primarily to oneself, where God lives and dwells and desires our wholeness and purity. For Christians, the grace of God takes even those actions which are not perfectly and moral and, united with "purity in spirit" makes us fit to "see God" through the merits of Christ.

So, can one be Catholic and Taoist? Well...no. Nor can one be Christian and Platonist or Aristotelian, if by that you also mean adopting all the practices and teachings of those teachers without modifying and discerning in them the Christian mindset, or you mean making the practice of Tao some sort of secondary religion. But one could learn to formulate the faith within a Taoist construct, just as within a Dionysian construct, and freely acknowledge the image of truth that's there. Lao-Tzu, after all, was primarily a philosopher, and not a religious figure.

Posted

[quote name='heavenseeker' post='1125575' date='Nov 21 2006, 09:49 PM']
ok, i feel like you all got the wrong impression on that i meant being taoist in the sense as a religion but its not what i meant. Yeah i know that in some parts of the world thats how it is treated but its not the only way of doing it. I agree that not all parts of the Tao are true but that is a very small part from how i understand it. The way i read it about 90-95% of the Tao Te Ching ties in wit hour Catholic teachings.

I believe that it is possable to use non-christian teachings like that of the Tao to sorta help one understand their christian faith and help relate it to others(i know that makes no sense to you guys but it does to me). Like if you were talking to someone that avoides talking about the christian faith because they dont believe what we do then to be like "ok then try to look at it this way" and then point out how it has the same or very simular teaching to that of christianity. In a way like St. Augustine, and St. Thomas Aquainas were influenced.

Anyways I didn't think this would turn into a debate or have somany people think i meant being taoist in the way that it was interpritated.
[/quote]


I get your point, and perhaps it could help you in explaining the faith more thoroughly to someone, but I still think that it's dangerous to do that. I mean, if you have a clear understanding of the faith, then you will be able to explain it and present it, hopefully the way God wants you to. You just have to pray about that one and trust God that He's speaking through you in a way. But still, living the Catholic faith should be enough for you, in every aspect. You shouldn't have to bring in another religion in the picture to help you out, God gave us all the means to convert and live this faith, with His help.
I just think it could be dangerous to use other religions. Satan can make another religion look tempting because it sounds like the Christian faith. When the Catholic faith is the only true church and we shouldn't be bringing other religions in.
I know you say your not using it as a real religion, but thats what it is. It's a religion and in my view you can't use it as 'guidelines' esp. with the Catholic faith.
Make any sense... at all?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...