Myles Domini Posted November 22, 2006 Posted November 22, 2006 [quote name='son_of_angels' post='1125640' date='Nov 22 2006, 04:37 AM'] I have read and studied the Tao Te Ching, and there are definitely some attractive points to it... 1. It acknowledges that there is a level of purely potential being which supports the existence of everything, which connects all things together. It seems to me that this accords with Christianity and Platonism. 2. It focuses on the need for meditation and ascetism, for a withdrawal from the world, and for a contentment with simply being, something also present in Christian monasticism. As for the whole evil/good thing....In a way, this can be reconciled with Catholic teaching. All moral acts are contingent upon a single moral principle, which, while it must be acknowledged in order to have logical continuity between moral norms, nonetheless cannot be deduced without an acknowledgment that God created man "and saw that it was good." Or, as Kant put it, "treat other people always as an end and never simply a means." So, what I'm saying is that there all moral principles are contingent upon one, decreed moral principle that has no origin other than the Will of God, and therefore all actions can be moral in one sense, and immoral in another. It would require the perfect union with the will of God to make an action absolutely moral, and even an evil action could be seen as moral, removed enough in effect from the action itself. Hence the relevance of evil is not to others, but primarily to oneself, where God lives and dwells and desires our wholeness and purity. For Christians, the grace of God takes even those actions which are not perfectly and moral and, united with "purity in spirit" makes us fit to "see God" through the merits of Christ. So, can one be Catholic and Taoist? Well...no. Nor can one be Christian and Platonist or Aristotelian, if by that you also mean adopting all the practices and teachings of those teachers without modifying and discerning in them the Christian mindset, or you mean making the practice of Tao some sort of secondary religion. But one could learn to formulate the faith within a Taoist construct, just as within a Dionysian construct, and freely acknowledge the image of truth that's there. Lao-Tzu, after all, was primarily a philosopher, and not a religious figure. [/quote] From what I glean from your post. I'm troubled by the word 'potential' in connection to the principle upon which all created being exists. I wont take issue with the stuff about contemplation and asceticism since you have no elaborated on the doctrine that follows the Taoist understanding of why one practices it. Confused...what do you mean when you say an evil action can be seen as moral?
suuran Posted November 22, 2006 Posted November 22, 2006 I guess I'm still wondering about the question I posed: Do all y'all who think it's wrong to draw wisdom from Taoist philosophy also think it was wrong for St. Thomas Aquinas and St. Augustine to be heavily influenced in their thinking by the pagan philosophers Plato and Aristotle? In one of Archbishop Fulton Sheen's books--[i]The World's First Love[/i], a book about Mary--he quotes passages from the Quran in relation to Mary which he thinks are particularly beautiful and capture truths about Mary well. They're not inspired Scripture, but he thought it useful to present what was good in the Muslim understanding of Mary. He also connected reverance for Mary to the Islamic veneration of Fatima, Mohammed's...daughter, I think? Archbishop Sheen also pointed out that Mary is apparently aware of this connection, given the name of the town where she appeared to three Portugese children . He isn't saying the Islam is completely congruent with Catholicism on Mary, but he thought it was fruitful to recognize what Islam gets right and appreciate those passages in the Quran which express Marian truths well. He actually believed that the way Muslims could possibly be converted is through Marian devotion, because they already have such a deep respect for Mary and the ideal of the perfect woman. Heck, the Archbishop even quotes the nihilist philosopher Nietsczhe (sp?) in [i]Three to Get Married[/i] (an awesome, awesome book on marriage and sexuality)--the quote is something like "You should never marry a woman you wouldn't want to talk to every day for the rest of your life." Nietsczhe's philosophy is deeply depraved--he was one of Hitler's inspirations--and Archbishop Sheen knows that perfectly well, and criticizes him often, but, in that particular case, he phrased an idea very well, and the Archbishop gave credit where credit was due and drew that fragment of wisdom from a philosophy who is usually dead wrong. Even a stopped clock is right twice a day, after all. I just don't see how it's wrong to acknowledge good where good exists. One should be firmly grounded in one's faith, of course, and know how to seperate the good from the bad--no one's denying that.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now