Resurrexi Posted November 29, 2006 Posted November 29, 2006 There are two really huge musical liturgical abuses going on at my indult: 1. The Sanctus is being stopped half way through and then the Benedictus is being sung after consecration when they are one prayer and are supposed to be sung as one song. 2. Not all the hymns within the Mass are not being sung in Latin (the processional and recessional hymns, though, I know may be sung in the venacular since they are not within the Mass Itslef). What should I do?
phatcatholic Posted November 29, 2006 Posted November 29, 2006 i'd imagine you'd do the same thing you would do w/ liturgical abuses in the NO mass. first, charitably discuss your concerns with your priest. if that does not work, go on up t he chain of command: priest --> bishop --> congregation for divine worship
Thy Geekdom Come Posted November 29, 2006 Posted November 29, 2006 Just confirms what an elderly priest once said, "there were just as many abuses in the Tridentine Mass...it's just that nobody knew they were there because they were in Latin.
bonoducchi Posted November 29, 2006 Posted November 29, 2006 (edited) [quote name='phatcatholic' post='1130312' date='Nov 28 2006, 09:10 PM'] i'd imagine you'd do the same thing you would do w/ liturgical abuses in the NO mass. first, charitably discuss your concerns with your priest. if that does not work, go on up t he chain of command: priest --> bishop --> congregation for divine worship [/quote] CDWDS doesn't really care about little irreularities like that. After your bishop, I would consult the USCCB comm. on liturgy, Bishop Trautman, chair. But really, he probably doesn't care either. Edited November 29, 2006 by VaticanIILiturgist
Thy Geekdom Come Posted November 29, 2006 Posted November 29, 2006 Good to know that people don't care. I really hope Fr. Brian is right about his bishop's latest appointment.
Resurrexi Posted November 29, 2006 Author Posted November 29, 2006 [quote]CDWDS doesn't really care about little irreularities like that. After your bishop, I would consult the USCCB comm. on liturgy, Bishop Trautman, chair. But really, he probably doesn't care either. [/quote] pessimest.
bonoducchi Posted November 29, 2006 Posted November 29, 2006 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1130543' date='Nov 29 2006, 12:52 AM'] pessimest. [/quote] Have you ever seen a bishop's, not to mention a cardinal's, schedule? They schedule time to breathe! They would first direct you to the office of prayer and worshio for your diocese. Check there first before you play liturgy police.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted November 29, 2006 Posted November 29, 2006 [quote name='VaticanIILiturgist' post='1130565' date='Nov 29 2006, 02:44 AM'] Have you ever seen a bishop's, not to mention a cardinal's, schedule? They schedule time to breathe! They would first direct you to the office of prayer and worshio for your diocese. Check there first before you play liturgy police. [/quote] The Church has a right to the Mass in its proper form. It is not playing "liturgy police" to report abuses.
Theoketos Posted November 29, 2006 Posted November 29, 2006 [quote name='VaticanIILiturgist' post='1130565' date='Nov 29 2006, 01:44 AM'] Have you ever seen a bishop's, not to mention a cardinal's, schedule? They schedule time to breathe! They would first direct you to the office of prayer and worshio for your diocese. Check there first before you play liturgy police. [/quote] People are often unreasonable, illogical, and self-centered; Forgive them anyway. If you are kind, People may Accuse you of Selfish, Ulterior motives; Be kind anyway. If you are successful, you will win some false friends and some true enemies; Succeed anyway. If you are honest and frank, people may cheat you; Be Honest and Frank anyway. What you spend years building, someone could destroy overnight; Build anyway. If you find serenity and happiness, they may be jealous; Be happy anyway. The good you do today, people will often forget tomorrow; Do good anyway. Give the world the best you have, and it may never be enough; Give the world the best you've got anyway. You see, in the final analysis, it is between you and God; It was never between you and them anyway.
bonoducchi Posted November 29, 2006 Posted November 29, 2006 [quote name='Raphael' post='1130722' date='Nov 29 2006, 08:37 AM'] The Church has a right to the Mass in its proper form. It is not playing "liturgy police" to report abuses. [/quote] Let me outline the typical conerversation between priest and bishop regarding these matters. P: Hello? B: Hi Joe, its Bishop Smith P: Good morning, Excellency. How's Jerry doing? B: Oh, just fine. Did you get that new boiler system approved? We're waiting to transfer $100,000 into your expense account. P: No, we're still wading through some red tape on that. SOmething about the electrical code, if I'm not mistaken. B: Well let us know. Listen, Joe, I got a letter from a parishoner and they're concerned that you're singing some hymns in English during that idult Mass you requested. Have they spoken with you? P: Yes, they have, Bishop. B: Look, I don't care if you sing them in Japanese, but you might want to try to iron this out with them. Tell them it's quite permissible in the 1962 to sing in English. If you need some help, give Rita a call in the Liturgy Office. You have the number right? P: Yeah, its somewhere on this desk.... B: Great. My love to everyone please. P: THank you, Bishop. Dont' work too hard! If there is a phone call. Most of the time, the Diocensan Office will call up first. Then the conversation is even shorter.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted November 29, 2006 Posted November 29, 2006 [quote name='VaticanIILiturgist' post='1130761' date='Nov 29 2006, 11:30 AM'] Let me outline the typical conerversation between priest and bishop regarding these matters. P: Hello? B: Hi Joe, its Bishop Smith P: Good morning, Excellency. How's Jerry doing? B: Oh, just fine. Did you get that new boiler system approved? We're waiting to transfer $100,000 into your expense account. P: No, we're still wading through some red tape on that. SOmething about the electrical code, if I'm not mistaken. B: Well let us know. Listen, Joe, I got a letter from a parishoner and they're concerned that you're singing some hymns in English during that idult Mass you requested. Have they spoken with you? P: Yes, they have, Bishop. B: Look, I don't care if you sing them in Japanese, but you might want to try to iron this out with them. Tell them it's quite permissible in the 1962 to sing in English. If you need some help, give Rita a call in the Liturgy Office. You have the number right? P: Yeah, its somewhere on this desk.... B: Great. My love to everyone please. P: THank you, Bishop. Dont' work too hard! If there is a phone call. Most of the time, the Diocensan Office will call up first. Then the conversation is even shorter. [/quote] Except that the original poster pointed out that he didn't have a serious problem with hymns in English, didn't he. Splitting the Sanctus, however, is most certainly not allowed. I've worked for a diocese, too. Bishops do care about liturgical abuses...granted, they're usually busy, but the Church defends the right of Christians to receive the liturgy in its proper form. No matter how busy (or negligent) a bishop may be in his duties, that is still the right of the Christian and it is still wrong and objectively sinful to abuse the Mass. Don't try to say that a bishop's schedule nullifies the rights of Christians. That's false.
Aloysius Posted November 29, 2006 Posted November 29, 2006 as a "Vatican-II Liturgist", I assume you're familiar with Redemptioris Sacramentum and how it says the laity have the right to a mass according to the rubrics and a right and duty to report any and all deviations from the rubrics to the proper authorities? of course, as a Vatican-II Liturgist you probably aren't competant to be a Tridentine Liturgist; and since the indult is governed by the liturgical laws in place in 1962 and Ecclesia Dei Afflicta forbid any mixing of the rites, you'd really have to have the attitude of a Tridentine Liturgist to determine what they should be doing at an indult mass, huh?
shortnun Posted November 29, 2006 Posted November 29, 2006 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1130791' date='Nov 29 2006, 11:21 AM'] as a "Vatican-II Liturgist", I assume you're familiar with Redemptioris Sacramentum and how it says the laity have the right to a mass according to the rubrics and a right and duty to report any and all deviations from the rubrics to the proper authorities? [/quote] To the proper authorities... yes, but not to triangulate and go over and above someone to the highest perceived authority to solve a problem (exceptions excluded of course). I don't need to be a Tridentine liturgist to know that in StThomasMore's original example, he would want to politely speak/write to the director of liturgy and/or pastor before bringing the issue to anyone else.
Aloysius Posted November 29, 2006 Posted November 29, 2006 that's true. it just seemed to me VIIL was trying to apply a post-VII attitude towards the Tridentine Liturgy. the Tridentine Liturgy is much more highly codified and there is far less room for differentiation, and that's the way it should remain according to the indult given for it. perhaps I perceived an attitude that was not there... but no one should ever not bring abuses (which are not being dealt with by the priest after you talk with him) to bishops on the basis that 'they won't care'... maybe it's true, but Redemptioris Sacramentum says we are obligated to bring them to their attention anyway, and if they don't care we are obligated to bring them to the atteniton of the Papal Nuncio.
Resurrexi Posted November 29, 2006 Author Posted November 29, 2006 (edited) [quote]B: Look, I don't care if you sing them in Japanese, but you might want to try to iron this out with them. [b]Tell them it's quite permissible in the 1962 to sing in English[/b]. If you need some help, give Rita a call in the Liturgy Office. You have the number right?[/quote] But's it's not for the Offeratory and Communion hymns... Edited November 29, 2006 by StThomasMore
Cam42 Posted November 30, 2006 Posted November 30, 2006 [quote name='VaticanIILiturgist' post='1130504' date='Nov 29 2006, 12:22 AM'] CDWDS doesn't really care about little irreularities like that. After your bishop, I would consult the USCCB comm. on liturgy, Bishop Trautman, chair. But really, he probably doesn't care either. [/quote] Quantifiably untrue. And I am sure that Bishop Trautman does care.
Cam42 Posted November 30, 2006 Posted November 30, 2006 [quote name='VaticanIILiturgist' post='1130565' date='Nov 29 2006, 01:44 AM'] Have you ever seen a bishop's, not to mention a cardinal's, schedule? They schedule time to breathe! They would first direct you to the office of prayer and worshio for your diocese. Check there first before you play liturgy police. [/quote] Yes, I have. And this is part of their job, so they allow for these questions. And secondly, I will type this slowly: [quote name='Redemptoris Sacramentum #176']The diocesan Bishop, “since he is the principal dispenser of the mysteries of God, is to strive constantly so that Christ’s faithful entrusted to his care may grow in grace through the celebration of the sacraments, and that they may know and live the Paschal Mystery”. It is his responsibility, “within the limits of his competence, to issue norms on liturgical matters by which all are bound”.[/quote] [quote name='Redemptoris Sacramentum #177']“Since he must safeguard the unity of the universal Church, the Bishop is bound to promote the discipline common to the entire Church and therefore to insist upon the observance of all ecclesiastical laws. He is to be watchful lest abuses encroach upon ecclesiastical discipline, especially as regards the ministry of the Word, the celebration of the Sacraments and sacramentals, the worship of God and the veneration of the Saints”.[/quote] [quote name='Redemptoris Sacramentum #178']Hence whenever a local Ordinary or the Ordinary of a religious Institute or of a Society of apostolic life receives at least a plausible notice of a delict or abuse concerning the Most Holy Eucharist, let him carefully investigate, either personally or by means of another worthy cleric, concerning the facts and the circumstances as well as the imputability.[/quote] [quote name='Redemptoris Sacramentum #179'] Delicts against the faith as well as graviora delicta committed in the celebration of the Eucharist and the other Sacraments are to be referred without delay to the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, which “examines [them] and, if necessary, proceeds to the declaration or imposition of canonical sanctions according to the norm of common or proper law”.[/quote] [quote name='Redemptoris Sacramentum #184']Any Catholic, whether Priest or Deacon or lay member of Christ’s faithful, has the right to lodge a complaint regarding a liturgical abuse to the diocesan Bishop or the competent Ordinary equivalent to him in law, or to the Apostolic See on account of the primacy of the Roman Pontiff. It is fitting, however, insofar as possible, that the report or complaint be submitted first to the diocesan Bishop. This is naturally to be done in truth and charity.[/quote] So, we can see that the bishop is to strive constantly so that Christ’s faithful entrusted to his care may grow in grace through the celebration of the sacraments, and that they may know and live the Paschal Mystery”. It is his responsibility, “within the limits of his competence, to issue norms on liturgical matters by which all are bound." Also, the Ordinary must carefully investigate, either personally or by means of another worthy cleric, concerning the facts and the circumstances as well as the imputability. And finally, the faithful have the right to lodge a complaint regarding a liturgical abuse to the diocesan Bishop or the competent Ordinary equivalent to him in law, or to the Apostolic See on account of the primacy of the Roman Pontiff. It is fitting, however, insofar as possible, that the report or complaint be submitted first to the diocesan Bishop. This is naturally to be done in truth and charity. [quote name='Aloysius' post='1130791' date='Nov 29 2006, 11:21 AM'] as a "Vatican-II Liturgist", I assume you're familiar with Redemptioris Sacramentum and how it says the laity have the right to a mass according to the rubrics and a right and duty to report any and all deviations from the rubrics to the proper authorities? of course, as a Vatican-II Liturgist you probably aren't competant to be a Tridentine Liturgist; and since the indult is governed by the liturgical laws in place in 1962 and Ecclesia Dei Afflicta forbid any mixing of the rites, you'd really have to have the attitude of a Tridentine Liturgist to determine what they should be doing at an indult mass, huh? [/quote] Good thing that I am here then Al, as I am trained extensively in both; with an equal love of both.
Norseman82 Posted November 30, 2006 Posted November 30, 2006 In my experience, it's not that the bishop doesn't care, it's getting past the secretary. Don't underestimate the power of "gatekeepers".
homeschoolmom Posted November 30, 2006 Posted November 30, 2006 [quote name='Theoketos' post='1130758' date='Nov 29 2006, 10:25 AM'] People are often unreasonable, illogical, and self-centered; Forgive them anyway. If you are kind, People may Accuse you of Selfish, Ulterior motives; Be kind anyway. If you are successful, you will win some false friends and some true enemies; Succeed anyway. If you are honest and frank, people may cheat you; Be Honest and Frank anyway. What you spend years building, someone could destroy overnight; Build anyway. If you find serenity and happiness, they may be jealous; Be happy anyway. The good you do today, people will often forget tomorrow; Do good anyway. Give the world the best you have, and it may never be enough; Give the world the best you've got anyway. You see, in the final analysis, it is between you and God; It was never between you and them anyway. [/quote] Mother Teresa... I love this quote.
photosynthesis Posted November 30, 2006 Posted November 30, 2006 i go to the indult every week, and I've heard them split the Sanctus within the high mass. But the benedictus was usually said in another part of the eucharistic prayer. Apparently lots of composers have composed seperate sections of the sanctus. never heard english hymns during the mass, though.. although I wasn't aware that wasn't allowed.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now