Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Liturgical Abuse At My Indult


Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='Raphael' post='1130722' date='Nov 29 2006, 08:37 AM']
The Church has a right to the Mass in its proper form. It is not playing "liturgy police" to report abuses.
[/quote]

Thank you and rock on

I have a friend who studies the liturgy in depth, and it gets annoying to hear dissaproving comments from others when they think he is being too meticulous for bringing up problems and abuses...

Posted

[quote name='Didymus' post='1132285' date='Nov 30 2006, 06:18 PM']
Thank you and rock on

I have a friend who studies the liturgy in depth, and it gets annoying to hear dissaproving comments from others when they think he is being too meticulous for bringing up problems and abuses...
[/quote]

Liturgy is about the work and prayer of the people - not rubrics. Anyone can read. A really good liturgist cares about how the faithful prayer through the liturgical action, not about crossing t's and dotting i's just becuase they're there.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='VaticanIILiturgist' post='1132633' date='Dec 1 2006, 12:50 AM']
Liturgy is about the work and prayer of the people - not rubrics. Anyone can read. A really good liturgist cares about how the faithful prayer through the liturgical action, not about crossing t's and dotting i's just becuase they're there.
[/quote]
Liturgy is about the work and prayer of the people in communion with God. That means that their work and prayer need to follow the way set out by God. God has inspired His Church and obliged the faithful to follow her lead. Therefore, the good liturgist must do everything in his power to resist the tendency to ignore the rubrics and trust that God and His Church know what they are doing. The rubrics are there because hundreds of good liturgists sat down to consider "how the faithful prayer [sic] through the liturgical action." Do you consider yourself a better liturgist than the Magisterium or its auspices?

Posted

[quote name='Raphael' post='1132855' date='Dec 1 2006, 10:02 AM']
Liturgy is about the work and prayer of the people in communion with God. That means that their work and prayer need to follow the way set out by God. God has inspired His Church and obliged the faithful to follow her lead. Therefore, the good liturgist must do everything in his power to resist the tendency to ignore the rubrics and trust that God and His Church know what they are doing. The rubrics are there because hundreds of good liturgists sat down to consider "how the faithful prayer [sic] through the liturgical action." Do you consider yourself a better liturgist than the Magisterium or its auspices?
[/quote]
First, don't act like an editor with {sic} - it an internet posting, not a doctoral thesis.

Secondly, priests and bishops making decisions about the capacity and dispositions of less educated and quite differently disposed people 50 years in the furture who live in a radiacally different culture does not, in my estimation, make a lot of sense. I don't profess great knowledge of the Missal of 1962 because most bishops at Vatican II hoped it would not be celebrated with great frequency and my diocese does not celebrate it with any appreciable frequency. The sensibilities of those attending the unfortunate indult that does occur (which does seperate the celebrants from the vast majoirty of praying Catholics worldwide) does speak to the isolationist tendency of some Catholics and further contributes to the crisis of identity that is growing in the American Catholic culture. Why is the Missal of 1970 not adequate enough for prayer that special permission has to be gained to pray a rite that was changed?

I know the 1962 Missal is still permissible to celebrate, but one must ask why is it needed in the first place? If you question the validity of the 1970 Missal, then we must consider your own fidelity to Rome. If you simply prefer the old rite, then one must ask why? If Rome drew up an Order of Mass, regardless of your own feelings as to the piety and reverence of it, you must accept it as valid. Isn't it more important to worship as an entire body than to fraction off into small groups using different orders of worship?

If the Latin language is your concern, turn to page 1055 in your Sacramentary. It's all there, including all four main EPs.

And, yes, the Church gets lost in rubrics and rules, quite often forgetting its people. In that regard, I do consider myself a liturgist with a broader view than rules, regs and kissing Rome's feet.

Posted

most bishops AT the council hoped it would be reformed slightly with Latin being retained. the synod of bishops rejected the new order of the mass in 1968; Paul VI promulgated it anyway. this decision was certainly not made with any collegiality.

most bishops nowadays don't want it widely celebrated... well, except the bishop of Rome (JPII and BXVI) who asked for a wide and generous application of the Eclessia Dei Afflicta indult.

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1132935' date='Dec 1 2006, 12:32 PM']
most bishops AT the council hoped it would be reformed slightly with Latin being retained. the synod of bishops rejected the new order of the mass in 1968; Paul VI promulgated it anyway. this decision was certainly not made with any collegiality.

most bishops nowadays don't want it widely celebrated... well, except the bishop of Rome (JPII and BXVI) who asked for a wide and generous application of the Eclessia Dei Afflicta indult.
[/quote]

Why should it be celebrated widely? What value does it have over the current Ordo Missae?

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1132935' date='Dec 1 2006, 12:32 PM']
most bishops AT the council hoped it would be reformed slightly with Latin being retained. the synod of bishops rejected the new order of the mass in 1968; Paul VI promulgated it anyway. this decision was certainly not made with any collegiality.

most bishops nowadays don't want it widely celebrated... well, except the bishop of Rome (JPII and BXVI) who asked for a wide and generous application of the Eclessia Dei Afflicta indult.
[/quote]

Quite frankly, most liturgists and clergy that aren't nuts view Ecclesia Dei Afflicta as an attack on the validy and reformative direction of Vatican II. It says "...moreover, respect must everywhere be shown for the feelings of all those who are attached to the Latin liturgical tradition, by a wide and generous application of the directives already issued some time ago by the Apostolic See for the use of the Roman Missal according to the typical edition of 1962." What if I'm attached to improvsing the EP like in the first 500 years of Chritianity? Should my feelings be respected? What's needed is united front promoting the validity of the Missal of Paul VI.

J2P2 and Benedict (who I actually like as a theorist with repsect to liturgy) have been making Vatican II appear less and less valid by granting indults left and right. What is to be gained by doing that? If a new order of Mass is promulgated, why are we clinging to an older rite? It decreases Catholicity - not increases it.

Posted

you've never shown any citation of the Eucharistic Prayer being improvised in the first 500 years. anything which said that would be merely speculating at the lack of liturgical texts, which is to be expected from the time period and does not indicate that the Eucharist Prayer was "improvised"

every indication is that from at least the 6th century the liturgy was in the same form as it is now; and there is no indication that it was any different in the other 6 centuries.

in any event: the Second Vatican Council did not call for a complete re-writing of the missal. its interpretation after the council in forming the new ordo missae may not have been correct.

anyway, the past two cheif liturgists of the Church were also some of the principal forces of Vatican II and know much better what it indtend.

there has never been any precedent set for the abrogation of a rite which is more than 200 years old. and, in fact, there is no precedent now. that's what Ecclesia Dei's indult recognized; even if there is now a new missa normativa, the ancient heritage of the Church cannot merely be thrown out the window; and yes, the Vatican is saying that liturgists who interpretted the reforms of the Second Vatican Council as meaning that are absolutely wrong.

even the Tridentine Codification of the mass caused a plurality of rites by retaining all the rites of over 200 years use. the Novus Ordo Missae, promulgated by Paul VI against the wishes of the Synod of Bishops who were in charge of implementing Vatican II, then really ought to allow for a plurality of rites

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1133247' date='Dec 1 2006, 06:04 PM']
every indication is that from at least the 6th century the liturgy was in the same form as it is now; and there is no indication that it was any different in the other 6 centuries.
[/quote]
What part of the liturgy is the same form now as it was in/since the 6th c? :blink:

I have three scholarly books on my shelf that would argue otherwise. And I'm sure a quick library search could turn back some books [i]with imprimaturs[/i] to support my books. Perhaps I'm misunderstanding you.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1133247' date='Dec 1 2006, 06:04 PM']
you've never shown any citation of the Eucharistic Prayer being improvised in the first 500 years. anything which said that would be merely speculating at the lack of liturgical texts, which is to be expected from the time period and does not indicate that the Eucharist Prayer was "improvised"

every indication is that from at least the 6th century the liturgy was in the same form as it is now; and there is no indication that it was any different in the other 6 centuries.

in any event: the Second Vatican Council did not call for a complete re-writing of the missal. its interpretation after the council in forming the new ordo missae may not have been correct.

anyway, the past two cheif liturgists of the Church were also some of the principal forces of Vatican II and know much better what it indtend.

there has never been any precedent set for the abrogation of a rite which is more than 200 years old. and, in fact, there is no precedent now. that's what Ecclesia Dei's indult recognized; even if there is now a new missa normativa, the ancient heritage of the Church cannot merely be thrown out the window; and yes, the Vatican is saying that liturgists who interpretted the reforms of the Second Vatican Council as meaning that are absolutely wrong.

even the Tridentine Codification of the mass caused a plurality of rites by retaining all the rites of over 200 years use. the Novus Ordo Missae, promulgated by Paul VI against the wishes of the Synod of Bishops who were in charge of implementing Vatican II, then really ought to allow for a plurality of rites
[/quote]

Could you try answering my questions about WHY the Missal of 1962 should even be celebrated?

Eucharistic prayer 1 was codified between 500 and 600 AD. It was a assemblage of improvised prayers from the past several hundred years, which expains why from a literary point of view it shows a certain degree of disunity. (The Eucharistic Prayers of the Roman Rite, Enrico Mazza, Pueblo Press). Before that, they were improvised (History of the Mass, Robert Cabie, Pastoral Press). Where do you think the prayers that comprise the EPI came from in the first place? Did they lock some staff flunkies in a room and say "Write a prayer - go! We'll be back in a day to see what you have so far. There's pizza in the fridge."

So, in your theory that a new order of mass may not have been called for by V2, Prot. n. 166/70 is simply a collosal mistake and we shoudl still be celebrating the Tridentine Rite? Am I understanding you correctly? Is this some sort of ecclesiastical conspiracy theory?

Edited by VaticanIILiturgist
Posted

because it is a liturgy of ancient tradition of more than 200 years (at least 1000 years, as a matter of fact), it is ritually superior (the rituals represent our faith in a much deeper way than the gutted modern liturgy), more doctrinally sound, and more in continuity with the organic growth of the liturgy through the years.

we are not a Church of innovations, they are destructive to culture and faith. a liturgy full of modern innovations with only vague reconstructions of theoretical primitive liturgies with only one written source which is not very reliable of Hippolytus vaguely describing a liturgy is a problem.

the first recorded liturgies are much more similar to the Tridentine Liturgy than to our current one. can you point me to a liturgy which was recorded which is more similar to the novus ordo? and liturgies were only recorded after being in place for centuries in that way-- passed by oral tradition in the process of educating and ordaining priests and not 'improvised'.

there is no reason not to pray the liturgy of 1962, the last organic developement in the ancient rite before a complete re-write-up of a new rite.

[quote name='VaticanIILiturgist' post='1133358' date='Dec 1 2006, 08:26 PM']
Could you try answering my questions about WHY the Missal of 1962 should even be celebrated?

Eucharistic prayer 1 was codified between 500 and 600 AD. It was a assemblage of improvised prayers from the past several hundred years, which expains why from a literary point of view it shows a certain degree of disunity. (The Eucharistic Prayers of the Roman Rite, Enrico Mazza, Pueblo Press). Before that, they were improvised (History of the
Mass, Robert Cabie, Pastoral Press).

So, in your theory that a new order of mass may not have been called for by V2, Prot. n. 166/70 is simply a collosal mistake and we shoudl still be celebrating the Tridentine Rite? Am I understanding you correctly? Is this some sort of ecclesiastical conspiracy theory?
[/quote]
no, I'm ultra-montane all the way-- the Pope is the cheif liturgist and is perfectly within his powers to reform the liturgy. I hope some day a pope will come along who will restore much of what was gutted from the Roman Rite, but until then it is the missa normativa. In the same way, the cheif liturgist has given permission and asked for widespread application of that permission for the missal of 1962, in the same way Trent allowed for rites over 200 years old to remain said. I do think it was a mistake to propose an entirely new mass instead of following an organic development in the existing rite. it has given us an extreme disconnect from the rest of the sui juris churches with their traditional liturgies in place, from the orthodox church, and from our own church and our own rite, our own saints and our own history

what ancient document says "improvise the Eucharistic prayer"? the ancient Church was a Church of traditions, passed orally mostly. this is clearly a codification of a prayer already in widespread use for centuries, otherwise it would not have been so easily accepted. there was no real change, just a codification of an already in-place practice.

Posted

[quote]Eucharistic prayer 1 was codified between 500 and 600 AD. It was a assemblage of improvised prayers from the past several hundred years, which expains why from a literary point of view it shows a certain degree of disunity.[/quote]

Show me examples of disunity in the Sacred Roman Canon. I'd like to see your point of view on the matter, atthough it is probably incorrect.

Posted

[quote name='StThomasMore' post='1133462' date='Dec 2 2006, 12:08 AM']
Show me examples of disunity in the Sacred Roman Canon. I'd like to see your point of view on the matter, atthough it is probably incorrect.
[/quote]

There is none.

Posted

[quote name='VaticanIILiturgist' post='1132633' date='Nov 30 2006, 11:50 PM']
Liturgy is about the work and prayer of the people - not rubrics. Anyone can read. A really good liturgist cares about how the faithful prayer through the liturgical action, not about crossing t's and dotting i's just becuase they're there.
[/quote]

If a "really good liturgist" cares about how the faithful pray through the liturgical action, then it is about crossing the t's and dotting the i's. The liturgical action is about participatio actuosa. You are making the classic error that most "liturgists" make.

The error is that there is a separation between participatio actuosa and particiaptio activa. One cannot exist without the other. Participatio actuosa is the full, conscious, and active participation of the faithful. That understanding of the liturgy includes knowing and accepting of the rubrics as well.

One of the glories of the Tridentine Mass is that it has prescribed actions for almost everything. The intention of the Council Fathers was that Sacrosanctum Concilium would streamline those moves. The Church never intended the rubrical actions to be completely eliminated, in favor of the new, but rather streamlined from the orginal. The Ordo Missae was intended to be a revision of the previous rite, not a wholesale abandonment of it. This has been made very clear since 1984, starting with the document [url="http://www.catholicliturgy.com/index.cfm/FuseAction/DocumentContents/Index/2/SubIndex/11/DocumentIndex/395"]Quattuor Abhinc Annos[/url]. I have also had the privilege of being able to read the peritti notes of Msgr. Rudolph Bandas.

However, the "liturgists" got in the way and rewrote the Mass in their own image, after the Council. Does this mean that I don't accept the Ordo Missae? Hardly, but I do see the errors of the "liturgists."

Here are some notable changes, listed by Msgr. Bandas in 1968 of which are not helpful to the liturigical life of the Church and nowhere does the Council say these things should be adopted (certain issues have been dealt with and corrected, but all have happened at some point or another):

[quote name='Msgr. Bandas' notes from the first session of Vatican Council II']That infant baptism is to be abolished;

That children's confessions are to be omitted before first Holy Communion and postponed several years beyond the age of reason;

That general confessions and general absolutions are to replace private individual confessions; Vatican II urges the frequent reception of the sacrament, points out the great value of the Sacrament of Penance for the religious life, urges priests to make themselves easily available for confessions, and orders pastors to call in outside priests who can hear confessions in the language of the people;

That preaching should be concerned exclusively with social problems and the brotherhood of man; on the contrary, bishops and priests should "point out the divinely revealed way to give glory to God and thereby to attain to eternal happiness;"

That main altars are to be dismantled or removed; the pastor is only the administrator, not the owner, of parish property;

That the altar railing and pulpit are to be removed from churches;

That statues and the Stations of the Cross are to be eliminated;

That daily Mass is to be abolished and replaced by a bible service;

That a plain table is to replace the main altar;

That the laity may recite the whole canon of the Mass with the celebrant; this was forbidden by the commission on the liturgy in April 1968;

That provisional, temporary, movable altars, facing the people, are to be set up in front of the main altar; on January 25, 1966, the commission on the liturgy ordered these removed;

That the Latin Mass, high Mass, and choirs have been abolished;

That the laity may crowd around the altar inside the sanctuary; the directions for the participated Mass presupposed that the lay people are in the body of the church;

That the priest may say Mass without the prescribed vestments, or without candles and a crucifix;

That selections from secular writing may be read at Mass;

That the celebrant is to leave the altar after the "Lamb of God" and shake hands with the people;

That women may assist at the divine services without a head covering;

That all Canon Law has been temporarily suspended;

That a priest may leave out or change or add any word to tell Mass prayers;

That a priest may smile while saying Mass and consecrating; that communicants may smile at the priest before receiving Holy Communion; that the celebrant may add the first name of the communicant to the communion formula;

That we must receive Holy Communion standing; we may receive kneeling or standing, but if we receive standing we must come in procession and make a "reverence" to the Blessed Sacrament before receiving the Eucharist;

That the celebrant may place the Sacred Host in the hands of the communicant who then communicates himself;

That Holy Communion may be given to non-Catholics;

That the celebrant may give the chalice at Holy Communion to whomever he wishes;

That in the Latin rite the celebrant may consecrate a whole loaf of bread or a bun;

That you may have hootenanny and rock rebellion Masses;

That priests and ministers may exchange places during divine services;

That we should stop making converts;

That devotion to Our Lady should be downgraded and de-emphasized;

That the Mass is a mere "meal;"

That Holy Communion is merely "holy Food;"

That Sisters and women may act as Rectors;

That private devotions, especially the Rosary, Holy Hour, Benediction and 40 Hours Devotion are no longer to be fostered;

That at the end of Mass the priest may say: "The Mass goes on forever; carry it with you into the world."[/quote]

A "spirit of the council" is genuine when it flows organically from, or is intrinsically connected with, a council decree or an official interpretation of the decree by the Holy See. A "spirit of the council" is spurious when it is opposed to a council decree or in no wise derives from it or is based upon it.

You go on about the "spirit of the liturgy," but the reality is that this "spirit of the liturgy" is found in the law of the liturgy. The law of the liturgy (or the rubrics) are very important. They provide a structure and a bridge to 2000 years of SACRED TRADITION. To simply consider that as second fiddle to the "inspriation" of the Mass is to separate the participatio activa from the pariticipatio actuosa and that nullifies both of them and it causes disunity.

son_of_angels
Posted

As far as my understanding goes, the use of English hymns AFTER the proper is sung in Latin was a permission from the Holy See by Pius XII, provided that it was allowed by the local ordinary. As such permissions have been granted, it would not seem contrary for such hymns to be sung.

Secondly, the splitting of the Sanctus is permitted if the piece is a long setting, so that the priest may continue with the consecration. At least if I remember correctly.

Posted

[quote]As far as my understanding goes, the use of English hymns AFTER the proper is sung in Latin was a permission from the Holy See by Pius XII, provided that it was allowed by the local ordinary. As such permissions have been granted, it would not seem contrary for such hymns to be sung.[/quote]

That may be true, I heard the opposite though... I might want to look into it more

[quote]Secondly, the splitting of the Sanctus is permitted if the piece is a long setting, so that the priest may continue with the consecration. At least if I remember correctly.[/quote]

[quote name='The Catholic Encyclopedia article "Sanctus"']At high Mass as soon as the celebrant has sung the last word of the Preface (dicentes) the choir begins the Sanctus, continuing his phrase. They should sing it straight through, including the Benedictus. The custom of waiting till after the Elevation and then adding the Benedictus, once common, is now abolished by the rubric ("De ritibus servandis in cantu missæ, VII) of the Vatican Gradual. It was a dramatic effect that never had any warrant. Sanctus and Benedictus are one text.[/quote]

[quote]That infant baptism is to be abolished;

That children's confessions are to be omitted before first Holy Communion and postponed several years beyond the age of reason;

That general confessions and general absolutions are to replace private individual confessions; Vatican II urges the frequent reception of the sacrament, points out the great value of the Sacrament of Penance for the religious life, urges priests to make themselves easily available for confessions, and orders pastors to call in outside priests who can hear confessions in the language of the people;

That preaching should be concerned exclusively with social problems and the brotherhood of man; on the contrary, bishops and priests should "point out the divinely revealed way to give glory to God and thereby to attain to eternal happiness;"

That main altars are to be dismantled or removed; the pastor is only the administrator, not the owner, of parish property;

That the altar railing and pulpit are to be removed from churches;

That statues and the Stations of the Cross are to be eliminated;

That daily Mass is to be abolished and replaced by a bible service;

That a plain table is to replace the main altar;

That the laity may recite the whole canon of the Mass with the celebrant; this was forbidden by the commission on the liturgy in April 1968;

That provisional, temporary, movable altars, facing the people, are to be set up in front of the main altar; on January 25, 1966, the commission on the liturgy ordered these removed;

That the Latin Mass, high Mass, and choirs have been abolished;

That the laity may crowd around the altar inside the sanctuary; the directions for the participated Mass presupposed that the lay people are in the body of the church;

That the priest may say Mass without the prescribed vestments, or without candles and a crucifix;

That selections from secular writing may be read at Mass;

That the celebrant is to leave the altar after the "Lamb of God" and shake hands with the people;

That women may assist at the divine services without a head covering;

That all Canon Law has been temporarily suspended;

That a priest may leave out or change or add any word to tell Mass prayers;

That a priest may smile while saying Mass and consecrating; that communicants may smile at the priest before receiving Holy Communion; that the celebrant may add the first name of the communicant to the communion formula;

That we must receive Holy Communion standing; we may receive kneeling or standing, but if we receive standing we must come in procession and make a "reverence" to the Blessed Sacrament before receiving the Eucharist;

That the celebrant may place the Sacred Host in the hands of the communicant who then communicates himself;

That Holy Communion may be given to non-Catholics;

That the celebrant may give the chalice at Holy Communion to whomever he wishes;

That in the Latin rite the celebrant may consecrate a whole loaf of bread or a bun;

That you may have hootenanny and rock rebellion Masses;

That priests and ministers may exchange places during divine services;

That we should stop making converts;

That devotion to Our Lady should be downgraded and de-emphasized;

That the Mass is a mere "meal;"

That Holy Communion is merely "holy Food;"

That Sisters and women may act as Rectors;

That private devotions, especially the Rosary, Holy Hour, Benediction and 40 Hours Devotion are no longer to be fostered;

That at the end of Mass the priest may say: "The Mass goes on forever; carry it with you into the world."[/quote]

Anathema! Anathema! Anathema!

Posted

[quote name='VaticanIILiturgist' post='1132890' date='Dec 1 2006, 08:59 AM']
The sensibilities of those attending the unfortunate indult that does occur (which does seperate the celebrants from the vast majoirty of praying Catholics worldwide) does speak to the isolationist tendency of some Catholics and further contributes to the crisis of identity that is growing in the American Catholic culture.
[/quote]


wow what a terrible sentiment for a Church filled with lots of different rites other than the Latin one. why is it such a crime for there to be a Tridentine rite, the same way there is a Copitc, Melkite, Bzyantine, etc? :idontknow:


there is beatiful diversity within the unity of Catholic worship and ignorant comment such as this speak negatively of all those not in the Latin rite, which ps. isn't the only one. <_<

[quote name='shortnun' post='1133351' date='Dec 1 2006, 05:20 PM']
What part of the liturgy is the same form now as it was in/since the 6th c? :blink:

I have three scholarly books on my shelf that would argue otherwise. And I'm sure a quick library search could turn back some books [i]with imprimaturs[/i] to support my books. Perhaps I'm misunderstanding you.
[/quote]


check the mass of st. justin martyr - much of the mass is nearly identical, in structure and form, if not in the actual spoken parts.

that dates from the 2nd c.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...