the Apologist Posted December 12, 2006 Posted December 12, 2006 Gibson's new Apocalyto was great! Go and see it but be ready because it is pretty graphic... it reveals the true history of the what was going on in the Aztec empire before Hernan Cortes arrived there and why the Spaniards did what they did... I don't want give away any more but it is awesome and timely... By the way, i have two new albums for free distribution if you want a copy... just email me at: josaphat@familink.com and i'll either email or mail you a copy! the apologist 2 albums: Very Marian (2006) Norvus Ordo EP (2007)
Paladin D Posted December 13, 2006 Posted December 13, 2006 I'm gonna wait till it comes out on dvd, and rent it. Sounds good though.
suuran Posted December 13, 2006 Posted December 13, 2006 I haven't seen it yet, but I probably will. I will not that this is the Mayan empire, not the Aztec one, and that Cortes is some time later--he wasn't the first Spaniard in the New World by far.
jswranch Posted December 13, 2006 Posted December 13, 2006 How bad is the nudity content? (Recovering porn issues) Is it really any more explicit than National Geographic?
the Apologist Posted December 14, 2006 Author Posted December 14, 2006 [quote name='jswranch' post='1141157' date='Dec 13 2006, 05:41 AM'] How bad is the nudity content? (Recovering porn issues) Is it really any more explicit than National Geographic? [/quote] yeah it is like National Geographic... i think you can safely go to see it with no problems
jmjtina Posted December 14, 2006 Posted December 14, 2006 I took my parents. They loved it. I think you could go without any problems!
goldenchild17 Posted December 14, 2006 Posted December 14, 2006 (edited) I'm not going to argue that this movie should be great as was the Passion. But why do you guys give so much support to Gibson? Seriously? I understand the whole, pretty much all of hollywood is bad and you can't avoid it type stuff. But if you guys can't support simple weblinks to "heretical" bookstores that are linking to a book that is completely licit, then how can you justify supporting Mel's movies, especially the Passion, which payed for his building the sedevacantist church in Malibu... Note this isn't bringing up a debate about Sedevacantism. I simply am confused as to the apparent contradictions. Why support a non-Catholic cause in one case and yet make a bold stand against another non-Catholic cause in another case. Both causes present great non-heretical material and both are apparently schismatic, so what separates the two? What makes one okay and the other not? I'm done . Continue. I haven't seen apocalypto but definitely intend to soon. Maybe when I get back home this weekend or next. Edited December 14, 2006 by goldenchild17
Theoketos Posted December 14, 2006 Posted December 14, 2006 [quote name='goldenchild17' post='1141818' date='Dec 13 2006, 10:38 PM'] I'm not going to argue that this movie should be great as was the Passion. But why do you guys give so much support to Gibson? Seriously? I understand the whole, pretty much all of hollywood is bad and you can't avoid it type stuff. But if you guys can't support simple weblinks to "heretical" bookstores that are linking to a book that is completely licit, then how can you justify supporting Mel's movies, especially the Passion, which payed for his building the sedevacantist church in Malibu... Note this isn't bringing up a debate about Sedevacantism. I simply am confused as to the apparent contradictions. Why support a non-Catholic cause in one case and yet make a bold stand against another non-Catholic cause in another case. Both causes present great non-heretical material and both are apparently schismatic, so what separates the two? What makes one okay and the other not? I'm done . Continue. I haven't seen apocalypto but definitely intend to soon. Maybe when I get back home this weekend or next. [/quote] I would expect a thomist like you to understand the distinction between material and formal support as well as admit to varying degree of such licit support.
goldenchild17 Posted December 14, 2006 Posted December 14, 2006 [quote name='Theoketos' post='1141827' date='Dec 13 2006, 11:45 PM'] I would expect a thomist like you to understand the distinction between material and formal support as well as admit to varying degree of such licit support. [/quote] Well I can't admit to being very knowledgeable philosophically or any other-ically . I am not exactly familiar with how Thomist thought works though I've always wanted to know. Basically I was just wondering what makes supporting a movie that funds a Sedevacantist parish and organization any different and better than supporting someone buying a prayerbook that happens to pay for an SSPX organization. I could see if one would either deny both, or support both. But what separates them? Thanks.
Socrates Posted December 15, 2006 Posted December 15, 2006 (edited) Definitley want to see this flick! [quote name='goldenchild17' post='1141835' date='Dec 13 2006, 11:49 PM'] Well I can't admit to being very knowledgeable philosophically or any other-ically . I am not exactly familiar with how Thomist thought works though I've always wanted to know. Basically I was just wondering what makes supporting a movie that funds a Sedevacantist parish and organization any different and better than supporting someone buying a prayerbook that happens to pay for an SSPX organization. I could see if one would either deny both, or support both. But what separates them? Thanks. [/quote] I'd personally have less problem giving money to Mel Gibson than to Steven Speilberg, Tom Cruise, or fill-in-the-blank-godless-hollywood-liberal. Buying a movie ticket doesn't mean I support everything the film-maker stands for. To take that approach, I'd have to boycott all movies period. Movies like the Passion have nothing in them directly promoting Sedevacantism. If Mel came out with, say, a pseudo-documentary about how Pope Benedict XVI is in reality an evil pawn of Satan bent on destroying the True Faith, I would probably refuse to watch it. But I don't think there's anything intrinsically immoral about doing business with or buying products from anyone who is not an orthodox Catholic. Otherwise, we'd be forced to live in tight isolated little ghettos (an idea some may like, but that's another debate. ). Edited December 15, 2006 by Socrates
-I---Love Posted December 15, 2006 Posted December 15, 2006 I think "giving him money" by seeing his movie is fairly equal to buying a book that was printed by the SSPX for example. What it comes down to is that ppl want to see movies, and because it seems radical to not see anyones movie that isnt catholic, which are almost 100% of them, we just don't care, as long as it's not clearly against Catholicism for example. I do the same thing. I don't know how much better or worse it is; but I certainly don't justify it.
goldenchild17 Posted December 15, 2006 Posted December 15, 2006 [quote name='Socrates' post='1142712' date='Dec 14 2006, 11:02 PM'] Definitley want to see this flick! I'd personally have less problem giving money to Mel Gibson than to Steven Speilberg, Tom Cruise, or fill-in-the-blank-godless-hollywood-liberal. Buying a movie ticket doesn't mean I support everything the film-maker stands for. To take that approach, I'd have to boycott all movies period. Movies like the Passion have nothing in them directly promoting Sedevacantism. If Mel came out with, say, a pseudo-documentary about how Pope Benedict XVI is in reality an evil pawn of Satan bent on destroying the True Faith, I would probably refuse to watch it. But I don't think there's anything intrinsically immoral about doing business with or buying products from anyone who is not an orthodox Catholic. Otherwise, we'd be forced to live in tight isolated little ghettos (an idea some may like, but that's another debate. ). [/quote] So you wouldn't have a problem with buying traditional, sound, Catholic material from a non-Catholic source, such as SSPX? [quote name='-I---Love' post='1143166' date='Dec 15 2006, 03:46 PM'] I think "giving him money" by seeing his movie is fairly equal to buying a book that was printed by the SSPX for example. What it comes down to is that ppl want to see movies, and because it seems radical to not see anyones movie that isnt catholic, which are almost 100% of them, we just don't care, as long as it's not clearly against Catholicism for example. I do the same thing. I don't know how much better or worse it is; but I certainly don't justify it. [/quote] Ok, that's all I was really asking. I don't see that it can be different for movies than it is from books. But we have the contrasting principles on here: this thread supporting a non-Catholic's endeavors and yet other thread(s) saying that we are not to buy things from stores that are run by non-catholics, such as SSPX.
Guest Rick777 Posted December 16, 2006 Posted December 16, 2006 (edited) Mel Gibson is not Non-Catholic. He was baptized into the Roman Catholic Church...no matter what he does, he'll still be a Catholic. Edited December 16, 2006 by Rick777
goldbug16 Posted December 16, 2006 Posted December 16, 2006 I dont think that I am going to see it. Read the following article written by a good Catholic. (Steven Graydanus for those who get the National Catholic Register.) [quote]Apocalypto (2006) Directed by Mel Gibson. Rudy Youngblood, Dalia Hernandez, Jonathan Brewer, Raoul Trujillo, Rodolfo Palacios. Buena Vista. From a National Catholic Register review By Steven D. Greydanus Despite the biblical-sounding title — and subtitled dialogue in an ancient language — Mel Gibson’s Apocalypto isn’t an eschatological follow-up to The Passion of the Christ. It has nothing to do with the book of Revelation, or with the end of the world — though it does touch on the end of a world, or more than one. Actually, although the English word “apocalypse” connotes the end of the world, the real meaning is revelation, “unveiling.” The form used in the title of Mel Gibson’s latest movie, Apocalypto, means “I reveal.” But what, if anything, is revealed by the film? What is Apocalypto about? With its pre-Columbian Mesoamerican setting, unknown cast of indigenous, largely first-time actors, and subtitled dialogue (Yucatek Maya), Apocalypto turns out to be a brutal action movie with unusually exotic production values. The film depicts the murderous conquest of peaceful jungle villagers by cruel Mayan warriors, some to be sold as slaves, others destined for a more terrible fate. Is there any larger meaning? The film offers various possible clues. There’s an opening quotation from historian Will Durant: “A great civilization is not conquered from without, until it has destroyed itself from within.” There are suggestive speeches about the crippling effects of fear, how it crawls into the soul and destroys inner peace. A village elder retells an intriguing myth about the unique power and restless hunger of man, who borrows the strengths of all the animals before they realize that man has a hole inside him that will make him take and take until the world has no more to give. Christological echoes crop up in the film: An unsettling prophecy suggests that the hero, Jaguar Paw (Rudy Youngblood), may be somehow chosen to overcome against the cruel Mayans, and a nearly miraculous turn of events strongly suggests that whatever powers that be are on his side. A lurid sequence set at a Mayan pyramid temple includes a speech that could be applied to contemporary politics and a hideous ritual that could be seen as an indictment of the culture of death, while a mountain of corpses connects the scenes of human sacrifice to the Holocaust. Above all, the film speaks the language of violence. Following in the footsteps of Gibson’s Braveheart, The Patriot, and The Passion of the Christ, Apocalypto is steeped in graphic bloodletting, mutilation and gore. Echoes of Gibson’s earlier work runs through the film: the throat-slitting, disemboweling and beheading execution, and suggestions of rape from Braveheart; the bloodied, battered hero fighting indestructibly on and on á là The Patriot; an eerie preternatural child and a stabbing wound to the side, among other things, recalling The Passion of the Christ. Why are Gibson’s movies so gruesome? What is the attraction? Some charge that the director’s work is simply sadistic, reveling in brutality for brutality’s sake. Yet morality and heroism are as integral to Gibson’s films as violence; Apocalypto isn’t just a Mesoamerican Texas Chainsaw Massacre. Nor does thirst for vengeance seem to be the main appeal, though it’s certainly part of the mix. (When one character says something like ”I’m going to peel off his skin and make him watch me wear it,” some viewers may be reminded of Gibson’s own graphic invective against New York Times writer Frank Rich in the wake of a Times piece on Gibson’s father: “I want his intestines on a stick. I want to kill his dog.”) At the same time, neither historical realism nor the narrative demands of the story seem sufficient rationales. Even in The Passion of the Christ, although enthusiastic commentators have suggested that the real brutality of Jesus’ passion exceeded that of the film, that Gibson actually toned down the violence in his depiction, realistically this is very likely an inversion of the truth. Certainly Jesus’ redemptive suffering exceeded what any film could depict, but in terms of actual physical violence the real scourging at the pillar could hardly have been as extreme as the film version. Some of the violence in Apocalypto, such as the ghastly scenes of human sacrifice and the vicious conquest and enslavement of the villagers, may be integral to the depiction of a ruthless, decadent civilization. Yet when a freak accident leads to a fleeting closeup of an angry jaguar chewing the face of a Mayan warrior, or when a team of warriors leap over a waterfall and an underwater camera captures one of them bloodily bashing out his brains on a hidden rock, it’s hard to see the historical or narrative necessity. Revealingly, Apocalypto opens with a pair of crude, cruel practical jokes that focus squarely on the theme of manhood. One of the villagers, a big fellow named Blunted (Jonathan Brewer), hasn’t been able to give his wife a child, and endures humiliating treatment as a result, starting with a bit of business involving the testicles of the quarry after a hunt. This opening gag graphically establishes a keen interest in what might be expressed as “having the stones.” From there, the film goes on to trade on deep-rooted male anxieties regarding protecting and providing, honor and shame, and above all male fear of powerlessness, of impotence, of inability to protect and provide, to prevent the destruction of one’s life and world. Against such fears, Apocalypto pits courage, something like fate or providence, and above all willingness to suffer. As in other Gibson films, the capacity to embrace and triumph in or through suffering, violence and humiliation — whether by enduring it, or potentially inflicting it — is both the path to victory and the badge of manhood. (Even Jesus in The Passion was depicted deliberately prolonging and intensifying the scourging at the pillar, standing up after the Romans had beaten him to the ground and provoking the incredulous centurions to renew their bludgeoning attack with even greater fury.) Actually, triumph through suffering may also be the badge of womanhood, particularly of motherhood. The Passion presented the Virgin Mary suffering with her Son, her heart pierced by a sword. Apocalypto gives even more screentime to maternal suffering, as Jaguar Paw’s pregnant wife Seven (Dalia Hernandez) and young son Turtles Run (Carlos Emilio Baez) are neither slain nor taken prisoner, but left trapped in a deep pit, threatened with starvation or dehydration, with Seven’s baby ready to come at any time. Seven’s efforts to escape, to protect her son from various threats, and the inevitable childbirth scene, while not quite as punishing as the gauntlet Jaguar Paw must run, are more than grueling enough. Such primal themes have always been part of Gibson’s work, but Apocalypto, with its pre-Christian setting, offers perhaps the ultimate theater for the director’s concerns. Perhaps even more than The Passion of the Christ, Apocalypto sums up who Gibson is and what he has to say as a filmmaker. If the film reveals anything, it reveals Gibson himself. Gibson is a consummate filmmaker, and the action is never less than riveting. Yet as the film repeatedly ratchets up the wince factor beyond what seems necessary or appropriate, it’s hard not to feel that suffering has been reduced to spectacle. The Passion offered a redemptive context for its brutality that seems lacking here. Gibson is still seeking life amid death, but the balance is off. The final showdown between Jaguar Paw and his detestable archrival is brilliantly orchestrated. But then comes a moment when the bad guy is not quite dead, but not long for this life… and, as he looks up at the hero, a thin jet of blood spurts from the side of his laid-open head, pulsing with his heartbeat. Does anyone want or need to see that? Gibson is a bold, powerful artist who is unafraid of challenges. For his next challenge, he might try exercising restraint. Much extreme graphic violence and gore; disturbing images; ethnographic nudity; frank sexual references and themes; implied rape; coarse and obscene language; grossout humor.[/quote] My opinion though.
Socrates Posted December 19, 2006 Posted December 19, 2006 [quote name='goldenchild17' post='1143233' date='Dec 15 2006, 05:13 PM'] So you wouldn't have a problem with buying traditional, sound, Catholic material from a non-Catholic source, such as SSPX? Ok, that's all I was really asking. I don't see that it can be different for movies than it is from books. But we have the contrasting principles on here: this thread supporting a non-Catholic's endeavors and yet other thread(s) saying that we are not to buy things from stores that are run by non-catholics, such as SSPX. [/quote] I don't think it would be in itself sinful to buy sound Catholic material from the SSPX. There would be no problem with it, if, say, it was the only source from which said materials could be obtained, and there were no orthodox Catholic sources selling the equivalent. Since most of these materials can be obtained from orthodox Catholic sources, I would see no need to buy them from a schismatic source. There is a difference between doing something with the intent to encourage schism and error, and making a transaction which gives money to non-Catholics. I think religious materials are a bit different from things such as movies here because of scandal, and giving the appearance of associating oneself religiously with something contrary to the Catholic Church. In buying tickets for the Passion (or something similar), I would be supporting a movie which gives glory to Christ, rather than something which attacks the Church. Most people would not see watching that movie as affiliating oneself with Sedevacantism Using your logic, it would be immoral to buy shoes from a Baptist, because that would give money to a non-Catholic.
suuran Posted December 19, 2006 Posted December 19, 2006 Goldbug: Greydanus' review is what convinced me to see it. I think it sounds worth the violence--Mel Gibson certainly does have a powerful vision, and I've enjoyed it and even been inspired by it in Braveheart, The Patriot, and The Passion.
littleflower+JMJ Posted December 19, 2006 Posted December 19, 2006 [quote name='goldbug16' post='1143379' date='Dec 15 2006, 09:11 PM'] I dont think that I am going to see it. Read the following article written by a good Catholic. (Steven Graydanus for those who get the National Catholic Register.) My opinion though. [/quote] You know the whole gruesomeness is what really opens your eyes to the understanding as to the reason why the Blessed Mother appeared to Mexico. The wrong and large killings did happen and that is the very reason why Our Lady appeared to them. To see where these people came from, to converting to Christianity shows how miraculous and necessary God's intervention for these people and country were needed. Something that could not have been done without Her appearance and intercession. I know, looking at the Virgen de Guadalupe, I have a deeper meaning to her appearance, to her message, knowing the history that Mel Gibson's movie portrayed. It is not a story of indians who were doing just fine like I learned in spanish class. It provided a great path to understanding the apparition that would follow. The movie shows how we need God and Christianity..... and how wrong we are without it.
Tindomiel Posted December 21, 2006 Posted December 21, 2006 (edited) [quote name='littleflower+JMJ' post='1145387' date='Dec 19 2006, 03:20 AM'] You know the whole gruesomeness is what really opens your eyes to the understanding as to the reason why the Blessed Mother appeared to Mexico. The wrong and large killings did happen and that is the very reason why Our Lady appeared to them. To see where these people came from, to converting to Christianity shows how miraculous and necessary God's intervention for these people and country were needed. Something that could not have been done without Her appearance and intercession. I know, looking at the Virgen de Guadalupe, I have a deeper meaning to her appearance, to her message, knowing the history that Mel Gibson's movie portrayed. It is not a story of indians who were doing just fine like I learned in spanish class. It provided a great path to understanding the apparition that would follow. The movie shows how we need God and Christianity..... and how wrong we are without it. [/quote] Goldbug and I understand the "need" for violence to get across the horror of the Aztec and Mayan civilzations. But she's talking about this: [quote]Some of the violence in Apocalypto, such as the ghastly scenes of human sacrifice and the vicious conquest and enslavement of the villagers, may be integral to the depiction of a ruthless, decadent civilization. Yet when a freak accident leads to a fleeting closeup of an angry jaguar chewing the face of a Mayan warrior, or when a team of warriors leap over a waterfall and an underwater camera captures one of them bloodily bashing out his brains on a hidden rock, it’s hard to see the historical or narrative necessity. Revealingly, Apocalypto opens with a pair of crude, cruel practical jokes that focus squarely on the theme of manhood. One of the villagers, a big fellow named Blunted (Jonathan Brewer), hasn’t been able to give his wife a child, and endures humiliating treatment as a result, starting with a bit of business involving the testicles of the quarry after a hunt. [/quote] I'm sorry, but I think Mel Gibson, although a great director, has major issues with violence, not to mention other things. I'm not going to hold up as a great Catholic someone who's into SSPX, states on interviews that he thinks his wife is going to hell because she's not a Catholic, played in movies like "Lethal Weapon" and "What Women Want" , and curses Jews when he's drunk - even if he did make "The Passion of the Christ." And I can't bring myself to support what he does. Matter of conscience. Edited December 21, 2006 by Tindomiel
CrossCuT Posted December 21, 2006 Posted December 21, 2006 [size=1]I saw it last night and I loved it! Very moving and powerful! [/size]
desertwoman Posted December 22, 2006 Posted December 22, 2006 I saw it last night as well. Great movie!
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now