Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Mel Gibson's New "apocalypto" Is Dope!


Recommended Posts

Posted

there's nothing wrong with buying a good book published by Angelus Press or some other sspx affiliated publisher or private individual. nor is there anything wrong with paying money to see Gibson's film. nor even with dropping a bit of money into an sspx collection plate, according to Rome at least.

haven't seen the film yet; but I intend to ;)

Posted

[quote name='Tindomiel' post='1146947' date='Dec 21 2006, 02:00 PM']
Goldbug and I understand the "need" for violence to get across the horror of the Aztec and Mayan civilzations. But she's talking about this:

[quote] Some of the violence in Apocalypto, such as the ghastly scenes of human sacrifice and the vicious conquest and enslavement of the villagers, may be integral to the depiction of a ruthless, decadent civilization. Yet when a freak accident leads to a fleeting closeup of an angry jaguar chewing the face of a Mayan warrior, or when a team of warriors leap over a waterfall and an underwater camera captures one of them bloodily bashing out his brains on a hidden rock, it’s hard to see the historical or narrative necessity.

Revealingly, Apocalypto opens with a pair of crude, cruel practical jokes that focus squarely on the theme of manhood. One of the villagers, a big fellow named Blunted (Jonathan Brewer), hasn’t been able to give his wife a child, and endures humiliating treatment as a result, starting with a bit of business involving the testicles of the quarry after a hunt.

[/quote]

I'm sorry, but I think Mel Gibson, although a great director, has major issues with violence, not to mention other things. I'm not going to hold up as a great Catholic someone who's into SSPX, states on interviews that he thinks his wife is going to hell because she's not a Catholic, played in movies like "Lethal Weapon" and "What Women Want" , and curses Jews when he's drunk - even if he did make "The Passion of the Christ." And I can't bring myself to support what he does. Matter of conscience.
[/quote]

Ditto to that.

Posted

[quote name='Tindomiel' post='1146947' date='Dec 21 2006, 02:00 PM']
Goldbug and I understand the "need" for violence to get across the horror of the Aztec and Mayan civilzations. But she's talking about this:
I'm sorry, but I think Mel Gibson, although a great director, has major issues with violence, not to mention other things. I'm not going to hold up as a great Catholic someone who's into SSPX, states on interviews that he thinks his wife is going to hell because she's not a Catholic, played in movies like "Lethal Weapon" and "What Women Want" , and curses Jews when he's drunk - even if he did make "The Passion of the Christ." And I can't bring myself to support what he does. Matter of conscience.
[/quote]
Are you saying you won't "support what he does" by watching his movies?
Then you'd probably better boycott [i]all [/i] Hollywood movies to be consistent.

No, Mr. Gibson is not "St. Mel," but he is someone who has at least made some attempt to convert, and is usually the first to admit he is a sinner.

That is far better than 99.9% of Hollywood, who unapologetically and openly promote perversion and immorality. Gibson gets press because his sins happen to be of a politically-incorrect variety.

littleflower+JMJ
Posted

[quote name='Tindomiel' post='1146947' date='Dec 21 2006, 01:00 PM']
Goldbug and I understand the "need" for violence to get across the horror of the Aztec and Mayan civilzations. But she's talking about this: [/quote]

Well, I understand its the job of the movie review to make sure we know the parts that aren't agreeable so we know what exactly is in there but theres alot to the movie than that mentioned thats all.

[quote]I'm sorry, but I think Mel Gibson, although a great director, has major issues with violence, not to mention other things. I'm not going to hold up as a great Catholic someone who's into SSPX, states on interviews that he thinks his wife is going to hell because she's not a Catholic, played in movies like "Lethal Weapon" and "What Women Want" , and curses Jews when he's drunk - even if he did make "The Passion of the Christ." And I can't bring myself to support what he does. Matter of conscience.
[/quote]

I was just addressing the violence and gruesome parts that goldbug had quoted and how parts of the movie are reasons for not seeing it. :idontknow:

If you have other issues for not seeing the movie (like Mel's past, etc.) thats a whole different cookie and reasons that are well on the personal, and thats fine more power to you. :P: I don't think seeing this movie calls him a "great catholic" by watching it, :mellow: just a great director. ;) Was this a problem when you saw TPOTC? :ninja:

I'm curious though if you see have seen other movies that hollywood makes, since those would have a longer list of reason not to see.

But thats fine and understandable, ^_^ since I have my own set of standards as well and don't agree with much of the stuff out there, but I do gotta vouch that this is a great one. :cool: ;)

Posted

[quote name='the Apologist' post='1140508' date='Dec 12 2006, 12:03 PM']
Gibson's new Apocalyto was great! Go and see it but be ready because it is pretty graphic... it reveals the true history of the what was going on in the Aztec empire before Hernan Cortes arrived there and why the Spaniards did what they did... I don't want give away any more but it is awesome and timely..[/quote]
Actually, the movie had some significant misrepresentation issues. I just finished a class on Mesoamerican art history and I would like to share an entry on the class blog that our professor posted about the movie. This will deal more accurately than I could right now with the historic truthfulness of the movie.

[url="http://tesserae.blogspot.com/2006/12/apocalypto-historically-inaccurate.html"]http://tesserae.blogspot.com/2006/12/apoca...inaccurate.html[/url]

Posted

Not trying to sound like a jerk but i think that Gibson is a little twisted making a movie this graphic I mean when I movie is more graphic than saw and saving private ryan i think we have a problem and aren't these the same people who were saying that gore has no place in a movie not that i think that way but yeah I heard about the movie from a kid who hunts and he said he almost threw up so if a kid who has a pretty good stomach is bothered by this kind of stuff and you aren't they're is a problem....why must we watch movies like this and desensatize(If thats even how its spelled) ourselves to

Posted

[quote name='Socrates' post='1147200' date='Dec 21 2006, 07:45 PM']
Are you saying you won't "support what he does" by watching his movies?
Then you'd probably better boycott [i]all [/i] Hollywood movies to be consistent.

No, Mr. Gibson is not "St. Mel," but he is someone who has at least made some attempt to convert, and is usually the first to admit he is a sinner.

That is far better than 99.9% of Hollywood, who unapologetically and openly promote perversion and immorality. Gibson gets press because his sins happen to be of a politically-incorrect variety.
[/quote]
We should support Christianity in Hollywood, otherwise think of what we would get.

littleflower+JMJ
Posted

[quote name='i'm only underOATH' post='1147230' date='Dec 21 2006, 10:51 PM']
Not trying to sound like a jerk but i think that Gibson is a little twisted making a movie this graphic I mean when I movie is more graphic than saw and saving private ryan i think we have a problem and aren't these the same people who were saying that gore has no place in a movie not that i think that way but yeah I heard about the movie from a kid who hunts and he said he almost threw up so if a kid who has a pretty good stomach is bothered by this kind of stuff and you aren't they're is a problem....why must we watch movies like this and desensatize(If thats even how its spelled) ourselves to
[/quote]


well, sometimes its not someone's cup of tea but how old was he?

I forget some of you phatmassers are so young (like 15 right?), and the movie is rated R so yeah, that might be an issue. ;) Not for kiddos.

Posted

Dude he was 18 and don't assume thing cause when you assume it makes an ass outta you and me ok....

littleflower+JMJ
Posted

[quote name='i'm only underOATH' post='1147376' date='Dec 22 2006, 11:16 AM']
Dude he was 18 and don't assume thing cause when you assume it makes an ass outta you and me ok....
[/quote]

well I wasn't assuming I was asking. :idontknow:

The reason I said the second part is because I had just realized pmers that had said they were not going to see it in thread who ARE younger than 18.... that was something I hadn't thought about when mentioning to see that movie that is a big thing to consider :mellow: . Then I read your post asking along the same line.

Gosh, I'm just glad it takes two to assume! :saint: LOL

Posted

[quote name='littleflower+JMJ' post='1147206' date='Dec 21 2006, 11:02 PM']

If you have other issues for not seeing the movie (like Mel's past, etc.) thats a whole different cookie and reasons that are well on the personal, and thats fine more power to you. :P: I don't think seeing this movie calls him a "great catholic" by watching it, :mellow: just a great director. ;) Was this a problem when you saw TPOTC? :ninja:

I'm curious though if you see have seen other movies that hollywood makes, since those would have a longer list of reason not to see.

But thats fine and understandable, ^_^ since I have my own set of standards as well and don't agree with much of the stuff out there, but I do gotta vouch that this is a great one. :cool: ;)
[/quote]

I'm afraid my post was rather confused - I was sort of trying to address two issues at once. I don't necessarily support Mel Gibson's personal life, and it does rather irritate me that many Catholic newspapers do treat him as a"St. Mel."

But I only boycott his movies insofar as they're reprehensibly violent - I do the same for movies made by hollywood non-Catholics as well. It was a problem with TPOTC, because I didn't even watch it. I agree with Mr Gredaynus when he says that although the intrinsic horror of Christ's Passion couldn't even be adequately expressed by Mel Gibson's movie, the physical violence was most likely exaggerated.

Gibson is certainly a great director, I just think he has major issues with violence in his personal life, and that this is reflected in his movies. I won't see movies by other hollywood directors in which weird ideas, etc. are reflected in the movies. If Mel Gibson ever comes out with a really good movie which I could watch without having to look away from the screen more than 30% of the time, I'd see it no matter what I thought of him personally.... :idontknow:

I hope that explains my position a little more clearly.... Of course, other people can handle greater levels of violence in movies, so I'm not saying that it's wrong for anyone else to watch it. I just really disagree with it personally....

Posted

Darn! I was just a doofus and posted under my sister's name.... :lol: anyway, I said the above.

Posted

[quote name='Light and Truth' post='1147229' date='Dec 22 2006, 04:50 AM']
Actually, the movie had some significant misrepresentation issues. I just finished a class on Mesoamerican art history and I would like to share an entry on the class blog that our professor posted about the movie. This will deal more accurately than I could right now with the historic truthfulness of the movie.

[url="http://tesserae.blogspot.com/2006/12/apocalypto-historically-inaccurate.html"]http://tesserae.blogspot.com/2006/12/apoca...inaccurate.html[/url]
[/quote]


I was actually going to bring that up. I'm an archaeologist, and while I don't specialize in Mayans, I didn't think it was quite historically accurate. For what it's worth, Archaeology magazine also had an article about this.

I haven't made up my mind about whether I'll see it. If I do see it, I'll rent it. I'm not one who has to have everything be completely historically accurate, I just like it when people realize what's accurate and what isn't. I mean, Gladiator is a great movie, if not completely accurate. Again, since i haven't seen this movie yet, I'll have to go from what I've read so far. Feel free to correct me if I'm wrong, as long as you're nice about it. :D:

Posted

Ok just to let everone know everything I said on this site was bologna I was just kidding so no one take offense and no one take anything I said on this topic serious i was just really bored ahhhhhhh....but my friend did say it was gross but thats ok...

Posted

I saw it last night and loved it. Graphic, yes, but I was fine. Honestly, look how many movies have graphic brutal killing in them...why is this one so disgusting and atrocious? Is it really an original phenomenon? Now, I am not saying that everyone should be excited about seeing such things, because they are not pleasant things obviously. I am just wondering why people were so taken aback...

I was inspired by the man's unimpeachable will to protect his family. What is it with Mel Gibson movies and manhood!

Posted

In Reply to other people who were upset about me and tindomiel not liking or supporting Mel Gibsons films, it is not because I hate the man, but because he holds himself up to be a great Christian and then goes out and makes disgusting movies (with violence and sleeping around) and gets drunk and whatnot...
You may call me stupid, but that is what I think. :mellow:

littleflower+JMJ
Posted

[quote name='SRMiller' post='1147984' date='Dec 23 2006, 06:00 AM']
I was actually going to bring that up. I'm an archaeologist, and while I don't specialize in Mayans, I didn't think it was quite historically accurate. For what it's worth, Archaeology magazine also had an article about this.

I haven't made up my mind about whether I'll see it. If I do see it, I'll rent it. I'm not one who has to have everything be completely historically accurate, I just like it when people realize what's accurate and what isn't. I mean, Gladiator is a great movie, if not completely accurate. Again, since i haven't seen this movie yet, I'll have to go from what I've read so far. Feel free to correct me if I'm wrong, as long as you're nice about it. :D:
[/quote]


An archaeologist? Neat! :cool: Welcome to Phatmass too! :welcome:

Posted

Just saw it - good flick!
I'm heading to bed, so this is kind of brief, though I'll probably say more later.

Yes, the movie was violent, but I didn't really find the violence and gore excessive the story. It really wasn't worse than a lot of R-rated action flicks.

As for historical accuracy, it took some poetic license, but I saw the movie more as a fable than as strict history (note the quote at the beginning). It kind of merged the story of the Mayans (whose civilization died out long before the coming of the white man) and those of the bloodthirsty Aztecs who ruled when the Spanish arrived and were conquered by Cortez.

And note that the archologist linked to said he had less a problem with historical inaccuracy than with the portrayal of the native peoples as in need of being saved. He shows the anti-Christian bias rampant in academia, wherein to suggest anybody might be better off under Christianity is the ultimate taboo.

Posted

And note that the archologist linked to said he had less a problem with historical inaccuracy than with the portrayal of the native peoples as in need of being saved. He shows the anti-Christian bias rampant in academia, wherein to suggest anybody might be better off under Christianity is the ultimate taboo.
[/quote]

Yeah, I realize that's more what it said now. Though I think there was also an issue of people believing this to be accurate. Of course, Archaeology magazine also had issues with the Curious George movie. :)

Perhaps I'll see it when it comes to DVD. Movies are pretty expensive in Liverpool. . .

littleflower+JMJ
Posted

I came across Trai's MS blog about it. (posted below)

-------------------------------------------------

There's a great article about Mel Gibson's Apocalypto over at Godspy. These are three paragraphs that I really liked, but I encourage reading the entire article:

"Fellini couldn't have fashioned a more outrageously surreal sequence than a bewildered Jaguar Paw's entrance into the Mayan capital, followed by an orgy of bloodthirsty ritual. It is in these fever-dream scenes that Gibson's Culture of Life versus Culture of Death theme comes into focus. The life-giving love of family, fireside, and kin that defined the film's first act gives way to the dispassionate dispatching of sacrificial victims by priest-kings-slayers determined to keep a firm grip on a suffering populace, growing unruly in the wake of fears of famine and an unforgiving cosmos.

The analogy to other empires, all empires—Roman, Aztec, the Third Reich, and (let's not mince words) modern-day America—is obvious, or at least obvious to the filmmaker. As St. Mother Teresa pointedly and perhaps prophetically observed, a culture that kills its unborn is on the road to war and possibly nuclear holocaust. Gibson hammers home the idea that when a culture chooses Death as a means to preserve power, it sets in motion a machinery of dehumanization that will not stand the test of time.

Set in opposition to the inhuman cruelty of the Empire, is Jaguar Paw, Apocalypto's Energizer Bunny protagonist. The Christ overtones are subtle, gradually coming into focus as the film unfolds. The comparison lies in the willingness to suffer for love, in the spiritual purity that arrives via suffering. Jaguar Paw's journey through the jungle is his Way of the Cross, as he endures countless torments in an effort to rescue his family. Not so subtly, he even receives a spear wound through his right side. Through Jaguar Paw and his plight, Gibson suggests that the Gospel themes of suffering, redemption, and love are perennial; not limited to the Judeo-Christian West."

I watched this movie last night. Simply amazing. I am in awe at the intensity and provocative violence which is the reality of the Culture of Death. Gibson's use of recurring themes in subtle and candid ways really express his eye for beautiful cinematography. His manipulation of the mise en scene is deserving of praise.

Also, the dramatization of facial expressions throughout the movie illustrating the exclamation of man's conscience was shown even in people at the Mayan palace (the mother at the sacrificial altar at one point showing disapproval, the lady who recognizes a man's face in the crowd as she is being carried-I am assuming the man she looked at was at one point her spouse before being taken by the new man) showing that even in the midst of the Culture of Death, man's conscience screams no matter how much we try to suppress it.

I also thought the young obese child at the top of the Mayan sacrificial altar was a great portrayal of how new generations in city-state/modern culture are vulnerable to the temptations for dualism, greed and thirst for "death as a means to preserve power" being fed by the generations of their parents.

Heres the article: [url="http://www.godspy.com/reviews/Apocalypto-Mels-Mayan-Book-of-Revelation-by-John-Murphy.cfm"]Godspy[/url]

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...