Thy Geekdom Come Posted December 27, 2006 Posted December 27, 2006 Yes. It's from the Vatican I document Dei Filius. [url="http://www.ewtn.com/library/COUNCILS/V1.HTM#4"]http://www.ewtn.com/library/COUNCILS/V1.HTM#4[/url] Search for the text "light of human reason" to find it. It's Canon 2 §1. "If anyone says that the one, true God, our Creator and Lord, cannot be known with certainty from the things that have been made, by the natural light of human reason: let him be anathema."
EcceNovaFacioOmni Posted December 27, 2006 Posted December 27, 2006 I was told by a theology professor that this meant we could know God but not prove His existence. Any thoughts?
Thy Geekdom Come Posted December 27, 2006 Posted December 27, 2006 [quote name='thedude' post='1150546' date='Dec 27 2006, 03:58 PM'] I was told by a theology professor that this meant we could know God but not prove His existence. Any thoughts? [/quote] How can we know Him from the light of human reason but not know that He exists? How could we use sound human reason to come to a knowledge of Him but not be able to prove He exists? Human reason follows the same logical rules across the board...what works for one person should work for everyone else. Therefore, we can prove that He exists. However, it doesn't tell us [i][b]how[/b][/i] to prove that He exists using human reason. It doesn't say we can prove anything else about Him, either, although I'd say you could.
Didacus Posted December 27, 2006 Posted December 27, 2006 [quote name='Raphael' post='1150547' date='Dec 27 2006, 05:01 PM'] [snip] It doesn't say we can prove anything else about Him, either, although I'd say you could. [/quote] What about His nature such as He is not Himself created for example? Or logical consequences of His existence such as we are all irrevocably dependant on our Creator?
Thy Geekdom Come Posted December 27, 2006 Posted December 27, 2006 [quote name='Didacus' post='1150552' date='Dec 27 2006, 04:09 PM'] What about His nature such as He is not Himself created for example? Or logical consequences of His existence such as we are all irrevocably dependant on our Creator? [/quote] The first question refers to a part of the very definition of God, so in proving that God exists, it would be proven true. The second is, as you say, a logical consequence. Logical consequences are the things I would argue one could prove also from the light of human reason.
EcceNovaFacioOmni Posted December 27, 2006 Posted December 27, 2006 [quote name='Raphael' post='1150547' date='Dec 27 2006, 04:01 PM'] How can we know Him from the light of human reason but not know that He exists? How could we use sound human reason to come to a knowledge of Him but not be able to prove He exists? Human reason follows the same logical rules across the board...what works for one person should work for everyone else. Therefore, we can prove that He exists. However, it doesn't tell us [i][b]how[/b][/i] to prove that He exists using human reason. It doesn't say we can prove anything else about Him, either, although I'd say you could. [/quote] I'm not all that sure that I understand exactly what he meant. He was always orthodox but seemed to think God's existence could not be proven. He said that if that were the case, we would not have free will in rejecting Him. The response I posted above was prompted by my bringing up the Vatican I statement in an e-mail. He seemed to be concerned with not making God something to be manipulated by human beings. What you said is how I understood it upon first seeing the text.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted December 27, 2006 Posted December 27, 2006 [quote name='thedude' post='1150561' date='Dec 27 2006, 04:22 PM'] I'm not all that sure that I understand exactly what he meant. He was always orthodox but seemed to think God's existence could not be proven. He said that if that were the case, we would not have free will in rejecting Him. [/quote] That assumes that humans will always accept the truth, which is false. Satan certainly knew God existed and yet freely rejected Him. Oh, and understanding is not manipulating.
dairygirl4u2c Posted December 27, 2006 Posted December 27, 2006 I had just been reading a paper I wrote on God's existance. Without getting into my arguments too much, here are some strong excerpts from the Catechism and Catholic encyclopedia. [quote]“The world, and man, attest that they contain within themselves neither their first principle nor their final end, but rather that they participate in Being itself, which alone is without origin or end. Thus, in different ways, man can come to know that there exists a reality which is the first cause and final end of all things, a reality “that everyone calls God.’”” (Catechism) “It is impossible to prove the principle of causality, just as it is impossible to prove the principle of contradiction; but it is not difficult to see that if the former is denied the latter may also be denied and the whole process of human reasoning declared fallacious. The principle states that whatever exists or happens must have a sufficient reason for its existence or occurrence either in itself [emphasis mine] or in something else ; in other words that whatever does not exist of absolute necessity - whatever is not self-existent -- cannot exist without a proportionate cause external to itself; and if this principle is valid when employed by the scientist to explain the phenomena of physics it must be equally valid when employed by the philosopher for the ultimate explanation of the universe as a whole.” (Toner) “…for the same relation of dependence upon a self-existing cause which is implied in the contingency of any single being is implied a fortiori in the existence of an infinite series of such beings, supposing such a series to be possible.” (Toner) “…the person who seeks God discovers certain ways of coming to know him. These are also called proofs for the existence of God, not in the sense of proofs in the natural sciences, but rather in the sense of “converging and convincing arguments,” which allow us to attain certainty about the truth.” (Catechism)[/quote] If you argue causation, someone will always argue that if God can just exist, then we can too. But it's a logical and rational deduction to say a cause made us. It may not be true necessarily, but it's still a proof. Or you could argue he is unknown. etc etc. They're all the ideas that scientists use to prove things the best they can. It's a proof, but yet it's not. I don't think the Church is necessarily wrong, even if you can't ultimately prove it, because you can in a sense, if you follow me.
Resurrexi Posted December 27, 2006 Posted December 27, 2006 "The [First] Vatican Council defined: Si quis dixerit, Deum unum et verum creatorem et Dominum nostrum per ea, quae facta sunt, naturali rationis humanae lumine certo cognosci non pose, anathema sit." ~Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma, Part 1, Section 1, Chapter 1, § 1
XIX Posted December 27, 2006 Author Posted December 27, 2006 Okay thanks! I knew that the Church teaches it's possible to prove the existence of God, I just didn't know if this was considered infallible.
dairygirl4u2c Posted December 28, 2006 Posted December 28, 2006 Plus it's important to note that if you define God as the unknown etc, then you could prove him definitely. Atheistis don't like that sort of thing, because it's wimsy. But, how you define Him does determine whether you can definiteively or not.
Guest JeffCR07 Posted December 28, 2006 Posted December 28, 2006 [quote name='dairygirl4u2c' post='1150597' date='Dec 27 2006, 06:03 PM'] If you argue causation, someone will always argue that if God can just exist, then we can too. But it's a logical and rational deduction to say a cause made us. It may not be true necessarily, but it's still a proof. Or you could argue he is unknown. etc etc. [/quote] Actually, that's not true. The arguments from causation, as you put it, are better described as arguments from contingency. These arguments move from the empirical observation of contingent being to the logical conclusion that they must be grounded in some necessary being. Understood in this way, if someone were to raise the question "well, why can't [i]we[/i] be contingent being," such an objection will make the person look ridiculous, because the whole discussion started with the observation that we are not, in fact, necessary. [quote]Plus it's important to note that if you define God as the unknown etc, then you could prove him definitely. Atheistis don't like that sort of thing, because it's wimsy. But, how you define Him does determine whether you can definiteively or not.[/quote] Just a quick note about the above: One cannot define God as merely "the unknown," because definitions are only meaningful if they give us some knowledge of the thing defined. To say that "God is that which cannot in principle be known in any way" is the same as saying "God is a brillig tov" - it is utterly meaningless. In fact, it is worse, because at least in the latter case it is possible that the terms are simply not understood, in "defining" God as the unknown one is actually committing oneself to a contradiction. I do agree, however, that how we define things is important. We must always remember that something can be a "definition" in one of two ways. The first, and more fomally valid, definition is a definition of essence (such as saying that Man is a rational animal). The second way that a thing can be defined is simply by explaining what is meant by a particular term (this need not capture the essence of the thing in question). It is in this latter way - and only in this latter way - that God can be defined. We can, with St. Anselm, say that by God we understand "that than which nothing greater can be conceived," but we cannot say that this phrase captures the whole essence of God. Indeed, that Divine Essence is transcendent and cannot be communicated to the human mind entirely. What we know of God is true of Him, but is entirely incomplete. Your Brother In Christ, Jeff
N/A Gone Posted December 28, 2006 Posted December 28, 2006 Jeff... PM me on this if you want, but what is your philosophy background and what are you doing with it?
Laudate_Dominum Posted December 28, 2006 Posted December 28, 2006 The natural knowability of God as creator and origin of all things is the basic presupposition of Divine Revelation. In other words the Catholic faith presupposes the possibility of a natural apprehension of Divine activities and presence in the created order; indeed the potential for certitude regarding the existence of the creator, which does not necessarily imply that such insight is reducible to syllogistic formulations and jazz. Hmm.. But I must say that there is much in the history of Roman Catholic teaching which would suggest that the perennial philosophical approach to the question of God's existence in some way expresses an appropriate relationship of faith and natural reason, or rather faith seeking understanding, and ought not be written off as simply naive and antiquated speculations.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted December 28, 2006 Posted December 28, 2006 [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1150780' date='Dec 28 2006, 01:45 AM'] The natural knowability of God as creator and origin of all things is the basic presupposition of Divine Revelation. In other words the Catholic faith presupposes the possibility of a natural apprehension of Divine activities and presence in the created order; indeed the potential for certitude regarding the existence of the creator, which does not necessarily imply that such insight is reducible to syllogistic formulations and jazz. Hmm.. But I must say that there is much in the history of Roman Catholic teaching which would suggest that the perennial philosophical approach to the question of God's existence in some way expresses an appropriate relationship of faith and natural reason, or rather faith seeking understanding, and ought not be written off as simply naive and antiquated speculations. [/quote] Please introduce a cessation to your loquatiously verbose and extremely complicated vocabulary. :
Justified Saint Posted December 28, 2006 Posted December 28, 2006 I would defer to a summation of Scheler's thought on this issue by Manfred Frings: [i]"Existence” itself is not provable. What can, strictly speaking, be proven are only propositions that have already been found. Furthermore, proofs can only pertain to already known existing things. The object must be there first in order to be able to be proved. In the philosophy of religion, therefore, proving the existence of God begs the very question in that the existing object is not there first.[/i] thedude's professor has a keen suspicion of existence proofs because with this understanding of existence, proofs can only be manipulation and objectification -- and thus idolatry.
Laudate_Dominum Posted December 28, 2006 Posted December 28, 2006 [quote name='Raphael' post='1150783' date='Dec 28 2006, 01:50 AM'] Please introduce a cessation to your loquatiously verbose and extremely complicated vocabulary. : [/quote] poppycock. :
Laudate_Dominum Posted December 28, 2006 Posted December 28, 2006 [quote name='Justified Saint' post='1150792' date='Dec 28 2006, 02:00 AM'] I would defer to a summation of Scheler's thought on this issue by Manfred Frings: [i]"Existence” itself is not provable. What can, strictly speaking, be proven are only propositions that have already been found. Furthermore, proofs can only pertain to already known existing things. The object must be there first in order to be able to be proved. In the philosophy of religion, therefore, proving the existence of God begs the very question in that the existing object is not there first.[/i] thedude's professor has a keen suspicion of existence proofs because with this understanding of existence, proofs can only be manipulation and objectification -- and thus idolatry. [/quote] The irony I see is that if, in relation to being, meaning precedes logical analysis (a conclusion drawn from the ultimate implications of the statements above), the question at hand takes on dimensions and depths that in turn render the above criticism irrelevant.
Guest JeffCR07 Posted December 28, 2006 Posted December 28, 2006 [quote]"Existence” itself is not provable. What can, strictly speaking, be proven are only propositions that have already been found. Furthermore, proofs can only pertain to already known existing things. The object must be there first in order to be able to be proved. In the philosophy of religion, therefore, proving the existence of God begs the very question in that the existing object is not there first. [/quote] There are a number of problems with this point. First, and perhaps foremost, it makes the all-too-common (and in my opinion banal) assumption that only propositions can be truth-bearers. Moreover, it really says nothing substantially more (and perhaps formulates it in a less clear manner) than the age-old Nominalist attempt to claim that you cannot argue from the existence of one thing to the existence of another thing. Finally, if taken to its logical conclusion this argument will force its adherents to maintain that nothing can be learned at all, since "proof" can only apply to things already present (and thus not in need of proof). Ultimately, unless you take the stance of Platonic recollection theory or Augustinian Illumination Theory, you're dooming yourself to skepticism. Your Brother In Christ, Jeff
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now