Justified Saint Posted December 28, 2006 Posted December 28, 2006 Jeff, I do not necessarily see the evidence that would suggest any of the conclusions you make. From what I know about Scheler (not much to be sure) he would not make the claim that only propositions are "truth-bearers". It is one thing to say that existence is not provable and yet quite another to say that only provable propositions are truthful. I would trust this is not an assumption you are making (which would be equally banal): that only that which is provable is truthful. That would be a problematic and unfortunate conflation of terms. [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1150822' date='Dec 28 2006, 02:23 AM'] The irony I see is that if, in relation to being, meaning precedes logical analysis (a conclusion drawn from the ultimate implications of the statements above), the question at hand takes on dimensions and depths that in turn render the above criticism irrelevant. [/quote] I suppose I could see your point, but I don't know why that would make the criticism irrelevant. After all, logic is the only language of the logician so in some sense you have to take on the same rhetoric of that in which is being critiqued. In some sense, this criticism is a starting point but in another sense it would take a lot of work to reach that point.
Laudate_Dominum Posted December 28, 2006 Posted December 28, 2006 [quote name='Justified Saint' post='1150900' date='Dec 28 2006, 12:42 PM'] I suppose I could see your point, but I don't know why that would make the criticism irrelevant. After all, logic is the only language of the logician so in some sense you have to take on the same rhetoric of that in which is being critiqued. In some sense, this criticism is a starting point but in another sense it would take a lot of work to reach that point. [/quote] I must say that my thing was first and foremost some sort of joke, but it was also a fairly involved train of thought that I reduced to a single sentence. And yes, it would take a lot of work to formally develop my claims, and it is doubtful that my conclusion is the only 'logical' one. I prefer to argue not for the "existence" of God directly, but rather toward an understanding of God as the presupposition of the possibility of being. Since what was at stake was really existence in its broadest sense in relation to theoretical knowledge, I saw an irony in the Scheler quote in that the perspective apparently expressed would tend toward a basic critique of conventional metaphysics as presupposing theoretical knowledge to be the most fundamental relation to being (my view admittedly takes some liberties). When this door is opened the question of knowing something of God takes a different shape and the initial criticism of metaphysical arguments regarding the 'existence' of God doesn't exactly speak to the issues. IMHO anyway. But ultimately I was just goofing around, so write me off if you feel like it.
Justified Saint Posted December 28, 2006 Posted December 28, 2006 Thanks for the clarification. You have an odd sense of humor -- must be a church scholar kind of thing
dairygirl4u2c Posted December 28, 2006 Posted December 28, 2006 (edited) [quote]Actually, that's not true. The arguments from causation, as you put it, are better described as arguments from contingency. These arguments move from the empirical observation of contingent being to the logical conclusion that they must be grounded in some necessary being. Understood in this way, if someone were to raise the question "well, why can't we be contingent being," such an objection will make the person look ridiculous, because the whole discussion started with the observation that we are not, in fact, necessary.[/quote] I should not have said "we" can just be if God can. I should have said existance can just be, if God can. We can reason that if God can just be, then existance can just be. God is even more complicated than existance, we could conclude. Acham's razor even might say we should just be too, instead of saying God created us, as it's the simplest argument in a sense. Not necessarily, but maybe. The problem I was pointing out though, I wander if you agree. That is, we can prove that the universe seems like it came from something, before the big bang, and that would be logical to deduce, so what was it? It's logical to say God, as per causation. But, that deduction does not prove God per se. if the world always existed in some way, we don't want to simply call that God (as was hinted at by the encyclopedia as what we might do etc), as it's not a good definition As you said, . So, ultimately, we cannot prove God, but it's a rational thing to say God exists given the complexity of existance, and the uncertainty of being before the Big Big. Otherwise, I would like to know how you prove God's existance. As you pointed out, Anslem's argument is only a shadow of God, not a proof per se. Pascal's wager only was a scare tactic practically. Justified's assertion that God is like existance is interesting. It's sorta remnisent of the notion I heard once that said "asking whether God exists is like looking around on a sunny day in July and asking where summer was." Actually, that quote probably better goes with causation because causation can be proven at least to a degree, and saying proving God is like proving existence does not fly. It doesn't fly because existance is a notion that we can "prove" by looking and thinking. it's not an ultimate proof, but it's a proof. Definitely much more of a proof than we can do with God. (not referring to the causation argument... we can't just look at God as we can with existance, or at least part of it) Edited December 28, 2006 by dairygirl4u2c
Guest JeffCR07 Posted December 29, 2006 Posted December 29, 2006 [quote] I should not have said "we" can just be if God can. I should have said existance can just be, if God can. We can reason that if God can just be, then existance can just be. God is even more complicated than existance, we could conclude. Acham's razor even might say we should just be too, instead of saying God created us, as it's the simplest argument in a sense. Not necessarily, but maybe. [/quote] The problem is that you are using "existence" equivocally, and that gets you into trouble. Anything that exists is either a contingent being or a necessary being. By "contingent being" we mean anything such that, in order to give a sufficient account of its existence, one must appeal to something outside. Now, we know that you or I, or any other thing that we observe is contingent precisely because we can point to other things that are their causes. In order to give a sufficient account of your existence, I need to appeal to something outside of you (say, your parents). In order to give a sufficient account of the existence of a statue, I have to appeal to the rock formation from which it was taken and the activity of the sculptor who made it. In this way, we see that [i]all[/i] things in the natural order are contingent things. Now by "necessary being" we mean anything such that, in order to give a sufficient account of its existence, one need not appeal to anything outside of itself. Does there have to be a necessary being at all? Can't everything just be contingent? What if it was just an infinite chain of contingent things? All of these are good questions, but it turns out that there [i]does[/i] have to be a necessary being. Even an infinite chain of contingent beings would not provide a sufficient explanation of its existence. Think of it like this: If I add an apple and an apple, I won't get an orange, I'll just have more apples. If I add an apple and an apple and an apple, I still won't get an orange. Even if I add an infinite series of apples, it will never magically produce an orange. In the same way, even an infinite series of contingent beings will never provide a sufficient account of why there is anything at all. But the whole nature of contingent being is such that there [i]is[/i] a reason that can be given for its existence, if only one will look outside of itself. Thus, we are forced to acknowledge that, in order for any contingent being to exist at all, there must be a necessary being. We know this necessary being to be God. Given the above, it is clear why "existence" can't be necessary, because whenever we say the word "existence" we have to qualify by saying whether we are talking about a necessary existence or a contingent existence. Merely saying "existence" and leaving it at that tempts us to misleading equivocation. Oh, and for the record, I don't think Anselm's argument is a mere "shadow" of God. Everything that it proves about God is both true and [i]actually applicable[/i] to Him. I was merely making the point that no finite being, no matter how brilliant, can capture the essence of God. : Your Brother In Christ, Jeff
dairygirl4u2c Posted December 29, 2006 Posted December 29, 2006 It's also hard for me to accept on the surface that you just proved God when so many dispute it but. I understand your example though about the infinite series needing a cause. Rationally that make sense. The series is contingent and God is necessary. But I don't think it necessarily proves God; it's only a reasoned argument, and a proof in a sense, but not a proof in the strictest sense. If you are trying to say that God is the essense, I'm not sure you're defining anything worthwhile or valid necessarily. It seems like you're adding something on, saying there must be a necessary being, when there does not have to be a being, necessarily. THe series can be necessary. Why is this thing necessary? You can use the analogies, but you don't describe how God can just be. If you say that's what he is, just being, then you're not saying how the series can just be. I'm trying not to get us in cirucles here..... why doesn't God need a necessary being? I don't think he does, as the definition of God is a necessary being if that's how you perceive. How do you respond to the idea that if God can just be necessary, then existence can just be necessary? I don't think you really responded to that. If the series is necessary then it's God, which is what you are saying if faced with the idea that the series does not necessarily need a necessary cause but I'm sure this is not your argument. To simply stamp your foot and say the series needs a necessary cause, when the necessary cause does not, does not compute. If God an just be, then the series can.
Guest JeffCR07 Posted December 29, 2006 Posted December 29, 2006 [quote] How do you respond to the idea that if God can just be necessary, then existence can just be necessary?[/quote] This is precisely what I was responding to, but I will try to make my response more clear: Simply using the term "existence" is equivocal, because whenever you say "why can't existence just be necessary?" I will respond, "what kind of existence do you mean, necessary existence or contingent existence?" Now it is my guess that, when you say "why can't existence be necessary?" you are talking about all this stuff we see around us. *waves hands* why can't [i]all of that[/i] be necessary, instead of God. The answer is that, when we actually observe all of the "stuff" around us, we find that it is [i]contingent[/i] and not necessary. Mountains don't [i]have[/i] to exist, they only happen to exist because the tectonic plates shift in certain ways and rain falls in certain ways. You or I don't [i]have[/i] to exist, we only happen to exist because our parents met and had us. The point is, for all the stuff we find around us, for all the stuff in the universe, for all the stuff that I think you mean when you say "existence," none of it contains within itself its own reason for being. When we look at the universe, we don't say "ah ha! It [i]must[/i] exist" but rather, we continue to look for reasons. Only necessary being need not appeal to anything outside of itself. so, the short answer to your question of "why can't all this stuff be necessary" is simply this: look around you, when you see all of these things, do you ever say to yourself "ah ha! This [i]must[/i] exist!"? If, like me, you don't, then you have answered your own question. Your Brother In Christ, Jeff
rkwright Posted December 29, 2006 Posted December 29, 2006 Jeff good to see you around! I love reading your posts
Guest JeffCR07 Posted December 29, 2006 Posted December 29, 2006 hahaha, I wish I could say the same. I [i]hate[/i] reading my posts, I always find something dumb or something I could have said way better
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now