Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

since I've tried to get rid of all of my shared files, I pretty much find it easier to just buy it on one of the online music stores. It might just be laziness, but i'd rather pay 88/99cents (or whatever it is) on a store that I have an account with, then go through searching for a whole intact share file on limewire or wherever. Its more organized, and if the file is not intact, then you can complain to the source, since you payed for it anyways.

Edited by Didymus
Posted

I don't believe file sharing is a sin for Canadians.

I have many threads on this. In Canada we pay a tax on all blank CDs that is supposed to go to artists. I don't think it is theft at all.

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='HisChild' post='1153226' date='Dec 31 2006, 11:56 PM']
It's still breaking one of the 10 Commandments. . . that's like saying 'but I only lusted after her/him in my heart, so it's not as bad, because we never did anything'. Jesus did say that if you've lusted after her/him in your heart, it's still adultery. Capisce?
[/quote]

Well, every sin in some way breaks most of the Ten Commandments. What about driving 5 mph over the limit? Or is it only sinful at 10 mph over? 15 mph? Depending on the amount of traffic and road conditions? Shouldn't the Catechism spell all this out so I know exactly how fast I can drive without committing a mortal sin?

If every sin of Lust is a mortal sin, even thoughts that are never acted upon, I wouldn't be able to attend Mass without committing a mortal sin. So it's like I'm damned if I do, damned if I don't, eh? :)

Posted

Just to clarify - lustful thoughts themselves aren't a sin at all - only consenting to them and entertaining them is.

Anyway, back to stealing music.....

Posted

It is incredible how little I have missed the goods once I got rid of them :-) Thanks for all the support!

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='morostheos' post='1179427' date='Jan 29 2007, 03:32 PM']
Just to clarify - lustful thoughts themselves aren't a sin at all - only consenting to them and entertaining them is.

Anyway, back to stealing music.....
[/quote]

But is it a mortal sin to entertain thoughts? That's the point I was getting at because someone earlier was trying to argue that downloading music that you didn't pay for is a mortal sin because it's stealing, which breaks one of the Ten Commandments. So my point is, if we're going with that logic, it's nearly impossible to go through a day without committing mortal sin.

  • 2 months later...
Guest Aragorn34
Posted (edited)

I've been downloading things over the internet for over a year, but only yesterday morning did it occur to me that it might be a mortal sin. Since then, I've done my research, and have come to the conclusion that it is in fact a sin. This afternoon I deleted all the music, movies, and software on my hard drive that I had obtained illegally. I want to know: Am I guilty of a mortal sin? Because I think you have to be aware that what you are doing is seriously wrong (which I was not) for it to constitute a serious sin. Am I [b]obliged under pain of sin[/b] to confess it?

Edited by Aragorn34
Posted

[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1181383' date='Jan 31 2007, 12:02 PM']But is it a mortal sin to entertain thoughts? That's the point I was getting at because someone earlier was trying to argue that downloading music that you didn't pay for is a mortal sin because it's stealing, which breaks one of the Ten Commandments. So my point is, if we're going with that logic, it's nearly impossible to go through a day without committing mortal sin.[/quote]
there is a distinction between a thought entering your head, and you making the conscious decision to entertain the thought.

same as there is a distinction between the thought of stealing entering your head, and you consciously going through the steps to steal something.

My understanding is that once the will is involved, then you enter the realm of possibility of mortal sin. Whether or not it is grave matter may be the real issue here, in my opinion.

(I'm hoping I haven't contradicted anything I posted earlier in the thread :pinch:)

[quote name='Aragorn34' post='1228841' date='Apr 3 2007, 05:30 PM']I've been downloading things over the internet for over a year, but only yesterday morning did it occur to me that it might be a mortal sin. Since then, I've done my research, and have come to the conclusion that it is in fact a sin. This afternoon I deleted all the music, movies, and software on my hard drive that I had obtained illegally. I want to know: Am I guilty of a mortal sin? Because I think you have to be aware that what you are doing is seriously wrong (which I was not) for it to constitute a serious sin. Am I [b]obliged under pain of sin[/b] to confess it?[/quote]
I'd say, if you feel that you should confess it, then confess it. Can't hurt. Might help. :idontknow:

Posted (edited)

I downloaded music when I was probably 12 or 13, and I assume it now that it was illegally, but I wasn't aware or considered the possibility of it being illegal at the time, all I knew is that this given program gives me the songs I like. I think that tonight I will confess it though, because although I didn't mean to be illegal, I was.

(plus, when you're 12 or 13, you're not always aware of laws and the background of everything.)

I want confess it, though it may / may not be mortal, because I did something I shouldn't have. I mean, if I ran over someone's cat with my car, I'd still apologize, even though I didn't mean to and I didn't go out of my way to hit it. I'd still feel bad, and I'd want to make amends. Ya kno?

Edited by got2luvjc
Posted

It's no different than going to a library, picking a book out, and copying a section you found interesting for your own benefit. Just because someone isn't making money off you doesn't make it stealing.

I'd be interested to see any ecclesiastical statements regarding this issue (whether there are any), and then I'd like to know what motivated them to speak on such an issue.

Just my opinion


Mortay

Guest Aragorn34
Posted (edited)

I certainly don't mind confessing it, but I wanted to know if I am forbidden to receive Holy Communion without doing so (I may not be able to get to Confession before Easter). In other words, if it's only a venial sin, Confession is recommended but only optional. Right?

Edited by Aragorn34
Posted

the Church says that we may recieve Holy Communion if there is really no opportunity for reconciliation beforehand, but a commitment must be made prior to recieving that you will go to confession as soon as humanly possible

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...