Resey Posted January 3, 2007 Posted January 3, 2007 They say its "sharing"...but is it really? Im confused to whether it is stealing or not, and if it is right to download songs off of it. What do you guys think? Sorry if this is the wrong section!
prose Posted January 3, 2007 Posted January 3, 2007 I always get flamed when I mention my thoughts on this. I don't believe it is stealing. But that is me. Most people here think it is.
xTrishaxLynnx Posted January 4, 2007 Posted January 4, 2007 If you're not paying for the songs / whatever you're downloading.. then it's stealing.
Kosh Posted January 4, 2007 Posted January 4, 2007 Limewire is stealing and full of viruses if I am not mistaken. It's 3vil.
goldenchild17 Posted January 4, 2007 Posted January 4, 2007 [quote name='prose' post='1155317' date='Jan 3 2007, 04:52 PM'] I always get flamed when I mention my thoughts on this. I don't believe it is stealing. But that is me. Most people here think it is. [/quote] I always assumed it was stealing, but I would be interested in why you think it's not, if you have any particular reasons. Thanks
tojo Posted January 4, 2007 Posted January 4, 2007 I'm not very knowledgeable about the subject, but I think it's stealing.
Noel's angel Posted January 4, 2007 Posted January 4, 2007 So logically, borrowing a CD from a friend is stealing?
Jesus_lol Posted January 4, 2007 Posted January 4, 2007 so listening on the radio and taping a tape is stealing?
prose Posted January 4, 2007 Posted January 4, 2007 It depends. I have spoken to priests about this. Some say it is some say it isn't. I don't think taping off the radio is stealing. I don't think borrowing CDs is stealing. My rational is that in Canada, we pay a tax/fee for all the blank CDs we buy that is meant to go to the artists that we are burning onto the CDs. Therefore, I AM paying for the right to record that song onto a CD.
Noel's angel Posted January 4, 2007 Posted January 4, 2007 I tend to agree with you prose. I mean, if we buy a CD, do we not own that CD? If we own something can we not choose to do with it what we like? I mean, you go and buy a car. You're making use of the expertise and designs of many people, but if you lend the car to your friend, is your friend stealing? What about books? Is borrowing a book from your friend wrong? Every priest that my friend and I have asked has said that it really isn't an issue. It would be different if you were using it to make profit. That would be wrong, IMHO.
Theoketos Posted January 4, 2007 Posted January 4, 2007 [quote name='Noel's angel' post='1155949' date='Jan 4 2007, 11:15 AM'] So logically, borrowing a CD from a friend is stealing? [/quote] Borrowing a CD or giving a friend a CD are different the PIRATING music, because you still have paid the just market price for that particular CD. [quote name='prose' post='1155989' date='Jan 4 2007, 12:53 PM'] It depends. I have spoken to priests about this. Some say it is some say it isn't. I don't think taping off the radio is stealing. I don't think borrowing CDs is stealing. My rational is that in Canada, we pay a tax/fee for all the blank CDs we buy that is meant to go to the artists that we are burning onto the CDs. Therefore, I AM paying for the right to record that song onto a CD. [/quote] This indeed might make it not stealing, or at least less serious "stealing" in Canada. edited
Era Might Posted January 4, 2007 Posted January 4, 2007 If you put out an album, and let's say you pressed 2,500 copies. And instead of buying the CDs that you pressed, thousands of people were just copying the album from one another, and you've only sold about 500 copies when you could have sold thousands had everyone bought a copy of the album that you pressed instead of pressing their own CD. Would you have a problem with that? I would.
Jesus_lol Posted January 4, 2007 Posted January 4, 2007 well, not that it makes it any less stealing or not, but much of the music i DL is from old, defunct, beyond rich bands, or underground metal bands that encourage music sharing as it gets them publicity. if for some reason i do want music from a smaller group getting started i will normally buy the CD
EcceNovaFacioOmni Posted January 4, 2007 Posted January 4, 2007 (edited) [quote name='Noel's angel' post='1155949' date='Jan 4 2007, 11:15 AM'] So logically, borrowing a CD from a friend is stealing? [/quote] That is not stealing if you just want to listen to the music. Stealing would be copying or ripping that CD and keeping it for yourself after returning the original to the friend. Isn't Limewire like Napster? Making copies of digital music on other's computers without paying for it is certainly illegal. The only way I see that such a service could possibly be legal is if there was a way that legally purchased songs could be shared so that only one person could listen to a licensed copy at any given time. There might even be problems with that, I don't know. Edited January 4, 2007 by thedude
Resey Posted January 5, 2007 Author Posted January 5, 2007 =| Wow. This is...interesting. Ick. Its incredibly tempting to use since its free....but Im kinda iffy about it, so I dont use it unless its an extremely rare song that I cant find on itunes.
xTrishaxLynnx Posted January 5, 2007 Posted January 5, 2007 If they're rare, it's probably worse. It most likely means not lots of people bought the album, and the artist is probably [i]needing [/i] to sell more.
N/A Gone Posted January 5, 2007 Posted January 5, 2007 on a side note..the south park episode on this is awesome. Musicians make money based on their ability to gather eyes. Gather a following that will attend concerts and support their music. If anything it makes more money for the artests when they have more people listening to their tracks and then going to their concerts. When you buy a cd you are not buying the music, otherwise you would have the legal right to distribute them. What you are buying is the product, the cd that is produced and put together with pretty pictures. "pirating" is a token term meant to scare someone. If you download a song and sell then that is wrong, because you do not own those rights. If you download a song and listen to it, or turn on the radio and listen to it then who cares. it is the same to me. The artest wants to get on the radio to get people to hear his song, same thing with p2p. In TV it is often considered ok to download an episode because it was on the TV so you could have seen/recorded for free. I have DVR I can record a whole season(I do btw) and I dont pay for it. I could have a recorded on my radio all day and record stuff(did this with tapes back in high school) there is no difference with that and limewire. My only issue with limewire is the porn access. That can be a trouble spot for people. btw, my mom is a musician...dunno if that matters. but to me it does
prose Posted January 5, 2007 Posted January 5, 2007 [quote name='Revprodeji' post='1156561' date='Jan 5 2007, 03:24 AM'] on a side note..the south park episode on this is awesome. Musicians make money based on their ability to gather eyes. Gather a following that will attend concerts and support their music. If anything it makes more money for the artests when they have more people listening to their tracks and then going to their concerts. When you buy a cd you are not buying the music, otherwise you would have the legal right to distribute them. What you are buying is the product, the cd that is produced and put together with pretty pictures. "pirating" is a token term meant to scare someone. If you download a song and sell then that is wrong, because you do not own those rights. If you download a song and listen to it, or turn on the radio and listen to it then who cares. it is the same to me. The artest wants to get on the radio to get people to hear his song, same thing with p2p. In TV it is often considered ok to download an episode because it was on the TV so you could have seen/recorded for free. I have DVR I can record a whole season(I do btw) and I dont pay for it. I could have a recorded on my radio all day and record stuff(did this with tapes back in high school) there is no difference with that and limewire. My only issue with limewire is the porn access. That can be a trouble spot for people. btw, my mom is a musician...dunno if that matters. but to me it does [/quote] I agree 100%. I just couldn't word it as well as you.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now