Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

PhatMassers,

Is it ever sinful?

Also, why would somebody think it is always sinful?

Peace,
Paddington

exquisitebones
Posted

Dont quote me on this because i am still learning this all.
but i think that its sinful, if you are using NFP to AVOID a pregnancy for selfish reasons?
if you dont have a just reason for doing it.. its considered a sin..

but there is no definitive line drawn over what constitutes a "just" reason...
so....

goldenchild17
Posted (edited)

Not sure trans lane is the appropriate place. I'll wait for a mod or someone to clarify this or move it to debate table. But exquisitebones, you're on the right track.

Edited by goldenchild17
Posted

If it is mutual catholics dialoguing about a catholic thing than this is the place. If it turns into a catholic vs catholic argument then it is wrong, if it is a multi-denominational dialogue then it might not belong here also. the only thing would be because of your status as a seperated breathen you NEED to be specific in the parts that are not representive of church teaching. This is not for me, cause I can sort, it is for people who are new to the concept like bones.

I have brought up mutliple threads about a theology issue I had. Go ahead and give me your gist Golden.

no pm? thats kinda weird. Im willing to box this out, since I have been on the receiving end also.

Posted

[quote name='exquisitebones' post='1164192' date='Jan 14 2007, 06:23 AM']


but there is no definitive line drawn over what constitutes a "just" reason...
so....
[/quote]

exquisitebones,

There needs to be. Maybe there is.

Peace,
Paddington

goldenchild17
Posted

I'm not sure the difference is completely worth the discussion. I have not yet learned if it is inherently evil or not, though leaning towards not completely. I believe though that Vatican II has altered the purpose for marriage and that this is what has allowed for nfp to become so widespread. I am not convinced that it is evil if used only under extreme positions. But those circumstances are far less common than what a lot of people might think. But mostly I am against it for it's common usage due to V2's having essentially changed the primary function of marriage. Then, if one enters into marriage with this particular intent, then I may call into question the validity of the sacrament.

Posted

[quote name='Paddington' post='1164221' date='Jan 14 2007, 12:32 PM']
exquisitebones,

There needs to be. Maybe there is.

Peace,
Paddington
[/quote]

The reason there is no definitive line is not because there are not guidelines for the morality of it, but because each case is different and the only ones who know the full implications are the couple themselves.

The guidelines for the morality of it is that there needs to be a grave reason a couple needs to abstain from having a child at that time.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

Anything can be used for a sinful purpose if you try hard enough.

Posted

[quote name='goldenchild17' post='1164222' date='Jan 14 2007, 05:45 AM'] I believe though that Vatican II has altered the purpose for marriage and that this is what has allowed for nfp to become so widespread. I am not convinced that it is evil if used only under extreme positions. But those circumstances are far less common than what a lot of people might think. But mostly I am against it for it's common usage due to V2's having essentially changed the primary function of marriage. Then, if one enters into marriage with this particular intent, then I may call into question the validity of the sacrament.
[/quote]


Those are some heavy words there sir.

1.) Questioning that Vat 2 has "altered" the marriage relationship. I assume you are talking about the focus on conjugal (sp) and the procreative. The procreative talk does not go away. I do not think this is altering their purpose, but expanding on it. Are you married? I do not desire to make this personal, but the idea that marriage is just procreative is dehumanizing to the wife, and could bring about some weird conclusions if you pressed it. There are numerous cases durng the patristic times of a marriage without children, where people where married but there was no procreation. Yet these were considered viable marriages.

2.) You call into question the validity of the sacrament. That is interesting, besides the fact that you do not have the authority to do so, why would you think this?

I think NFP can be a tool to being misused. Honestly, the people who are misusing NFP would have probably used another form of birthcontrol.

I have had this discussion before on this board, but I think the only time NFP is wrong would be without reason. But then again, who is the judge of inconvience vs legit reason? I will put myself on the stage here.

-Both my wife and I are in college, she is in a highly competative med program, I am a theology student. I run my own business which takes up a ton of time right now, but is starting to get to the point of running itself. We are newlywed, been dating for 4-5 years or so with a 1 year engagement. She also has some medical issues with having a child that will take some special care and attention. We use NFP right now to not have a child, but in the future we will use NFP to have a child. If something happened and we did become preg then we would accept and love the child completelty. But it is not in our plans to have a child right now.

ok sir..

Posted

personally, I await the day when some future Catechism says cases for NFP are "rare if practically non-existant"

haha... of course this is a case by case issue (kinda like that other thing that should be rare if practically non-existant)

lol... okay, I'm not hijackin or anything... just amusing myself...

calling into question the validity of the sacrament in many modern marriages is actually not some radical-fringe move (though blaming it on the magisterium raises controversy level to be sure). every annulment that is approved is a declaration that the marriage was [i]invalid[/i]... with the amount of annulments handed out today it is absolutely true that sacramental validity has been compromised by the confusion modern Catholics have about the nature of the sacrament.

But I certainly wouldn't say Vatican II caused marriages to be invalid. I do think the traditional understanding of the purposes for marriage and the marital act need to be re-emphasized such that we see the primary reason as procreation and then, as a secondary reason in service to the primary reason, for the purpose of unity between man and wife. the marital act done with NFP, then, is for the sake of unity between man and wife for the purpose of being better parents to the future child they plan to one day accept through the same marital act. all unitive aspects of the marital act ought to be in service, in some way, to the primary goal of procreation.

the reason for NFP has to be 'grave' (aka 'serious'). financial inability to support a child is a grave reason; serious health risks for giving birth are grave reasons. but solely for the sake of convenience is not a grave reason. but whether or not you're qualified to use NFP isn't gonna come out in a discussion on PM.

pm is not the place for a million practicers of NFP to spout off their reasons and see if people on whichever side will think they have a legitimate grave reason or not. that's a discussion to be had by a couple with a good orthodox priest who can really advise them with an indepth understanding of their situation.

Posted

sir,

if you say you desire cases of NFP to be "rare if not non-existent" then what would you replace it with? You later site a compassion for situations for NFp. In that compassion, what would you suggest as an alternative to fit your idealogy?

I do not think we need a hierarchy in procreation and unity as secondary. Adam and Eve were unitied as a partner far before they had child.

Posted

goldenchild,

I have a professor who commented the other day that the primary end of marriage is still procreation, remaining unchanged after Vatican II.

Posted

in an ideal world they would be rare if practically non-existent; of course that would only happen within a true Christendom society which produced conditions conducive to childbearing wherein not only would children not be a burden, but they would be a benefit.

anyway, I was just randomly amusing myself by comparing this situation with the death penalty debate... probably totally out of place but I got a kick out of it. if a Catechism can take one thing that must be decided case by case and make a broad generalization to say cases are "rare if practically non-existent" then it could do it with NFP, theoretically. anyway, in a more ideal society such a statement could even be considered accurate, but with the mess modernity has gotten itself into with children being burdens to be avoided instead of blessings to be coveted it probably isn't true (but I don't know, because I don't know every individual's case)

as to the purposes of the marital act: yes, one purpose is the unitive aspect. but the fruit and purpose of the unity is procreation. there would be no piurpose for the uniting of man and woman if not for that fruit, that ultimate and primary purpose.

and, the genesis story having been written in the context of a people who believed very strongly in a divine mandate to be fruitful and multiply and who saw that as a great duty for anyone engaging in the sexual act, I think it fair to say Adam and Eve did not engage in sex except after Eve was supposed to become the mother of all mankind. in any event, in the post-fall world there is that divinely mandated duty to procreate and the unity of a husband and wife is only to be strengthened through the sexual bond for the sake of being united as parental figures.

goldenchild17
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Revprodeji' date='Jan 14 2007, 03:14 PM' post='1164393']
Those are some heavy words there sir.[/quote]

I get that a lot of late, doesn't phase me :cool: .


[quote]1.) Questioning that Vat 2 has "altered" the marriage relationship. I assume you are talking about the focus on conjugal (sp) and the procreative. The procreative talk does not go away. I do not think this is altering their purpose, but expanding on it. Are you married? I do not desire to make this personal, but the idea that marriage is just procreative is dehumanizing to the wife, and could bring about some weird conclusions if you pressed it. There are numerous cases durng the patristic times of a marriage without children, where people where married but there was no procreation. Yet these were considered viable marriages.[/quote]

The unitive function must indeed be there. But it is a secondary means. I believe the Church has always taught that the primary function of the marriage union is conception and childbearing. This has been changed, not taking away any one aspect. But putting them at the very least on a level playing field has allowed for the widespread abuse of it.

[quote]2.) You call into question the validity of the sacrament. That is interesting, besides the fact that you do not have the authority to do so, why would you think this?[/quote]

I explained previously. If the two being married go into it with a mistaken view of what marriage is all about then it could lead to a wrongful intent to marry. Intent is necessary for a valid marriage. Now I don't know that I would make any blanket statement that yes or no it is invalid. But I would certainly bring it into question. Two people getting married must intend to do what the Church does, even if they don't know exactly what that is. They may be innocent due to their lack of knowledge. But the church would be conning them by making them believe their intent must be one thing, while in fact it is quite another.

With all due respect I do not address any statement regarding my lack of authority. I have no authority in the church, but any common layperson can recognize when something is quite off-base.

[quote]I think NFP can be a tool to being misused. Honestly, the people who are misusing NFP would have probably used another form of birthcontrol.[/quote]

I agree. I don't think nfp is essentially wrong. But I do believe it has been allowed to be abused. Grave reason no longer exists. Grave reason now includes people simply not being ready, whatever that means. As if God didn't know when someone is ready or not.

[/quote]I have had this discussion before on this board, but I think the only time NFP is wrong would be without reason. But then again, who is the judge of inconvience vs legit reason?[/quote]

I don't know if the Church has explicitly laid down the exact parameters of it. But I think she gives a basic outline. The premise being that the reason must be severe.

[quote]I will put myself on the stage here.

-Both my wife and I are in college, she is in a highly competative med program, I am a theology student. I run my own business which takes up a ton of time right now, but is starting to get to the point of running itself. We are newlywed, been dating for 4-5 years or so with a 1 year engagement. She also has some medical issues with having a child that will take some special care and attention. We use NFP right now to not have a child, but in the future we will use NFP to have a child. If something happened and we did become preg then we would accept and love the child completelty. But it is not in our plans to have a child right now.

ok sir..[/quote]

I have my thoughts, but I don't comment on particular private situations. Hypotheticals sure.



[quote name='qfnol31' post='1164467' date='Jan 14 2007, 05:00 PM']
goldenchild,

I have a professor who commented the other day that the primary end of marriage is still procreation, remaining unchanged after Vatican II.
[/quote]

I'm not sure that's the case though. Do you have a document that would help us out on this one. Because far as I know, right now I can only think of canon 1055 of the 1983 code which seems to place them on equal footing, and even changing the order (maybe not intentionally but I can't help to think that anything in a document so important would not be intentional).

Edited by goldenchild17
Posted

amongst faithful orthodox Catholics, the magisterium of the Church is presumed to have not changed its teaching unless proven otherwise. that's a matter of faith in Christ's promise to the Church that the Holy Ghost would guide her.

so, unless you can produce a document which actually says that the procreation is no longer the primary purpose we must read all documents in the light of Sacred Tradition and accept the Church as continuing to teach that the primary purpose of sex is procreation.

whether their current wording is prudent and clear in transmitting this continuity of tradition is another issue... one that I do not care to comment upon here except to say that Christ never promised that the Church would have a perfect way with words, just that she would never bind her faithful to believe error.

now, to say "the purpose of sex is unitive and procreative" is not erroneous. even to say "the purpose of sex is unitive" is not erroneous. one may even approach a near equal footing between the unitive nature of sex and its procreative nature; what is important is the understanding that the nature of the unitive purpose is to have as an ultimate purpose procreation. even within an NFP cycle in which a couple is nearly certain that that specific marital act will not bring about the fruit of their union through the blessing of a child, the couple ought to have the mindset that they are uniting themselves for the sake of a stronger familial bond anticipating the eventual completion of that procreation which is the ultimate goal.

Proud2BCatholic139
Posted

I believe that if you use NFP for selfish reasons, then it is a sin because you are closing the gift of life that God intended for marriage. BUT, NFP in general, I believe, is not sinful.

I know God intended marriage for man and wife to love one another as Christ loves the Church and for man and wife to multiply the earth, but that doesn't mean have 14 kids. I beleive there has to be some planning so you can take care of all your children and not have sex for the fun of it.

NFP is a wonderful tool, if used wisely. :)

MissScripture
Posted

It seems that in some of this discussion we are not considering the fact that NFP is also used as a way to have children, and not just as a way to not have them.

Posted

the ideal situation which all should strive for is a situation in which one is not compelled by grave reasons to limit the amount of children you receive.

the ideal situation is to continue in the marital act receiving children as they are given to you.

it is never ideal to plan and limit and control fertility. it is only permitted under serious circumstances.

NFP is something morally permittable, never something morally preferable.

"that doesn't mean have 14 kids" UNLESS, of course, you manage to get into a situation like that which was available to men for many millenia before our modern age of confusion and God chooses to give you 14 children as you act naturally without attempt to control or plan or limit.

and yeah, we're talking about NFP's use to limit children. using it to get children when conceiving is a difficulty for a couple is good. talking about the absolute ideal situation, one shouldn't have to use NFP to conceive. the ideal situation remains just giving yourself over to your marital duties without planning with complete trust in God. it is a good tool to help conceive if you are having difficulty conceiving; and it is a good tool to postpone conceiving when serious reasons prevent you from being able to receive the gift of children.

son_of_angels
Posted

Not being married, I cannot speak to the individual purposes of one in using/not using NFP. That is between one and their priest. I do know that the same "contraceptive" mentality which motivates many modern middle-class catholics should be considered sinful, just as wanting to kill someone but taking it out on a punching bag, while enoying the thought of killing them is really one and the same sin, with different effects.
However, perhaps one way to solve this is that, believing in a woman's ability to understand her cycles, it might also be a good thing for her to keep those cycles to herself, and not request or initiate sex during those periods of high fertility, if there was good reason. On the other hand, she might also consider even being cool to the idea at those times. However, she should not trouble her conscience or memory over it, and certainly not put the burden of responsibility for those decisions on her husband. Would this not be a stronger ideal, than systematically deciding when/when not to have sex?

Posted

[quote name='MissScripture' post='1164976' date='Jan 15 2007, 01:13 AM']
It seems that in some of this discussion we are not considering the fact that NFP is also used as a way to have children, and not just as a way to not have them.
[/quote]

MissScripture,

Does anybody debate the validity of using NFP to increase the likelihood of offspring?

Peace,
Paddington

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...