Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='Paddington' post='1164183' date='Jan 14 2007, 03:45 AM']
PhatMassers,

Is it ever sinful?

Also, why would somebody think it is always sinful?

Peace,
Paddington
[/quote]

If you are acting in selfishness, then NFP is sinful. In our conscience, we know when we are being selfish and when we are being wise and responsible. Every couple is in a unique situation and there are times in pretty much every marriage when it's responsible to plan against having children until later.

For that matter, it's sinful to [i]not[/i] use NFP (or complete abstinence) to avoid pregnancy when you have serious doubts about being ready for children. Of course, as someone else already pointed out, since NFP is simply telling you when you are fertile, it's used both to become pregnant and to practice abstinence in favor of loving each other in non-sexual ways. If anyone has fasted from food, you know how good it feels to eat a full meal once again. Well, just carry that analogy over to the bedroom... I'm sure you'll never read in Glamour magazine that abstinence makes for a better sex life :)

Posted

The only thing I would add here is that NFP educates a couple on a woman's reproductive cycle and health. When you're more aware of your health, you can also catch problems easier. As for it being sinful or not, right now it would be incredibly irresponsible of my husband and me to get pregnant, as we're both at university with no income whatsoever, other than our Stafford loan. But once we get jobs, we plan on using NFP to get pregnant. Personally, when I started learning about NFP and what all you could learn about your cycle from it, I just thought how awesome God is to have made us so complex and yet to give us a way of understanding ourselves.

goldenchild17
Posted

Not ignoring ya'll. I'm just waiting on some clarification about a document I was reading.

Posted

It's never sinful to not use NFP. no one is ever morally required to use NFP. people allowed kids to enter their marriages without planning it for thousands of years; when a kid comes then you deal with it. if at some point you can't take care of it, you get help from loved ones or anything that can help (because of the mess modernity has gotten itself into, certain social programs are necessary to help some)

it would be sinful to neglect a child you have conceived and let it starve. but not using NFP when you're not yet financial able is not some sort of anticipated neglect, you can live your life with a trust in God's providence and deal with expenses as they come.

NFP is never morally required or morally preferable. It is morally permittable when there are serious reasons for using it: that's it. Everything else that has mutated out of that to make it seem like all good orthodox Catholic couples MUST use NFP is monstrously out of line.

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='Proud2BCatholic139' post='1164822' date='Jan 14 2007, 08:29 PM']
I believe that if you use NFP for selfish reasons, then it is a sin because you are closing the gift of life that God intended for marriage. BUT, NFP in general, I believe, is not sinful. [/quote]

The problem is everyone defines "selfish reasons" differently.

Posted

Aloysius. would you rather have a married couple not have sexual union until they are ready for kids? i think that would be more damaging than NFP. There is nothing immoral about NFP. It allows a couple to still have union when they are not ready for children

Posted

married couples ought to have sexual union.

perhaps in helping a couple not yet married decide if they should marry, it should be considered whether they are ready for kids.

but certainly once you are married you ought to engage in intercourse. and if you are married and have serious reasons not to have kids, it is morally permittable to use NFP.

the mentality I'm supporting here is that the sex in NFP when you're basically sure this specific sexual act won't result in procreation is that you keep in mind an ultimate purpose of your eventual procreative act; and keep in mind that the union you are having has as its ultimate purpose to strengthen you to be parents together. all unitive aspects of sex are thus subservient to the procreative aspect, even if NFP is being used to delay it.

Posted

ok, so we agree there. I guess the only issue would be what "serious reasons" mean, and sad enough that is a case by case specific that will just anger people and cause us to judge people.

So, it seems like we agree otherwise. That is good to know, for my own sake I do not like to be against the faithful too much

Posted

I was never trying to pick a fight with you, just trying to make sure that your position wasn't vulnerable to an attack from the standpoint of traditional Catholic teaching.

serious reasons are financial and medical. it must be insisted that it must be serious reasons to exclude anyone who just wants to absolutely limit the amount of kids they're having because they don't want a big family. the fuzzy area is defining just what exactly financial reasons are, and just who exactly can and can't afford children. health issues are self-explanatory.

but yeah, it's definitely a case-by-case determination. but I can't think of any serious reasons other than financial or medical. anyone's welcome to suggest any hypothetical that wouldn't fit those two categories.

LouisvilleFan
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1165692' date='Jan 15 2007, 08:12 AM']
It's never sinful to not use NFP. no one is ever morally required to use NFP. people allowed kids to enter their marriages without planning it for thousands of years; when a kid comes then you deal with it. if at some point you can't take care of it, you get help from loved ones or anything that can help (because of the mess modernity has gotten itself into, certain social programs are necessary to help some)
[/quote]

[quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1165728' date='Jan 15 2007, 11:12 AM']
The problem is everyone defines "selfish reasons" differently.
[/quote]

This quote from paragraph 2368 of the Catechism seems to address both comments:

"A particular aspect of this responsibility concerns the regulation of births. For just reasons, spouses my wish to space the births of their children. It is their duty to make certain that their desire is not motivated out of selfishness but is in conformity with the generosity appropriate to responsible parenthood."

I agree that nobody is morally required to use NFP, but what I get from this is that if you in a state where it is irresponsible to have children, you should either abstain from sex entirely or practice NFP.

Since selfishness is a matter of the heart, it cannot be defined in black-and-white. Even mortal sins, which are defined, are not mortal if committed out of habit, under coercion, ignorance, etc.

Edited by LouisvilleFan
Posted

I would like to add another twist. The graver the reason the more strictly the rules can be followed and vice versa.

goldenchild17
Posted (edited)

Seems my argument bears more towards the purpose of marriage and the reasons that would make nfp allowable than the actual nfp. And it seems you all find this to be more subjective case by case, so I don't know that I will really get into this like I expected. I do have a question though (and one I don't really intend to argue as I don't believe I can find fault with you for believing it if you do). What do you think of section 2372 of your catechism?

"The state has a responsibility for its citizens' well-being. In this capacity it is legitimate for it to intervene to orient the demography of the population. This can be done by means of objective and respectful information, but certainly not by authoritarian, coercive measures. The state may not legitimately usurp the initiative of spouses, who have the primary responsibility for the procreation and education of their children. In this area, it is not authorized to employ means contrary to the moral law."

I understand if you agree with it, it being from your catechism and all, but what then would be considered a lawful means for orienting the demography? I looked through the compendium and it doesn't really seem to address this particular statement.

Edit: this doesn't really seem to be inherently on topic, but I was interested in hearing how you guys interpret it.

Edited by goldenchild17
LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='goldenchild17' post='1166955' date='Jan 16 2007, 03:27 PM']
I understand if you agree with it, it being from your catechism and all, but what then would be considered a lawful means for orienting the demography? I looked through the compendium and it doesn't really seem to address this particular statement.
[/quote]

Lawful means that come to my mind include the Child Tax Credit and the Family Medical Leave Act, which encourage married couples in the U.S. to have children by aleviating some of the financial and career-related risks that would be involved otherwise. I'm not sure if those are the best examples and I can't think of anything else off the top of my head, but obviously the two key points in that paragraph are that the government is watching out for the well being of their citizens without denying their freedom.

goldenchild17
Posted (edited)

So you would say the government is only allowed to employ means to [b]encourage[/b] more children and the gov would not be permitted to do anything to limit the number of children? I suppose this could be but I don't really see that in the text context having been placed in a section that goes over what is and isn't lawful means for limiting children.

Edited by goldenchild17
LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='goldenchild17' post='1167971' date='Jan 17 2007, 02:57 AM']
So you would say the government is only allowed to employ means to [b]encourage[/b] more children and the gov would not be permitted to do anything to limit the number of children? I suppose this could be but I don't really see that in the text context having been placed in a section that goes over what is and isn't lawful means for limiting children.
[/quote]

Well, the Catechism only says "it is legitimate ... to intervene to orient the demography of the population" as long as it is for the peoples' well-being and no authoritarian or coercive measures are taken. "Orienting the demography" could include either encouraging or discouraging higher birth rates. There could be tax incentives that were limited to a certain number of children or something like that, just so long as each individual couple retains the freedom to have as many children as they desire.

Of course, placing an 80% income tax on large families would be over the top. That's like giving blacks the right to vote while charging a tax to get into the polls.

Posted

I would consider any action taken by the government to discourage large families to be absolutely immoral. The only thing that could qualify as orienting the demography under the strict moral guidelines of the Catechism would be to make information on NFP available.

any extra taxing of large families would be absolutely immoral. it would border on a coercive means of population control, would violate the moral principal that large families are a blessing from God to be cherished (by punishing them)

That paragraph clearly gives the state ONLY the tool of offering information, not the tool of tax incentives or anything of that sort. Obviously without that Catechism quote, the state can still be seen to have the right to offer tax incentives for families that have more children. That in itself would be the state supporting the Catholic position on children as a blessing to be cherished. That Catechism quote does not give the state the authority to make any tax incentive for having few children; it does not give the state the authority to in any way, shape, or form discourage large families. it gives them the authority to offer information on NFP, basically.

All it can do is offer objective and respectful information to the public (i.e. about NFP) if it wishes to help orient a demography. It forbids any other means of orienting a demography and offers only the one: by supplying objective and respectful information..

goldenchild17
Posted

ok, thanks for the explanation. Not sure I read that in the context but it's all good.

Posted

I re-read the whole section and that is the final paragraph in that section... coming right after everything saying that large families are a blessing from God et cetera et cetera; and then with this final afterthought in all that context it cannot be giving the state any authority to actually affect anything detrimental to large families. reading all the context before it, it is very clear that when it says they have the right to orient the demography by means of "objective and respectful information, but certainly not by authoritarian, coercive measures", it becomes clear that the only thing it is saying here in this insignificant afterthought to the whole section is "the state can give information about this allowable form of family planning so that people who cannot afford children have available the moral means by which to not have them until they are financially able"

personally, I don't even like the way it uses the words "orient the demography"... no matter how much it says "only by information and not by any coercive means" afterwards, it has already yeilded to the state a role that it's inevitably going to screw up with all sorts of anti-child coercive means.

goldenchild17
Posted

Okay. It does say to do so by "information" which makes a difference. But I still would have to be at odds with the idea because I totally cannot see Catholic support for NFP in regards to matters of state.

Posted

I want to clear up one of the basic assumptions of the "NFP bad" argument. It's been said that V2 has changed, or rather, "de-emphasized" the procreative aspect of marriage in favor of a unitive one.

History just does not bear this out. Christian marriage, from the early apostles, through the middle ages and into the modern era, has always been dual-natured, and viewed as such by the Church.

I researched an wrote a paper for an honours Medieval History class (I got a B... good research but not long enough) and there are clear indicators in the historical record, from writings of Church fathers, through penitential texts, that this is the case.

Also, the common tanslation of Humanae Vitae is a bad one. The word "grave"... as in grave matter... in latin does not come across nearly as severely. It should read more like "serious".

This of course leaves room for sinfulness in the practice of NFP... of course! You can sinful in the practice of going to mass depending on your disposition!

So there is certainly room in the Church and society for NFP for reasons deemed serious enough by a couple.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...