Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

What can Christians learn from Buddhism?

What do you tell a Christian who is considering leaving the Church for Buddhism?

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Gershom' post='1176128' date='Jan 26 2007, 12:02 PM']
What can Christians learn from Buddhism?

What do you tell a Christian who is considering leaving the Church for Buddhism?
[/quote]

Christians having nothing to learn from Buddhism, theologically speaking, as it is the Religion foundered by Jesus Christ that contains and full and entire truth.

First is this Christian a Catholic? How you dialogue talk with him/her will depend on what he/she already believes. Because you've got to start from foundations when convincing someone. If the person is Catholic, show him/her the miracles throughout the ages which attest to the truth of the Church's claims, as well as how the foundations of Catholicism is clearly coming directly from Jesus Christ, etc. To this end I recommend this website which may have some good material of help : [url="http://www.catholic-legate.com/"]http://www.catholic-legate.com/[/url]
Or more specifically: [url="http://www2.nd.edu/Departments/Maritain/etext/sscr.htm"]http://www2.nd.edu/Departments/Maritain/etext/sscr.htm[/url] - the first part showing the credibility of the Christian Revelation.

Also what has attracted this person to Buddhism? Bad experiences with Christians and good expereinces with Buddhists, reading false material on supposed past life recollections (which could possibly even be inspired by the fallen angel/s), or simply an attraction to the tenets of this religion?

Edited by Hirsap
Posted

[quote name='Gershom' post='1176128' date='Jan 25 2007, 05:02 PM']
What can Christians learn from Buddhism?

What do you tell a Christian who is considering leaving the Church for Buddhism?
[/quote]

If a Christian is thinking of becoming a Buddhist, perhaps you might mention that Buddhism is not a very "personal" religion, in that one tries to almost annihilate himself into the "oneness" (losing the atma soul into the brahma soul). The whole point of Buddhism is the achievement of Nirvana - or really, "nothingness".

What a Christian will lose by becoming a Buddhist, is the deeply personal experience of having a saviour, Jesus, who sacrificed himself for each of us individually so that we wouldn't have to try to reach God on our own. There is nothing "personal" in Buddhism and this can make it feel very lonely. Trying to achieve Godhood through Nirvana simply creates an isolation from the world and from God, and there is no guarantee of ever really knowing God.


Some Christians are not aware of the prayer of quiet however, and Buddhists use meditation, which is a type of prayer of quiet, when one "listens" instead of "speaks". I think that meditation can be a valuable way to learn this type of prayer. The Buddhist philosophy of compassion and reverence for life is also a positive thing, but the loss of knowing God in a personal way is too great a price to pay for the path of the Tao.

Trying to reach God through our own efforts has historically not proved very successful - that is why God sent his only Son to make the connection for us. Through Jesus, we have a guarantee that we can have eternal life with Him in Heaven. No one ever made a greater sacrifice than Jesus did - and all because of love for us. Why would anyone want to give up that personal relationship with God for a mantra or breath meditation? Bad choice IMO :ohno: .

Posted

The Catholic Church and Religion being the “pillar and ground of the truth” is the fullness of truth. Thus all truth belongs to the Catholic Church even if a person is not fully aware of this reality. Because all people in some way know of God, even though not in the fullness of the Holy Church, this truth ultimately belongs to Holy Mother Church and impels to Catholic unity. Therefore, when we look at other “communities of belief” regardless if non-Catholic or non-Christian we can see fundamental truths with them.

For example, the Buddhists propose an ethical code that proposes purity and self-mastery, which is similar to Catholic theology but we cannot take this Buddhist perspective for it is incomplete and altered for their own uses. Therefore, for those things regarding God and Religion we turn our attention to the Catholic Church whom is our infallible guide.

For anyone proposing a change of religious belief, regardless of what to what, one needs real reasons and justification. If one is becoming “whatever” simply “because they want to” this isn’t a real reason. They are not even following after Religion or God but rather after themselves. Therefore, what you should try to do is talk to them about why we need an infallible guide to Religion and God. Moreover, how them not taking religion seriously is not only immature but also dangerous.

Although for all others we should extend the hand of confession. For many have trouble with the Church for their lives are not reconcilable to God therefore they rationalize themselves away from God. While discussion and evangelization is helpful and even needed, we shouldn’t subtract from the message of forgiveness for it is far easier to relate to God when we are in the friendship of God.

I cannot offer much help other than that because so little information has been given. I hope this helps... Pray, pray, pray...

Posted

Thank you all for your thoughtful replies.

I think there must be something Christians can learn from Buddhism, because Christians learned so much from the people they evangelized in the past. Consider the influence Classical philosophy has on Catholic thought.

Attractive concepts in Buddhism for the person in question are the idea of non-attachment, the impermenant nature of existence, and the cause and remedy of suffering.

Posted (edited)

May I offer a distinction? Christianity can't learn from Buddhism, but Christians can learn from Buddhists. This upholds Jesus Christ as the full and final revelation of God, while acknowledging our individual limitations in understanding, appreciating and living out that revelation. There's nothing wrong with a Christian finding a verse from the Tao or Ramayana or Book of Mormon to be a particularly helpful articulation of some truth. We just remember, at the same time, that whatever truth that is is already contained in Christ. We aren't learning an extra-Christian truth, but coming into better understanding of the truth in Christ. If something is definitively "extra" to Christianity, than it is not true and probably malicious.

A Christian who is considering leaving for Buddhism is in grave crisis of faith. I'd suggest that the problem is not in any doctrinal or apologetic realm, but in the most fundamental order of faith. This person needs to fall in love with Jesus Christ. To be captivated by the Glory of God made manifest in Him. To be overwhelmed with gratitude for a salvation so amazing that we wouldn't have even known to ask for it.

Of course, there's a lot we can do to help people see that beauty. For instance, highlighting the difference between Buddhist and Christian approaches to the world. For instance, Buddhism is right that we should be detached, but very wrong about why and how. Buddhism is right that we should purify ourselves of worldly desire, but doesn't perceive the One to whom all desire is finally ordered, in Whom all desire is fulfilled. Et cetera.

Edited by beatty07
Posted

[quote name='beatty07' post='1176764' date='Jan 26 2007, 11:53 AM']
Buddhism is right that we should purify ourselves of worldly desire, but doesn't perceive the One to whom all desire is finally ordered, in Whom all desire is fulfilled. Et cetera.
[/quote]

I invite you and all other posters to elaborate on this "et cetera." Thank you in advance. If anyone has a personal experience with Buddhism, or has converted from Buddhism, I invite you the PM me and to consider discussing this through instant messages.

Posted (edited)

I don't know, I guess I'd inquire why someone would be interested in Buddhism. If you're looking for spirituality Christianity is overflowing with it, it's just a bit harder to find. Ever notice books on Catholicism don't deal a lot with spirituality? On the other hand, pick up a book on Eastern Orthodoxy and you'll be amazed. We're not missing anything, even though thing's have been watered down.

As I think about it, someone who would be interested in a Buddhism is really yearning for that spirituality in Christianity, just hasn't found it. My solution to many problems is to turn to tradition. The vast ocean of Catholic spirituality will overshadow anything you have come accross. Things like "detachment" are present in all spiritual traditions, and so I'd encourage that person to seek first in his own faith before stepping out on to others.

Lastly, putting spirituality aside, there is Salvation in and through Catholicism.* Catholicism has a historical basis, Buddhism is largely myth and legend.

I'll send you an excellent site via Private Message, be sure to check soon!


*edited for the sake of clarity

Edited by mortify
Posted

[quote name='Gershom' post='1177083' date='Jan 26 2007, 06:15 PM']
I invite you and all other posters to elaborate on this "et cetera." Thank you in advance. If anyone has a personal experience with Buddhism, or has converted from Buddhism, I invite you the PM me and to consider discussing this through instant messages.
[/quote]At one time my best friend and famiy were devote buddists and even had a shrine in the back of their home...

Posted (edited)

[quote name='mortify' post='1177144' date='Jan 26 2007, 08:03 PM']
Catholicism has a historical basis, Buddhism is largely myth and legend.
[/quote]

What attracts the person in question is not the historical Buddha, but the concept that freedom from suffering can be acquired through detachment from desire and expectation, and the promise of Buddhism to provide a means to find that freedom, in a nutshell.

Edited by Gershom
Posted

[quote name='Gershom' post='1177499' date='Jan 27 2007, 01:42 AM']
What attracts the person in question is not the historical Buddha, but the concept that freedom from suffering can be acquired through detachment from desire and expectation, and the promise of Buddhism to provide a means to find that freedom, in a nutshell.
[/quote]

I'd say this person is unconsciously seeking that happiness that is with Jesus and eternal life. I think even the Buddhists refer to this life as samsara (the world of suffering.) It will not end with detachment. The way of Christ is not seeking pleasure and avoiding pain, it is as Jesus said: Anyone who wishes to be My disciple must abandon himself, take up his cross, and follow Me.

I would not trust a figure so shrouded in mystery and uncertainty as Buddha. The philosophers of the world got some things right but they also got things wrong. Christ is the Mediator who brings us to God and sheds light on all things that the philosophers could not grasp. Salvation is only in Him, and that is the true freedom. Hell is the true suffering.

Encourage your friend to follow Christ, for He promised us many things, and He is worthy of our trust.


God bless,
Mort

Posted

A very insightful article:

Tranquility or the Cross?

By Alice von Hildebrand

[url="http://www.catholic.com/thisrock/2001/0103fea3.asp"]http://www.catholic.com/thisrock/2001/0103fea3.asp[/url]

[quote]On a purely human level, anyone contemplating the serenity emanating from a statue of Buddha and comparing it to a painting of Christ in agony on the cross will opt for Buddhism. Would it not be foolish to choose torture and agony when the Buddha is guaranteeing calm and tranquility? But Paul was right: What is foolishness to man’s fallen nature is gloriously transfigured by those who have penetrated the mystery of divine love.[/quote]

she_who_is_not
Posted

I enjoy reading Buddhist authors, especially Pema Chedron. However, I find many Buddhist writings to be helpful on a psychological level rather than a spiritual level. I was astounded once reading Chedron's idea that to be truly "enlightened" one must give up all hope and faith in God. I immediately thought that eliminating two of the cardinal virtues would make it extremely difficult to live out the third. Without hope and faith I could not live a charitable or compassionate life. It left me with great respect and great sorrows for practicing Buddhists.

Posted (edited)

[quote]Christians having nothing to learn from Buddhism, theologically speaking, as it is the Religion foundered by Jesus Christ that contains and full and entire truth.
[/quote]

It saddens to me to see that other religions respect and try to learn from Christianity, like hinduism and buddhism for example. Hinduism,the Bagava'gita feels that whatever way man comes to Lord Krishna he is pleased, because the point is that they are worshiping him and they are pleased to preach that Christ is indeed an incarnation or avatar of God himself. However, Christians do not have this attitude. They seem to be the only religious belife that accepts no one that believes the way they do. Buddha could not come to Christ through the Truth he was seeking because he wasn't Protestant or Catholic is preposterous. You might be save throught faith. But, does no one here agree that you cannot be rewarded for seeking out truth and rejecting the darkness!? Buddha didnt know who Christ was, Buddha was before Christ, but many Christians scholars mention how close their messages seem to be. In a missions of "converting," Christains have taken copies of the Sermon on the Mount to Tibetan monks. These monks, instead of converting, gave the sermon back to the missionaries and exclaimed that the man they read was indeed enlightened, not knowing who they were complementing.
Christ said that he was the Way, Truth, and Life. However, even Christ himself knew that these ideas of "truth" and the idea of "way" were very, very broad. Buddha writes in his sutras about finding the Truth (and yes it is even capitalized in the sole text.) and those that find truth have to being very very wise or they are in turn captured by what he says is a "sutble swirling mass of darkness"

Christians can learn many things from Buddists. I have held my life by the Eight Fold, which is very commonly know to be realtive to the ten commands brought down by Moses to the Children of Irseal.

1. Right View
2. Right Aspriations
3. Right Speech
4. Right Conduct or Action
5. Right Livelihood
6. Right Endeavor
7. Right Mindfulness
8. Right Meditation

I also believe in the 4 Noble Truths.

Although its not possible to become a Buddist Christian. Being a Christian with Buddhist views and practices are very admirable. If you need any extra info PM me.

P.S.

Read Thich Naht Hanh, he is a Tibetian Buddist monk and a devout Christian. Awesome author. He writes on the Honnor he gives to Buddha and the Worship he offers to Christ

Remember, The LORD moves in Mysterious ways. Even through the Buddha he can move mountains. Christ came and dinned with sinners, such as Mary Magdalene who was a whore. She is now a saint.

Edited by GloriaIesusChristi
Posted (edited)

[quote name='GloriaIesusChristi' post='1177812' date='Jan 27 2007, 11:26 AM']Hinduism,the Bagava'gita feels that whatever way man comes to Lord Krishna he is pleased, because the point is that they are worshiping him and they are pleased to preach that Christ is indeed an incarnation or avatar of God himself. However, Christians do not have this attitude. They seem to be the only religious belife that accepts no one that believes the way they do.[/quote]
one of the problems with that is that their "god," Lord Krishna, is pleased by whatever way man comes to him. Jesus is the only way to the Father. (John 14:16) If hearing of the good news of Jesus Christ, they choose to believe they can get to God through some other means, then they still deny part of that good news message. They do not then believe the way that we Christians believe.

The way is through following Christ: The truth is His Gospel message.

Edited by Light and Truth
Posted

[quote]The way is through following Christ: The truth is His Gospel message.[/quote]

I'm not saying that it is not. What I'm saying is that the Hindu's respect Christ and Christianity in admirable, but it seems that not alot of Christians have much respect for Hindu's, whether we follow their religion or not. Christians that I have know in the past would start up a Bible study in their home, then invite themselves over to a friends house in an attempt to convert these people because they don't believe their way. However, the Buddhist friend never does any of this and admires the religion from a distance so as to not offend the Christian family. Christians on the other hand don't care who they offend just so long as they "convert" them to their denomination, not just Christianity. I am not ashamed of missions nor preaching to the lost, some views of Buddhism and the majority of Hinduism are included.

I feel that the method of our actions as a form of conversion would be a great lesson we could learn from Buddists. As a matter of fact, one of the greatest Christian slogans is "Actions speak louder than words."

Convertions are not points on a Godly scorecard.

Posted (edited)

There was a priest on EWTN who was covering for Mother Angelica, and he said we could learn from other religions, just take the good, and leave the bad. He said that we could admire Islam for its profound monotheism and the idea of complete surrender, but reject that God is not triune. With Catholicism we accept everything. With other religions we try to look at things from another point view and see if it makes sense in the Catholic Faith. And if not, reject it. It is well-known that Catholics from other countries have different devotions and different ways of looking at things, much of which they brought with them from their pre-Catholic religion.

If learning about other religions troubles your faith, then I can understand your hesitance. There are many admirable things about other religions that have profound correlates in Catholicism. I am just trying to make sense of Buddhism, within that context.

Edited by Gershom
Posted

[quote name='GloriaIesusChristi' post='1177812' date='Jan 27 2007, 04:56 PM']
1. Right View
2. Right Aspriations
3. Right Speech
4. Right Conduct or Action
5. Right Livelihood
6. Right Endeavor
7. Right Mindfulness
8. Right Meditation

I also believe in the 4 Noble Truths.

Christ came and dinned with sinners, such as Mary Magdalene who was a whore. She is now a saint.
[/quote]

GloriaIesusChristi,

Can you expound on the Eight Fold please? I'm not used to that kind of terminology. And what are the 4 Noble Truths?

Also, I have heard that Mary Magdalene being a prostitute is only legend. Do you know for sure that she was a prostitute?

Peace,
Paddington

Posted (edited)

[quote]Also, I have heard that Mary Magdalene being a prostitute is only legend. Do you know for sure that she was a prostitute?[/quote]

Tradition claims that she was. However, all we Biblically can prove is that Christ casted 7 demons out of her. I apologize for the confusion. I quoted tradition, or legend.

as for the eight-fold path, The path is a process to help you remove or move beyond the conditioned responses that obscure your true nature. In this sense the Path is ultimately about unlearning rather than learning - another paradox. We learn so we can unlearn and uncover. The Buddha called his teaching a Raft. To cross a turbulent river we may need to build a raft. When built, we single-mindedly and with great energy make our way across. Once across we don't need to cart the raft around with us. In other words don't cling to anything including the teachings. However, make sure you use them before you let them go. It's no use knowing everything about the raft and not getting on. The teachings are tools not dogma. The teachings are Upaya, which means skillful means or expedient method. It is fingers pointing at the moon - don't confuse the finger for the moon.

Lemme know if you need more. Buddhism is grand and beauiful, however, some of her institutions can be irrational. Such as the precept of [i] an-atman[/i] and agnosticism. We must also not be totaly consumed with self-enlightenment, but enlightenment through the saving grace of Christ crucified. If this path is an enjoiment to you, research on Catholic enyclopedia about Catholic/Christian Mysticism.

Edited by GloriaIesusChristi

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...