Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

Is it possible to hold the entire Catholic Faith (ie believe it all), and at the same time, accept the Four Noble Truths and practice the Eightfold Path? Can you do this without compromising any Catholic doctrine?

To all:

Maybe I should rephrase my initial question.

If Buddha was sitting at Christ's feet, and he was telling him, "It appears that the situation is X, and this is what I taught my disciples about X and what it means. Lord, is this correct?"

What would Jesus say? How would Jesus put what Buddha grasped without access to Christian doctrine in Catholic words? What would he tell him was wrong?

Does this make sense? Where is Thomas Merton when you need him?

Edited by Gershom
Posted

[quote]What do you tell a Christian who is considering leaving the Church for Buddhism?
[/quote]

We have disscussed Buddhism this whole time and I never really seemed to answer your question, my apologies.

You must explain to your friend that in Buddhism your taught that only [b]you[/b] can save yourself by detaching yourself from worldly things. The issues in the statement is that [b]we must[/b] be detached from the world, but we are given a free gift by God, Christ and his salvation by the death on the cross. This is not a work of man, so no one has room to boast about its accomplisments. Man is lost in the world and as the Buddha says it's product, darkness, is subtle and massive, we can be swept away in a moments time. This is true, even for Gi'nanna Yoga - a specific yoga used frequently by Buddhists, it is the yoga of Philosophical Speculation.
Bhakti Yoga ( its origins stem from classical hinduism) is the yoga of personal dedication to a personal God or Savior. This yoga is looked on in Buddhism as too caught up in the world.

Posted

[quote]What do you tell a Christian who is considering leaving the Church for Buddhism?
[/quote]

We have disscussed Buddhism this whole time and I never really seemed to answer your question, my apologies.

You must explain to your friend that in Buddhism your taught that only [b]you[/b] can save yourself by detaching yourself from worldly things. The issues in the statement is that [b]we must[/b] be detached from the world, but we are given a free gift by God, Christ and his salvation by the death on the cross. This is not a work of man, so no one has room to boast about its accomplisments. Man is lost in the world and as the Buddha says it's product, darkness, is subtle and massive, we can be swept away in a moments time. This is true, even for Gi'nanna Yoga - a specific yoga used frequently by Buddhists, it is the yoga of Philosophical Speculation.
Bhakti Yoga (it's origins stem from classical hinduism, in the Vedas) is the yoga of personal dedication to a god or savior. This yoga is looked on in Buddhism as too caught up in the world, however it is not looked down upon. Since the graph of Buddhism is based upon the Agnostic worldview of Prince Siddartha, the mentality of "God" or "gods" is not totally refuted or abstained from in Buddhism. It is catastophic that your friend in leaving the Christian faith for Philosophical Speculation, but this doesnt mean that he is taught not to believe in God.

What you must explain to him is that we, as sinful men ( he will believe the sinful part, most Buddhists believe in the Noble Truth of Suffering. They don't call it "sin," but it is still seen as "wrong doing".) cannot save ourselves, we were depraved of sin until Christ came and now we have an advocate with God himself throught Jesus Christ. This in know way means that you [b]can't[/b] totally follow Buddhism, but you must understand that man has a soul and he is totally accountable for that soul and what he does will catch up to him in the next life, or what Buddhists would call "Karma" the philosophical expression of [i] you reap what you sow[/i] Christians would follow more of the Buddhists understanding of Karma that the Hindu version. I feel that there will be some Buddhists whom love God with all their heart pledge the 5 ethical truths and follow the path rightly doing good, in the coucil of Heaven, I know this because, Buddhists, unlike Hindus do not believe in Reincarnation, but re-birth. Did not Paul mention a Re-Birth in Christ?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...