RezaMikhaeil Posted January 29, 2007 Posted January 29, 2007 From what I'd heard Shawn Hannity claims to be a Roman Catholic but how does that affect his political views? From what I understand his stances [several of them] highly contradict what the Roman Church stands for [such as his pro-execution stance], so how does that work in regards to his interaction with the church? Is he forbid from taking the Eucharist or how does that work? Reza
Nathan Posted January 29, 2007 Posted January 29, 2007 Hannity is a neoconservative Catholic. He is theologically orthodox as long as the Magisterium does not conflict with the neoconservative political agenda; if it does, he chooses Caesar over Christ. George Weigel and Richard John Neuhaus are similiar. 90% of the time their writings are totally orthodox and reverent of the Church, but the minute the Church is critical of the actions of America or Israel (merely reinforcing the Magisterium) it's "Ah, what do they know?"
ardillacid Posted January 29, 2007 Posted January 29, 2007 The death penalty is not forbidden by the Church
cmotherofpirl Posted January 29, 2007 Posted January 29, 2007 [url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sean_Hannity"]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sean_Hannity[/url] [url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_John_Neuhaus"]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_John_Neuhaus[/url] Wiki does have its uses You will find I have posted many wonderful articles by Father Neuhaus.
Nathan Posted January 29, 2007 Posted January 29, 2007 (edited) I'm sure you have -- Father Neuhaus has written many wonderful articles. But I have read enough from his pen (and know enough about him personally) to know which side his bread is really buttered on when push comes to shove. Edited January 29, 2007 by Nathan
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted January 29, 2007 Posted January 29, 2007 Nathan, you are exactly right. Hannity is uncompromisingly pro-war, pro-israel etc. He is basically the definition of a neo-conservative.
Dave Posted January 29, 2007 Posted January 29, 2007 Hannity has also said on his show that he disagrees with Church teaching against contraception.
RezaMikhaeil Posted January 29, 2007 Author Posted January 29, 2007 See I understand his political agenda, but what I'm asking is how do Romans deal with such an individual? Do they ever reject him the Eucharist [since he doesn't repent of things that are blatantly against the church], etc? Reza
Knight of the Holy Rosary Posted January 29, 2007 Posted January 29, 2007 As someone who often listens to Sean Hannity, I find his obedience to the Church questionable. I've heard him: 1.) Contradict the Church directly on the War in Iraq. 2.) When the Bishops declared refusal of Communion to Pro-Death politicians, he said something to the effect of 'Well if they did that to everyone, nobody would be in Church!' (paraphrase). [quote]....but the minute the Church is critical of the actions of America or Israel (merely reinforcing the Magisterium) it's "Ah, what do they know?"[/quote] Bingo. Iv'e never heard that stuff about Fr. Neuhous though..... Can you give me a source?
Nathan Posted January 29, 2007 Posted January 29, 2007 Hannity is in little danger of being excommunicated. The Holy See tends to be a lot softer on those who dissent from the right (politically) than on those who dissent from the left. It is probably because liberal dissent is far more categorizable and easier to spot; it is the usual suspect. [quote name='Knight of the Holy Rosary' post='1178935' date='Jan 28 2007, 09:58 PM']Iv'e never heard that stuff about Fr. Neuhous though..... Can you give me a source? [/quote] The "Catholic Neocons" section on the [i]New Oxford Review[/i] website is a good start. [url="http://www.newoxfordreview.org/dossier.jsp?did=dossier-neocon"]http://www.newoxfordreview.org/dossier.jsp...=dossier-neocon[/url]
Dave Posted January 29, 2007 Posted January 29, 2007 From EWTN: [quote]Disagreement with the Pope Question from on 05-18-2004: In certain cases, are Catholics at liberty to disagree with the Pope? For example, the Pope was against the war in Iraq. As a Catholic, am I at liberty to decide for myself if I think the war was a just war, or should I be obedient to the Pope and support his decision? Answer by Fr. Stephen F. Torraco on 05-18-2004: There is a distinction to be made between a doctrinal teaching of the Church and a prudential judgment. Doctrinal teaching is binding upon conscience, while the prudential judgment of a Church official is not. According to the Church's doctrinal teaching, war can be morally justifiable if certain criteria are met. According to the same doctrinal teaching, it is the responsibility of the legitimate temporal government, and not of the Church, to determine whether a specific war meets such criteria. This determination is a matter of prudential judgment rather than of doctrinal teaching. This means that Catholics can disagree about whether a specific war is morally justifiable, but must accept the doctrinal teaching that it is the responsibility of the legitimate temporal government to make its best prudential judgment about the matter, even if Catholics disagree with the government's prudential judgment. But this also means that Catholics can disagree with any Church official's prudential judgment. [/quote]
Nathan Posted January 29, 2007 Posted January 29, 2007 The above is all very true and important to realize. But Iraq is just one piece to the puzzle of the neoconservative movement. I believe that in due time, when its fruits have been more firmly established and clearly seen, the Church will officially condemn it as being fundamentally at odds with the Gospel. The Church just hasn't caught up with it yet.
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted January 29, 2007 Posted January 29, 2007 [quote name='Nathan' post='1178943' date='Jan 28 2007, 10:22 PM'] The above is all very true and important to realize. But Iraq is just one piece to the puzzle of the neoconservative movement. I believe that in due time, when its fruits have been more firmly established and clearly seen, the Church will officially condemn it as being fundamentally at odds with the Gospel. The Church just hasn't caught up with it yet. [/quote] i think a lot of Neo-cons subscribe to the Americanist heresy. Im not sure this aspect of it has been explicitly condemned, but what i see in a lot of neo-conservatives (as Nathan described above) is that they put America before their faith. they put the Enlightenment thinking and their "freedoms", and their opinion about how great America is, above Catholicism.
KnightofChrist Posted January 29, 2007 Posted January 29, 2007 He has also stated he is for abortion or will allow for abortion is some case "rape or incest." And has also stated something along the lines when voting for a person that is proabortion not to be a "one issue" voter, and not to die on that hill.
Anomaly Posted January 29, 2007 Posted January 29, 2007 Good thing you guys are all 'better Catholics' that Shaun. It would not be hard to find Bishops and Cardinals who agree with Shaun. But they're old school or something, and couldn't change with the times.
Veritas Posted January 29, 2007 Posted January 29, 2007 [quote name='Dave' post='1178941' date='Jan 28 2007, 09:17 PM'] From EWTN: [/quote] + This is SO important to note. Disagreeing about Iraq and disagreeing about doctrine are two completely different things.
Mercy me Posted January 29, 2007 Posted January 29, 2007 [quote name='RezaLemmyng' post='1178859' date='Jan 28 2007, 08:09 PM'] From what I'd heard Shawn Hannity claims to be a Roman Catholic but how does that affect his political views? From what I understand his stances [several of them] highly contradict what the Roman Church stands for [such as his pro-execution stance], so how does that work in regards to his interaction with the church? Is he forbid from taking the Eucharist or how does that work? Reza [/quote] Sean Hannity is a Roman Catholic and clearly it does color his views. I only that he is against abortion and I have not heard him directly say that he supports it in the case of rape or incest. I think that these issues give him a problem and that he has not sorted it out yet. There has been a great deal of discussion on this board about both the war in Iraq and about the death penalty. It is not against the church to support the death penalty. May church officials including the pope do not support it but the church herself cannot say it is wrong in all cases. You can read the various threads for more information. I can't think of any Catholic politicials who have been denied communion. Kennedy, Kerry, and Pelosi all openly support abortion even partial birth abortion and yet they have not been denied communion.
RezaMikhaeil Posted January 29, 2007 Author Posted January 29, 2007 [quote name='Mercy me' post='1179161' date='Jan 28 2007, 11:01 PM'] Sean Hannity is a Roman Catholic and clearly it does color his views. I only that he is against abortion and I have not heard him directly say that he supports it in the case of rape or incest. I think that these issues give him a problem and that he has not sorted it out yet. There has been a great deal of discussion on this board about both the war in Iraq and about the death penalty. It is not against the church to support the death penalty. May church officials including the pope do not support it but the church herself cannot say it is wrong in all cases. You can read the various threads for more information. I can't think of any Catholic politicials who have been denied communion. Kennedy, Kerry, and Pelosi all openly support abortion even partial birth abortion and yet they have not been denied communion. [/quote] Yeah I'm not posetive but I did hear that John Kerry did have some troubles with accepting communion during his campaign believe it or not. I dont know what came of it, just that it was an issue with his local priest [and bishop too I think]. Reza
Paddington Posted January 29, 2007 Posted January 29, 2007 [quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1178983' date='Jan 29 2007, 01:43 AM'] He has also stated he is for abortion or will allow for abortion is some case "rape or incest." And has also stated something along the lines when voting for a person that is proabortion not to be a "one issue" voter, and not to die on that hill. [/quote] I think you need to clarify his views. From what you said, we don't get the full picture. He might be against all abortion morally, but believe that 3% of abortions should be legal. After all, everybody draws a line somewhere on government coercion on each moral issue. When it comes to rape, the woman did not choose to be pregnant. The "one issue" voter thing can be hard to accept too. There are people who genuinely believe that abortions would not diminish if made illegal. There are people who genuinely believe that environmental damage will (or at least can) ultimately kill more people than abortion. Also, not all Republicans are pro-life. When given the choice between two pro-choice candidates, Sean might take the Republican instead of a pro-life third party candidate. There was a "Ralph Nader" type of Republican who ran against Rudy Guiliani, because Guiliani is pro-choice. Maybe Sean thinks that was the wrong move. It would only help the pro-choice Democrat that Guiliani ran against. If he is truly in favor of contraception, then....he could be deceived about what belongs in the deposit of faith and what does not. Just some possibilities.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now