Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

I'm taking a metaphysics course this semester (my final semester at the university I decided I wanted to try some of it) and have a few general questions about some things...

We're just getting into it and have started out with the realist vs nominalist debates. It seems easy to get very bogged down in all the distinctions and I'm trying not to lose sight of the big picture here.

How should one view realism v nominalism in light of our Catholic beliefs? What were the some of the great Catholic theologians?

Sometimes I wonder, does it really matter?

Posted

Metaphysics is the question of “why”, the Liberal sciences the question of “how”, and the physical sciences the question of “what.” All three are necessary to understand the world around us or to make correct presumptions. Saint Justin the Martyr being a pagan convert was very versed in metaphysics. He was in depression for what man understood metaphysically that time did not match the pagan system of belief but when meeting the preaching Christians it all connected together.

It is important but to the average person to understand the “theory of knowledge” is not going to hinder you to live a full and happy life, or hinder salvation. But because Satan does not only pervert those things of religion but all things there needs to exist in the world those people who understand the upper sciences to correct those abuses of the lower sciences. Such as Atheists often attempt to use the physical sciences to prove their madness, but never prove anything but rather distort and abuse true science.

Guest JeffCR07
Posted

The Nominalism/Realism debate is one that has vast implications for the Faith. Just as the first example that comes to mind, the denial of Realism and the assertion of Nominalism logically leads to a rejection of the doctrine of Original Sin.

The first Nominalist (perhaps) was William of Ockham. By far the majority of orthodox Catholic theologians have been realists or, more properly, "moderate realists" as opposed to "exaggerated realists."

If you have any specific questions concerning the Realist/Nominalist debate, I would be more than happy to help you out.

Your Brother In Christ,

Jeff

Posted

If you want a Catholic metaphysics text perfect for students... Purchase "The One and the Many" by Fr. W. Norris Clarke, SJ.

If you're going to talk about Being, you have to be talking about what's real. If nothing's real, then there's no way to do metaphysics.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='JeffCR07' post='1180884' date='Jan 30 2007, 09:28 PM']
The Nominalism/Realism debate is one that has vast implications for the Faith. Just as the first example that comes to mind, the denial of Realism and the assertion of Nominalism logically leads to a rejection of the doctrine of Original Sin.

The first Nominalist (perhaps) was William of Ockham. By far the majority of orthodox Catholic theologians have been realists or, more properly, "moderate realists" as opposed to "exaggerated realists."

If you have any specific questions concerning the Realist/Nominalist debate, I would be more than happy to help you out.

Your Brother In Christ,

Jeff
[/quote]
This is a touchy issue, but Ockham is not the first to be labeled a nominalist, he is often identified as the first in a wave of nominalists but a new thing these days is to argue that Ockham was in fact no nominalist at all but was only subsequently interpreted in that way. There is a prof at FUS who attempts to make this argument but I've never been interested enough to really learn the ins and outs of this reinterpretation of philosophical history. Just an interesting tidbit for what it's worth.

Perhaps I should be curious to learn exactly where such people are coming from since it seems hard to square with the general perception of Ockham as quite an exemplary nominalist. He is supposed to have declared quite explicitly that "univerals are not things other than names", and he closes the [i]Ordinatio[/i] with this clear profession:
[i]"I do hold this, that no universal, unless perhaps it is universal by a voluntary agreement, is something existing outside the soul in any way, but all that which is of its nature universally predicable of many is in the mind either subjectively or objectively, and that no universal is of the essence or quiddity of any given substance."[/i] :idontknow:

[quote]If you want a Catholic metaphysics text perfect for students... Purchase "The One and the Many" by Fr. W. Norris Clarke, SJ.[/quote]
Amen. That text is certainly a good starting point in studying metaphysics. Cool.

Posted

[quote name='JeffCR07' post='1180884' date='Jan 30 2007, 08:28 PM']
The Nominalism/Realism debate is one that has vast implications for the Faith. Just as the first example that comes to mind, the denial of Realism and the assertion of Nominalism logically leads to a rejection of the doctrine of Original Sin.

The first Nominalist (perhaps) was William of Ockham. By far the majority of orthodox Catholic theologians have been realists or, more properly, "moderate realists" as opposed to "exaggerated realists."

If you have any specific questions concerning the Realist/Nominalist debate, I would be more than happy to help you out.

Your Brother In Christ,

Jeff
[/quote]

Would you mind showing the jump to the rejection of Orginal Sin?

I attend a public university, and though I have a very Orthodox Catholic prof, I highly doubt he'll go into the implications of orginal sin. Then again I could be jumping the gun; it is afterall only the 2nd week of classes.

It's good for me to have something to apply a lot of this instead of just talking about 'Socrates is courageous'.


[quote name='Antonius' post='1181159' date='Jan 31 2007, 12:19 AM']
If you want a Catholic metaphysics text perfect for students... Purchase "The One and the Many" by Fr. W. Norris Clarke, SJ.

If you're going to talk about Being, you have to be talking about what's real. If nothing's real, then there's no way to do metaphysics.
[/quote]

Thanks for the book suggestion, though with the text already assigned in this class along w\ all my other classes I'm not sure how much time I'll have to get around to it.... But maybe? Someday... :D:

Guest JeffCR07
Posted

lol, L_D I figured you or someone else would bring up the Ockham-wasn't-the-first-Nominalist thing so I put in that "(perhaps)" just to cover myself in that department. In fact, I agree, as the seeds of Nominalism were present in some of the less-intense ancient Skeptics and Academicians, and even in some of the Sophists (Protagoras in particular). However, I still maintain that Nominalism as a formalized sysem has its roots firmly in Ockhamism. :idontknow:

rkwright, here is a very brief answer to your question:

Original Sin is not personal sin, but rather, it is called "hereditary" or "inhereted" sin in the Catechism. The separation from God that "Original Sin" refers to is the separation that we receive on account of our human nature. Because all of human nature was contained in our First Parents, and our First Parents fell from communion with God, human nature itself is no longer in communion with God. It is only by uniting ourselves to the person of Christ that our fallen nature is capable of being restored to share the life of the Blessed Trinity.

Now Nominalism rejects the objective reality of all universals, and this includes the "natures" of things. Thus, for a Nominalist, there is no such thing as "human nature," there is only a large number of particulars that we artificially designate as being in the class of "human." The term "human" however, does not refer to any aspect of reality, it is only a term that we use for an artificially constructed set. If there is no such thing as "human nature" then there is no way that "human nature" could fall through the sin of Adam. Rather, all you have is two particulars who are "fallen." Under nominalism, there is not human nature that Adam and Eve communicate to their children, and, as such, there is no Original Sin that man could inherit.

Your Brother in Christ,

Jeff

Posted

hmn.. this looks nothing like the stuff we're doing in my metaphysics course lol... we're studying aristotle, plato, and aquinas, and their views on what is real, soul ("form" actually) and matter.

Posted

[quote name='Franimus' post='1183028' date='Feb 2 2007, 12:00 PM']
hmn.. this looks nothing like the stuff we're doing in my metaphysics course lol... we're studying aristotle, plato, and aquinas, and their views on what is real, soul ("form" actually) and matter.
[/quote]I'm sure that you have been. Have you studied Aristotle's categories? This is where the universals/particulars comes into play, especially since Plato said that the universals (Forms) are the really real things, not the primary substances (particulars that are not said of anything, not predicated of anything) as Aristotle held.

Posted

[quote name='Antonius' post='1181159' date='Jan 31 2007, 12:19 AM']
If you want a Catholic metaphysics text perfect for students... Purchase "The One and the Many" by Fr. W. Norris Clarke, SJ.

If you're going to talk about Being, you have to be talking about what's real. If nothing's real, then there's no way to do metaphysics.
[/quote]


Father Clark is a good writer. I've read some of this stuff on Neo-Thomism.

Posted

I was doing a little research on all this and found this over at catholic.com
[url="http://www.catholic.com/thisrock/2005/0510fea4.asp"]http://www.catholic.com/thisrock/2005/0510fea4.asp[/url]

[quote]Ockham went so far as to say that the Incarnation had value only to the extent God gave it value; God could have redeemed mankind just as easily by becoming a stone, tree, or donkey. If there is no common, or universal, human nature, the Incarnation was not so much about the Logos taking on human nature as it was about God working as he wishes, in a manner unrelated to any sort of logic or reason.

Because of the arbitrary nature of reality, man cannot know the essential nature of sin and grace. Thus, he has no way of knowing his state before God—outside of intuition and inner experience. Besides, nominalism insisted, God can declare sin and grace to exist within man at the same time, regardless of man’s worthiness.[/quote]

Jeff could you explain how the author feels that man could have both sin and grace to exist at the same time? Or how we would have no way of knowing our state before God?

Guest JeffCR07
Posted

I can give it a shot, but you must understand that you are asking me to try to elaborate on the position of someone with whom I am not familiar, and with regards to a subject (Nominalism) that I do not find intellectually compelling.

My answer to "why would a nominalist be unable to know his or her own state before God other than "intuition" is probably my stronger guess. Chances are, the author is thinking along the lines that if there is no such thing as a common, universal human nature, then there are no grounds for saying that "if a human being commits mortal sin, he or she is no longer in communion with God, while if a human being does not commit mortal sin, he or she remains in communion with God." This statement is intelligible if and only if there is some common human nature that we share. If there is not, then there could be different conditions for each individual person.

Now I have two guesses with regards to how sin and grace might simultaneously exist, but I don't think either are very good, so I invite other scholars to add in their two cents worth. The first guess is that in the same way that there is no common nature for all humans, neither is there a common nature for all "graces" or all "sins." If there is no common nature to either, then one could never make the statement "grace and sin are incompatible," but rather, one would be forced to ask whether [i]this particular grace[/i] and [i]this particular sin[/i] are incompatible. My second guess would be that the author is equivocating between Nominalism and Ockhamism. In the latter, stress and emphasis is put on the Will of God over and above the Reason of God. Ockham does not see God's Will as tied to Reason, and so it would be possible (in Ockham's mind) for God to do what seems to us to be contradictory, including the infusion of grace into a person in a state of sin. If this latter guess is correct, then the author has illicitly attributed a view of Ockham's to Nominalism as a whole.

Your Brother In Christ,

Jeff

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

Jeff,

My first answer would have been your second answer. rkwright's quote doesn't seem merely to be speaking of Ockham's nominalism but of that nominalism coupled with a radical voluntarism; the latter arguably being the logical conclusion of the former.
God can declare sin and grace to exist in a person simultaneously because God's Will is His Essence and God's acts are not bound by any notion of universal natures or logic. At least that is the way Ockham is typically presented. As I indicated before, there are novel interpretations of Ockham out there which may or may not have merit.

:idontknow:

P.S. It should be noted that one can be a voluntarist and a realist. My own views on theology tend toward voluntarism but I can hardly be said to agree with Ockham (at least as his thought is typically described).

Guest JeffCR07
Posted

L_D, I definately agree that my second answer is the more likely interpretation. The reason I placed the first one, well, first, is because I didn't want to open by accusing the quote's author of such a rudimentary mistake as equivocating between Nominalism proper and Ockhamism in particular. I just find its always safer for me to open with the most charitable interpretation of the people with whom I'm disagreeing. :smokey:

Anyways, I totally agree, your answer is the more likely case.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='JeffCR07' post='1184362' date='Feb 3 2007, 10:50 PM']
L_D, I definately agree that my second answer is the more likely interpretation. The reason I placed the first one, well, first, is because I didn't want to open by accusing the quote's author of such a rudimentary mistake as equivocating between Nominalism proper and Ockhamism in particular. I just find its always safer for me to open with the most charitable interpretation of the people with whom I'm disagreeing. :smokey:

Anyways, I totally agree, your answer is the more likely case.
[/quote]
I think I should be taking notes since apparently I lack that particular sensitivity. :blush:

Jeff for Church Scholar! :yahoo:

Guest JeffCR07
Posted

hahaha, I wish my habit of doing that was entirely motivated by charity, but really, it comes from one of my professors. He always tells his students that anyone can argue with someone else, but the mark of a true intellectual giant is if they can give the most charitable reading of their opponent's position, even [i]strengthening[/i] it if they can, and [i]then[/i] tear it apart. He's a totally brilliant Hegel scholar, and one of the smartest men I've ever met, so I just try to be like him :saint:

Posted

As I continue my studies I thought I'd post a few more questions and thoughts here rather than starting a new thread...

Could the same be said of say the Eucharist? For the nominalist it is merely a particular of bread and there is no nature that is being changed? Can the nominalist defend transubstantiation?

Also we're getting into concrete particulars; bundle-theory and substratum theorists. Just after a quick read it seems that a bundle-theorist couldn't defend the Eucharist either, or am I mistaken here?

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='JeffCR07' post='1185606' date='Feb 5 2007, 06:31 PM']
hahaha, I wish my habit of doing that was entirely motivated by charity, but really, it comes from one of my professors. He always tells his students that anyone can argue with someone else, but the mark of a true intellectual giant is if they can give the most charitable reading of their opponent's position, even [i]strengthening[/i] it if they can, and [i]then[/i] tear it apart. He's a totally brilliant Hegel scholar, and one of the smartest men I've ever met, so I just try to be like him :saint:
[/quote]
That reminds me of Newman since it was said that in debates he would often enunciate his opponents views more lucidly and profoundly than they did, just prior to utterly refuting them of course. :lol:

Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1186432' date='Feb 6 2007, 03:04 PM']
That reminds me of Newman since it was said that in debates he would often enunciate his opponents views more lucidly and profoundly than they did, just prior to utterly refuting them of course. :lol:
[/quote]

L_D do you have any comments on my questions? I hold your opinions in high regard and enjoy reading your posts. Even your 'harsh' ones (though I'm with you on the open-theism stuff... your response was the first thing that came to my mind; though I normally wait in case I'm completely wrong..)

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...