rkwright Posted February 8, 2007 Author Posted February 8, 2007 My professors response... [quote]Interesting set of issues. The first thing to think of by way of a response is simply the way in which a nominalist would respond to any other question about natures. So, just as the nominalist would not let his denial of natures prevent him from saying all oranges are fruits, or that any tree that grows from an orange seed will be a fruit-bearing tree, so he could say (if he wished) that all men have a tendency to sin, and that any man born of woman will tend toward sin. Now as to Ockham's remarks about how God might have redeemed humans, I'm simply not schooled enough in Ockham scholarship to know what to say. But it's hard for me to see that everything attributed to him in the passage you cite follows from nominalism alone. Thing is, I'm just not sure what all is behind Ockham's claims.[/quote]
Guest JeffCR07 Posted February 10, 2007 Posted February 10, 2007 rkwright, your professor is correct in saying that this is probably how a nominalist would respond, but the response is not satisfactory. Because nominalism denies real universal natures, terms like "fruit" are, for nominalists, nothing more than place-holders for the set of all particulars identified as fruits. Nominalism denies that there is anything about the individual fruits themselves that are common in all fruits. This means that Nominalism cannot made deductive arguments, only [i]inductive[/i] arguments. This is true because any deductive argument (that is syllogistic as opposed to modal or propositional) must proceed from universal to particular. Let's take an example to make this more clear: Deductive Argument Major Premise.) All humans are mammals Minor Premise.) Jack is a human Conclusion: Jack is a mammal. This argument [i]must[/i] be true because it proceeds from a universal claim, takes a particular, and considers the relation between the two in order to draw a conclusion. Now, [i]inductive arguments[/i] don't do this. They are never certain, they are only ever "strong" or "weak." So lets take a look at an example: Inductive Argument Major Premise.) All the pigs that I've seen are messy Minor Premise.) Jack is a pig Conclusion: Jack is messy Here, it may be probable that Jack is messy, but it is far from certain. So what does all of this have to do with Nominalism? Because the word "pig" does not refer to anything that must necessarily be the same in all instances of individual pigs, Nominalism will never be able to make a certain deductive argument. It will only be able to make strong inductive arguments. This is really important when we look back at what your professor has, rightly I think, supposed the nominalist response to be. When a Nominalist makes the statement that "all men have a tendency to sin" what he is really saying is that "in the set of all things which we call 'men,' there is nothing that does not have a tendency to sin." This is a significant distinction because when you look at what the Nominalist is really saying, there is no reason why something that [i]doesn't[/i] have that tendency to sin couldn't be included in the set of all things called "men" at some later point. So the Nominalist will only be able to say that it is highly [i]probable[/i] that every man is fallen and needs Christ's redemption, he can't say that every man is [i]necessarily[/i] fallen and needs Christ's redemption. Clearly, Christians make the latter claim, with which Nominalism is incompatible. I hope that helps! Your Brother In Christ, Jeff
rkwright Posted February 10, 2007 Author Posted February 10, 2007 Thanks Jeff; your help is greatly appreciated. A question; could the nominalist say that 'All objects that are pigs are objects that are messy' ?
Guest JeffCR07 Posted February 11, 2007 Posted February 11, 2007 again, it would depend on what they mean when they say it. When a nominalist says "all pigs are messy" or "all objects that are pigs are objects that are messy," what they mean is something like this: "Whenever I look at the set of all things to which the term 'pig' applies, I find something that is messy." This however, does not mean that any claims can be made about the nature of pigs in general. For the nominalist, there is no quality that is common among all pigs necessarily. The fact that all pigs happen to be messy (in our hypothetical example) is, for a nominalist, accidental. Your Brother In Christ, Jeff
rkwright Posted February 15, 2007 Author Posted February 15, 2007 Jeff- I'd like to post the reply I got. You've got my professors interest and hes been bringing up the emails in class. Though I'm not sure how much more he'll reply but he did want to hear your response. "The nominalist can make deductive arguments as well as anyone else, if he has the premises. The trick is to get the premises--e.g., All humans are prone to sin. What he will do to try to get that is to talk about things being similar, without mentioning any *respect* in which they are similar. So he might say that you and I are similar in both being human, and that we are both being inclined to sin. He might add that to date, all beings who are similar in being human have been inclined to sin. And he might then venture a guess that *all* who are similar in being human will be found to be inclined to sin. He will admit there is an inductive leap here--but no less egregious, he will argue, than that of the realist, who thinks he's got the so-called "nature" _human_ pegged on the basis of a finited number of cases. Now remember I am no nominalist, and I think the nominalist has no true explanation for attribute agreement, since he cannot explain similarity. But that does not mean he cannot make deductive arguments. It's just that he can't really offer a persuasive account of how any of this works." In class today he said he wanted to 'tack on' another response on the end of it. He also said (and forgive me if I get this wrong I'm still learning here) that a nominalist could make the same claim on natures as in attribute agreement. That is that All humans are prone to sin just a brute fact; a particular in itself. Anything on this?
Guest JeffCR07 Posted February 16, 2007 Posted February 16, 2007 Your professor is entirely correct. As he says, though, for the nominalist "the trick is to get the premises." The only way for a nominalist to get the premises for a deductive argument is for him to identify a similarity common to every particular in the set. However, the issue being discussed in my above post was the theological issue of original sin and redemption, and for this, even that isn't enough. Recall that I made the point that even if a nominalist [i]did[/i] say that every individual in the set of all things called "human" has a tendency to sin, this in no way allows him to claim that everything which is "human" [i]must[/i] have a tendency to sin. Even if a similarity is common to every member of the nominalist's set, there is no way for nominalism to assert that this [i]must[/i] be so; they are able only to say that it [i]is[/i] so. This is the significant point for the issue of original sin and redemption. If it is even [i]possible[/i] for a regular human being like you or me to [i]not[/i] to have a tendency to sin, then it is possible for a human being not to need Christ, and this is contrary to the Faith. The nominalist can say "every current or past human being needs Christ for redemption." The nominalist cannot say "every human being, past, present, or future, needs Christ for redemption." But that, my friend, is exactly what the Church teaches. This is true because, as your professor implicitly pointed out, the nominalist can only work with the immediate particulars in front of him. He cannot, therefore, make necessarily true claims about future particulars. Your Brother In Christ, Jeff
N/A Gone Posted February 16, 2007 Posted February 16, 2007 I know this is off-topic..but how messed up is my metaphysics..
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now