Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

We were discussing this recently. Could this phenomenon be some sort of undiagnosed narcolepsy??

It just seems to me that if the Lord was going to let someone rest in Him, it would happen all the time after receiving the Eucharist.

What do you think?

Posted

Garrrgh!

That was me. Hubby forgot to sign out again!!

:maddest:

Posted

I have always thought it is faking.

:idontknow:

But I am a big skeptic of everything.

Posted

[quote name='prose' post='1202789' date='Feb 22 2007, 07:24 PM']Garrrgh!

That was me. Hubby forgot to sign out again!!

:maddest:[/quote]


that's what happens when you quit smoking

Posted

I'd like to learn more about this as well.

Posted

I am very skeptical, too... although I know people who "rest in the Spirit" who are very sincere Catholics. It doesn't make any sense to me, but it could be that I just don't understand.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

I always figured it was the power of suggestion

Posted

A bunch of charismatics you guys are huh? ;) I've found that after 3 years at Franciscan University there are just bigger fish to fry than trying to go after God fearing orthodox Catholics. You are probably right that it very much is peer pressure and the power of suggestion, but ultimately charismatics, at least those at FUS, are very holy people in the lives that they live.

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='Terra Firma' post='1202794' date='Feb 22 2007, 07:28 PM']I have always thought it is faking.

:idontknow:

But I am a big skeptic of everything.[/quote]
Yes, yes you are.

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1202881' date='Feb 22 2007, 10:12 PM']I always figured it was the power of suggestion[/quote]
That's always been my thought.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' post='1203395' date='Feb 23 2007, 03:52 PM']A bunch of charismatics you guys are huh? ;) I've found that after 3 years at Franciscan University there are just bigger fish to fry than trying to go after God fearing orthodox Catholics. You are probably right that it very much is peer pressure and the power of suggestion, but ultimately charismatics, at least those at FUS, are very holy people in the lives that they live.[/quote]
I always assumed 99% of them were. :)

Posted

Having been rested in the Spirit once (prior to anyone telling me what it was), I can attest to the fact that it is NOT fake.

I was in adoration once, deeply praying, sending God pretty much as much praise as I could muster when, all of a sudden, I began to shake. It was a slight tremor at first, and then it became more pronounced. I didn't know what was going on, so I decided to change my posture. I prostrated myself and continued praying. Then, all of a sudden, this feeling of peace came over me. I felt as if my mother was wrapping me in her arms, hugging me firmly. Simultaneously, this slight weight begun to form on my back, like I was being hugged from behind. I felt so loved, and continued to praise God...and then I felt myself falling...like I was falling into an abyss of love...

I emerged about 20 minutes later with my 2 brothers praying over me.

I can't describe it...it was this amazing feeling of love and peace and healing.

Don't be so skeptical. God loves us.

Posted

It's not that I think it [i]never[/i] happens. I just think that maybe people who have it happen ALL THE TIME might have some form of narclepsy? :idontknow:

Posted

[quote name='Fishmaker' post='1202788' date='Feb 22 2007, 07:23 PM']We were discussing this recently. Could this phenomenon be some sort of undiagnosed narcolepsy??

It just seems to me that if the Lord was going to let someone rest in Him, it would happen all the time after receiving the Eucharist.

What do you think?[/quote]

Narcolepsy would express itself at other times too. Being "slain in the spirit" is a specific phenomenon associated w/ the Charismatic Renewal. It has happened to me a number of times, once in adoration but usually while being prayed over. I've seen people big and small, in good health and bad, and I cannot attribute it to narcolepsy. I've seen it happen to people who rarely sleep or have difficulty sleeping. Moreover, it is not sleeping, per se. All the times it has happened to me I have been fully conscious throughout. (However, the one in adoration was apparently a vision and I lost most contact w/ the outside world during it.)

Posted

[quote name='kujo' post='1203448' date='Feb 23 2007, 06:48 PM']Having been rested in the Spirit once (prior to anyone telling me what it was), I can attest to the fact that it is NOT fake.

I was in adoration once, deeply praying, sending God pretty much as much praise as I could muster when, all of a sudden, I began to shake. It was a slight tremor at first, and then it became more pronounced. I didn't know what was going on, so I decided to change my posture. I prostrated myself and continued praying. Then, all of a sudden, this feeling of peace came over me. I felt as if my mother was wrapping me in her arms, hugging me firmly. Simultaneously, this slight weight begun to form on my back, like I was being hugged from behind. I felt so loved, and continued to praise God...and then I felt myself falling...like I was falling into an abyss of love...

I emerged about 20 minutes later with my 2 brothers praying over me.

I can't describe it...it was this amazing feeling of love and peace and healing.

Don't be so skeptical. God loves us.[/quote]
Had you [b]eaten [/b]that day? Sounds like you fainted. Not to trivialize your experience or anything, but usually the most mundane explanation is the correct one.

Posted

[quote name='prose' post='1203470' date='Feb 23 2007, 06:59 PM']It's not that I think it [i]never[/i] happens. I just think that maybe people who have it happen ALL THE TIME might have some form of narclepsy? :idontknow:[/quote]
I think it's based on a feeling that if they don't receive these gifts then they won't fit into the community. I think that very nearly all instances are self-induced, such as when voodoo adherents trance out. If the desire is strong enough for something to happen, fakery is not above some people.

Posted

[quote name='toledo_jesus' post='1203644' date='Feb 23 2007, 07:24 PM']I think it's based on a feeling that if they don't receive these gifts then they won't fit into the community. I think that very nearly all instances are self-induced, such as when voodoo adherents trance out. If the desire is strong enough for something to happen, fakery is not above some people.[/quote]
Keep in mind that this is coming from the man who thinks zombies have rights too :rolleyes:

Posted (edited)

[size=1]Personally, I tend to assume its fake before I go believe it.
Maybe some people really experience it, but I think 98% of it is their mind playing a trick on their body because they want to experience it so bad...or they are just faking for attention.
They just want to believe it happened sooooo bad that they trick themselves into thinking that it acctually did.

I just have a hard time believe that sort of thing. :idontknow:
[/size]

Edited by CrossCuT
Posted

[quote name='Fishmaker' post='1202788' date='Feb 22 2007, 08:23 PM']We were discussing this recently. Could this phenomenon be some sort of undiagnosed narcolepsy??

It just seems to me that if the Lord was going to let someone rest in Him, it would happen all the time after receiving the Eucharist.

What do you think?[/quote]
It's called resting in the Spirit, not resting in the Son.


I understand the skepticism. I would be skeptical. I was skeptical. You probably should be skeptical...

but you prolly don't have to be. I can personally attest to the fact that it just happens...just because it did happen to me prior to my knowing what it was (I thought slain in the spirit was far more dramatic than it actually was).


I'll get into it more later, but trust me, it's not fake. At least with me it wasn't. And I'm at least 96% sure that it's not fake with most other people. It has nothing to do with fitting in. It...just.......happens? Yeah. That's it.

Posted

[quote name='toledo_jesus' post='1203642' date='Feb 23 2007, 08:22 PM']Had you [b]eaten [/b]that day? Sounds like you fainted. Not to trivialize your experience or anything, but usually the most mundane explanation is the correct one.[/quote]

I am a big boy. I had eaten a solid breakfast (grapefruit juice, bowl of cerel), a decent sized lunch (sandwich, milk), and a quality steak/potatoes dinner. I was also extremely well-rested, relatively happy and otherwise healthy.

Mundane explanations trivialize God's amazing power. I repeat from my other post: don't be so skeptical. God can do what He wants, no matter how strange or seemingly-illogical those actions may be.

Posted

[size=1]I have ONLY seen it happen in a charismatic environment.
Never at church in silent adoration, or right after communion at a regular service.

Only when there is music to influence your mood have I seen people drop down and laugh, cry, sleep, seize, beat other people, talk in tongues, or eat hamburgers "in the spirit".
Never any other time have I witnessed it, so I still believe 98% is fake.

I think all these people are tricking themselves.
[/size]

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...